sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

Debunked Rumors about Harry Potter & The Deathly Hallows  email this discussion to a friend?

ratnapro (60)   ranked 491 out of 1,067 in harry potter series 6 years ago

Before each Harry Potter book comes out, there are always people who will try to turn theories they've concocted into fact, or even those who will simply create rumors for the fun of it. Currently, there are a few about Book 7 and below you can find the ones which JKR has debunked.

Character Information

* Dumbledore is really dead. He is not in hiding and is not coming back.
* There will be no character named "Icicle," and JK said that she didn't recall saying there ever would be
* Dumbledore is not Harry's relative
* Harry is not related to Voldemort and he is not related to Salazar Slytherin
* Lily Potter is not alive
* Lily was not a Death Eater
* Crookshanks is not an Animagus
* Neville is not the son of Peter Pettigrew
* Remus Lupin does not have a twin brother
* Petunia is not a Squib
* Dumbledore is not Harry/Ron from the future
* Mrs Norris/Crookshanks will not be discovered as an Animagus

Plot Information

* Harry will not become Minister for Magic
* Peter Pettigrew’s silver hand will not kill Lupin
* Lupin will not return as a DADA professor
* The prophecy refers to Harry, and not in any way to Neville
* The final part of the prophecy does not mean Harry has to kill Neville, or vice versa

 

harry potter series
sponsors
Harry Potter Costumes
Great selection of Harry Potter costumes and robes.Purchase online.
www.costumes4less.com

Boarding School
Looking For Boarding School? Find It Nearby With Local.com!
Local.com

Teen Boarding School
Get A Better Education Through Boarding School. Find Free Info Now.
westridgeacademy.com

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  harry potter, deathly hallows, rumors, voldemort, book 7
 
1. myLot reputation of 99/100. Trace86 (3618)   ranked 198 out of 1,067 in harry potter series   6 years ago

I was really hoping that Dumbledore wasn't dead.
I am pretty sure that Voldemort was the one who was related to Salazar Slytherin.
There is no way anyone with a working brain could think that Lily would ever be a death eater. Voldemort tried to kill her because she opposed him. The magic of her love was strong enough to save Harry from Voldemort's evil spell.
Most of those other rumors I have not heard.


myLot reputation of 69/100. SK401001 (823)   ranked 253 out of 1,067 in harry potter series  6 years ago

Yeah I agree there are some I was not aware of, here is the link to the above info. http://www.mugglenet.com/...

Harry Potter Costumes Great selection of Harry Potter costumes and robes.Purchase online.  www.costumes4less.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 69/100. SK401001 (823)   ranked 253 out of 1,067 in harry potter series   6 years ago

Some nice information. But I think part of the excitment is trying to figure out what could happen. All the conspiracy, Its Fun... Men, Dumbeldore is really dead, I was hoping the old koot was still alive and hoppen around. Darn, thanks for the info so

Boarding School Looking For Boarding School? Find It Nearby With Local.com!  Local.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 95/100. tentwo67 (2443)   ranked 4 out of 1,067 in harry potter series   6 years ago

I think that there will end up being something that connects Lily to Voldemort or to Snape. I have wondered if Petunia talking about Lily with "that awful boy" might not have been Harry's dad. I wonder if the surprise from Petunia (which JKR has referred to) could be additional information about that.

I think there's a decent chance that Harry will be one of the characters who die in book 7, but I hope it doesn't happen. I think it would be such a downer for all of us who have followed the books for so many years, but I can appreciate that the author might want to ensure that no one tries to continue the series after she finishes it.

Teen Boarding School Get A Better Education Through Boarding School. Find Free Info Now.  westridgeacademy.com
 
4. myLot reputation of 78/100. joy358 (460)   ranked 89 out of 1,067 in harry potter series   5 years ago

Thanks for this very useful info. With all the rumors circulating around about the final Harry Potter book its very hard to sort out what's true or not. Your info above really helped clear my expectations on the next HP book. I've always thought that Harry could be related to Godric Gryffindor. It's just sad though that Dumbledore is really dead...


ratnapro (60)   ranked 491 out of 1,067 in harry potter series  5 years ago

Thanks for dropping by....Yeah u r quite true...Until the book comes out its not possible to relax....I think we have to wait... I also heard that Voldemort is gonna kill Harry....
Is this really true???

