sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

Is Structure Satisfying to a Dog?  email this discussion to a friend?

CynthiaBlue (4) 5 years ago

I have been wondering lately if dogs feel more satisfaction from doing something that is structured, than doing something that is random and just fun in the moment.

(Assuming, of course, that dogs feel, which I completely believe, and assume that dogs are capable of satisfaction, which I think they are (look at that contentment when chewing a good bone.).)

If a human bangs on a piano keyboard and makes noise.. it can be fun, but only for a short period. What is really rewarding is when the human learns a song. Puts in the effort to learn the structure that produces a song. Same with dancing... you can flail your arms about, but it's more satisfying if you learn a routine and a structure to follow.

I do dog sports... agility, obedience, (some herding) and flyball. I also take my dogs to the mountains to run amok. They seem to enjoy both. There are always rules. As all animals must follow rules, even in the wild. I just wonder if my dogs get more satisfaction when they follow my instruction in the dog sports... say agility, rather than randomly running around the equipment with no goal in mind.

Of course they get rewards when the follow my direction, which is more reinforcing. But sometimes those tunnels are just Too Much Fun and off the dog goes into one when not supposed to.

So my question is, do dogs get more satisfaction out of a structured activity than a non-structured one? I wonder...

 

dogs
sponsors
FREE Dog Agility Plans
Build your own PVC Dog Agility Equipment for Less.
www.formufit.com/FreeDogAgility

Pet Hotel in Los Angeles
3 Time Winner Best Full Service Pet Care in Los Angeles
www.barkavela.com

Healthy Happy Puppies
Adorable Puppies from Responsible Breeders with Health Guarantee
CaliforniaPuppiesforSale.com

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  agility, dog, dog agility, dog training, flyball
 
sponsors
Ask A Dog Vet
13 Veterinarians Are Online! Current Wait Time: 7 Minutes.
Dog.JustAnswer.com

Become Leader of the Pack
Have your dog become a certified AKC Canine Good Citizen!
PrecisionPackDogTraining.Com

Doggiwater 10% OFF!
Give your dog the best diet possible! 100% Natural Vitamin Beverage.
www.Doggiwater.com

similar discussions


speedmouse
(45)
dog agility

Does anyone out there do dog agility? I'm deeply involved in the sport and write professionally for...

Started by speedmouse (45) in dogs • 1 response • Last response by speedmouse (45) • 5 years ago
Tags: agility, dog agility, dogs

breepeace
(2268)
Agility Cats

If anyone has ever seen the agility events that are so popular with dog owners, here's a lady who...

Started by breepeace (2268) in cats • 2 responses • Last response by anij34 (275) • 5 years ago
Tags: cats, agility, agility cat, agility training, cute videos

edwardchan87
(60)
Agility Training

Hey everyone! Okay, I'm going to become a member soon. The only reason for that is to train my...

Started by edwardchan87 (60) in runescape • 4 responses • Last response by edwardchan87 (60) • 5 years ago
Tags: agility, runescape, training, training agility

edwardchan87
(60)
Agility

Hey people, does your agility level affect you on a free player server?

Started by edwardchan87 (60) in runescape • 6 responses • Last response by MasterTimer (87) • 5 years ago
Tags: runescape, agility, members skill, rs

reaperz
(978)
Did you know.......

Did you know that in runescape...agility can help out how long you can run in members and non...

Started by reaperz (978) in runescape • 4 responses • Last response by edwardchan87 (60) • 5 years ago
Tags: agility, did you knowwhat you know
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.