Oh dear, not comfy. Walk? Ride?

@MsTickle (25180)
Australia
September 18, 2007 6:13pm CST
This is in several parts so please bear with me and help if you can. My legs are getting uncomfortable when I sit for over an hour. I get up and walk around and do stretches but it's all to no avail. Help with this if you can please. I know I need to lose weight and I know I need to eat less and exercise more. Not a day goes by without me becoming more physically uncomfortable. I was thinking of getting a walking machine...a treadmill. They are quite expensive and so I would like some feedback from anyone with any experience please. Are they worth the money? Did you loose weight? Should I try ebay? or an on-line store? I used to have an exercise bike which I rode dilligently, 20 klms a day for over a month. I wasn't so big then as now but still, it had no effect. I lost no weight. It was very disappointing. A friend has a very modern exercise bike in her loungeroom and it is holding up her pile of ironing so I'm thinking she has not had much success here either. Does anyone know the story with these weightloss appliances? Are they a waste of money as well as time?
7 people like this
17 responses
@BELMCstar (1341)
• Australia
18 Sep 07
I would suggest trying to hire a treadmill for a while, just to see if you will use it. Perhaps you could borrow your friends exercise bike for a while. She is obviously not using it for the purpose which it is designed for, so perhaps you can borrow it for a while, and then use a treadmill as well. Have you thought about the Tony Ferguson Program? It is very easy to follow. My husband lost 30 kilos in 6 months with it, when he was following it dilligently. He has put on a little bit of weight now, but he is back to what he was when we were married 12 years ago. He is hoping to lose 11 kilos before the end of November, and I am sure he can do it. Perhaps you and your friend can go for walks together. That way you get exercise and social interaction. Good luck with it.
@MsTickle (25180)
• Australia
20 Sep 07
I did look at the Tony ferguson programme but from what I can gatHer it's a very expensive meal replacement programme. To me this is a good way of making money but not a good way to loose weight and keep it off. The way I see it...whatever my plan of action it has to be something I can do the rest of my life...otherwise, I'll just gain the weight back when I stop doing what caused me to loose it. Thanks for the input. Hope your hubby continues the good work.
@CatsandDogs (13963)
• United States
19 Sep 07
I have one that I bought at a department store where I could extend the warrenty if I wanted to. Yes it does work, I lost a few pounds but more inches than the pounds and instead I built muscle mass and toned up really nice. It's well worth it for it also helps your lungs and stamina. I wouldn't buy one online or ebay because it's really hard to know what you're getting without seeing it first hand.
2 people like this
@MsTickle (25180)
• Australia
21 Sep 07
I've looked at the ones on ebay and they are very well explained as most of them are new and coming direct from a wholesaler. It's a good point you raise because I know next to nothing about them. I'm learning though just by looking at the difference in the features. The thing that gets me is the postage...$125. It's a bit of a shock and a rip-off as another place I buy from only charges $99. I want to lose weight and inches, tone up and become fitter so that all sounds good.
2 people like this
@CatsandDogs (13963)
• United States
21 Sep 07
Gosh! That is a lot to be paying in shipment. I'd rather spend that much on the product itself from a nearby store and get the added features with the machine. Just a thought for you to ponder. :) Good luck!
@GardenGerty (157918)
• United States
19 Sep 07
I like electric treadmills and I wish I had a place for one. I believe that walking on a treadmill burns more calories than riding an exercise bike. I like to use the kind that you can adjust the incline, and the speed. I think I get less bored. If I were to get one it would have to be one with those two options. I do not care if it has the computer gizmo that tells me I am burning this many calories, but I do like to know how fast I am going. When I used a fitness club I would play with my mind by challenging myself to go so many minutes this fast, and so many minutes at this incline. I could rev it up, and go fast or run for one minute, then slow down really slow for a few minutes. I could walk uphill or down, which then worked on different muscles. Any improvement you make will come in small increments, but if you pick a program and do it for a month, you should be able to breathe easier, and do more, physically. It is hard to make yourself feel like working hard if you are bored, or if you do not see results. Good luck. Maybe you could start out renting one, and see if you would stick with it, or notice any benefit.