Legos Harry Potter Items Find Legos Harry Potter Video Games, Playsets & More for Cheap!  www.Calibex.com/Legos-Harry-Potter
 
5. myLot reputation of 79/100. prashanth1489 (656)   ranked 16 out of 1,067 in harry potter series   5 years ago

These are likely to happen
* According to Harry, he will return to the Dursley's one last time for a "short visit" (p. 650 HBP, American Edition).
* After the visit, Harry plans on returning to Godric's Hollow and visiting his parents' graves (p. 651).
* Harry plans to begin tracking down the remaining Horcruxes after his visit to Godric's Hollow (p. 651).
* Ron and Hermione plan on accompanying Harry to the Dursley's and going with him wherever he goes from there (p. 651 HBP). What cool friends!
* Harry will turn 17 on July 31, becoming an adult in the wizarding world. This means that he will be able to perform magic outside of school and Apparate...legally. Unfortunately, coming of age also means that the protection left by his mother will wear off, but Voldemort was finding a number of ways around this enchantment anyhow, so Harry probably won't be in tears over it.


These are the things that will happen
* We will find out what Dudley saw in Order of the Phoenix when he was attacked by the dementor.
* We will find out the true identity of R.A.B., though most fans are quite sure it's Sirius's brother, Regulus.
* We will see Viktor Krum again.
* We will find out a little bit more about Harry's Grandparents.
* We will find out what happened to Sirius' flying motorcycle, "but the real sleuths among us might be able to guess." Care to hazard a guess?
* Wormtail's life debt to Harry will come into play, somehow.
* We will find out what Lily and James did for a living. This piece of information is "important to a later plot." Possibly something Harry finds out during his visit to Godric's Hollow?
* The shroud that surrounds Snape will fall and we will see where his loyalties truly lie.
* One of Harry's classmates will go on to become a teacher, but it isn't "maybe the one you think, hint, hint, hint," and it isn't Ron, either. Our guess is Neville, but we'll see!
* We will find out something extremely important about Lily and James and it will have a direct effect on what Harry has to do. And no, conspiracy theorists, it's not that they were actually both working for Voldemort, an idea that sickened Ms. Rowling (see below).
* We will see Dolores Umbridge again.
* We will see Rita Skeeter again. At the Edinburgh Book Festival, Rowling had this to say: "I actually quite like Rita. She is loathsome - morally, she's horrible - but I can't help admiring her toughness. She is very determined to do the job and there is something quite engaging about that. There is more to come on Rita."
* The last word of the book is "scar," though that may change with future edits.
* We will find out something "incredibly important" about Lily Potter.
* Harry's eye color will come into play. Also, JKR said that "he has his mother's eyes and that's very important in a future book."
* There is "more to the Sorting Hat" than what was presented in the first six books; we will "find out what it becomes" in book seven.
* Although Aunt Petunia is neither a witch nor a Squib, "there is a little bit more to her than meets the eye," and we will find out what that is.
* According to Jo, "one character got a reprieve, but I have to say two die that I didn't intend to die. A price has to be paid. We are dealing with pure evil. They don't target the extras, do they? They go for the main characters, or I do."


What we know might be true, or is likely to happen:
* It is likely we will see the two-way mirror again.
* We may see Sirius again, but we do not know what form it will be in.
* "There is a character who does manage in desperate circumstances to do magic quite late in life, may perform magic in desperate circumstances." We know it's not Petunia (see below)...so, who is it?
* Book seven is predicted to be smaller than Order of the Phoenix. (JKRowling.com Feb. 28, 2006 diary entry)
* If Hogwarts reopens, yet another new teacher will take up the Defense Against the Dark Arts post; perhaps for as long as Professor Merrythought, assuming Harry vanquishes Voldemort.
* Fawkes will likely play a vital role in book 7.
* Harry "might get a different pet."

What we know is not likely to happen:
* Harry will not become a Hogwarts Headmaster.

What will not happen:
* Snape will not be revealed to be a vampire.
* Voldemort will not be revealed to be Harry's, or any other character's, father. That's just sadistic.
* Draco and Hermione will not end up together, nor will they ever, in their wildest, most twisted dreams, even consider it.
* Aunt Petunia will not perform magic, because she is not a witch, nor will she ever be.
* Lupin will not reoccupy his role as Defense Against the Dark Arts teacher.
* Wormtail will not use his silver hand to kill Lupin.
* The Sorting Hat is not a Horcrux.
* Neither Crookshanks nor Mrs. Norris is an Animagus.
* Harry is not a Metamorphmagus.
* Neither Dumbledore, nor any other character in the series, is another character who has come back from the future. If you remember, JKR cleverly wrote in Half-Blood Prince that in the Department of Mysteries skirmish in book five, all of the Ministry's Time Turners were destroyed, proving wrong the ridiculously complicated time-travel theories out there.
* Luna is not Snape's daughter.
* Nicolas Flamel will not teach potions at Hogwarts. He died, remember?
* Luna and Neville will not become a couple...what a shame!
* Harry is not related to Dumbledore.
* Lily Potter is not alive, and she never was a Death Eater.
* Neville is not Peter Pettigrew's son. Just because neither of them have won Witch Weekly's Most Charming Smile Award five times in a row doesn't mean they're related! Really, now...
* Lupin is not a twin.

