How do you handle it when there is someone disabled that you happen to see

@suspenseful (40192)
Canada
July 28, 2008 6:34pm CST
We were at the food court the other day and there was a woman, two girls, and the son. The son was in a wheelchair. He probably had muscular distrophy and I knew someone who had it and I remember that it is mainly a disease that affects men, and he is dead now. Oh he was very bossy and did not have his eyes up to heaven as was supposed. I felt so sad for the family who would not have him around for long. My husband was upset that I was looking that way, but then I also look at everyone because I am a writer and very curious and he gave a lecture about not staring, about this friend he knew who was a bit odd *oh the friend excuse as why he does not go to church etc. How the Two by Two Church I used to belong to excommunicated him because he tried to commit suicide. And then about that guy with cerebal palsy who went into a restaurant and people started talking about him= not me, but I felt he could have said "I am on a diet so I just want plain dry toast," instead he made a big issue out of it saying "no mayonnaise, bread with no butter etc." I told my husband that I suppose others will make a big fuss about the boy in the wheelchair and he said they would, but that is not right. So I told my husband that the next time I see a disabled person, I will just ignore him since looking at him is rude and yet I look at everyone else. So do I have to look and observe everyone else except for those in wheelchairs?
9 people like this
21 responses
@dragon54u (31633)
• United States
29 Jul 08
I've never stared at people like that, I pretend that being in a wheelchair is normal and I treat them as such. I will offer help if I see them having difficulty but otherwise I see them as normal with some extra equipment.
5 people like this
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
29 Jul 08
I was not staring. I was just looking and I have looked that way before. But just because the boy was in a wheelchair he made a point of criticizing me. I was not gaping, but he made such an issue that when there is someone who is crippled or handicapped, I will go the other way. The thing about it I had been a bit afraid of people who have handicaps and I have been trying to get over it, you know the "It could have been me thing," but now all that work to overcome my fear has gone to naught.
3 people like this
@dragon54u (31633)
• United States
29 Jul 08
I'm sorry, I misunderstood what you were saying. If he was criticizing you, he has more going wrong than his handicaps. Perhaps he has something going on "upstairs" that's not quite right.
3 people like this
@capirani (2817)
• United States
29 Jul 08
If the person you were "looking" at catches your eye, do you look away in guilt as though caught doing something wrong? Or are you able to smile and say "Hello" like you might with anyone who is not disabled? It makes a lot of difference. I am fairly newly disabled and only started using motorized carts in the stores just before Christmas a year and a half ago. It was very embarrassing to me at first. I have had various reactions but not a lot of staring. I have confronted the same rude people who would be just as rude were I still able to walk around the stores. Then I have encountered those who are gracious. Nothing wrong with looking around and being a people watcher. But if when you are watching someone for a longer time than is really necessary, it can be considered staring whether you meant to be staring or not. But it sounds like two issues in your post. One is your attention to the boy in the wheelchair, and the other your husband's reaction to your watching this boy and how you felt about it. That sounds like there is an issue between the two of you that you might want to discuss in private and suggest that in the future, such comments need to be made in private rather out in the public arena where everyone else can hear and where you are made to feel embarrassed. If that doesn't work, then I guess you will have to decide if you can live with his public reactions and comments or if you would rather just not accompany him out in public. Or whatever else you decide to do, which might even be to ignore all this and do nothing.
3 people like this
@cripfemme (7698)
• United States
29 Jul 08
As a disabled person myself, I don't know why people think it's ok to look at me obnoxiously. I actually have had people do the whole, "I'm an open mouthed ape" thing to me. If you are curious about someone with a disability, however, I think it's ok to go up and ask questions (especially if you're a writer). You might want to mention that actually so people don't think you're being rude. As long as your ok with them saying, "I don't want to talk to you" I don't see any problem with this strategy. However, your husband is right. Just looking at someone to look at them is incalculably rude whether you meant it to or not. My friend, Mary Frances who is also in a wheelchair and a very large woman weighing 600 pounds, used to say to people who stared at her, "Staring fee is $0.50". I admire her moxie and have since used that line myself.
