Do you have relatives in the nursing home?

@Bebs08 (10681)
United States
April 27, 2009 7:33pm CST
In the Philippines we don't have nursing homes. We have to take care of our sick relatives at home but in the US.. most sick people specially the older ones are recovering in the nursing homes. Lately, I have been visiting the nursing homes and I've seen people who are lonely because they are away from their loved ones. What a pitiful situation. They are being cared for by other people other than their families. How would you feel when your sick family member will be away from you, sad and lonely? I might not be able to sleep at night thinking of them. We never do that in my country. What about you? is there any big reason why you can not keep them at home? or why they are being cared for by other people?
7 people like this
15 responses
@surveygrrl (1270)
• United States
28 Apr 09
My Grandma is in a nursing home. She just went into one back in December. She is 89 and had a stroke. We all live in different states and cannot provide the medical care that she needs, round the clock, due to some of her ailments. I wish she lived closer but she does't want to leave the stat she is in. My uncle lives close and stops to see her every day and now everyone in the family can fly down to see her for free. I am currently 38 weeks pregnant and can't fly but hope to visit her again soon.
2 people like this
@Bebs08 (10681)
• United States
29 Apr 09
Oh!! that's sweet that even you re too far you still have a time to visit and see her. Maybe there are some valid reasons why some families are taking their old members to the nursing homes like what you said.
@salonga (27775)
• Philippines
28 Apr 09
I'm glad the Philippines is not like the U.S. in terms of how they value the oldies. I would not ever allow somebody else to take care of my Mom (my Dad already deceased) while I am still alive. How could I ever just entrust her to someone else after all the love and care she gave me as a child and till I grow and made a family of my own. I firmly believe that when parents have grown old, it is the responsibility of the children to care for them. This good example of the children will likewise be followed by their own children when they themselves become old parents.
1 person likes this
@Bebs08 (10681)
• United States
28 Apr 09
That's right my friend because that is our culture and there is no medicare there in our country that supports that sick people except when you are hospitalized and you have meddicare but here in US, almost all citizens have their medicate and health insurance and whatever it is... that would support them for that matter. And their families have no time because they are busy with their job. My friend, it is not easy to be here in America as what others think. Everybody has to work to earn a living.. some have 2-3 jobs just to let both ends meet. Taxes are high,cost of living is higher plus bills and other things. I think, it;s good in the Philippines because we can live simply and commodities are a lot cheaper. That is you have a good there? it's better to just live there. My hubby wants to live in the Philippines when he will retire.. hahahaha.. that would be better.
1 person likes this
@salonga (27775)
• Philippines
28 Apr 09
Yes dear I believe you. I have a friend there too who is saying exactly what you said. It is just the people here were thinking life is better then in the U.S. I can't agree with them. I love the simple living here and you are right the commodities are far cheaper. I can even eat with only the vegetables I planted around as dish and already happy. I love simple life but God is gracious enough, He gave me even more that I was asking!
1 person likes this
@marciascott (25529)
• United States
28 Apr 09
I do have a Aunt in a Nursing home. She has been in there for a while. I don't think she will be getting out soon.
1 person likes this
@Bebs08 (10681)
• United States
29 Apr 09
Did you visit her there? I hope so.
@cher913 (25782)
• Canada
28 Apr 09
i have an elderly aunt that lives in one here in canada and it is a very nice but very expensive. it is a privately owned one and kept very well. she is there because she needs round the clock care which no one, except a trained proffesional can give her.
1 person likes this
@Bebs08 (10681)
• United States
29 Apr 09
Oh!! I can understand that situation. But those who had the time but just don;t want to do it, am sad for the old one. I think Canada is a better place to live than US.. hehehe
@eichs1 (1934)
• Philippines
29 Apr 09
I just want to correct the fact that there are no nursing homes in the Philippines. There are some actually and it is not just those operated by the government. There are also private nursing homes and some managed by non-government organizations/ foundations. Nursing homes may not be that popular in the Philippines. What is customarily done is for those who can afford to employ a private nurse or household help living-in with them. As much as possible, I also favor oldies staying with their relatives. But as @kellyt82 has enumerated, there are lots of reasons why some old folks have to be kept in the nursing homes. I would rather have the old folks with medical problems to be in the nursing homes than abandoned at family's/relatives' homes. There are also abusive and relatives without patience who are not apt to take care of their oldies. This type of family/relatives should turn-over their old folks to nursing homes.