1 person likes this
@mtdewgurl74 (18151)
• United States
22 Sep 07
I wished they had virtual reality treadmill where you put on this head gear and it can take you to any place you choose to walk. Be great I think would make us feel like were outside. If they had them like that I would love to take a walk in Ireland..Renting one could cost a pretty penny when it adds up for the monthly cost if you get it from a place like rent to own you end up paying almost triple the price. Maybe some thrift shops might have one. I would have loved to have started Curves but I am two big for the equipment weight wise since alot of equipment won't hold over 220-300 lbs. To bad they can't loan stuff like that to people to help them lose weight that be cool. If you had a wheelchair you could walk using that or something similar to it so that when you start hurting or having problems you could sit down and be able to roll home. Holding onto something might help a little.
1 person likes this
@MsTickle (25180)
• Australia
21 Sep 07
That all sounds great GG...just the sort of info I'm looking for. My daughter works at a club and they have a gym there. I'm thinking I'll get her to suss out the trainers and ask their advice and maybe she can rent one for me with an option to buy or something. She's coming to visit soon.
@GardenGerty (157918)
• United States
22 Sep 07
Well this is my second time to respond here, just because I see two or three people I would choose to respond to in the discussion. Mtdewgrl--your thought on a wheel chair brought something else to my mind that I have seen, it is smaller, and less expensive as well. There is a type of wheeled walker, with a shelf or seat in it between handlebars. I have seen them at Sam's Club. I do understand about being off for a walk then needing to sit, and having no seat. I also see the other responder who has heel pain. I had tendonitis in my feet for a long time, it got better with weight loss and rest, I was working two jobs. Now I have heel pain, and I have regained the weight plus some, and I am now working two jobs again. You can have neuropathy without diabetes, but she is wise to get checked. I do have neuropathy both in my legs and feet, the doctor just says, "Some people do" and yes, I have had my blood sugars checked. I do not even fall into the "pre diabetic" category, thank goodness. This is a very interesting discussion, in my opinion, and I hope we can find some ideas that help all of us. Everyone, be sure to do some gentle stretching.
1 person likes this
@MsTickle (25180)
• Australia
22 Sep 07
It's very thoughtful of you Gerty. I'm distressed to think that so many of my friends here have health problems and are uncomfortable or in pain. I love that we can share our thoughts and our trials with each other. Don't you hate it when Drs are non-comittal? I, too can recommend gentle stretching. One of my favourite stretches is to stand with my feet firmly on the floor in a doorway and reach up to touch the door sill. It feels sooo good. If you do it slowly and gradually so you can feel your whole body gently loosen, it feels very therapeutic.
@raijin (10345)
• Philippines
19 Sep 07
Availing excercise equipments are really expensive, so I just you do the old-fashoined way. An early morning walk would be more appropirate for that, as that's what health specialists would always advice. Or try the stairs excercise, those two steps would be enough for you to burn fat and lose weight. I think they call it stair climbing, just make sure that you also warm up and do some stretchings before doing it. You don't need to spend more money on costly gym equipments, all you need is to simplify and improvise..
@MsTickle (25180)
• Australia
21 Sep 07
The thing is I can no longer do stairs...me, who used to run up and down 4 at a time now have to pull myself up and down carefully because my knees don't work. There are no paths around here so walking is a bit rough and I'm no longer sure footed enough to enjoy it.
@mtdewgurl74 (18151)
• United States
22 Sep 07
Sorry to butt in here but what part didn't you understand raijin she said she couldn't do the steps, she could seriously do herself some damage if she tried and then lost balance because her knees went out. I know about this some not only do I have knee problems but so does my mom and most my family who have had to have surgery because of it. Why put herself through that sort of pain? I have used a concrete block instead of doing the stairs and using things to hold onto but it still can hurt like crazy I wouldn't recommend the stair stepping thing until she lost weight to where she feels more comfortable doing that sort of thing after first consulting a doctor or someone to see if she is able or if it would just cause her more pain. Not everybody is the same what is good for one is not good for all. So while simplifying and improvising is all good it's not for everyone. Especially if it takes you from somewhere you are able to readily sit down if the need strikes you. I know how it is to walk a half mile or more down the road then wish you hadn't because you need a place to rest and there is no place but the side of the road with the Poison Ivy. So it is best to be at home safe or atleast around the house or close to a bunch of chairs and a cold drink and a fan.
@raijin (10345)
• Philippines
21 Sep 07
I think you can still do the stairs, but don't climb up and down it. You can always climb back and forth on the FIRST two steps, do it in a manner like you are skipping.
