Is it really safe to have a dog if you have a child?

@liquorice (3887)
April 14, 2008 7:42am CST
I have a few friends who have dogs and children. They had the dogs first and when the babies arrive the dogs found it a bit hard getting used to them at first and then adapted. The children of course are used to the dogs as they've always had them around. I love dogs but I could never have one in the house with my daughter as they are unpredictable and can turn nasty at any minute. You hear so many horrible tales about dogs attacking children that I sometimes think it's actually quite irresponsible to have both. What you do think?
3 people like this
25 responses
@cortjo73 (6498)
• United States
14 Apr 08
I don't think that having a dog and a baby in a house together is irresponsible. I grew up with dogs from the day I was born on and, yea..we had one sort of cranky dog but, all of the others were really great. And, they can be quite protective. My dog is a big black labrador retriever. He is the sweetest thing with babies and children. He is so gentle, and curious and really quite perfect with children. So much so that, even though he is 120 lbs and can use his tail as a weapon, one of my friends from down the street has actually bragged about him to others about how great he is with kids. He will wip an adult with his tail but, when a child is around, he will still that tail and just play carefully with them. He actually gets as much amusement from them as they get from him. One time, one of our friends sons was about a year old. He was not fully sturdy on his feet yet but, could stand and, he would get himself up on his feet in front of my dog and then Frizbee (my dog) would gently nudge him with his nose on his chest, the boy would fall onto the floor and start laughing about it hysterically. Friz would snort which is his form of a laugh, wag his tail, pant a bit and wait for the boy to get back up on his feet and the two of them would do it all over again. I know that if the boy was upset about it, Frizbee would have stopped it entirely. But, the fact that the boy was having so much fun with it made Frizbee happy too. It was so cute. And, trust me, we are careful. We understand his size and, we believe he does too. In fact, that is part of what my friend was bragging about with him. That he does seem to understand his size and is so careful around kids. He seems to know what he can get away with and what he can't with each child. We taught him to accept snacks with his lips, not with his teeth so, he understands that his teeth can't touch people. We taught him by yelling at him and saying, "No, Ouch!" when we were training him as a puppy. So, he doesn't use his teeth. He also knows the word "gentle" and acts accordingly. My 6 year old neighbor also voted him the nicest dog in our cul 'd' sac. So, no...in my opinion, having dogs with babies in the house is not irresponsible. I am sure that there are dogs out there that are dangerous to have around children. But, not my dog. I think he is better with kids than some humans.
2 people like this
@cortjo73 (6498)
• United States
16 Apr 08
Thank you for the Best Response! I enjoyed telling you about my sweetheart dog! He is such a good boy and I credit my hubby with being the one who did so well teaching him his manners! Thank you again!
@liquorice (3887)
15 Apr 08
That's a really lovely story, it sounds like you really trained him well and you've learnt to read his moods and interpret his mannerisms just like I did with my daughter. (Didn't realise this worked in the same way with a dog!) I love how he played with the 1-year old and that he enjoyed it as much as the baby did. Thank you for your reassuring post!
1 person likes this
@uath13 (8192)
• United States
14 Apr 08
It's only irresponsable if you don't take the time to train both. I don't think toddlers should be allowed with pets as their too young to understand & properly mind instruction. Older kids & well trained animals are fine. Most of the horror stories stem from one side or the other not being properly prepared.
1 person likes this
@uath13 (8192)
• United States
14 Apr 08
Usually these dogs that "turn" had all kinds of warning signs & people just either didn't recognize them or decided to ignore them. Dogs don't just turn for no reason. Something happened to cause it, usually somebody neglecting or abusing it. You should never trust any animal ( humans included ) completely. Your spouse or friends could be a bigger threat to your child than any animal. You should always be observant & know what's going on then take the proper safely measures.
1 person likes this
• United States
15 Apr 08
I agree with you uath, however, I trust and understand my dog way more than a lot of people.