• Canada
29 Jul 08
I have a white cane. I walk a little differetly because of poor balance. I get so SICK of questions, like I'm a curiosity of some sort. I know people need to be educated, but teachers get a break now and then. Why don't disabled people?
4 people like this
@cripfemme (7698)
• United States
29 Jul 08
I totally agree! Well said, I get tired of putting on my educator hat as well. But I'd rather have them ask then stare or make stupid assumptions.
4 people like this
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
29 Jul 08
I stare at everybody and where I live there are lots of people in walkers, and in those scooters and we are the fat capital of Canada. I think my husband was wrong, because I did not stare, I just turned around and when we had our coffee, he walked right by them close up. If he did not want me to look at them, he could have walked the way we usually do when we have our coffee- through the middle. So he made a point so that I got curious. I have seen many disabled people before and I know a girl who is not only disabled, but has a mind of a child and her mother brings her to the Mall every time, but they were going out the door before I had a chance to say, Hi. Now if I happen to run into them and my husband is with me, I dare not say anything.
2 people like this
@Thoroughrob (11742)
• United States
29 Jul 08
Absolutely not. My son is in a wheelchair and I would tell you to never ignore them. Treat them as you would want to be treated. I think I would make a little more effort to send a friendly smile or greeting. It usually will make their day, but don't ignore them or snub them.
4 people like this
• Canada
29 Jul 08
I obsere people for who they are. The person walking down the street on two feet ges o more otice than the person in the wheelchair, or the person walking with a cane or whateer. I am legally blind so in order to see aything I have o look a little longer in that direction I just don't spend that much time looking at people. Disabled people need to be treated the same as eeryone else.
4 people like this
@Lakota12 (42600)
• United States
29 Jul 08
I would say not if he was demanding I am sure other eyes were on him and being in a wheelchair mak you no different than one standin how do you know tht they might not have a fake leg or something else wrong with them. I knew a kid with MS and he wouldnt let any one help him if he fell he marries and I think they had kids. I know his brother did and it ran in the famiy most of the boys had it I think the grand ma had had it but she was gone. KNew anoither kid in a wheel chair went to bars and danced in the wheel chair he had no legs but he really enjoyed himself! was great to see and watch!
4 people like this
@Lakota12 (42600)
• United States
29 Jul 08
Hope it isnt around any more and the Fathers of the Catholic church cant marry either. Guess thats why they go after the kids now huh? Or the nuns along time ago
2 people like this
@Lakota12 (42600)
• United States
29 Jul 08
th is hard for alot of little kids just cause you couldnt sayit then was no reason for them to put you there! And is wrong for a church to do that for him trying to kill himself they needed to help him!
3 people like this
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
29 Jul 08
It was a fake church. It took the Bible wrong. It said the apostles were single and that if you want to be a minister you donot marry and it showed a lack of forgiveness. There was a woman who joined who had been a mistress of a rich man, she gave up that life, and they did not forgive her. I mean none of the widowers asked her to marry him and she had a son who was around fourteen.
2 people like this
• United States
29 Jul 08
sory but my God wont punish the disabled for not attending a church service remember sitting in a church no more makes us a Christian than sitting in a garrage will make one a car remember also that we have an awsome and understanding God !
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
29 Jul 08
It was a fake Church. I am glad I am no longer a member. And he was kicked out because he tried to kill himself and that was because his brother was a homosexual. That was in the 1970s. I left the church, went through the usual searching until I found the one I go to. My husband rejected God and the church altogether. I pray for him all the time.
2 people like this
@GardenGerty (169505)
• United States
29 Jul 08
Look, observe, add a smile, say hello. That is if that is how you would treat everyone else. Yes, some people make a spectacle of their special needs, like dry toast or whatever, but even "normal " people do.
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
29 Jul 08
I am good at talking to total strangers and I did work at a place with children with disabilities, when I was in my twenties, but they did not like me because I was always talking to the children as if they did not have disabilities. (We were to show pity and condescension) so that did not last long and it did not help me with adoption anyway. (You know, there is an assumption that if you cannot bear children that God is punishing you and you have no maternal instincts and you have to show how loving you are of children who are disabled or of a different race, etc. Utter nonsense, of course.) Oh and the people in walkers, there is my husband who had a slight stroke and when we see a woman of 60 plus in a walker, he says she's sixty, and you might end up that way, then he says that we are old. So I try to avoid them as much as possible. It is as almost as he wished I was in a walker or a wheelchair.
