2011 is year for boyband and girlband in indonesia

@adhyz82 (36248)
Indonesia
January 1, 2012 10:27am CST
like or dislike, 2011 is year for many boyband and girlband.. many poor boyband and girlband broke the music industry (my opinion) they come as a celebrity without good voice..they only depends on their dance, and always use lypsync..how come they can be a good artist? i dont understand many people admit them as singer..i always only categorize them as dancer what about you??
6 responses
ekoytyas
@ekoytyas (4679)
• Indonesia
2 Jan 12
those boy and girl band become famous, and the pioneer was Smash. but most of them was try to become like korea pop.. not original, too bad.
adhyz82
@adhyz82 (36248)
• Indonesia
2 Jan 12
boy band and girl band is like sinetron.. poor but amazing, many people like them.. but the future of boyband and girl band is like product of AFI and several many instant program who only depends on our SMS as decision maker..
adhyz82
@adhyz82 (36248)
• Indonesia
6 Jan 12
hm..sooner or later, we forget about girlband and boy band..i really dont like this genre music ...too many dance but forget the quality of voice
ekoytyas
@ekoytyas (4679)
• Indonesia
5 Jan 12
first when boy band and girlband appear, most of audience just see how their face and their dance. but with this, another people interested to get instant famous with become boyband
1 person likes this
areskya
@areskya (398)
• Indonesia
2 Jan 12
I don't have the same opinion as you, I think some of them have good voice and style. It make Indonesian music become more colorful. They also give new style, it makes me as the audience feel not bored in listening Indonesian songs
adhyz82
@adhyz82 (36248)
• Indonesia
2 Jan 12
do you ever watched the program boy band and girlband in SCTV every saturday night and every monday night?? you can know their real voice..it`s terrible for me
adhyz82
@adhyz82 (36248)
• Indonesia
3 Jan 12
so you must watch it.. i can give the comments they broke music industry because i ever watched it.. and it`s terrible..mostly of them had no good voice
areskya
@areskya (398)
• Indonesia
3 Jan 12
No, I haven't. I only watch the review of it on certain infotainment, I don't like to watch that programs. I like to watch any music program but I don't have any interest to watch it, yeah just see the winner the next, how qualified are they
indahfth
@indahfth (11161)
• Indonesia
2 Jan 12
Yes. You are right in 2011, many boyband, and girlband. It's very disappointing, the quality of their voices. They also frequently appear lipsing. But yesterday, I saw a boy band, who play live, and not lipsing. But his voice was very chaotic.
adhyz82
@adhyz82 (36248)
• Indonesia
2 Jan 12
of course..they only play their dance...what a pity for music industry..
sql_cell
@sql_cell (1427)
• Indonesia
2 Jan 12
It is i my opinion can only be returned to the music lovers. If they do not pay attention to major in musicthat it is legitimate sound quality. it's fine. But actualy in music that must be considered aspects included the sound quality of a musician or music group. There are like and there is no like. Those two things very naturally happened.
adhyz82
@adhyz82 (36248)
• Indonesia
2 Jan 12
yes, it will be returned us as music lovers..but many of people is so stupid.. make idol a people who had no quality..what a pity
adhyz82
@adhyz82 (36248)
• Indonesia
2 Jan 12
i think we must boycott the album or the product from a people who want to be singer, but can`t sing
microengineer
@microengineer (587)
• Indonesia
3 Jan 12
Not a genre that I like. Instant artist without real ability. They are not musician nor singer. Dancer? I am not really sure. Why? for an artist they must understand art. Why they dance like that? what is the philosophy? what is art behind it? Not merely dance for fun and follow the rhythm of the music which is sometime not suitable. They should not only singing but do not know what is melody etc... They call themselves as Band, but do not perform as Band, only merely performer (not even worthy to be called as dancer). Band to me is just like Dewa 19 (although not like them). For group of singer you can call Kahitna (they have music background) or Kla Project. For Parody Band, project P is still the best, why? they have concept. For female group, I choose AB three and Rida-Sita-Dewi. For Pop group, Padi or Sheila on 7 is much better than current what so called boyband. oh my poor Indonesia, why we always copy cat J-pop and K-pop and other things... we have great musician such as Elfa S., Bubby Chen and so on..
adhyz82
@adhyz82 (36248)
• Indonesia
4 Jan 12
the K Pop era maybe was started from many Korean drama or movies. but there is something different when real K-Pop and imitate K-Pop.. why i said K-pop imitate?? i give example, Smash.. they are really terrible band(if we can call band) but unfortunatelly, the poor band like Smash get many fans, it`s amazing for me.. and from like that several poor band appear, not only boy band, but girls band even arise and want to get fans..from Cherry belle and so on.. the fact, mostly of them only sell the face(bad, they are not really handsome too for me) and sell how to dance, and make many fans scream when see their performance, oh My God..
macanan
@macanan (153)
• Indonesia
3 Jan 12
yes i think last year was full of boyband and girl band. but i dont like them, especially smash. they appearcnec are looak alike sheshe boy, evethough many teenager are crwazy and addicted to them, calling themself, smashbalst. their music and lyric are not good to listen
adhyz82
@adhyz82 (36248)
• Indonesia
3 Jan 12
it means you are indonesian like me.. do you like Smash??