sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

gibson vs.fender..the great debate..  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 99/100. scarlet_woman (11395)   ranked 35 out of 8,281 in listening to music 5 years ago

ok..i have seen discussions go on for hours over this one..
if you play,which is your fave and why?
if you like another type instead,that's ok to mention also..

 

listening to music
sponsors
Air Conditioning Repair
Affordable Air Conditioning Service& Repair
www.theplumbingdoctoronline.com

Cash For Gold, 100% Real
30+ Years of Honest Business. Get 3x the Cash for Your Gold!
www.CashForGoldUSA.com

eBay ® - Official Site
Get great deals on eBay. Buy It Now or Win It!
www.eBay.com

KrazyKlingon (3288) response was accepted on 3/14/2007.
denotes best response, click it to go to the best response.
tags:  fender, gibson, epiphone, fender stratocaster, gretsch
 
1. myLot reputation of 96/100. Jaytech (675)   ranked 333 out of 8,281 in listening to music   5 years ago

I prefer Gretsch guitars, I don't dislike Fender or Gibson I'm a player & love them all. But Gretsch have this big fat warm tone that I just can't get from another guitar.

Although you may not know that Gretsch guitars are now built & distributed by Fender. They teamed up in 2004 & the quality of the guitars is now so much better, I thank Fender for getting involved :)


myLot reputation of 99/100. scarlet_woman (11395)   ranked 35 out of 8,281 in listening to music  5 years ago

fender owns gretsch now?i didn't hear that
i'll have to check into that it sounds interesting


myLot reputation of 96/100. Jaytech (675)   ranked 333 out of 8,281 in listening to music  5 years ago

No they don't own Gretsch, they teamed up, Fender build & manufacture Gretsch.

http://www.gretschguitars...

It explains there :)


myLot reputation of 99/100. scarlet_woman (11395)   ranked 35 out of 8,281 in listening to music  5 years ago

ah!
thanks for the link-i will check it out :)

Air Conditioning Repair Affordable Air Conditioning Service & Repair  www.theplumbingdoctoronline.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 92/100. pitstop (2315)   ranked 685 out of 8,281 in listening to music   5 years ago

I've used a Fender just once and was impressed - as you can guess. Never used a gibson.
I always assumed that a Fender was better, but my lack of actually using both makes me a poor judge!


myLot reputation of 99/100. scarlet_woman (11395)   ranked 35 out of 8,281 in listening to music  5 years ago

you should try one if you get a chance-you might like it :)

Cash For Gold, 100% Real 30+ Years of Honest Business. Get 3x the Cash for Your Gold!  www.CashForGoldUSA.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 83/100. KrazyKlingon (3288)   ranked 162 out of 8,281 in listening to music   5 years ago

I have actually used both, Fender & Gibson guitars. It is very difficult to describe, but both brands are great guitars. However, it is usually easier to replace a broken string on a Gibson Les Paul or a Gibson Flying Vee than a Fender Stratocaster. It actually depends on the type of sound you want, especially if you're one of those who can hear what type of guitar is being used in various parts of a song.

The only difference I have run into between a Gibson & a Fender, particularly with electric guitars, is that Gibson guitars are more expensive.


myLot reputation of 99/100. scarlet_woman (11395)   ranked 35 out of 8,281 in listening to music  5 years ago

i know what you mean-i borrowed a friend's strat

i never tried a gibson v model but i did have a dean
for awhile.god,it had beautiful tone to it.
pickups sucked tho-had changed them out for di marzio's.


myLot reputation of 83/100. KrazyKlingon (3288)   ranked 162 out of 8,281 in listening to music  5 years ago

Unfortunately, the Gibson Flying V is a discontinued guitar. Michael Schenker (one of the original founders of The Scorpions with his older brother, Rudolf) seems to have endorsed a relatively unknown brand of guitars that make their flying Vee's (Dean Guitars). I don't know if it is some kind of partnership between Michael & the guitar maker or if he actually is maybe one of their biggest customers.


myLot reputation of 96/100. Lewah69 (1166)  5 years ago

As i read Dean guitars in your post scarlet women, doesn´t Dave Mustaine play a kind of Flying V model from that guitar brand? i think so.


myLot reputation of 83/100. KrazyKlingon (3288)   ranked 162 out of 8,281 in listening to music  5 years ago

It is a possibility, Mike. On the website for Dean guitars, there is a list of musicians who regularly use Dean guitars.