@liquorice (3887)
14 Apr 08
Thanks for your replies. I get what you're saying, and I agree that the relationship between the dog and the child is a lovely one and that the kind of incidents I'm worried about can be limited by proper training. I just feel like you can never fully know a dog like you can a person as they still have a bit of the wild animal in them. I'd be worried that any dog, even the more docile friendly breeds could still turn unexpectantly. Do any of you dog-owners ever worry that your dog might suddenly turn nasty and be a threat to your child, or once you've had a dog for a long time do you just start to trust it completely?
@palonghorn (5479)
• United States
14 Apr 08
It is perfectly safe to have a dog and a baby in the same house. It also depends on the breed of dog. I had a doberman, and had a baby a year after I had had him, he was great with her. He would watch over her, and he never once showed any type of aggression towards her. I also had a golden retriever when I had my second daughter, and she was great with the baby. It all depends on the breed of dog, where you got them from, the breeder makes a big difference. Not all breeds of dogs are aggressive or unpredictable.
1 person likes this
14 Apr 08
it is definetly not safe to have a dog when there is a baby around..u can have one when the baby is old enough
@goergineo (1498)
• Jordan
15 Apr 08
I agree with akssac. It is not same to have a dog and a child at hoom.
• United States
15 Apr 08
You haven't been around many dogs have you? I have had probably 6 different breed dogs throughout my lifetime, and my parents had their dachsund long before I was born. They also had one when my oldest was born, and once she got big enough for a walker, he would stand up on the back of it and 'push' it, and she would giggle. As for my doberman, she climbed all over him, and pulled his ears, and not once did he ever growl, snap, or act aggressive to her in any way. Goldens and labs are very loving, affectionate dogs, that would never think of hurting anyone. Now, a pitbull, no I wouldn't have one around a child, however, I would have one period.
@tessah (6617)
• United States
14 Apr 08
dogs are no more unpredictable than people are. yes, some dogs will bite.. some people will shoot you in the face. to say its irresponsible for people to have both kids and pets is.. well, irresponsible. there isnt anything wrong with having both, in fact, having pets for your children is a good way to help teach them responsibilty and compassion. my daughter just turned 8 today.. she has two cats and a dog, and she tends to the responsibles of them now that shes older(shes had a pet since she was 1) and has learned how to behave around and respect the beastial members of this family. she is expecting kittens in a couple months and plans to midwife the birth. so i guess im an "irresponsible" parent.. but shes learning things that are quite valueable, so im just fine with that.
1 person likes this
@liquorice (3887)
15 Apr 08
I think it's really nice that your daughters' so responsible and I do agree that having a pet definitely teaches them a lot of great qualities. I didn't mean by implication to call you an irresponsible parent, it sounds like you've got a lovely family/pet situation. I would like my daughter to have the chance of having a pet one day, I guess I'm just trying to educate myself about it, and not having experienced the close relationship that lots of people here say you can get with a dog I suppose I'm just a bit fearful about what can happen. It sounds like the incidents I'm worried about don't happen very often if you do it all properly.
• India
15 Apr 08
i dont think it is safe to keep pet when there are chidren are at home
1 person likes this
@pooh08 (671)
• Vietnam
15 Apr 08
I think a dog doesn't have mistake. The mistake in here is your friends don't look after their babies.
1 person likes this
@liquorice (3887)
16 Apr 08
That's a good point. From a lot of these posts I'm getting the message that it's not just the dog that can be the problem, it can be that people need to ensure that the kids and the dog are not left alone, and that sometimes it can be problematic when the children haven't been taught how to act around a dog and how to respect it. Thanks for your post.
• United States
15 Apr 08
On a general note dogs only go bad and attack when they are treated badly. There is nothing wrong with having children and dogs at the same time. I have kids and have 2 dogs.
1 person likes this
• United States
15 Apr 08
You can have both a baby and a dog. You do need to prepare the dog for the new baby before you bring him or her home. As the Dog Wisper has pointed out on his show you need to make sure the you are the pack leader and that your dog knows that the baby is also a pack leader.
1 person likes this
@jstaubin (423)
• United States
14 Apr 08
It is safe to have dogs around kids. I have had big dogs and little dogs around my children and have never had a problem. While it is true that an animal can attack in most cases dogs do not go off the deep end unless they feel threatend for some reason.
