Do you read your kid's mail?

United States
June 5, 2009 4:11pm CST
Recently I was involved in a conversation with a friend who admits she reads her child's diary and mail. I was so amazed. Her thinking was that she doesn't have as close of a relationship wih her kids as she would like so this is how she "gets to know" them. I was so shocked. For me it was a trust issue. I never read anything of theirs unless they asked me to share it with them. I always felt like it was a breech of trust even though they were my children and I "had the right" to read anything in my house. I chose to build the trust factor... What do you think? Is it wrong or fair to read your kid's stuff??
2 people like this
8 responses
@katsmeow1213 (28717)
• United States
5 Jun 09
I do believe it is fair to read a child's diary and mail. Some parents just don't have that bond with their child, no matter how hard they try and no matter how much they want their child to talk to them. Sometimes that's just how it goes. It is the parent's responsiblity to know what's going on in the child's life, and to intervene if there is a problem, that's my stand anyways. I wouldn't question it if a parent said they were reading their child's diary. I personally do not go snooping through my kid's stuff, but if they leave a notebook on the kitchen table and walk away from it, I might pick it up and flip through it. I haven't ever found anything other than some doodles, but I still look. Yes, I open the mail too.
2 people like this
• United States
6 Jun 09
Would it be okay if they picked up your notes laying on the table and looked through it? I know if they are smaller that is one thing, but when do they get old enough to have their own privacy? I know there are times parents are concerned if there are huge swings in behavior and stuff like that...Would they ever be able to become responsible enough to prove that to you as their parent?
1 person likes this
• United States
6 Jun 09
I don't view children as small adults. I view them as children who need to be guided through life into adulthood. How can we do that if we don't know what's going on in their lives, and expect them to just tell us everything? What if your 13 year old daughter is kissing her boyfriend at school? What if she's keeping that from you? Don't you want to know about this? Are you just going to sit back and wait for her to tell you she's sexually active... or worse yet... that she's pregnant? On the other hand, you could read it in her diary, know what is going on in her life, and discuss these things with her so she fully understands the gravity of particular actions. How we raise our children, and how we treat them is up to each individual parent. You want to be your child's friend and allow them full privacy... that's your choice. I realize we don't live in a perfect world, and peer pressure is a powerful motivator. So I want to know exactly what's going on in my child's life, and I am not going to trust that my child tells me everything, because I know for a fact I didn't tell my parents everything!
2 people like this
• United States
6 Jun 09
I do understand what you are saying, however, if my child does not trust me because I went through her stuff uninvited she not only won't tell me things, but she'll also make sure to hide her diary and keep things like that hidden at school or somewhere that I cannot retrieve it, making the matter worse. I still haveto vote for the trust issue... the other things will come to light in major behavior swings or moodiness or withdrawal... keeping up with where your kids are and who they are hanging with come fro being with them not simply reading a diary it's a moment by moment adventure....
1 person likes this
@w1986114 (158)
• China
6 Jun 09
I think parents have no right to read their kids' mails. Until now, I am still an apple of parents' eyes and I've never been mother before, but I can say something on behalf of children on this issue. All children know their parents care so much about them, no matter how treasonous they are, but once they find their well-respected parents read their mails without permission, they may feel their parents didn't give them rudimental trust and evetually lose the confidence in their parents.
2 people like this
• United States
6 Jun 09
I would rather my kids hate me and be alive and safe,...rather than be the cool parent and allow them to hide things and get hurt.
2 people like this
• United States
6 Jun 09
The funny thing is.. they will be more likely to not write the stuff you are so worried about... still involvement is the best medicine! And trust is the best prevention in my opinion!
1 person likes this
@queenlove (495)
• United States
6 Jun 09
For some parents, reading their mail and diaries is the only way that they can keep up with what their child is doing. It does not matter how close you are with your daughter, she is not going to tell you EVERYTHING! If everyone read their child's diary, whether it is ethical or not, they would learn some things about their kids that would shock them! I am not defending this or saying that it is right. All I am saying is that doing this, you could help prevent them from making really bad decisions. What if a child has been chatting online with a strange man and you didn't know about it. By reading about it in her diary, or in her emails...you could put a stop to it before something terrible happens. Statistics show that 90% of murders among teenagers were due to a situation that the parents knew nothing about and the parents thought that they knew everything about their child. Besides, I look at it like this. If you are under 18, and you are my child and live in MY house, and you don't pay the bills or contribute to the household...then you don't have the right to privacy. Everything in this house....bedroom, computer, utilities,her clothes, ect. I PAID FOR...so I have the right to monitor it as I please.