2 people like this
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
29 Jul 08
I was always nervous around people in wheelchairs, etc. and I did not know how to speak to them. I did not want to make a big fuss or go especially out of my way, but felt that I was being pressured to make a point of being extra ordinary nice to them. He did make a spectacle. I am sure if he had not done all that rigamoralle, and just asked for help, no one would have said anything.
3 people like this
@capirani (2817)
• United States
29 Jul 08
I know it can be difficult to know how to talk to someone in a wheelchair or with some other kind of disability. Let me help you out there. Just try to accept that the chair might be different than the kind of chair you sit in, but the person in the chair is just the same. So speak to him or her the same way you would someone who was not disabled. It can take practice, and if you are truly interested in learning more about this, try volunteering at your local nursing home. There are lots of wonderful people living there who are in various stages of disability and are in wheelchairs, or using cains or walkers, or can't hear or see. They love company and love to talk. Mostly it will just take a simple open ended question and you might not have to talk much at all...they will do it all just to have someone to talk to. It will greatly help you get more comfortable around people with disabilities.
3 people like this
@nonew3 (1941)
• United States
5 Aug 08
I notice everyone, disabled or not. For me, everyone gets equal notice so that no one feels ignored and no one gets special treatment. I have gotten this attitude since I had several months or so with a blind cane due to vision problems coming from my migraine disorder, and also one time I was on crutches due to sprained knees and sprained ankles. I remember what it was like to be stared at and to be asked a lot of questions that were really inappropriate and none of their business. Oh, yes, and I was often accused of faking it. Everyone is equal in my eyes, or at least that is what I am aiming for.
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
5 Aug 08
I can tell if someone is faking. Do they not moan and groan only when the attention is on them?
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
5 Aug 08
I never told anyone that they are faking. I am not an expert. There is the insurance companies that find out. And if your doctor said you need crutches maybe you can shove the doctor's instructions in her face. I never even ask questions unless it is an older man, and then I assume that he fell on the bomb to save his comrades. so I ask about the war and in most cases, it is a war injury and that is because when I was a baby, the Second World War was on so when I see someone older than me like in their eighties, I tend to think of the disability as a war injury. I do wonder about those in those scooters though. My mother-in-law thinks that once you get in one, if you cannot walk that good (she had bad hips and they were almost gone) you will never get out. I do not know if they need the scooters, the disabled people who use them, whether it is because they walk too slow that a car would run over them before they cross the street, or whether they are so crippled, and would have to rely on a wheelchair anyway. I guess it is the same with walkers, before people used canes and had someone to help them, now it is the walkers.
@nonew3 (1941)
• United States
5 Aug 08
I try not to judge whether or not someone is faking. I was definitely NOT faking it, although some outright accused me of such, and although rumors were spread around that I was faking, and although this went on for many years and I have lost some friends because of this. (One woman, a former best friend, actually told me to my face that I am faking my disabilities and to never speak to her again. Of course, she never bothered to consult my doctors first before doing that.) Unless we are that person's medical doctor, I don't think it's our business to make that kind of judgment. We don't really know all the details.
1 person likes this
• Canada
29 Jul 08
Hi again... I did not realize until now that you live in Winnipeg...and are a writer. Wow...a kindred spirit who is so close to us. David and I used to live in Winnipeg, but now live in Manitou in South Central Manitoba. How interesting. Anyway, my view on this topic is that as I writer I also observe people, events and life's happenings. I was taught not to stare...but not looking at disabled persons was not acceptable either. My mother felt that not looking could create a feeling of invisibility...and I tend to agree with her. Ignoring, looking away, avoiding eye contact with a "challenged" person is not all that respectful either...in my view anyway. So...it can be a hard to know what to do...but I guess my approach is...whatever seems to be the most, loving choice. Raia
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
29 Jul 08
I just look long enough to see the whole person, but I am a sucker for babies, and I usually smile at them and if possible try to speak to their mothers and say how adorable they are and how old is he or she or what his or her name is. So it should be the mothers of the babies who should complain not the people in wheelchairs or in walkers. So how is it in Manitou? Is it a small town? I have some friends who live in Carmen, it is not near there, is it?