BTW, on another note - if I was to have a guitar dropped on my toes, I'd rather that it be a Fender because it won't hurt as much as a Gibson.


myLot reputation of 96/100. Lewah69 (1166)  5 years ago

Yeah... LOL hope you are not talking from own experience, haha. I never had a Flying V model in my hands i wonder how it feels sitting at home and practicing on it. I think the Firebird is a great Gibson model in guitars a friend of mine has one, awesome.

ps. About Dean guitars yes i found a video on Youtube, Dave Mustaine presenting his new Dean guitar at the NAMM show 2007. As he get´s asked what he thinks about it, he replays: "awesome, i can´t wait to beat up someone with this guitar" ...LOL.. he´s so damn funny in that video.

www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dhb7FTsctMA

hope you don´t mind me puting this link on here scarlet women.


myLot reputation of 99/100. scarlet_woman (11395)   ranked 35 out of 8,281 in listening to music  5 years ago

no problem-i don't mind at all-plus i get to check it too :)

eBay ® - Official Site Get great deals on eBay. Buy It Now or Win It!  www.eBay.com
 
4. mckgamer (21)   ranked 2,912 out of 8,281 in listening to music   5 years ago

I like Gibson better. I have both a Fender Strat and a Les Paul, and the Les Paul just has a nice warm tone. Of course, Fender is great too, just depends on what song you are playing. Overall though, I notice myself picking up my Gibson more often.


myLot reputation of 99/100. scarlet_woman (11395)   ranked 35 out of 8,281 in listening to music  5 years ago

i hear ya.i used to have a deluxe myself
*sniff* i miss it.
been leaning toward ibanez the last few years
but i'd love to have a gibson again

Jerry's Pawn Shop 404-207-1162 Atlanta's Leading Pawnbroker for over 55 years  www.jerryspawn.com
 
5. myLot reputation of 96/100. Lewah69 (1166)   5 years ago

Yes right i think this debate will still be on air at the last day of manchild... LOL

For my self i prefer and also use a Fender Strat and most of it has to do with the pickups. I love that sound of the single coil pickups in my opinion they also react much better on expressiv playing as the humbuckers. Some people i know mostly replace the bridge pickup for a humbucker but i wouldn´t do that to my guitar. But yes Gibson guitars are also great, i specialy like the Firebird and the SG models, i´m not very fond of the Les Paul body form it´s somehow not very affecttionate.

ps. As K.K. befor me said that Gibson is very expensive i really agree on that fact.


myLot reputation of 99/100. scarlet_woman (11395)   ranked 35 out of 8,281 in listening to music  5 years ago

a friend of mine just got an SG doubleneck..
he's in love LOL

i know people who complain of the weight of the bodyform-
some have switched to hamer-it's not quite the same,tho slightly similar in shape it is a much lighter guitar i'll give them that


myLot reputation of 96/100. Lewah69 (1166)  5 years ago

Hi there,
wooohhhh... a SG doubleneck, that must be a heavy load to carry. I remember John Mc´Laughlin from the Mahavishnu Orchestra played mostly one in their concerts or even great Jimmi Page. I think one day if i have the money i get me a normal SG model to have a second guitar that has a different sound to the Strat i have. They are very expencive her in germany as all Gibson guitars.


myLot reputation of 99/100. scarlet_woman (11395)   ranked 35 out of 8,281 in listening to music  5 years ago

yea-the person in question is a big page fan
that's where most of his influence lies.
he picked it up for..i think he said $1500 w/case


myLot reputation of 96/100. Lewah69 (1166)  5 years ago

Hello, you said $ 1500 that´s a very good price you know what... i tell you this in Germany i saw this guitar in a store and it coasts 3900 € (Euro) that´s about $ 4800, that´s just ridiculous, who would pay that much for a SG doubleneck. The funny thing besides is that on a website from that store it said you save 740 € if you order, so the normal price would be 4640 €, imagine that price just for a guitar. I paid about 1000 € for my Fender Strat i think that was enough money. Here´s a pic for you.