related resource:
adult living


ratnapro (60)   ranked 491 out of 1,067 in harry potter series  5 years ago

Great work buddy.... Your info was very good...I appreciate ur trouble of gathering such a lot of info
Thanks

Grocery Coupons Free Get Theme Park Coupons on Groceries. Get Free Grocery Coupons Online!  ShopAtHome.com/GroceryCoupons
 
6. myLot reputation of 96/100. lvap0628 (582)   ranked 32 out of 1,067 in harry potter series   5 years ago

We are all playing the waiting game with regards to Book 7 of the Harry Potter series. There are numerous things that we would all like to happen but only JK Rowling has the answers to all our questions. Some of these speculations may come true but even more theories will not. One thing is sure, JKR will not disappoint us.

BuddyTV Read candid news and spoilers, watch TV videos, and play fun games!  http://www.buddytv.com
 
7. myLot reputation of 97/100. meleshia (477)   ranked 523 out of 1,067 in harry potter series   5 years ago

Now, I thought I wasn't as excited as some people are with the outing of the final book, but having read all the debunked/semi-confirmed rumors in this discussion sure does upped my anticipation. Now I can't wait to get my hands on the last book. And I will just content myself with reading the previous books...waah the excitement!!!! XDD


ratnapro (60)   ranked 491 out of 1,067 in harry potter series  5 years ago

U r very right.....I too never get tired of re-reading the previous Harry Potter books.....every time a new theory, a new imagination crops up in my mind....
This is a bit sad that this is gonna be the last Harry Potter novel.

Tradition and Innovation Prepare Young Women for the Future  www.oldfieldsschool.org
 
sponsors
Legos Harry Potter Items
Find Legos Harry Potter Video Games, Playsets& More for Cheap!
www.Calibex.com/Legos-Harry-Potter

Grocery Coupons Free
Get Theme Park Coupons on Groceries. Get Free Grocery Coupons Online!
ShopAtHome.com/GroceryCoupons

BuddyTV
Read candid news and spoilers, watch TV videos, and play fun games!
http://www.buddytv.com

similar discussions
Harry Potter Series in 3D
Hey friend It would be awesome to see harry potter series back to back in 3D The Philosopher's...
Which new Movies 2012 would you like to see this year?
Definately better than rango, i hope so, Are you looking out for some personal favorates to view...
Harry potter series
Harry potter series are so very popular with kids. They want to see all the movies on their home...
Have you read the Harry Potter books?
I don't have time to read but I notice my daughter being interested so much with Harry Potter that...
Harry Potter...final part is coming soon that ends the film sequel
hello everyone, I really love harry potter series of movies...some are really interesting things in...
New Harry Potter Movie
Harry Potter's journey came to an end in the last movie of it entitled "Harry Potter and the...
Do you think that the next book of J.K Rowling will be about Harry Potter again?
I read that Rowling is writing a new book now, and I wonder....Will it be Harry Potter again???I...
which is your favourite book of harry potter series till now?
My favourite book is harry potter and globlet of fire.As her all books are good.But i like this...
Harry Potter - The character you hated most
Ok, so everyone knows Harry Potter. Some cried when it was over, some were relieved. But I bet that...
Modern form of witchcraft....
When I'm still not sensitive on my spiritual aspect in life.. i'm a number one fan of Harry...
sponsors
Legos Harry Potter Items
Find Legos Harry Potter Video Games, Playsets & More for Cheap!
www.Calibex.com/Legos-Harry-Potter
Grocery Coupons Free
Get Theme Park Coupons on Groceries. Get Free Grocery Coupons Online!
ShopAtHome.com/GroceryCoupons
BuddyTV
Read candid news and spoilers, watch TV videos, and play fun games!
http://www.buddytv.com
Tradition and Innovation
Prepare Young Women for the Future
www.oldfieldsschool.org
Movies Online
The Best Movies Online
TrailerAddict.com
Lego Harry Potter Cheap
Best Value for Lego Harry Potter. Find NexTag Sellers' Lowest Price!
www.NexTag.com
lego harry potter the
Find lego harry potter the Online. Free Shipping $50 on 100,000 Items!
www.Target.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.