Would you put child for adoption.

@agrim94 (3805)
India
March 2, 2009 8:21am CST
This is a question can be hypothetical... would u advise a 16 years old girl whose bf has deserted her to abort or put up the kid to be for adoption or raise the kid herself knowing fully well that she has no means to support a child and she is too a child ( only 16) and is not mature enough to bring up a child .
6 people like this
19 responses
@moondancer (7433)
• United States
2 Mar 09
Many young girls still have their chld, go to school, and take care of what needs to be taken care of. This is a decision that only the girl can make. It's her thoughts and feeling at stake here. I wouldn't want to tell her to give up her beloved child and then have her feel guilty or want the child back later. If she can deal with it it's her decision. A father is not needed i the echilds life. But a mother is. The childs mother knows whats best for her baby. As long as she has the help of her family then she could keep her child and finish school so she can get a good job to support herself and the child.
1 person likes this
@agrim94 (3805)
• India
2 Mar 09
:) i hope it is definitely this easy to do this.. i dont think she can raise a child while she herself would be so young and no money with her. What job can she get and say even if she gets 6 or 7$ a hour job and school too so either she can work 3 hours a day or neglect the baby altogether. so 20$ a day in a country like usa and no job in country like India i dont think her taking care of baby. If she has very strong family support then it is different becausue then her mom can look after the baby and the family can also support girl till she completes her study and she gets good job to support herself and child.
1 person likes this
• United States
2 Mar 09
I have to admit I don't know what it's like for job in India. Here in the US many girls have and keep theri babies. They get help from family and friends to watch the baby while she works and goes to school. She must finish school and college to get a good job. If she thinks she can pass it and you have a test that she can take that is the equivalent of a high school degree then that's probably what she needs to do, that way she can go ahead and get training fo a job. I wish her well and blessings in what she decides to do.
1 person likes this
• United States
2 Mar 09
definetly adoption. unless she had a strong family network who would help her raise her child. i think that abortion should (almost) never be an option. there are very few cases, like rape, where i think abortion would be a choice.
1 person likes this
@agrim94 (3805)
• India
2 Mar 09
adoption is good if the child can have a nice home and foster parents after adoption .. then if you live in a third world country like india then the family name is tarnished and can lead to huge social problems for the parents and if she lives in a country like Pakistan or middle east..she might be killed if the news leaked out so abortion is acceptable in these circumstances.
1 person likes this
@rsa101 (37933)
• Philippines
3 Mar 09
Well if youwould ask me I wouldn't do that at all. That is part of you already. That flesh and blood of your daughter which is also yours. Why would I give that up and just lose the identity of the child. It was not her fault why she was here why would I give up her real identity.
@rsa101 (37933)
• Philippines
3 Mar 09
Well adoption is a choice of course. But under the cirucumstances that you've mentioned then it is really up to her. It is that when I think about it after sometime, you might still long for the baby that is supposed to be yours but you gave up on him a long time ago. He may be in good hands right now but then there is this part of you that you've lost permanently that you will never be able to know how he is. He is part of you no matter how you gave up on him because of some reasons.
@agrim94 (3805)
• India
3 Mar 09
Thx rsa for the respons but just think it is not fault of child to live whole of his/her child hood in real real poverty and the child would have to live a life of being called Bast*** whole life which is meanest of mean things to say to anyone in this part of world while if the child gets foster parents he can have a nice home, pvt school education and can become something in life.
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
3 Mar 09
I was in the same situation as this girl was and I would tell her to give up her child for adoption. I would tell her to find a good agency, and look for couples who are of the same ethnic group as she is, same coloring, etc. That would ensure that if in the future the child as an adult looks for her, she or he would not resent the adoptive parents who look so different from her birth mother and if that child never finds her birth mother, he or she will not so much different from her relatives. I think a lot of problems arise when the child seeings that her or she does not fit in.
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
3 Mar 09
Usually if the parents and the child are similar, then the child thinks that maybe his new parents are related to his birth mother and never has the desire to look for her. It only becomes a problem when the child looks different. Of course, the birth mother needs reassurance that she is not thought of as a bad mother because she made the choice and one has to be sure that the child was not taken away by someone assuming she is a bad mother. And the child has to be reassured that the birth mother gave him up because she loved him, not because she wanted to go and party all the time.
@agrim94 (3805)
• India
3 Mar 09
Thanks suspenseful. You made quite an interesting subject for thinking. Right this problem can arise in western countries where there are lot of races but here it is same race so it shouldnt be a problem and yes i think it is best for everyone if child never finds his real mom or parents after he is adopted and if child never finds out that he was adopted.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
2 Mar 09
I would not send my own child for adoption no matter what, i will do everything i can to survive and support her. It will be my greatest regret if i let her go and be adopted by someone else. Here in my country, even if it's a poor country, i see a lot of women do hard work for their loved ones and adoption is not their solution. I knew a lady friend who is a neighbor who has 8 kids and is not tired of feeding them all. She do hard work like laundry service and ironing clothes to meet both ends. I can say that it is a personal choice if you decide to let your own blood and flesh be adopted by someone else just to see if she/he will be in good hands with proper education and all. But i guess i cannot do it if it happens to me. My child is mine, and i will never give it away.