3 people like this
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
2 Aug 08
I do fiction writing, mostly novels. I do have a blog listed on my profile, and I have done some article writing, but not good at that stuff. I am better at writing novels, and I am on the sixth draft of my novel. It is not finished yet and I will have to do three more drafts. It seems my character will not cooperate. I have some fan fiction, but with myLot I do not have the time to pursue that. I do have one article published and I won an Alfred Hitchcock contest once.
• Canada
2 Aug 08
Hi again, I can relate to your approach with babies...it is something I do as well. I also agree with looking without staring and taking in the whole person. So we are on the same page on that one too. We love Manitou...it is a friendly, safe, clean community. We moved here in December of 1994 and then left to pursue our dream of having an acreage in the Lake of the Woods. After a couple of years we moved back to the very house we left and are sooooo glad that everything worked out the way it did. We love our home, Manitou, the Pembina Valley and rolling hills surrounding our little town. The property taxes are way lower than Winnipeg as well. Carman is about 45 minutes from where we are. It has an interesting "feel" talking to someone from our old home town. Often we are chatting with people in places much further away than that. What type of writing do you do? I have a column in the The Aquarian that comes out 4 times a year called Perspectives on Healthy Living. I have also written for Alive magazine and the Healthy Living Guide out of Vancouver. In the last couple of years I have been doing photojournalism work for a number of local newspapers. Great chatting with you...and look forward to more! Raia
1 person likes this
@SomeCowgirl (32189)
• United States
29 Jul 08
I feel that people who stare for long periods of time are rude. I don't start at the disabled because my mother is and I know that she wouldn't want me staring at her all day. I don't think it's right that people stare just because a person is disabled. I don't think you were wrong in staring for a little bit, maybe a few glances, but staring at them for a long period of time only makes them feel even more self conscience then they already are. I hope you get many responses here and that you have a wonderful day.
3 people like this
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
31 Jul 08
I think of staring as taking a long time to look at a person. My eyes wandered all over the place. I am also looking for anyone I know at the same time. Now had I known that boy in the wheelchair, I would have said hi anyway, but I never got a chance to find out -is five seconds a stare?
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
29 Jul 08
I was not staring at him, just looking and I looked as long as I look at anyone else. It was just that my husband made a point of it. The boy was too busy talking to his sisters to notice anything other than them. Also there is a store behind him, and I usually look that way or rather take a panoramic view of things. It is as if I was told I did something wrong when I was just being normal, observing people.
3 people like this
@SomeCowgirl (32189)
• United States
30 Jul 08
I hope that I did not confuse you, or make you feel as if I was insulting you. You sort of confused me yourself by your discussion, but I do appreciate your clarification. People take staring in all different ways, wherein you were just taking a glance, your husband may have thought that you appeared to be staring.
1 person likes this
@Elixiress (3878)
29 Jul 08
I would pay them no / little attention. When I am in a store, I barely take any notice of anyone, okay I take enough notice to not bump into them and then I talk to people that talk to me such as cashiers, but other than that I do not look at people etc, so I do not go out my way with disabled people. I know many of them feel really bad when people do that, my Gran is disabled and hates is when people offer to do everything for her, because it makes her feel useless and if she needed help then she would ask.
3 people like this
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
29 Jul 08
I observe everyone, so for me to look at someone who is disabled is just as natural to me as my looking at that cute baby, or the couple talking to each other, etc. So it was not that I was bug-eyed and bushy tailed staring at that boy. I was just looking. I am also interested in what people are saying. I get quite a few ideas, like we were in Tim Hortons once and there was this mechanic talking about his work and he would never recommend a -- I forgot what it was, so I am an observer.
1 person likes this
@kenzie45230 (3560)
• United States
29 Jul 08
Tell your husband that there's a huge difference between people watching and staring rudely. And I'm betting most disabled folks would realize that you're a people watcher. Perhaps they're even watching you...and if you DID ignore a disabled person who had noticed you people watching, he/she might feel badly because you merely glanced around him/her instead of studying, like you did with the "normal" folks.