bye Mike



myLot reputation of 99/100. scarlet_woman (11395)   ranked 35 out of 8,281 in listening to music  5 years ago

beautiful!
what year is that?

yea-he got a steal on that SG,i've seen it for much more
a lot of times they don't come with the case anymore you have to buy it separately.
either that,or they give you a gig bag if anything.
i really wouldn't put a guitar i valued in a gig bag.
i'd be afraid of something happening to it.


myLot reputation of 96/100. Lewah69 (1166)  5 years ago

Oh... it´s sadly not from the 50´s.. LOL

i bought it in 2002. It´s built similar to the ones from the 50´s bought with some better modifications, like it come swith Texas Special pickups, which are much better then the regular ones built in a American Standard Strat.
Also it has special mechanics which put more tension especialy on the higher strings and some more. I bought a lot of guitars in the past 19 years but that´s the best i ever got. Befor i had a low price Fender Strat which was really rotten but it was cheap and i didn´t have much money for spending on guitars that time. I just don´t understand why we in Germany have to pay such more money for them then in the U.S. Do you play guitar for longer?


myLot reputation of 99/100. scarlet_woman (11395)   ranked 35 out of 8,281 in listening to music  5 years ago

no-that definitely isn't fair you guys pay more
i guess they consider it an import over there
imported things always cost more :(

um..i've been playing on and off for about 20 yrs..i recently switched to bass because of a serious lack of bass players around.

i think i'm a better artist tho,but i have fun ;)


myLot reputation of 83/100. KrazyKlingon (3288)   ranked 162 out of 8,281 in listening to music  5 years ago

I'm thinking the reason it costs more in Germany is maybe they make it in the United States or elsewhere, & then it gets imported into Germany?


myLot reputation of 99/100. scarlet_woman (11395)   ranked 35 out of 8,281 in listening to music  5 years ago

that's what i'm thinking-the import fees :(


myLot reputation of 96/100. Lewah69 (1166)  5 years ago

Ok, yes sure i´m not a idiot it´s normal to pay more for imported stuff but we pay far to much for music instruments here in Germany. Also if i look into theFender.com site to read up their price lists the page doesn´t show up for me. I think because i´m login in from Germany so just please do me a favour and look into that site and tell me if you can see that list if your login in from the U.S.

http://www.fender.com


myLot reputation of 99/100. scarlet_woman (11395)   ranked 35 out of 8,281 in listening to music  5 years ago

it wouldn't show for me at first either
i had to let it update adobe reader

if you still can't get in lemme know
i can look up something if you wish


myLot reputation of 96/100. Lewah69 (1166)  5 years ago

Oh great... thanks, you´re to kind
well i had another try but it doesn´t work maybe i do someting wrong, just a blank page shows up. But i would just be interested in how much a regular American Stratocaster would coast in the States.

ps. as you said you also play bass, do you play in a group?
and by the way my 5 year younger brother plays bass guitar and we play together for long time now.


myLot reputation of 99/100. scarlet_woman (11395)   ranked 35 out of 8,281 in listening to music  5 years ago

ok..average price looks like $2142.84 w/case
although-they do have a robert cray model for $928.57

um..not presently.my mom requires 24/7 care,not an option right now.maybe in the future tho.
very cool!
my brother also used to play bass-he had to give it up tho
he started to have a serious problem with his wrist.


myLot reputation of 96/100. Lewah69 (1166)  5 years ago

Wow... is that the American standard model? that´s a high price for it, or is it a special model. I think that´s a good price for the Robert Cray model, i know it´s sold for about 850 € here in Germany (that´s about $1060).

ps. sorry i somehow got mixed up and gave the have of my comment what sould be written here to my comment on your Remake topic... LOL i think this wouldn´t be happening when i would write in german language. nice day


myLot reputation of 99/100. scarlet_woman (11395)   ranked 35 out of 8,281 in listening to music  5 years ago

it seemed to have the same price as the yngwie-unless there's a typo

no worries-i've mixed things up writing before too.
it just happens.


