Carly Smithson voted out on American Idol, why America, why????

Philippines
April 24, 2008 6:45am CST
I am hurt and even crying while typing. Why does Carly voted out from Idol, is it her voice. I remember her having a good judgement by Simon last night, what happened?. Maybe i don't have the right to say this, but i think they got it wrong again...oh please America don't be offended, i am just saying that Carly is a great singer. Well maybe this is the start of her career,she will remain outstanding to me. Go Carly!!!
3 responses
ladym33
@ladym33 (10978)
• United States
24 Apr 08
I don't know what people were thinking with last nights voting. People need to quit with the sympathy and popularity votes, it is too late in the game here. They are trying to pick a recording artist not America's Sweet Heart.
grecychunny26
@grecychunny26 (9482)
• Philippines
24 Apr 08
You are right, these is a singing contest not a modelling contest. I can't get over it.
sutanhartanto
@sutanhartanto (4122)
• Indonesia
24 Apr 08
that broke my heart...again. the first time is when ramiele voted out. i hope she will be at least in the last three. well, what to do.
grecychunny26
@grecychunny26 (9482)
• Philippines
24 Apr 08
I don't know why they do it again. I am hurt when Michael Johns voted out and now Carly. I will not really surprise if David Cook will be next.
lkbooi
@lkbooi (16070)
• Malaysia
28 May 08
Hi there, this is a discussion a month old and the final result had already announced. The seventh season American idol is David Roland Cook, and David Archuleta is the runner up. Of course the hearts of Archuleta’s fans were deeply hurt. I like watching singing contest. I enjoy only the singing. It doesn’t matter who the winner is as long as he can really sing well and fascinating.