• China
3 Mar 09
that's bad, i hate that bf though the question is hypothetical, but i love baby so much, i can't accept my baby to be raise by other one. come to this question, the best way is adoption.
@agrim94 (3805)
• India
3 Mar 09
yes either abortion or adoption .. i think this way but i may be 100% wrong
• China
4 Mar 09
yeah, who knows the best way? no best way.
• United States
3 Mar 09
In my opinion for me I wouldn't put the child for adoption nor to abort it. In this case even she is a 16 yrs girl if she decided to not abort her child guess she is ready the consequences to raise her child even she is a young lady. Its not about co'z she young and can't raise her child its a matter how she loved her child and want to be a good mother to her child even we really know that she was disappoint her parents. Its her decision on that, good luck to her.
@agrim94 (3805)
• India
3 Mar 09
Thanks journey for ur valuable opinion.. i would let her know about what you think. and ur right let her have the final say what she wants.
@kissie34 (2294)
• Philippines
3 Mar 09
Well, if I am in her situation maybe I will put my child for adoption. I just rather let my child hate me for the rest of my life and not being with me than killing him/her in hunger and able not to give him/her a good life for his/her future. Of course, if I will adopt my child I'll make sure that she/he will be in a right hand. I'll choose the person who will adopt my child so that I can see to it that she/he will have a good and happy life with her/his foster parents. However, if I can afford to take care of my child and my family will be there to help me then I won't adopt my child. Maybe, if I get pregnant as my age right now (22) then maybe I can take care of my own child even without the help of my boyfriend/ the father of my child since in my age I can already find a good job and I can handle with my life already.. I think this kind of situation is really not easy to decide because it also depends in your status and situations in life. A lot of sacrifices and you must really have faith in yourself in deciding things like this.
@agrim94 (3805)
• India
3 Mar 09
Thx kissie for your response and yes ultimately it comes down to money and ur right in this.. if the girl has means to bring the child and give him everything that is required for a normal and healthy childhood then she can keep the kid .. i think thats wise enough.
@paula27661 (15811)
• Australia
3 Mar 09
I know 16 is far too young to be a mother, but I have seen what putting your child up for adoption can do to a woman. In my opinion because abortion would be out of the question it would depend on the type of girl the mother to be is. If she is relatively mature and has a good support network I would advise she keep the baby. On the other hand if the girl in question was a troubled young woman with emotional problems or addictions etc... I would recommend she give the child up. If a young woman is to have a baby good support is paramount. When I say she should keep the baby I don't mean to make it sound easy or trivial, it's the one thing that will affect the rest of her life forever and not an easy decision by any means.
@agrim94 (3805)
• India
3 Mar 09
to be single mom is very difficult thing and then that too for a 16 years old girl who is poor and have no good education and if she was responsible enough i don't think she would be in this dilemma and wouldn't have become pregnant in first place. She is still 16, a baby herself and got whole life in front of her , would she want it to be ruined by keeping the child?
@lynnemg (4529)
• United States
3 Mar 09
Although I could never personally give a child up for adoption, no matter what my circumstances were, I would have to say that this is a choice that is quite prersonal. At 16, most girls are not ready to be a mother, but, they can learn how to care for their baby properly. If she has parents that will help guide her, I would not advise adoption, because she may grow to regret her choice later on, or may go the other directon and become pregnant again knowing that sje coulf give that baby up too. I would never recommend abortion. I do nelieve that it is a woman's choice, but I also believe that the baby didn't ask to be conceived and doesn't deserve to miss on out life. I know that there are many oppossing arguments to that, but, that is my opinion. If she absolutely has no means of talking care of that baby after checking out absolutely every avenue of help possible, then, and only then would I think that adoption is the right choice.
@agrim94 (3805)
• India
3 Mar 09
hi lynnemg thanks for your opinion.. aborting is very personal choice if other factors esp the social stigma of being an unmarried mother ( as in some countries)or how would ur family react to it... suppose u think ur father would hang himself if he finds out that his daughter got pregnant b4 marriage then what would ur response be.
• United States
3 Mar 09
I would not have an abortion now or ever...not even if my life is in danger. However, if i could provide a good home life and stable finances for my child then i would keep it. If not i would give it up for adoption. I know my Aunt wanted children so badly all her life and she could not have but one and she still wanted another. I know there are many people in the world who would love a child and i would find a good home for the baby.