3 people like this
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
29 Jul 08
I tried to tell my husband that, but would he listen? He just kept on with his lecture. I mean I do not ignore people, I am a people watcher.
2 people like this
@richiem (3644)
• Philippines
4 Aug 08
I think disabled persons are really eye-catchers in public places but I also think it would be rude to look for a long time. I think it would make him feel insecure. I would just give him a glance and then that's it. Have a nice day!
1 person likes this
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
4 Aug 08
I look all over the place, so I cannot just ignore that boy and go all over the place with everyone else. I think two or three seconds is not staring, do you or is there a difference between looking at someone with a disability then with other people? I mean here I am in Winnipeg and I see disabled people all the time, there is always someone with a limp, using a walker or a wheelchair, that I cannot avoid it. Does that mean for healthy people I can look for three seconds but for disabled the time limit should be one second?
1 person likes this
@richiem (3644)
• Philippines
5 Aug 08
There should be no difference really. If you stare at me, I would also feel insecure and I would think that you are thinking of something bad about me. It's just that when we see disabled person, sometimes we do not notice that we are staring at them for a long time already because we get curious of their looks and things like how do they handle it.
@bamakelly (5191)
• United States
29 Jul 08
I have come across many handicapped people in my life, especially in wheelchairs. I always feel bad for them, however I don't make it a habit to stare to long or make a big fuss. If they need help or I feel they need help I will ask them. There has been a couple of occasions where I have helped walk somebody while they were sitting in a wheelchair and they appreciated it. I think that sometimes these people like to be independent and don't want to be fussed over all of the time.
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
29 Jul 08
I was just looking the same way as I look at everyone else. It was just that my husband thinks I should not even look at them for one second, that I should just read the Coffee News and drink my coffee. And I would never fuss over them. I do not like treating people as special, to me it is sort of worshiping them.
1 person likes this
@Pigglies (9329)
• United States
30 Jul 08
One of my friends is disabled and I was at the mall with her before when she saw some girl in a wheelchair that was bald and looked so sickly that she was most likely going through chemo. And my friend actually pointed at her! I was so embarrassed. My friend thinks it's pretty rude when people see her and then just look away though. I usually just look at everyone about the same, not staring but not obviously trying my hardest to look away or anything. The only people I usually can't help staring at are the people with mohawks and things like that.
1 person likes this
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
30 Jul 08
I was just looking at this boy as I look at everyone else. I was not gawking and it was just that the boy was young and in a wheelchair that my husband got upset, and started that long lecture. As I said previous in this post, I was nervous around handicapped people because when I was around five or so, I could not pronounce the th and they put me in this place with children who were severely disfigured or strange looking because of several mental handicaps, and that scared me for a long time. It made me so that I wanted people to be know for being people and that what was inside of them, not what they looked like outside. I mean maybe I should have just said look as I look at everyone else or you would not have thought I had my mouth gaping over and my eyes like saucers.
@coffeeshot (3783)
• Australia
30 Jul 08
Ok I kinda lost you at the mayonnaise bit but I think I understand what you're saying. I get very emotional when I see disabled people. I think it's the nurturing side of me. I admit I do stare, subtley, but not rudely. I imagine how I would like people to treat me if I were disabled and I think 'I'd like people to just ignore me and not single me out'. SO I try to look away and not stare but sometimes I just can't help but want to be friends with disabled people. It probably sounds really weird but it does upset me when I see them. Most probably they are happy with their lives and quite satisfied and have many people who love them, so I shouldn't feel sorry for them. Near me there is a main road and all the time you'd see this young guy with cerebral palsy walking down this road (it's a Looong road) and he'd be hobbling along and I'd so want to stop and give him a lift cos I felt so sorry for him. Then I'd think about the people who have ever driven past him and yelled mean things out the window. My emotions come into play a bit too much when I see disabled people, at times I've even wanted to give up my career and work in that area as a counsellor or something. So yeah I understand that you watch all types of people and you're not being rude, you're just interested in different people.