@faith210 (11224)
• Philippines
19 Sep 07
Hi MsTickle! I do have a treadmill and I was so excited in using it during the first few days. The first few days, I started for an hour then went on for two hours twice a day and then it became less and less as the weeks passes. Now it is gathering dust. I think I got lonely. LOL! I would rather do some brisk walking now within our subdivision because I can see other people doing the same thing. Take care and have a nice day.
@MsTickle (25180)
• Australia
22 Sep 07
If that was how things end up, I'm sure I'll have no problem selling it.
@weemam (13372)
19 Sep 07
I had a treadmill and yes it worked for me AT THE TIME , I was really strict ans stuck to it , I have arthritis in my knees and it was too much impact so I went for a glider , I got bored with that too , I now have 2 exercise bikes in the spare room , I think if you make up your mind you are going to do it pal then go for it , I did it for ages and I really saw and felt the difference with the treadmill , But it was going for my knees , If you are going to get one just go for the cheaper model as it does the same thing really m the have quite inexpensive ones in Argos , sometimes though you can pick up a good second hand one and it serves you just as well , good luck with it pal , it is the sticking to routine thats the best thing , xxx
@MsTickle (25180)
• Australia
21 Sep 07
Now that's interesting Wee as it's my knees that give me the most bother. Maybe I should check with a medico first. I was always very active and eventually my knees got louder and louder with a crunching and grinding noise when I did stairs. When the noise eventually stopped, I could no longer walk up or dopwn stairs with any ease....running is out. Maybe a treadmill won't work for me. Darn it!
@peaceful (3294)
• United States
19 Sep 07
I am of the mind that natural is best when it comes to exercise- I like being outdoors and in motion... some exercise equipment is useful- I like ski machines and exer-bikes, but when it comes to weight training, I prefer free weights along with aerobic exercises, like jogging... Here is a site that can offer you the advice and support that you are seeking: http://www.freetrainers.com/FT/jsp/index.jsp
1 person likes this
@MsTickle (25180)
• Australia
21 Sep 07
I signed up a few days ago...thanks my friend. I haven't explored much...I need two of me to do all the online things I want to do and another two (at least) to do everything else....lol. Have a peaceful, happy day. x
@TerryZ (22076)
• United States
20 Sep 07
Hi Ms Tickle! I dont think the treadmill is a waste of money at all. I know alot of people who have bought them second hand. Just keep looking in your paper for used ones. I think its great exercise. My best friend bought one and used it every day and she lost alot of weight but she cut back on what she was eating too. And drink alot of water.
@MsTickle (25180)
• Australia
22 Sep 07
What a lot of positive enthusiasm...thanks mate, it's much appreciated.
@rosie_123 (6113)
19 Sep 07
Oh dear - I'm sorry you are so uncomfortable. First I have to be honest and say I have no personal experience of these things. I am one of those people "blessed" with being underweight, not overweight, so I have never tried to lose weight in my life! I honestly think the only way to do it is to combine gentle and regular exercise with a sensible eating plan, which means no junk food, fried food, greasy food, and a lot of fresh fruit and vegetables. Here in England I know they have special medical plans set up with fitness regimes at gyms to help the overweight, and special diet plans with support from trained counsellors. I certainly wouldn't spend lots of money on anything too expensive unless you have researched it very well and it has been proven that it really will help.
@MsTickle (25180)
• Australia
21 Sep 07
Lucky you Rosie. I was like you till my late 40's. I eat pretty well, just too much...lol. I'm not a huge fruit eater though. I think our health insurance companies have similar plans but you pay through the nose. I live way out the back of nowhere so I have to manage on my own. I agree with the research part so i'm picking people's brains here...doing well with it too. Thanks ..
19 Sep 07
Like you I find it difficult to take normal regular exercise as my legs don't always work too well. I used to have an exercise bike which was a complete waste of time and money. I didn't lose any weight and I found my legs were quite painful sometimes. To be honest, the best form of exercise for me has been swimming as it is an *all over* tone up as well. Personally I wouldn't waste my money on expensive machines now.
1 person likes this
@MsTickle (25180)
• Australia
21 Sep 07
I found the same with my bike. I'm not a good swimmer either. Thanks for the feedback.