1 person likes this
@Bebs08 (10681)
• United States
29 Apr 09
Oh? maybe you know of some in other parts of the Philippines but in the place where I was, there is none.. not common. I know of a home for the aged but it was operated by the DSWD. If there are nursing homes in there, maybe not in the place where I was. I can agree with that, round the clock care of the trained nurses which the family members can not do but it is our Filipino culture and tradition to take care of our old family members when they are not able to take care for themselves. A return favor of what they did to us when we are young.
• China
28 Apr 09
I do not have any relatives in nursing homs.I know that it is very easy to go to nursing homes ! There are good and bad aspects about it !
1 person likes this
@Bebs08 (10681)
• United States
29 Apr 09
You are right!! but many people choose to do that because they have no time to take care of their sick family members round the clock. They are busy with work.
@spoiled311 (5500)
• Philippines
28 Apr 09
hi bebs08! hi, i am also from the philippines and to answer your question, no, we don't have relatives in nursing homes or homes for the aged for that matter. our families stay with us up until God decides to take them home to be with Him. yeah, i think it is sad to stay in nursing homes. but i guess that is just part of our culture. in other countries, i think they prefer to stay in these homes where they can be taken care of, because most of their families could not. or often choose not to. take care and God bless you! happy mylotting! :D
1 person likes this
@Bebs08 (10681)
• United States
29 Apr 09
I think there are 2 main reasons why most old and sick people here are taken to the nursing homes. It is because they have health insurance and benefits from the government that they are taking advantage of and secondly, their families have no time to take care of them because they are busy in their job. They have to work to earn because it is really hard here in US if you are not working. Everybody has to earn because everything is expensive. Specially the taxes and the bills.
@riyasam (16556)
• India
28 Apr 09
although we do have nursing homes here,it is not so popular here.i do think it is the duty of the children to care for their parents and almost all indians think similarly except some few who are trying to ape the western culture.
@Bebs08 (10681)
• United States
29 Apr 09
Correct!! Nursing homes are not common in other countries.. and it is not also in our culture to just send our old relatives to nursing facility and besides we can not afford to pay for private care except for the rich people.
@rsa101 (37952)
• Philippines
28 Apr 09
Well I think it is in the culture that these things happen. Although, there is an existing home for the aged in our country. But these homes are really intended for those that cannot afford to take care of their old ones or sometimes they really do not have anyone to take care for themselves. I have been into one and their situation is really desperate as our nursing homes are not as well equip as those that are in abroad. There is lack of government support perhaps in this kind of institutions in our place. I truly hope that they could have a better home but so far I haven't seen a good one to date. That is why many families in our country chooses to take care of our old ones because of that.
1 person likes this
@Bebs08 (10681)
• United States
28 Apr 09
Well, I know of one too when I was yet in the Philippines and that was under DSWD. Yes, the old people who are there mostly were abandoned by their families. They are not taking care of them and the government is the one helping them. But there are only very few of that.. most oldies were taken care of their own family like their sons and daughters who are adults.
@walijo2008 (4644)
• United States
28 Apr 09
I think Nursing Homes are sad places to visit, I feel for those who don't have any family to visit them, some of them are just there, their forgotten and I think its sad. I myself would never put a family member in one, if I can take care of them at home thats what I will do, thats what I told my mom, I'll never send her to one, its too sad.
1 person likes this
@Bebs08 (10681)
• United States
28 Apr 09
correct!! it is too sad.. I have to the nursing home most often and some of the oldies there said, they miss their families. They will be glad when groups of people from church come and visit them. that is nice.
• United States
28 Apr 09
No, my parents still take care of themselves.