1 person likes this
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
30 Jul 08
Thanks. I do not like single people out as what they look like or whether they cannot do what others do. I do not even like it when people get promotions and adulation on their disabilities or color. I would expect that they are embarrassed by that. It is as if they are important because of their looks and not what is inside of them.
• United States
30 Jul 08
It is rude to look at those in wheel chairs. We all need to learn how to be tolarant of others no matter what disabities they have. People in wheelchairs are just like us only in wheel chairs is the only difference. My Mom never let us stare at anyone.
1 person likes this
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
30 Jul 08
I look at everyone and it would not look right for me to look at everyone else and then just ignore them. So the next time I see a disabled person who is with people who are not, I just turn my head and just look at the ones that are not, right? Is that just as bad or worse because you are encouraging them to be ignored? No wonder I feel nervous around people in walkers and wheelchairs. You cannot look at them as you look at other people, and yet that leads to me thinking that they are very special. Anyway I was not staring. I just glanced over. I mean that was a very unusual wheelchair. I guess he was able to raise it up by a switch.
@cdparazo (5765)
• Philippines
31 Jul 08
I try not to but I thought I am being more obvious when I don't look. So I just look and then look away as if there is nothing is really wrong and as if I didn't notice. But there is this one particular child wherein I just couldn't help ogling. His head is bigger than his body and it really kind of scary to look because his head is very big. I saw the child a number of times already in SM Cebu and everytime I see him, I always felt like crying. But the child is smiling and seemed resigned to his fate. So I make exception to this particular child and everytime I see him there, I do stare at him. My heart always breaks everytime I see and I always see a prayer for him that whatever he is going through, won't be that painful and that he may live what is left of his short life happily.
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
2 Aug 08
There is a lady in the church on the other side of the district where I live that has a daughter who is not only mentally retarded, but severely so. She has the mind of a small child She is in a special wheelchair that lies down and she also has cerebral palsy. She cannot do more than shriek or make gestures. We do not know how long she will be on this world, but every time I see her, I feel like crying. I do not know what to say, but I do not turn away when I see them. I just smile. My husband's sister is in a wheelchair having several strokes and possible Lou Gehrig's disease that left her almost paralyzed, unable to swallow water, can think but the nerve centers of her brain do not connect and my husband does not want to see her because he would be so upset. Me I am more nervous about people with disabilities, but we see so many in wheelchairs and walkers that it is so common.
@maximax8 (31042)
• United Kingdom
4 Aug 08
I observe people for who they are and it doesn't matter what they look like. A person in a wheelchair must deal with getting around in a world that is not always easy to move around in. My toddler son is in a pushchair and I find steps hard to get up and down. He has spina bifida and at 14 months old he looks like a normal child. He has had an operation on his back and on his head to put a shunt inside it. He has one strong leg and one weak leg. Nobody is sure if he will be able to walk when he is older, he drags himself along my lounge floor at the moment. He seems intelligent but he has to put up with catheter care and lots of therapy. One of my friends has muscular distrophy. She can walk but can't lift anything heavy and she gets quite a lot of pain.
1 person likes this
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
5 Aug 08
It seems my husband figures I cannot just look at them, he figures either I should turn away or show a lot of sympathy and go up and help them. To me, I do not want to do either. If I know them, I will say hi, but with my husband's attitude I am inclined to go and ask if they need any help, so making their disabilities count more than the person, it puts me in dire straits. So I am fighting the see them as a person and the see them as a disability and when I read your response it seems that you want me to do the latter. I hope I am wrong.
@Sherry12 (2472)
• United States
5 Aug 08
I try to treat everyone the same. I think it is rude to stare at anyone. I would probably try to say something to the person in the wheelchair, or maybe smile at them. Ignoring them would be rude. They know they are in a wheelchair and to not acknowledge it or pretend it isn't there wouldn't be right. My mother-in-law was great in making a handicapped person smile. She always knew just the right thing to say to make them comfortable.
1 person likes this
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
5 Aug 08
If I see them and they see me, I smile and say hi, but that boy in the wheelchair was so engrossed talking to his sisters, that a bomb could have gone off right besides him and he would not have flinched.