I just became a Messianic Jew.

@nonew3 (1941)
United States
August 11, 2007 6:14pm CST
I have just changed from being a Christian, per se, to being a Messianic Jew, as of Thursday. I kept thinking, Yahshua (Jesus) was a Jew, and He kept the Saturday Sabbath, the Passover, and followed the Torah, and why weren't the Christian churches doing all that? I could never get a satisfactory answer to all that. And, I kept getting the impression that Yahshua never really got rid of the Torah and the festivals that He (Yahweh) had implemneted. I kept sensing that a huge chunk was missing all those years I spent in the Christian churches, and now I feel a lot better knowing that those missing pieces are finally filled in: The Jewish roots and heritage of the Christian faith. I honestly do not believe that G-d meant for there to be a split between the Jews and the Christians, but this only came about because so many Jews had (and still do) reject Yahshua as the Messiah. We Messianics (for short) believe the Old and New Testaments to be equally holy, by the way. Just my two cents about why I changed over, and all that.
2 people like this
5 responses
@estherlou (5015)
• United States
12 Aug 07
How interesting and congratulations. I've heard of Jews becoming Messianic Jews, or thereby...complete; but I've never heard of a Christian becoming a Messianic Jew. But, we all know we have a rich Jewish heritage and history. Good luck in the journey.
1 person likes this
@nonew3 (1941)
• United States
14 Aug 07
Thanks for the encouragement! I have received very mixed reviews from those Christians I have thus far told about this. One Christian has cut off all contact with me whatsoever, so that all emails I send to him bounce back. Another Christian told me that I have thrown away Jesus Christ by throwing away Christianity, when in fact nothing could be further from the truth. And, another Christian tried to evangelize me. Um....yeah...I still worship Yahshua (Jesus, in Hebrew), but now from a Jewish perspective. Same Messiah. I just take a different approach to worshipping Him now. My mother, a Christian, has been very supportive. And, most of my Christian friends, well, I have not yet told about this change-over. I can only handle so much discussion and so many questions at one time, you know. You are very right about the rich Jewish heritage and history. I know the Christian side to this, and now I am learning the Jewish side. It has been amazing to learn about how Yahshua has been the fulfillment of the Torah, the prophecies, and the festivals of Judaism. It has been amazing to see how the Old and New Testaments complete and fulfill each other. Really, come to think of it, the Old and New Testaments are not separate and apart from each other, at all. They are the same testament of Yahweh's (G-d's) redemptive plan for Jews and Gentiles. And, it is very true that Yahshua was a Torah-keeping Jew, and so were the early disciples. He did not come to abolish the Law, but to fulfill it. Going this route has been very much an eye-opening and learning experience, to say the least. I had no idea that so many Christians would be so up in arms and defensive about my having done this. I'm not exactly an Orthodox Jew now. I still have the same Messiah as before. He is still my Savior, Redeemer, and Lord. I don't see what the big deal is about it. I have not rejected Him. I have just gone back to the Jewish roots of the faith. I wonder if one of the reasons why some Christians, the ones I have already told, are so upset about this, could be because of some deep-rooted anti-Semitism? Do you have any perspectives on this? I'm kind of puzzled, in a way.
@estherlou (5015)
• United States
14 Aug 07
I personally have never understood anti-Semitism. Maybe the ones who are upset don't fully understand what you have chosen to do. You are just finding the roots and the history to the life that Jesus led and grew up in...you are not refusing Him as Messiah.
@nonew3 (1941)
• United States
20 Aug 07
Some people do not understand how anti-Semitism, like racism and other evils, can run so deep that we are often not even aware of it. And, many people have the idea that to embrace Judaism means to reject Yeshuah (Jesus). However, just like there were Jewish followers of Jesus during His time on earth, there are Jewish followers of Jesus now. The whole idea of all Jews rejecting Jesus is completely and utterly false. Some Jews call us Christians and not real Jews, but we celebrate many of the Jewish festivals, many of us eat kosher, and many of us love the Torah. I, personally, do not eat any pork. I am very new to all this, and so I do not yet know how to make a matzah ball, and there are many things I still do not know, but I am learning as I go along. I am still learning what is and isn't acceptable to do on the Sabbath. I don't know how to make a Passover meal. There is really A LOT to learn! But, I'll get it down eventually as I continue to study all this.