1 person likes this
@Bebs08 (10681)
• United States
29 Apr 09
Well, good!! what if they will really getting very old?
• Philippines
28 Apr 09
Hi Friend, it has been quite a time since I have heard from you. Great that you are back in the circulation. Well, I came from the same country where you used to live and that is true we do take care of our elderly and nursing homes for most of us is not an option. I have been to several home for the aged in my place especially during the holiday and I can see loneliness in the old ones eyes and I know deep inside that they miss there relatives. I for one can't imagine putting my parents in such environment when they grow old. My grand mother lives with us and my aunt and mom makes sure she get all the care that she needs though we tend to joke at it at times that my lola nowadays is getting bratty for all the attention that she getting. LOL. With the Filipino culture and tradition families would unlikely consider nursing homes with their old love ones.
@Bebs08 (10681)
• United States
29 Apr 09
Correct!!! It is in our culture and tradition that we don't want our loved ones to be away from us specially when they are getting old. We want to take care of them personally. What I know about the home for the aged facility in our country is that they will accept clients who are abandoned by their relatives and no body took care of them, then the government will took them in. But here in US is different. Their families are really the ones who process for their their old ones to be in the nursing homes or retired homes because they have no time to take care of them.. they are very busy with work, and these old people have their disability insurance which will cover their expenses for their stay in the nursing homes. They are just making use of their contribution when hey are yet employed. That's the way it is here.
• China
28 Apr 09
Nursing home is a new thing in China. In Chinse concept,taking care of olders is reaonalbe, which is a tradition. if someone don't take care of their parents, they will be blamed by the senior. I think this is very good. But now, there are some changes especially in city. some young couples carry the older to nursing homes, the reasons:(1) the young do not like their life style;(2)the young were too busy to take care of them, as the high pressure in city. Personally, I will take care of parents whatever happen, because parents gave me the life and give me money to go to school. They should be paid.
1 person likes this
@Bebs08 (10681)
• United States
28 Apr 09
You are exactly right!! we should take care of our parents in return of their sacrifices for us and besides that.. we love them and we want to take care of them personally.
• Philippines
28 Apr 09
i'm really glad i'm a filipino... we are family oriented and would sacrifice almost everything to stay with our relatives... i have relatives from the us and eventhough that'smthe culture ther they dont allow someone in our family to stay at a nursing home... i think letting your someone stay there is cruel... they wont get better because they'l feel lonely. it's better for them to stay at home with their family s that they can feel their TLC.
1 person likes this
@Bebs08 (10681)
• United States
28 Apr 09
I agree with that. Tender Loving care would help a sick person to get better easily and of course with the help of the medicines but it is more comforting when families are around the sick person. Most Filipinos here that I know, said.. that they don't want to grow old in America.. hahahaha
@kellyt82 (204)
• United States
28 Apr 09
I, personally, do not have any relatives in nursing homes. I know that it is very common, though, in the U. S. I actually used to work in a nursing home so it allowed me to learn a lot of the reasons that people place family members in a home. A lot of people just do not have the means or the way to take care of their family member. Many times the family member is of the age where medicare will pay for all or most of the cost of the nursing home. Many people, as bad as it sounds, just do not have time to take care of their loved ones. Sometimes their family member needs constant medical care, so they place them in a nursing facility because they are unable to provide that round-the-clock care. Another reason is that they may not have any living family so it is one of the only places to go. I think that in the phillipines you all have a stronger family structure. Your culture seems like they will sacrifice what they can to take care of the family members that need it. I respect that about your culture.
1 person likes this
@Bebs08 (10681)
• United States
28 Apr 09
Oh!!! so you mean, they are there because of the medicare thing? I don't really have an idea of why most people take their sick family member in the nursing home. The only thing I know is that, they have no time to take care of them because they are busy working and that is sad. That is a very good explanation. Yes, I understand also that the sick needs 24 hours round the clock monitoring by the medical people. And that is what the Filipinos do with their outpatient family members. Of course they will take them to the hospital and if they are our from there, they will be the one to take care in their own home. yes, filipinos have close family ties and that is their culture.