sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionsblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLot

Dubt on Gandalf (Lord of the Rings)... email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 95/100. Astarte (569)   ranked 7 out of 76 in lord of the rings1 year ago

I have always wondered how come Galdalf uses so little the magic. He should be a powerful wizard, but when he fights with the enemies he always uses the wand! Few times he cast some spell and never during the fights. For instance, when there is the monster of the gates of Moria an any magician would have launched a spell against him, a lightning, a spellbound dart, etc. Gandalf doesn't do anything and doesn't even do anything when there is the final battle, always use and only the wand! Yet somehow he has defeated the demon that is found to Moria.. but as if it never uses his enchantments? What do you think about it? How come doesn't Galdalf ever use the magic?


Gandalf
 
 
lord of the rings
sponsors
Lord Of The Rings
Browse a huge selection now. Find exactly what you want today.
www.ebay.com

Discover Lord of the Rings Puzzles
Purchase Lord of the Rings Puzzles at AreYouGame.com.
www.areyougame.com

American Smeagol T-Shirts
The only clothing that Gollum wears. Get Lord of the Rings Tees Today.
SqueezeShirts.com

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  gandalf, lotr, wizard, lord of the rings, magic
 
1. myLot reputation of 63/100. GnosticGoddess (3421)   ranked 23 out of 76 in lord of the rings   1 year ago

I think it's because he doesn't want to depend solely on his magic. I think he only uses it when he has to. I think it is good because if everyone always depended on him and his magic for everything they'd never learn to defend themselves. I think that's probably another reason.


myLot reputation of 95/100. Astarte (569)   ranked 7 out of 76 in lord of the rings  1 year ago

Thanx for your opinion:)

Lord Of The Rings Browse a huge selection now. Find exactly what you want today. www.ebay.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 71/100. Willowlady (9093)   ranked 22 out of 76 in lord of the rings   1 year ago

With the gift of magic there comes responsibility. Just because you can does not mean you should. Long thought is required before we wield a power. The effects can be long reaching and without our scope. At his age too and the understanding he has perhaps it was expected that he use his magic and that was his advantage to not to do so. I was content with this performance. There was enough magic to be believable that he was indeed a wizard. Grey or White.


myLot reputation of 95/100. Astarte (569)   ranked 7 out of 76 in lord of the rings  1 year ago

Interesting opinion:)

Discover Lord of the Rings Puzzles Purchase Lord of the Rings Puzzles at AreYouGame.com. www.areyougame.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 84/100. Booker_t79 (187)   ranked 3 out of 76 in lord of the rings   1 year ago

he did not wanted to be consume by the power of wand. he has used the power when needed since he saw no option like saving Faramir when they were retreating from osligargth after they were attacked by hte orks from river since he had no choice. like i said he did want the power to take over him


myLot reputation of 95/100. Astarte (569)   ranked 7 out of 76 in lord of the rings  1 year ago

But.. WHY? if he is Gandalf the White, not a young wizard but an expert wizard that win against a Daemon..why he think that the power take over him?? He should must to control totally this power..

American Smeagol T-Shirts The only clothing that Gollum wears. Get Lord of the Rings Tees Today. SqueezeShirts.com
 
4. olorin_majestic (1)   1 year ago

until gandalf became gandalf, the white his powers were very limited. after he becomes white he does break saurman's staff. we can onlyy assume that he doen't use much magic after that as he didn't have to or that he lost most of his powers when he came from valinor. remember saurman was originally meant to lead the wizards against sauron before he became evil.

JRR Tolkien's Lord of the Rings Music Celtic music CD inspired by Lord of the Rings tribute CD. Features the free Celtic gold single MP3 by the Brobdingnagian Bards. Over 2.5 million Mp3s downloaded. tolkien.bardscrier.com
 
5. myLot reputation of 91/100. missak (1152)   ranked 1 out of 76 in lord of the rings   1 year ago

You're talking about the film, I think. Aren't you interested in the books? The personality of Gandalf is more devolopped on "The Hobbit" while the story of his mission in the world is narrated in the "Silmarillion". Gandalf has been sent by Illuvatar, the God over all gods (Valars) when he realized the other one sent (Saruman) was corrupted by darkness. So he had not as much magic knowledges as Saruman, but he was more clever.

Yahoo! Music: Free Videos Watch what you want, when you want. Music Videos On-Demand. Free. music.yahoo.com
 
6. myLot reputation of 64/100. Cephoozee (329)   1 year ago

Well..if you really want to get techinal and philosophical, okay. First of all..from my understanding of thr wizards and spellcasters of Middle Earth, the power is in their voice, Gandalf uses his magic through the movie..destorying the bridge to save the fellowship and take down the Balrog and into his ascension into White. Indeed the Nazgul have their own magic, such as their demonic screeches, which in the books describes as the effect on men being to cower in catonic fear, it was Gandalf's voice that kept the men of Minas Tirith fighting. Secondly, I think that if Gandalf used too powerful of a spell he would kill those he was trying to protect..sure, he could probably very easily destroy the whole of the Orc army with a giant fireball from the sky, but that would end up killing the Men of middle Earth as well. Thirdly, if he always used his magic, the Men of middle earth would come to depend on it and become cowards, always begging for aide from the White Wizard.*deep breathe* And on another side note, did anyone know that Sauron, is actually of the same order that Gandalf and Saruman are from, only he "ascended" even farther into the colors, and is an ultimate Black...he was Sauron the Black before become the Dark Lord of Mordor. and his master before that. I think the order of mages and Wizards is called the Order of Excellion..I'm not sure. but yeah,^.^

Lord of The Rings Jewelry Buy LOTR jewelry direct from New Zealand. Free gift wrapping. www.ShopNewZealand.co.nz
 
sponsors
JRR Tolkien's Lord of the Rings Music
Celtic music CD inspired by Lord of the Rings tribute CD. Features the free Celtic gold single MP3 by the Brobdingnagian Bards. Over 2.5 million Mp3s downloaded.
tolkien.bardscrier.com

Yahoo! Music: Free Videos
Watch what you want, when you want. Music Videos On-Demand. Free.
music.yahoo.com

Lord of The Rings Jewelry
Buy LOTR jewelry direct from New Zealand. Free gift wrapping.
www.ShopNewZealand.co.nz

similar discussions
Why did Gandalf turn into the White Wizard
my knowledge on the lorf of the rings is limited. What I have always wondered is Why did Gandalf...
How powerful really is Gandalf?
I noticed that Gandalf really did not do anything much in the movies, except when He had some kind...
which chareter you like most in lords of the ring
i like the charecter of aragon whts u
Will you stil watch "The Hobbit" even if...
Even if Peter Jackson (Lord of the Rings) would not be directing the new version of "The...
Who is ur favourite character in lord of the rings?
For me its Aragorn, what about u?
sponsors
JRR Tolkien's Lord of the Rings Music
Celtic music CD inspired by Lord of the Rings tribute CD. Features the free Celtic gold single MP3 by the Brobdingnagian Bards. Over 2.5 million Mp3s downloaded.
tolkien.bardscrier.com
Yahoo! Music: Free Videos
Watch what you want, when you want. Music Videos On-Demand. Free.
music.yahoo.com
Lord of The Rings Jewelry
Buy LOTR jewelry direct from New Zealand. Free gift wrapping.
www.ShopNewZealand.co.nz