myLot reputation of 96/100. Lewah69 (1166)  5 years ago

Oh yes... the Malmsteen signature model is great, i had it once in my hands but i´m not used to scalloped fretboard. It also features some similar to the model i have, like the colour vintage white i really love. Alder body, maple neck & fingerboard & american syncronized tremolo bridge. The price was about 2000 € that´s a lot, double price for the one i own.


myLot reputation of 99/100. scarlet_woman (11395)   ranked 35 out of 8,281 in listening to music  5 years ago

another friend of mine also has a similar model
it's a 1990-no blonding whatsoever of the white
i was amazed it was 17 years old-he's taken good care of it


myLot reputation of 83/100. KrazyKlingon (3288)   ranked 162 out of 8,281 in listening to music  5 years ago

Last time I looked at Gibson or Fender guitar sites, they did not show their prices. I actually had to do searches for prices from various guitar sellers. My conclusion is that they don't sell guitars individually. They only sell/ship to distributors or musical equipment sellers.

Local Fender Stratocaster Find Fender Stratocaster Near You. See Actual Customer Reviews!  Local.com
 
6. myLot reputation of 92/100. RachelleDD (368)   ranked 1,512 out of 8,281 in listening to music   5 years ago

I've played the guitar since I was 12. I own a celebrity ovation, beautiful guitar with a deep smooth sound...It wouldnt matter to me if it was a beef bucket with strings stretched across the top, if the sound is there, its there..lol..


myLot reputation of 99/100. scarlet_woman (11395)   ranked 35 out of 8,281 in listening to music  5 years ago

LOL!

i've seen some acoustic ovations in the last few years
that have a fiberglass type body instead of wood.
it sounds really good-i was amazed


myLot reputation of 92/100. RachelleDD (368)   ranked 1,512 out of 8,281 in listening to music  5 years ago

I think I may have an original, but cant be sure, I do know that the guitar is really old. I purchased it second hand about 15 years ago...got a good deal on it as well. Every now and then I'll go searching to see if the guitar is worth anything, but no luck thus far...thanks for the site on the comic books...cant get the hubby off the puter now..lol


myLot reputation of 83/100. KrazyKlingon (3288)   ranked 162 out of 8,281 in listening to music  5 years ago

If you share the computer, & want him off of it so you can get on, try singing in your WORST voice. It might just annoy him enough to get him off the computer so he could have some peace & quiet.


myLot reputation of 99/100. scarlet_woman (11395)   ranked 35 out of 8,281 in listening to music  5 years ago

rachelle-
i'm not sure if musician's friend has a value listing for guitars there..you could check-or at least compare to newer ovations..might help

i guess you wouldn't want him seeing the wizard website then..hehe :)


myLot reputation of 92/100. RachelleDD (368)   ranked 1,512 out of 8,281 in listening to music  5 years ago

there is another site?..oh dear lord, if he knows there is another one to appraise or sell his comics I dont think i will ever get a chance to look at the computer screen ever again...lol...


myLot reputation of 99/100. scarlet_woman (11395)   ranked 35 out of 8,281 in listening to music  5 years ago

LOL!
those are the two most accurate ones..although the market fluctuates by demand and what people are willing to pay.
tho some comics,especially the first issue,you could auction and practically name your own price.
like detective comics #1-i think that's up to 5 figures now..

Pawn Shop. Instant Cash. Sell. Loan. Cash-instantly.Gold, diamond, watches, cars, etc.  www.a-pawnshop.com/
 
7. ripley84 (26)   ranked 4,753 out of 8,281 in listening to music   5 years ago

it really depends on what type of music your into or what sound you want to create. i have played a fender lite ash telecaster and a gibson les paul studio, i equally liked them both but i perfer to use the gibson because i tend to play heavier stuff. The Les Paul's humbuckers respond well to distortion.


myLot reputation of 99/100. scarlet_woman (11395)   ranked 35 out of 8,281 in listening to music  5 years ago

i agree-an ex of mine used to play hamer also-
the pickups seemed very similar to those of gibson,
they surprised me how well they took distortion.
i can't remember if his were entirely stock,but i think they were.he had a habit of changing them out on most of them.