@agrim94 (3805)
• India
3 Mar 09
I understand your feeling and i do hope no girl esp teenage girl has a baby out of wedlock.. it helps preventing so many complications.. Baby has a proper last name and both parents can raise a baby so good and baby needs love and care of both parents to develop in to nice adult .. he needs a home full of love and understanding but if he sees his mom alone who got pregnant before marriage then he would think this is normal thing and wont think twice before making any girl pregnant when he is adult or if it is girl she might go her mothers way..
@elysium (169)
• United States
3 Mar 09
If she has no means to support a child, then I would say to give it up for adoption. But, that sixteen - year - old girl is the only one who can make the right decision. If I was her, then I would take care of the baby, even if it is by myself. I would not want my baby to be taken care of strangers because I would constantly be worried about how my child is doing. I would want my child to know that I am willing to be a good mother to him/her, even if he/she grows up without a father.
@agrim94 (3805)
• India
3 Mar 09
I understand but Elysium the Girl is just 16 and she has whole life and sooner than later she would have other men in her life too who might not be too kind on the kid and she has no money , no proper education and no support to take care of kid.
• Philippines
3 Mar 09
yes, put that child in adoption right away, if you cant go on with your life then go put it in adoption! a child raised in a different side might be unknown by his parents.. its quite hard to grow up without mom or dad..
@agrim94 (3805)
• India
3 Mar 09
it is very hard on both single mom and one parent child.
• Canada
3 Mar 09
I would consider abortion out of the question i believe it is a terrible practice that should not even be allowed. If she has no means of support than adoption seems the only logical choise
@agrim94 (3805)
• India
3 Mar 09
Thx Mitch for ur answer here, and i do believe that abortion is individual choice and if she goes for abortion i got no prob. There are 1000s of question raised if the girl is from a respectable middle class Indian family and gets pregnant before marriage.
@winterose (39887)
• Canada
2 Mar 09
I am a full grown woman I would not put my child up for adoption but in that girl's case it may very well be the best thing for her and the baby at this point in her life.
@agrim94 (3805)
• India
3 Mar 09
Yes for the kid if she doesnt think of aborting it, it would be the best provided she can find real good parents and home for the kid
@maximax8 (31053)
• United Kingdom
2 Mar 09
I would suggest that the sixteen year old considers having her baby adopted. It would be the sort of adoption that is open. I would like her to be able to choose the adoptive parents she thinks are most suitable. It would be great if she received a yearly progress report about the baby. I would tell her that it would be possible for her to keep her baby. She could give help in the way of second hand baby equipment and get a home through the Housing Association. I would offer to help her until she is mature enough to manage on her own. She could get Housing Benefit and Child Tax Credit to live on. I would encourage her to go to an evening class once a week to gain qualifications. I would not agree with an abortion. Her baby would be an innocent one that would want to live, be cared for and loved.
@agrim94 (3805)
• India
2 Mar 09
Thx for your response maximax8 but she doesnt have any income to pay any tax so no need for tax breaks and there is no such thing as housing assoiciation when we have so much shortage of houses and prices of even a small 200 sq ft flat ( apartment) in suburb of delhi is well over 50,000$ and u can think of how life would be in 200 sq ft apartment and girls dont work here when they are 16 unless she is from very poor family and all she can do is do dishes and clean homes in other people home where she can earn about 60 to 100$ a month.
• United States
9 Mar 09
i would advise to abort or adopt.. i think some teens feel that they have to keep the kid sometimes (most of the time they feel they have to give it up but i have known some people that really forced their kids to keep them etc) i dont think its right to make them keep the baby because your punishing everyone (especially the kid) if she chose abortion then at least she woudlnt have to deal with the whole pregnancy which i would think would be better than having to deal with the stigma of being pregnant so young.. but i guess if i wasnt pro-choice i would think totally different..
@bombshell (11256)
• Germany
2 Mar 09
the teenagers should know how to prevent of not getting pregnant before opening their legs if they are not ready for having a kid.i dont have choices of thisits realy sad that kid is growing in a different people.
@agrim94 (3805)
• India
3 Mar 09
It definitely is and i hope every teenage girl can take your advise but when it comes to going down in bed then most people forget what the books have been screaming for centuries
@fasttalker (2796)
• United States
2 Mar 09
My advice would b adoption for two reasons. Forst I don't believe in abortion and second I have an adopted son that I just adopted a few months ago. There are a lot of people out there that would provide a good home and family for a child. With that being said I also believe that if the 16 yr old chooses to raise the child on her own it if fully possible for her to do so. That's not saying it would be easy but definately possible. It just depends on how serious she is about taking on the task and how much support she has.
@agrim94 (3805)
• India
2 Mar 09
I think what you say make sense but it is so difficult to adopt a child here and if a childless couple who desperately want a child do adopt a child it is good for everyone provided they keep the child like their own.. It has been seen if that childless couple have a child of their own after they adopted then they do differentiate between two children and the adopted child is definitely discriminated against.