@twoey68 (13627)
• United States
20 Sep 07
I have the same problem somewhat. I have Diabetes and my legs swell horribly. When they do they become very painful. I've thought of getting a treadmill to be able to walk when their not swollen but lke you I don't have much knowledge of them. Thank you for posting this discussion, perhaps I can get some advice from it as well. **AT PEACE WITHIN** ~~STAND STRONG IN YOUR BELIEFS~~
1 person likes this
@MsTickle (25180)
• Australia
22 Sep 07
In spite of a couple of egative comments, I think I'll go ahead and get one. I had no problem riding my exercise bike so I don't think it will be a fad. I thought of asking my daughter to pick one up for me so i can save the postage but it will probably cost her fair bit of fuel to go get it and I doubt it will fit in her car with two kids and luggage. When I look at what I would have to spend to GO and buy one, the postage seems reasonable. As for fresh air, I can easily set mine up on my front patio if I want or put it in the living room and open my wide front patio doors and by big windows...I get lots of fresh air so that's not a problem. Diabetes is one of the things I'm anxious about...I think I may have it it the early stages now, so I want to do something more than I've been doing so far. My ankles have disappeared. Just looking at all the different types of treadmills on Ebay has been a bit of an education.
@susieq223 (3742)
• United States
19 Sep 07
My experience is that if I don't just do regular exercise, I probably won't use any exercise equipment either! I have gone through several kinds of exercise machines and have wound up selling them or giving them away. The treadmills are not only expensive, but they take up a lot of room. If you have space for one, okay, otherwise, you'll wish you didn't have it. Also if you are heavy, walking can be very hard on your knees. I don't know if those glider or ski type walkers are helpful or not. I would suggest taking a yoga class or some Tai Quan Do. Those are slow movements that use isometrics and stretching to keep muscles loose and limber. They also work on your way of thinking about your body which impacts the way you eat. Another thing to do would be get a exercise CD or VHS tape, or find an exercise program on TV and do that. If you can stick to those then you might stick to a treadmill (if you still need it) and not waste your money on something you won't use. Losing weight is so hard if you are like me and really hate that "e" word!
1 person likes this
@MsTickle (25180)
• Australia
22 Sep 07
Yes, my knees are a problem but I love walking. I'd rather walk in the comfort of my home than subject myself to the elements. Exercise is not a word in my vocabulary, but walking is enjoyment, not exercise.
@mummymo (23706)
19 Sep 07
Oh sweety I am sorry that you are having these problems - suffering with back problems that have caused bad nerve damage in my legs I can totally understand and empathise with your frustrations! I know a lot of people who buy expensive exercise 'gadgets' and very few who actually use them or feel they are worth the money unfortunately. Trampolining is one thing I have heard a lot of people have success with - you ca get the great big ones or the little platform 'bouncers' for indoor use. What about regular walks out in the fresh air? Sometimes a change of scenery helps and the fresh air is an added bonus? I wish you lots of luck with whatever you try and hopefully one day soon I will be able to exercise, maybe even walk a bit too - then my friend and I are going to use the exercise bikes together, she has 2 set up in her spare room so we can talk and exercise at the same time! xxx
1 person likes this
@MsTickle (25180)
• Australia
22 Sep 07
I really don't understand the benefit of a trampoline. Our weather conditions can be very harsh and there are no paths to walk on here, I don't enjoy walking out and about as I used to for some reason. It seems I may have a setback with my dodgy knees from what others have said. I went for a walk with my dog yesterday and last night there was a live band at the pub so I did a lot of dancing, I've tried to be less sedentary lately and I jumped on the scales this morning to see my weight has dropped 4 kilos. No doubt, it will come back, as usual but I'll keep trying. Your condition sounds extremely uncomfortable and painful, I hope you have good days sometimes. Bless you Mummymo.
@subha12 (18441)
• India
19 Sep 07
I think walking will be best Better will be if u can manage a little bit of running. Also try some exercise at home. May be those can solve the problem a bit. And off course losing weigt is a god idea.
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
8 Nov 07
We got our treadmills from Sears and so far, it has been used fairly well in the winter, but not the rest of the year because then I can go for walks. The best ones cost money, and the only way to lose weight is not only to use them, but to increase the resistance, in some you can raise the level to make it harder to walk. They do have programs on them and it would be best to start as a beginner. The exercise bikes are worse than useless. You could also walk more, eat more salads, and more veggies and fruits, whole grain breads and cereals, and drink lots of water.
@susieq223 (3742)
• United States
19 Sep 07
P.S. Be sure to get a physical and make sure your weight and discomfort are not because of some physical reason, too, like thyroid problems.