Does smoking really make people thinner?

China
March 25, 2008 12:15am CST
I watched a television show the other day.It told that smoking can be a way to keep body thin. I really wonder if it is true .If it really is, why not give it a try ? But at second thought , i wonder how many negative effects it will bring to me . And if one day I want to quit,will the weight that I had lost come back again or even worse? Anyway,I am really excited about this news- no needs to go on a diet Are you a smoker? Give me some tips!
4 people like this
9 responses
• United States
25 Mar 08
ive been smoking for over 15yrs now. and i can tell you that smoking does NOT make you thinner! nicotine may VERY SLIGHTLY, TEMPORARILY suppress the appetite, however the longer you smoke the less you will probably feel that effect. most long time smokers who try to quit, gain weight because of the habit of "doing something with your hand and mouth" you end up snacking on something to try and fill the habit of putting the cig to your mouth. it is a surprisingly strong habit to overcome. if you dont currently smoke and are thinking of starting for the weight loss, THEN DONT! it WILL NOT make any difference that is big enough to be truly a BENEFIT, when compared to the negative effects.
2 people like this
• China
25 Mar 08
I really hear people saying that it's difficult to quit smoking.And it also gives side effects to people, but I wonder what if i make it in a limited number, say one cig a day, then it won't give me as much harm ,right?
@gabrielle47 (1219)
• Philippines
26 Mar 08
Well partly that's true as when you smoke, some says it interferes with your senses and appetite. So when you smoke and ur appetite is suppressed, naturally you can get thinner. But I have a friend who is fat that no matter how much she smokes, she dont get thinner. I also heard that it could make you fat once you stop smoking as it will want you to crave and some smokers eat candy in replacement of their cravings so as a result, it makes them gain weight. Aside from the many unhealthy benefits of smoking, once you learn to smoke, for some its difficult to quit. So for your sake, I just recommend you to just diet and do exercise to get thinner and not learn to smoke. Have a nice day dear!
1 person likes this
• China
26 Mar 08
Thanks for your informative and caring advice! I just come to understand the harm smoking will bring to me and also the difficulty I have to go through in order to quit it.I just think I am not a strong-willed person and maybe i could never quit it.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
28 Mar 08
You are welcome colourless. I hope you value your health and be strong in the temptation smoking brings.
1 person likes this
@academic2 (7000)
• Uganda
30 Mar 08
smoking is something you should avoid if you can help it-it has no gains except the many health dagers associated with it!
1 person likes this
@ESKARENA1 (18260)
•
26 Mar 08
No smoking does not make people slim but one of the side effects of nocotene addiction is the supression of appitite, so smokers tend to be slimmer than those who dont smoke. I quit smoking June last year and so far have put on 3 and a half stone in weight, but the health benefits of stopping far outstrip the weight gain problem blessed be
1 person likes this
• China
27 Mar 08
Glad to hear that you have stopped smoking completely ! You just won over the addictive substance.I kind of respect your strong will. Plus you just take yourself as an example to illustrate how tabacoo brings side effects to people. There is nothing that can better prevent me from smoking that! Really, thanks, dear friend! Sound health!
1 person likes this
@chiyosan (30185)
• Philippines
30 Mar 08
I dont think people will get thinner by smoking.. you might lose all the fat if you dont eat and just smoke, perhaps. :)
1 person likes this
@wy2008 (185)
• China
30 Mar 08
is that so ? i don't think so . because my dad is a heavy smoler , but he get fatter and fatter , and many other person i recognise who smoke don't lose any weight . i think the best thing that can lose weight is on diet and do exercise.
@pumpkinjam (8873)
• United Kingdom
31 Mar 08
I heard that it does but nicotine is a suppressant so it stops people feeling hungry and therefore smokers may be inclined to eat less. Smoking in itself, I don't believe [b][/b]makes you thin. I can also tell you that I know many overweight smokers because the rest of their life is unhealthy too. I wouldn't recommend taking up smoking to find out. It will cause more harm than good and, apparently, it leavs fatty deposits on your lungs. I'd rather have my fat on the outside thanks!
@sungat (1015)
• Pakistan
30 Mar 08
it is not ture as far my consideration i am a smoker i have never seen any loss in my weight well it may be useful on other people but as my opinion it is wrong statement
1 person likes this
@Perry123 (363)
•
15 Apr 08
well as 90% of suprmodels and 65% of jockeys smoke I say they are the proof of the pudding. it increases your metabolism and surpresses appetite. of course if you still stuff your face ridiculously no it's no good.