Aftyer cleaning my gals fish tank alll the fish started dying.
By deodavid
@deodavid (4147)
Philippines
March 29, 2012 4:23am CST
Hi there everybody,
This is actually a story that happened last week, it is really sad because being a new fish owner you dont want something you took care of or has a life die because of your mistake or what ever you did.
To begin the story my girl and i planned to clean her 10 liter aquarium a day before so we prepared the water and put the right amount of anti chlorine and anti fungals like always everything was done by the number. Precautionary measures were set into play and that there is to be no problem.
SO we transferred the fish in a small and cleaned soap free buckets and put there air in it then had cleaned there aquariums and even really thoroughly cleaned them, off course no soap or chemicals were used just tap water, We even clean the pebbles cleaning each set of pebbles for two aquariums 5 times in water then soaking them in hot water before letting them cool down with tap water.
So we finished it designed the whole aquarium with the rocks and placed the over night treated water and then returned the fish gently like they were children 4 ryukins and 5 koi's to be exact in different tanks according to there kind.
Then after and hour they started gasping for air lying on the aquarium floor and started dying one hour after the other only two remains now only two koi's they are healthy.
Any suggestions guys why did this happened, the water we used in the tanks were filtered water the same thing we drink in there house, and it was treated overnight.
Thanks guys for any details on this matter
2 people like this
8 responses
@deodavid (4147)
• Philippines
3 Apr 12
I didn't use tap water i used distilled water my gals house had this distilling thing that distills water for there drinking purposes and i did try to let them set on a plastic bag on top of the new water for the temp but i think it wasn't long enough i think it was the temp that did the fish. I'll never make the same mistake again.
@minx267 (15526)
• Hartford, Connecticut
29 Mar 12
There are many things that need to be checked.. the PH of the water can not be too varied from what the fish are in currently.. and also the Temperature they have to be slowly adjusted to the temp from the bucket they came from to the temperature of the water in the tank. That is why they tell you to leave the bags you bring them home in sitting in the water for 1/2 hour before you let the fish out into your tank.
A shock in temp or ph could potentially kill your fish.
@deodavid (4147)
• Philippines
3 Apr 12
i did put them in an open bag that had the old water in it then let them sit on top of the water but it was only maybe 15 minutes that must had been it that killed the fish, i had also put the right amount for a PH treatment i think you are right maybe it is the temp.
@minx267 (15526)
• Hartford, Connecticut
3 Apr 12
also there is an ammonia test kit.. you should have... and check as well.
When you say you tested the PH.. did you test only the PH of the NEW water or the old water as well.. because if the change of the PH was DRASTIC from the OLD water to the NEW water that would be a shock to there system.. that is why the ph kit instructions tell you to gradually change the waters PH to the right level (if it if very off from neutral) over the period of days to weeks. Not all at once.
@Fishmomma (11658)
• United States
29 Mar 12
First don't take the fish out of the tank when cleaning it. Stress kills many fish. Never change all the water in the tank, as that is really hard on the fish meaning more stress. I suggest a small water change and don't clean the pebbles, as the tank sounds like it was over cleaned.
1 person likes this
@topffer (42155)
• France
29 Mar 12
Hello deodavid,
Sad story : you don't want to see something like this happening
. 10 liter is a small aquarium, but I think you should do like for a large one, and not change all the water at the same time : it is very stressing for a fish, it kills bacteria useful for purification -- and without them ammonia and nitrites, toxic for fishes, will increase during weeks --, and it is difficult to know exactly the amount of chlorine in tap water, as it varies -- I think that chlorine killed your fish : 0.1 mg/liter is lethal for a fish --. Changing 30 or 40% of the water once every week or every 2 weeks -- and cleaning it roughly at this moment -- is probably enough for a 10 L aquarium.
. 10 liter is a small aquarium, but I think you should do like for a large one, and not change all the water at the same time : it is very stressing for a fish, it kills bacteria useful for purification -- and without them ammonia and nitrites, toxic for fishes, will increase during weeks --, and it is difficult to know exactly the amount of chlorine in tap water, as it varies -- I think that chlorine killed your fish : 0.1 mg/liter is lethal for a fish --. Changing 30 or 40% of the water once every week or every 2 weeks -- and cleaning it roughly at this moment -- is probably enough for a 10 L aquarium. 1 person likes this
@deodavid (4147)
• Philippines
3 Apr 12
It was a ten liter aquarium, we have two of them, one for 4 ryukins and another for 5 koi fish, i used distilled water water and i had the anti chlorine and the anti fungal treatment set for a whole evening in a clean pail before cleaning the aquarium putting that clean water as new water. i do this all the time i don't know it is the same water that we drink at my girlfriends place so i think it was pretty clean. I don't know. What do you think?
@almond24 (1248)
• Hungary
29 Mar 12
If I understood well, you took out the fish of the aquarium, and let them back after cleaning?
Seems like they had too many new things to adapt to at once. If you have a thermometer or water heater, you should check that the temperature is the same in the aquarium and the new water. There might have been too many chemicals in the water for the fish as well.
It's not necessary to take the fish out all the time you want to change the water. When I had an aquarium I used to let 1/2 or 1/3 part of the water out using a small plastic tube. Then let the new water flow in the aquarium through that tube slowly. That way the fish will be less upset, and the temperature of the water won't be different.
I'm sorry about your girlfriends' fish. I think they should have told you about the details where you got them. Some fish are very sensitive and even when you handle them carefully they don't like it, while others are not so much.
1 person likes this
@dogsnme (1264)
• United States
11 Apr 12
I've had fish for a couple years and have lost my share through trial and error. I'm no expert but I'll throw this out there anyway. One thing that jumped out at me, and I think some other mylotters touched on this in their own words, is the water change. Unless you are planning on putting a different type of fish in the tank you don't really have to take all the water completely out to clean it. If you do, you want to make sure you keep a substantial amount of the old water to put back in, say around 25%. This is to help the biological "filter," the friendly bacteria that helps get rid of ammonia and other harmful substances, to quickly reestablish itself. The bacteria lives mostly in the substrate(the gravel). When you clean the substrate that thoroughly you destroy the biological filter. Remember, the biological filter, once established, is the fish's best defense against harmful ammonia buildup. You can keep this in mind for the future. Just some helpful info. However, based on how quickly you said the fish started dying I don't think it has to do with a biological filter imbalance. Are you sure you used the right amount of water conditioning solution? And I assume you know for sure that your water has chlorine since you used conditioner to get rid of it. One thing about chlorine. In case you didn't know. Chlorine, based on what I've read by experts, can kill suddenly, and not always with symptoms. It's probably more lethal to a fish than ammonia. So, if you didn't use enough conditioner that might be a cause. Also, if you used too much conditioner it might be a cause as well. I don't know what conditioner you use but I use Amquel Plus and it does mention on the bottle that the conditioner will cause a moderate drop in oxygen levels in the water for the first few hours if aeration is not adequate. One more thing that another mylotter mentioned. Koi are a type of goldfish that just keep growing. They don't just grow to the size of your tank like some fish do. They will eventually outgrow your tank if they haven't already. I don't know how many gallons 10 liters translates into but I don't think a 10 liter tank is sufficient enough for koi. Koi are actually more suitable for outdoor ponds because they grow so big. I don't know if any of this info helps you solve your problem. If anything, hopefully, it will help make your water changes a little easier and more effective in the future.
@Tamosree1993 (1525)
• India
6 Apr 12
Hello friend,
It is very sad news. Hope they are ok.
Have a nice day.









