sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

Which of the 10 existing Star Trek feature films is your favorite  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 84/100. alexdiazgranados (505)   ranked 1 out of 3 in star trek movies 6 years ago

As you may have heard, Paramount Pictures and J.J. Abrams (Alias, Lost) are developing an 11th Star Trek feature film. Rumors about its story center on the possibility that it'll be a prequel to the Original Series and will feature Kirk, Spock and McCoy at Starfleet Academy.

Until Star Trek XI is made and released, though, there are 10 movies out there now, based on the first two television series. Some fans tend to see them as one big film series, while others see them as two distinct storylines, linked only loosely by Star Trek: Generations.

My personal favorite is Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan. Yes, there were other good films, and even the weak ones (Star Treks I, V, Generations, Insurrection, and Nemesis) had their good bits, but for me, the literary allusions, the break from Roddenberry's stranglehold on story ideas, and Nicholas Meyer's fresh approach saved the franchise from being defunct after the ponderous Star Trek: The Motion Picture.

To see how I rank the 10 films out on DVD or VHS, please see http://www.epinions.com/content_4328104068.

Now, can you, without the use of Ceti eels as in Star Trek II, tell me which is your favorite Trek feature film and why? (Again, one-liners with just the title will get negative ratings.)

 

star trek movies
sponsors
Nicholas Meyer Found
Get Nicholas Meyer's Address, Phone Number Background& More!
USSearch.com

Company Rankings
Find Providers of Co. Rankings. Your Business Solution Business.com
www.business.com

Web Sites Ranking
Top million sites ranked by traffic. Unique visitors, Nielsen rating
ranking.com

FloatingGum (310) response was accepted on 12/23/2007.
denotes best response, click it to go to the best response.
tags:  best 10 star trek films, borg, epinions, nicholas meyer, ranking
 
1. myLot reputation of 99/100. twilight021 (1620)   ranked 2 out of 3 in star trek movies   6 years ago

I think "First Contact" is my favorite. The Borg are my favorite star Trek "big bad" and I really enjoyed the interaction between the Borg Queen and Data. The parallel story of the first warp drive was also a fun story that was easy sci-fi...not too scienticically complex while retaining a very human feel.


myLot reputation of 84/100. alexdiazgranados (505)   ranked 1 out of 3 in star trek movies  6 years ago

Good choice. Of the Next Generation films, First Contact is the best one, and I concur with your reasons. I would also like to add that Jerry Goldsmith's score and the relationship between Capt. Picard and Lily add emotional resonance and dramatic depth to this film.

Thanks for your response!

Nicholas Meyer Found Get Nicholas Meyer's Address, Phone Number Background & More!  USSearch.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 99/100. groomtobe23 (427)   6 years ago

Of the ten films, I liked First Contact the best, because it was an evolving storyling that had a ton of dramatic overtones. Of the ten, it is right up there with The Voyage Home in regards to sheer number of times I have seen it. (I wouldn't put Part IV in my top list though...lol) I know though, that I am excited about possibly getting to see a new Star Trek film make it to theaters.


myLot reputation of 84/100. alexdiazgranados (505)   ranked 1 out of 3 in star trek movies  6 years ago

I like the way First Contact blended elements from all the existing TV shows (as of 1994), including Voyager and Deep Space Nine, plus James Cromwell really did a great job as Zefram Cochrane.

Company Rankings Find Providers of Co. Rankings. Your Business Solution Business.com  www.business.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 90/100. FloatingGum (310)   ranked 3 out of 3 in star trek movies   6 years ago

My favorite was The Undiscovered Country. I just have this thing for Klingons...

Seriously, I like the whole script in that and how it's acted and how it plays out. Yes, Kirk admits he's WRONG about something, he's not GOD and PERFECT. It has a good deal of comedy amid the crisis as well.

I don't think I will like a prequel. These always tend to contradict what's already aired because writers and directors come in with a story to tell rather than looking at the history we already know from the series. I am not optimistic if this is the direction they take.


myLot reputation of 84/100. alexdiazgranados (505)   ranked 1 out of 3 in star trek movies  6 years ago

"You've not experienced Shakespeare until you've heard him in the original Klingon."

Interesting how Nick Meyer was able to get creative freedom and tweak Star Trek beyond Roddenberry's somewhat naive "Starfleet captains aren't soldiers, they're explorers" Utopian views and "there can be no conflict between the crew members" dogma. That "social commentary" along these lines was relevant during The Original Series' run from 1966 to 1969 is "sans reproach," as it were, but asking writers to create films without conflict (overt or suggested) was one reason Roddenberry was eased out as Executive Producer of ST-TNG.

As Meyer has said in his audio commentaries to Star Trek II and The Undiscovered Country, he benefited greatly from being a Trek outsider. He was willing to keep what worked from the mythos of Kirk and the Enterprise, but he was compelled to also follow his own path as a storyteller, which is why The Wrath of Khan and your fave film work so damn well.

Web Sites Ranking Top million sites ranked by traffic. Unique visitors, Nielsen rating  ranking.com
 
4. myLot reputation of 71/100. handsomeitaliano (762)   3 years ago

I can tell you which one was the absolute worst of them all:
http://www.cinemaroll.com...

#1 Agriculture Stock BION Why Smart Investors Consider Agriculture "The Next Bull Cycle" -> BION  www.BioNitrogen.com/Invest_Today
 
sponsors
#1 Agriculture Stock BION
Why Smart Investors Consider Agriculture "The Next Bull Cycle" -> BION
www.BioNitrogen.com/Invest_Today

Get Online Degrees Fast
Get University Degree Online Faster. Explore Financial Aid Options Now
University-College.com/University

Finding A Niche Is Easy..
Always Ready To Deliver Your Niche Fast, Easy, Affordable Niche Tool
Niche-Sensei.com

sponsors
#1 Agriculture Stock BION
Why Smart Investors Consider Agriculture "The Next Bull Cycle" -> BION
www.BioNitrogen.com/Invest_Today
Get Online Degrees Fast
Get University Degree Online Faster. Explore Financial Aid Options Now
University-College.com/University
Finding A Niche Is Easy..
Always Ready To Deliver Your Niche Fast, Easy, Affordable Niche Tool
Niche-Sensei.com
Mutual Fund
Invest In Money Market Mutual Funds. See Exclusive Online Offers Today.
firstcountybank.com
Mutual Funds
Learn about the Top Performing Mutual Funds, Today!
ssgaFunds.com/MutualFunds
Rates Hit Low 2.90% APR
Fannie Mae Cuts Requirements to Refi. Calculate New Mortgage Rate Now!
www.MortgageRatesExperts.com
What Is Mutual Fund
Looking For What Is Mutual Fund? Find It Nearby With Local.com!
Local.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.