Maxim rated "It's a Wonderful Life" worst Christmas movie of all time. How can this be??

Well I don't understand why either as I love this movie to
I think it is the most wonderful heartwarming Movie about

I guess because it's old,clean,good for the family,teaches respect,has no drugs,no sex,no swearing so it guess to them it stinks! I guess they think the perfect christmas movie needs sex,swearing,drugs and someone in jail for murder,rape etc...

Hi! Consider the source! I'm sure wholesome movies aren't a priority at the Maxim offices!

"It's a Wonderful Life" is probably one of the most delightful movies ever made. It's charm has touched millions of people for over 50 years. Maxim is a so-so magazine that appeals to those with a certaion smarmy mindset.

I love this movie and make it a tradition to watch it every year with my family. I must admit that it's a bit of a struggle to get my husband to sit down and watch the movie with me, but he knows how important it is to me so he does it!
I think that Maxim is a terrible magizine and probably voted some porn as the number one Christmas movie of all time. I wouldn't worry about what it has to say about a quality family movie like It's a Wonderful Life!

I guess that some people have the morals of a tomcat and can't appreciate anything that's good and wholesome.

Then, I know of some good, wholesome people who don't like this movie. Most of them are younger, though, and probably turned off by its being old and in black-and-white.

Anyway, I really like it. I'm not familiar with Maxim, but it sounds to me as if this is a magazine (or whatever it is) that would like to wipe memories clean of wholesomeness in movies.

It IS the most heartwarming movie ever! I have seen it over and over and over again and still feel the same way I did when I saw it for the very first time. I don't go by how others judge a movie..if I did I would never get to see much. I am a romantic though and believe in angels, so I could be judged too. LOLOL

Maybe for bubble-breasted blondes it is the worst movie because they don't get the meaning of the movie. I am a huge fan of Jimmy Stewart's movies and this one is up there as one of the best if not the best performance he ever did.

It is a timeless movie that will always be an American/Christian/Christmas tradition.

Since I hate this movie, I'm agreeing with their rating. I think it's a sad, depressing movie that doesn't really mean anything about the season. It's also cheesy. Just doesn't mean anything to me.

It's sad, I don't think I've actually ever seen this movie. I could care less what Maxim rated it. I just haven't ever seen the movie. And of course seeing what time era it came from, I highly doubt I'd enjoy it. I'm not fond of that kind of sappy movie that is as cliche as a cliche itself.