• United States
14 Apr 08
I also believe it depends on the breed of dog and how the dog is raised. I have labs, and they are fabulous with kiddos - when the petites were bebes, my blond lab used to let them crawl all over him, pull his ears, tail, etc. Just sweet as he could be and loved the attention. My black lab is a little more rambunctious, and we had to watch more carefully, not because she would bite or anything, but occasionally in her enthusiasm would knock the kiddos over. Even breeds that are "known to be dangerous" can be great with little ones - a friend of mine bought a rotweiller (spelling?) puppy when her daughter was 18 months old. Now the rottie is her best friend and sleeps across her doorway at night. If you train your dog to be a guard dog, you might have more difficulties - I would imagine dogs that are trained to be aggressive could be more dangerous. I do believe that until you know how your animals are going to react, that it is extremely important to supervise any interaction carefully.
1 person likes this
@rombi001 (941)
14 Apr 08
I think it depends what kin of dog you want... If you are willing to settle for a poodle or a pekinua... then they can't harm anyone, but if you want a german shepherd or a husky then you better keep them away from your child!!!
15 Apr 08
It can be safe but, it is up to the parents to be sensible enough not to leave a baby in a room with a dog on their own. Most dogs are the way they are because of the way they have been raised or trained and so if you have trained your dog well then there is no danger as long as you just make sure you don't leave them together. The child benefits from having a dog around from an early age as they will grow up respecting animals and treating them right and at the same time a brilliant bond can be formed between children and animals that will last a lifetime.
1 person likes this
• India
14 Apr 08
hi... i was 5 wen my parents got me a pet n trust me ders nothing more wonderful than having a pet dog... it not only gives d child a companion, but also instills responsibility in d kid... as far as ur concern regarding d safety of d kids goes...dey r not completely baseless...der r dogs which r a bit aggressive and might turn violent if proveked (but dis is a highly unlikely situation) so wat u can do is to take a more 'homel' dog... a golden retriever would b my suggestion...
1 person likes this
@smlaw88 (39)
• United States
15 Apr 08
To me a dog acts how it raised to act..if u get a dog raise it to be kind towards ppl and itll be fine around children..Also this is strange to me but i use to babysit for a family and their little boy had Asthma their doctor told them to get a small dog and itll help with the Asthma!
1 person likes this
@Ravenladyj (22904)
• United States
15 Apr 08
We had the kids THEN got the dogs but my kids werent tots anymore...If research is done on what the best type of dog to get is for the family, lifestyle etc etc and the owners TRAIN the dogs properly then there shouldnt be a problem ya know..
@nengs10 (3180)
• Philippines
15 Apr 08
It depends on how you train the dogs. First things first, dogs are meant to be friends of the kids. They should be well trained to guide the kids and befriend with them so as to foster a certain bond between the two.
@littleowl (7157)
15 Apr 08
hi liquorice-there is no worries about having a dog when you have a baby,they seem to take them into the 'pack' meaning your family and tend to be protective ocer them-obviously if you feel it is wrong to have a dog and a baby at the same time there is another way,when you have had the baby then get a dog in that way the dog accepts that the baby is family-i have two bearded collies and when my grandson came along they were so loving towards him and let him play with them as he got to about two-now he is four and more active they stay out of his way cos they are wimps!! so i wouldn't worry about having a dog with a baby-littleowl
• India
14 Apr 08
no way u should not have a dog
@liquorice (3887)
15 Apr 08
Yes, I'd really like one, one day anyway. I suppose I'm partly put off by seeing other peoples' dogs being a bit crazy in the park, as that's the main place I get to see dogs. I guess it must be different with your own...
@elle43 (20)
• Philippines
15 Apr 08
I think it is safe to have both, because if you want to have children and dogs at the same time I think you should know what to do. I grew up to have dogs always at home and I got married , have children and still have dogs at home. It is just a manner of adjusting and observing them... and not leaving the kids alone with dogs if you think it is not safe.
• United States
15 Apr 08
i think that it is safe to have a dog and a child in the same house and yes i think that it depends on the breed and how the owner of the dog before u treated it. we have two little boys who are very rough and she just stands their and takes it and has never bite them or growled at them and if she does not feel like playing then she goes to mine and my husbands bedroom adn they know to leave her alone when she goes in there.