sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionsblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLot

Frankenstein: Was the book anything like what you expected? email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 95/100. Penfencer (247)2 years ago

I think a lot of people these days have the image stuck in their heads of the Hollywood version of Frankenstein's monster. Did anyone read Mary Shelley's Frankenstein expecting the same sort of beast?

Personally, I was pleasantly surprised by the book. I'm glad to see that the original version is nothing like the movie versions of Frankenstein (though I'm aware that some more recent movies feature a closer relation to the book).

 
 
frankenstein
sponsors
Young Frankenstein Tickets
Just Buy Young Frankenstein Tickets Broadway Musical NYC or Seattle.
JustBuyTickets.com

Frankenstein
Browse a huge selection now. Find exactly what you want today.
www.ebay.com

Young Frankenstein Tickets For Sale
Buy Tickets for Young Frankenstein with No Service Fees at Checkout.
www.NoFeesTickets.com

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  frankenstein, book versus movie, classics, reading, books
 
1. shanty_ina (7)   ranked 2 out of 2 in frankenstein   2 years ago

It seems to me the character or "creature", which was created by dr. Frankenstein in the book is more gruesome, more horrific than that depicted in the movies. Granted the one where Robert DeNiro starred in and played as the "creature" is almost true to the original story (scarred, stitched from many body parts), yet I still like another Frankenstein movie, which starred Donald Sutherland (I forgot the actor's name who played Dr. Frankenstein in this one). The latter movie is more intense, true to the original storyline, but the "monster" itself was not as scary as played by Robert DeNiro.

IMHO I think Frankenstein is a sad tale, especially the "creature", who was created with such a big heart, yet rejected and isolated due to his appearance.

Young Frankenstein Tickets Just Buy Young Frankenstein Tickets Broadway Musical NYC or Seattle. JustBuyTickets.com
 
2. DJules (54)   1 year ago

When I read the book, I already knew that "Frankenstein" was the doctor, not the monster, and had enough of an idea of what the book was about that I wasn't surprised.

I was surprised by how very much I grew to dislike Dr. Frankenstein, he became the true "villian" of the book for me, because he did not take responsibility for what he had created, simply because he found the reality unappealing. I have a feeling the creature might have had a much better life if his creator had been willing to take that responsibility, and the deaths would not have happened.

Frankenstein Browse a huge selection now. Find exactly what you want today. www.ebay.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 67/100. ArsonCuff (2667)   1 year ago

The book is a bit better. There is a musical coming out now:

http://www.terrortube.com...

Young Frankenstein Tickets For Sale Buy Tickets for Young Frankenstein with No Service Fees at Checkout. www.NoFeesTickets.com
 
4. myLot reputation of 57/100. Farside604 (617)   6 months ago

Today we see movies that oversimplify the themes of frankenstein so much that they dont resemble those of the original work. I was very intrigued with the story telling that was offered by mary shelly as well was the versimiltude she brought to her novel. Moreover each allusion left me searching for the next as it really contributed to the themes.

Instantcast: Become A Movie Star Actors & models needed. No prior experience necessary. Get info now. www.instantcast.com
 
sponsors
Instantcast: Become A Movie Star
Actors& models needed. No prior experience necessary. Get info now.
www.instantcast.com

similar discussions
Today, August 30th, is Frankenstein Day
Do you have a favorite version (movie or book)?I remember when the version came out in the...
What are the best horror/suspense books?
Hello friends I'm currently reading Darren Shan's books but at the rate at which I am going, I...
Current Readings
What are reading right now? Any new books youve encountered?I just delved into reading...
Frankenstein: City of Night by Dean Koontz (2005)
Frankenstein: City of Night, is the second book in a trilogy. It is basically the continuation of a...
sponsors
Instantcast: Become A Movie Star
Actors & models needed. No prior experience necessary. Get info now.
www.instantcast.com