2 people like this
• United States
6 Jun 09
True... on a very shallow level... if we remain very involved with our children and know what they are doing and who they are hanging with it will stop a lot of that. My kids never went to someone's house I did not know or had not met. When they played sports I or a family member was there to watch. I took them where they needed to go.. or where I desired for them to go. I did not send them. Many times they did not get to go somewhere because I did not trust the people hosting the event. In hanging out with my kids and not working 24/7 and making sure that I knew where they were 24/7 I knew what was going on because I was involved with them and they were involved with me. I took them with me everywhere I possibly could. They did not always like that... but that's the way it was... and this kept us all in communication.
1 person likes this
@aabuda (1722)
• Philippines
6 Jun 09
I think it is unfair reading with your childrens' mails. Although, it is a matter of trust, but everyone of us deserves to have his privacy. It was actually my feeling when I was young when every mail that comes in our mail box was already open before reaching my very hands. Soon, time flies that I am already working, and I already missed seeing my mails opened, well I guessed they will no longer open my mails because they will only have heartache upon receiving and reading my bank statements!
@aabuda (1722)
• Philippines
8 Jun 09
yes, and I think parents and those who would be parents should also consider this thing with their children. In that way, their children will feel that their parents also respect them and their privacy.
• United States
8 Jun 09
I have to agree with you there!!!
• United States
6 Jun 09
I agree it is a matter of trust! I do not like getting mail that is already opened either.. even if it is bank statements! lol!! the trust factor is a biggy... and it must be protected I think...
• United States
6 Jun 09
Hello, I will have to say I do read my childrens mail, because of this crazy world that we live in have really sick indivisuals in it. I think there are more crime that goes un noticed by parents because that don't pay attention to what their child/children is up to. You here about grown adult men online seeking out young teen age girls to harm them etc, and the parents never knew that these types of acts are going on. So I read my childrens mail, not to intrude on them but to protect and guide them, because I'm resposible for them. Happy My Lotting!
2 people like this
@tashakau (131)
• Canada
7 Jun 09
It is not a good thing to read your childs private things. However, I would read their mail if I felt that was my only option to help my child and understand what is going on in her head. But I would not make it a habit. I would first try to talk with my child and reading their private things would only be my last option.
1 person likes this
• United States
7 Jun 09
You are probably right... I just never felt the need to read their private stuff.. most of it they shared with me anyway...
• United States
8 Jun 09
I would have hidden all my stuff. I do know one time that my mom found a picture of a boyfriend I had hidden under my clothes in my drawer. She said she was putting away clothes, but she didn't usually do that! The boy was of a different race so that was an issue in my home at the time. I lost a lot of my trust for her that day...
• Lubbock, Texas
6 Jun 09
My children grew up a very long time ago when the world was a safer place. I still think teaching them your standards and ethics and gradually letting go and letting them make decisions will lead to a better relationship with your child whatever age. I never read my childrens' mail, or snooped through their things to find a diary. I tried to give them the respect I expected to get. Yes I am the parent. Yes I was the authority figure, but they had a right to their lives to a certain extent without sharing everything with me. Maybe some people were so sneaky and devious as teenagers themselves, they just expect their children to do all those thing too. I've personally known a few like that. I feel like that drives the children to even worse behavior.
1 person likes this
• United States
6 Jun 09
you've made a very good point, we do tend to judge others by our own actions and intents! Thanks for sharing!
@cupkitties (7421)
• United States
6 Jun 09
My children always read their diaries to me right after they write in them if I want to hear it or not. I don't even have to ask. lol I don't think its fair to read it with out their permission. Of course there are exceptions I would take like if they have given you reason not to trust them and you think they might be in trouble.
1 person likes this
• United States
6 Jun 09
Absolutely if they were in danger, but then there's no gaurantee that it would be found in a diary or notebook if they were. I'm with you my kids continue to tell me all those things I don't even want (or need) to hear... but there is still open communication and that is worth a lot! My son used to come in late at night and plop on the end of my bed and strt talking.. no matter how tired I was... I listened.. and he's still talking to me today!