@nesher (237)
• United States
11 Oct 07
You just reminded me about a first time I met Messianic Jews. It was in Eilat, Israel, in 1992. At this time, we did not have money for hotel, even the cheapest one, and we spent our nights on the beach. This tent was impossible to miss. It was a biggest and the most visited in the view. People were coming there and going. We came as well. And we did not leave it until our departure. It was a different world, we loved. Every day at night there were pitas and fruits, and every bypasser was invited to share the food. There were talks about everything: religion and Universe, christians and jews, good and evil. You could hear the spiritual stories and hot discussions. The leader of the community, John, had a shelter there, so he invited everyone to take a shower and drink coffee. There you could see Israel soldier, arab muslim, and French millioner (at least he was saying that he is) peacefully discussing the fate of the State of Israel. I wish their palns ever come true. I am happy that you are happy with your new path. Good Luck. BTW, you can visit me on Yuwie - nesher my name.
@nonew3 (1941)
• United States
11 Oct 07
Thanks! Will do. My nick there is now Organic Fair Trade Coffee. I changed it last night.
18 Dec 09
I think this whole room is forgetting about paul's encounter and his reaction to the Judaizers in the New Testament. That might be why some of your friends are against you being a Messianic Jew. The law was for law breakers. The purpose of the law was to identify sin and to act as a school master until the Messiah came and brought a Spirit that would engrave the Law on our hearts. Now we are not expected to be conscious of the law. But we are expected to be righteousness-conscious, walking according to the Spirit. Being directed by the spirit. The Law cannot do that. Only one's fellowship with the Holy Spirit can do that. Once somebody understands this there's no reason for him or her to label themselves as a Messianic Jew. Just be a believer in Christ and walk according to the Spirit's instructions. That's the most important part. That's what you'll be judged for in the end. -0-
• United States
19 Aug 07
Mazel Tov. I am so glad that you found a religion that answers your questions.I think there would be more respect between Jews and Christians if everyone could remember that Jesus was a Jew.
• United States
20 Aug 07
I am glad that most of your friends have understood your new path. And any "friend" that became hostile is not a good friend.Take Care.
@nonew3 (1941)
• United States
20 Aug 07
It is my personal belief that a lot of the split between the two religions stems from the fact that many Christians have forgotten that fact. He celebrated the Passover, even. I am just going back to the same Jewish roots of my faith that Yeshuah (Jesus in Hebrew) practiced. I have great respect for Judaism and our traditions and festivals, and I have great respect for Yeshuah. I see my choice of religion as a way to sort of combine the two. A lot of Christians say that they believe that it is not Christianity, per se, that saves, but following Yeshuah as Messiah, Savior, and Lord, and so it makes no sense why some of my Christian friends have gotten up in arms, and some of them dowright hostile, when they have found out that I have turned Messianic Jew, and yet some others have been very accepting of my transition. Whether or not I celebrate Passover or Easter, or Channukah or Christmas, Yeshuah (Jesus) is always the same. I have not abandoned my Savior in this transition. I wish that this rift between us would cease to be.
1 person likes this
• Sweden
13 Oct 08
Hello! I hope start practising Torah non-selectively! You can learn how to be a follower of the historical Jesus here. Historical Scholars in leading universites agrees that the historical Ribi Yehoshua was a Torah-practising Jew.: www.netzarim.co.il From Anders Branderud
• Canada
16 Jul 10
You still don't get it friend! The Jewish people, for thousands of years, say multiple times a day in their prayers that G-d is ONE! One means one, and it doesn't mean 3!!! Believing in jesus is idol worship and a big sin in Judaism. I don't have much hope that you're going to pay any attention to this-though it would be nice if you would. But I write it for my fellow Jews so they not be swayed by your post. JUDAISM HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH JESUS! G-D IS ONE!!!
• United States
16 Jun 11
I don't think she said her religion is Judaism, and I don't think she is here anymore, so I guess it really doesn't matter...lol