Generous Loans on All Baltimore's oldest & most trusted Pawnshop since 1922. Family-owned.  BaltimorePawns.com
 
8. myLot reputation of 74/100. xfallenxlostx (1811)   ranked 1,430 out of 8,281 in listening to music   5 years ago

i really like Gibson and Epiphone. i have an Epiphone SG 310 in black. It is a beautiful guitar. i need to get back to playing. i didn't play the whole time i was in the hospital and have not plyed since...so i haven't played since some time before December 9, 2003. Wow, that is a long time. i wonder if i even remember anything...


myLot reputation of 99/100. scarlet_woman (11395)   ranked 35 out of 8,281 in listening to music  5 years ago

epi's are nice.a friend of my just bought an ace frehley model epiphone.

Rated #1 Gold Buyers Sell Gold Jewelry - Highest Payouts - #1 Place to Sell Your Gold  http://www.goldbuyerct.net
 
9. myLot reputation of 99/100. recycledgoth (7430)   ranked 1,817 out of 8,281 in listening to music   5 years ago

I asked my partner on this one hun, he's the guitarist here. He has a Gibson Les Paul, a Fender Telecaster and a Fender Stratocaster but he lusts after a Gretsch White Falcon. I pushed him to give me one choice and he eventually chose the Gibson.


myLot reputation of 99/100. scarlet_woman (11395)   ranked 35 out of 8,281 in listening to music  5 years ago

a falcon! pretty guitar indeed:)
i can see how it was a hard choice for him.


American Standard -63% Great deals on American Standard! Compare prices and save up to 63%.  www.best-deal.com/American-Standard
 
sponsors
Jerry's Pawn Shop
404-207-1162 Atlanta's Leading Pawnbroker for over 55 years
www.jerryspawn.com

Local Fender Stratocaster
Find Fender Stratocaster Near You. See Actual Customer Reviews!
Local.com

Pawn Shop. Instant Cash.
Sell. Loan. Cash-instantly.Gold, diamond, watches, cars, etc.
www.a-pawnshop.com/

similar discussions
What do you think of my guitar?
I have a Fender Stratocaster, made in USA, 16 years old. I think it's a great guitar, I'm...
Fender or Gibson?
While I personally own a Fender American Strat and I love it, I also love the feel of my dad's...
favoite brand
what is your favorite brand of guitar and why? I think that my favorite brand would have to be...
Freddy Fender
Yesterday i met my good friend , Ann for lunch at a new mexican restaurant. It was the first time...
What type of guitar do you have?
I have an epiphone..What types do you think are the most popular? or of best quality?
What brand of Guitar are you?
Gibson, Ibanez, Jackson, Fender? I personally prefer Ibanez because of their playability!
Who is a guitar player here in Mylot?
I would like to be in contact with other guitar players here, to share ideas and discuss about our...
Gibson or Fender?
I'm an intermediate guitarist who's been playing for about 2 years. My first guitar was a good old...
Electrical guitar made outside US?
I heard many famous brand like Fender and Ibanez is made in Korea,Japan and China.So it is not made...
Which brand do you think makes the best guitars?
Alright musicians! There are many brands of guitars out there, but the most popular brands that...
sponsors
Jerry's Pawn Shop
404-207-1162 Atlanta's Leading Pawnbroker for over 55 years
www.jerryspawn.com
Local Fender Stratocaster
Find Fender Stratocaster Near You. See Actual Customer Reviews!
Local.com
Pawn Shop. Instant Cash.
Sell. Loan. Cash-instantly.Gold, diamond, watches, cars, etc.
www.a-pawnshop.com/
Generous Loans on All
Baltimore's oldest & most trusted Pawnshop since 1922. Family-owned.
BaltimorePawns.com
Rated #1 Gold Buyers
Sell Gold Jewelry - Highest Payouts - #1 Place to Sell Your Gold
http://www.goldbuyerct.net
American Standard -63%
Great deals on American Standard! Compare prices and save up to 63%.
www.best-deal.com/American-Standard
Cheap American Standard
Buy cheap American Standard & save! Best-Price.com - the shop expert.
American-Standard.best-price.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.