the last 10 people
By winterose
@winterose (39887)
Canada
March 5, 2007 9:25pm CST
okay this is one of those questions that really doesn't have one right answer, every answer is right but it is a great question to debate.
There has been a nuclear holocaust 15 people survive. There is a boat that can take them to safety on a nuclear fallout free deserted island where they can start a new colony to preserve human kind.
The trouble is there are only places for 10 people, five people will be left behind.
Which ten would you choose, starting from the most important to the least important.
which five would be left behind, and why.
Here are the 15 people in no particular order
mr. and mrs brown from New york city, they are a young couple, newly married and do not yet have children
3. a pastor from saginauy michigan (male)
4. a doctor from London England (female)
5. a chemist from Shanghai, China (female)
6. an engineer from Montreal, Canada (male)
7. a Farmer from Israel (male)
8. a hollywood actor (male)
9. Female Jazz singer
10. an old sea captain from, Sydney Australia (male)
11. A male animal hunter from Africa
12. a new born baby girl, no one knows where she is from
13. a female teacher from Italy who speaks 7 languages
14. a young boy about 17 who is a computer geek from Madrid Spain
15. a retired nurse from Germany
Every one of these people share one thing in common they all speak your language.
Which ten people would you choose and why?
Which 5 people would you leave behind and why?
The faith of humanity rests upon your decision.
4 responses
@ElicBxn (64169)
• United States
6 Mar 07
All right, first I would include the Brown's because they are capable of reproducing and having children, vital to the start of a new world.
The doctor from London, medical care will be critcal in this new world and she can also reproduce - well, one assumes so and hopefully she will have trained a midwife by the time she needs one.
The chemist, not only is she female, but there will probably be a need for at least some simple chemistry in the new world - maybe she & the doctor can figure out some simple medicines.
The engineer, even if it is as simple as working out levers, or bridges, he can be helpful, besides providing a larger gene base.
The farmer - well, duhhhhh, this is going to be a critical skill in their new world.
The big game hunter, because there will probably be a need for hunting at least to some part (he might find his game is smaller than he likes.)
The baby girl, because the genetic pool will always need to be larger and to provide potential mates to the sons of the Brown's.
The teenager, he can be retrained to a new skill (farming?) and he can also provide a younger person to be between the young babies & the adults.
And the sea captain - because who's going to get them to the island.
An older man can still provide genetic stock while an older woman, can't. I left off the actor, the jazz singer, the teacher, the nurse and the pastor because, while the teacher might have needed skills, in this new world, education will probably go back to the teacher/apprentice sort of training situation, and the entertainers, because they don't really have a skill that'll help survival. The pastor might just annoy everyone, we don't know anything else about him, so we can't be sure, better to not take the chance and the nurse, well, we assume the nurse is female, but still, the only old person we know I'm taking it the sailor because he has a useful skill (and probably can fish after they get there.)
2 people like this
@winterose (39887)
• Canada
6 Mar 07
I like your reasoning it is fun how everyone's answers are going to be different.
@foxyfire33 (10005)
• United States
6 Mar 07
This was a tricky one...
1&2 Mr. and Mrs. Brown-they would be needed to hopefully help repopulate. Since the are a young couple, they have a good chance of producing children. Ans because of their age (hers in particular) they will have time to have a large number of children.
3.the Pastor-Since all but one of the people I'm choosing is an adult or close to it, I'm assuming their faiths, if any, are already established. I think the pastor in this situation would be important to emotional well being and willing to be open to other faiths if any are present.
4.the doctor-if these are the only people, they will need to remain healthy if there is to be any hope for mankind. I think a doctor would be important.
5.the chemist-considering the primitive situation they will be living in, I doubt a chemist would be very helpful.
6.an engineer-similar as the chemist, under the circumstances don't think his abilities would be able to be put to use.
7. the farmer-his knowledge would be very valuable to their survival. He will have better knowledge on how to begin crops, care for them and store the harvest.
8. Hollywood actor- I think he wouldn't be vital under the circumstances.
9.jazz singer-She could be useful as a female but without a usable skill, she would have to stay behind.
10. old sea captain-He has experience on the seas. There would be no point in choosing who to put on the boat if no one knew how to sail it. Also perhaps he would have time to return for the other 5.
11. animal hunter-his skills would also be extremely important to their survival. Unless this new world became strictly vegan, they would need to have some one knowledgeable in hunting animals for meat.
12.newborn girl- she would be needed as the beginning of the second generation. She would be a guarantee that the Brown's son, should they have one, would have a partner (besides their own sisters).
13.teacher- she would be important because she is a female and a teacher, her language skills would only be helpful if they wanted to preserve all the languages instead of just using the one they have in common.
14.young boy- He wouldn't be needed for his computer skills but for his age. The main goal of this group of people is to repopulate. A younger boy/man has a higher chance of being fertile.
15.retired nurse-I really wanted to put her on too but didn't have the room. She would have been helpful to the doctor. Actually I assumed female although it didn't specify. I chose to leave her behind because although her skills could have been put to use, if she is retired she is most likely past her childbearing years.
1 person likes this
@winterose (39887)
• Canada
6 Mar 07
very interesting choices I am assuming you put them in order of one to 10 on the priority list?
@foxyfire33 (10005)
• United States
6 Mar 07
Well no, I listed them in the same order as you did. I put my reasoning for taking them or leaving them beside each of their names/titles. If I had to put them in order of importance I would first have to consider what "things" would be more important. I'll give it some thought and get back to you though.
@joey_matthews (8354)
•
7 Mar 07
Hey =)
The five which I would keep.
1. a doctor from London England (female)
2. an engineer from Montreal, Canada (male)
3. a new born baby girl, no one knows where she is from
4. a female teacher from Italy who speaks 7 languages
5. A male animal hunter from Africa
I did this list by which would be needed more. Of course the island would need a doctor and someone who can understands how to mend and build things. (most know electric and diy too)
The baby girl wouldn't be anything, so the possible to gain knowledge and allow her to become what ever the island needs. (well being young) which is important.
The teacher is very important to pass and help the growth, awhile the hunter can find food and the experience is very, very useful for survival.
Kudos,
~Joey
1 person likes this
@winterose (39887)
• Canada
7 Mar 07
Joey you had five more choices, only five had to be left behind that is why it is called the last 10 people lol
@revdauphinee (5703)
• United States
6 Mar 07
mr. and mrs brown from New york city, they are a young couple, newly married and do not yet have children (Take)
3. a pastor from saginauy michigan (male) (leave behind he probably dosent share my beliefs anyway)
4. a doctor from London England (female) Take will be needed
5. a chemist from Shanghai, China (female) (leave)
6. an engineer from Montreal, Canada (male) (take)
7. a Farmer from Israel (male) (Take will definatly need)
8. a hollywood actor (male) (leave not nececary)
9. Female Jazz singer (also leave)
10. an old sea captain from, Sydney Australia (male)
( take)
11. A male animal hunter from Africa (take will be usefull)
12. a new born baby girl, no one knows where she is from
(take she needs a chance at life)
13. a female teacher from Italy who speaks 7 languages
(leave not needed)
14. a young boy about 17 who is a computer geek from Madrid Spain (take)
15. a retired nurse from Germany (take)
1 person likes this
@winterose (39887)
• Canada
7 Mar 07
not exactly who I would pick though,
for example the teacher is needed to teach the young ones as they grow up.





