Is it wise to tell a pregnant woman: Work Out, Eat More?

@sedel1027 (17846)
Cupertino, California
September 12, 2009 3:32pm CST
I signed up for the What to Expect website and about twice a week I get an email from them with pregnancy tips or what the baby looks like at this stage. Yesterday I got an email and this was the topic: Work Out, Eat More! The email is saying for every 1/2 hour of strenuous exercise you can eat 100-200 extra calories a day. Even though that is very true - any who is health conscious knows that fact - I wonder if that is wise to tell someone who is pregnant. I do believe that everyone - pregnant or not does need to get exercise. I know not all pregnant women literally "eat for two", but a lot of women do use pregnancy as an excuse to eat whatever. I am thinking that some people who get an email about exercise just see the word "exercise" and "extra calories" think, "I can go for a quick 30 minute walk and eat Mc Donalds". When that is so not the case. Do you think an emailer saying you can eat more if you do X is a good idea? W hat abotu for people who aren't pregnant and just like to eat?
1 person likes this
6 responses
@much2say (53944)
• Los Angeles, California
13 Sep 09
This is quite an interesting topic! I am pregnant with my second, but this time I also have gestational diabetes. Exercise only helps my glucose (blood sugar) levels - and so does the special diet given to me by my dieticians. Being pregnant this way does NOT mean I can eat anything I want . . . I have to eat a combination of foods from different food groups in specific portions - in a timely manner if I want to keep up the good blood sugar levels that I maintain. Too much fruit, too many starches and processed carbs, even too much milk can raise my blood sugar levels . . . no matter how much extra exercise I do. So I say, it depends on the person, their situation, and probably on their metabolism. In my case, I can probably stand to do more exercise, but like I mentioned, I would still have to watch what and when I eat. Some pregnant woman cannot exercise because it is a risk to their pregnancy. Others don't have a thing to worry about and can eat whatever they want. I just don't think food /excercise solutions apply to everyone - because everyone is different. Now, there is a lot of conflicting, misleading (and sometimes totally incorrect) informtation out on the web. I would think What to Expect's website is pretty reputable, but still, not all articles would apply to everyone. As someone who has done a lot of online research on gestational diabetes, I can tell you there is conflicting information out there . . . everyone has their take on what is "right". That's why it's scary to do self-diagnosing online - who and what can you really trust? I think the best person to get info from is your own doctor - who knows what's going on with your body personally . . . whether you are pregnant or not.
@sedel1027 (17846)
• Cupertino, California
18 Sep 09
This was just a general mailer that was sent out. I think the headline could have just been worded better. I just think it gives the wrong impression. If you go to the site and check out the information they hand out, its pretty generic.
@mommaj (23112)
• United States
13 Sep 09
I think anyone who is pregnant had better start thinking for two instead of believing some email. If the pregnant lady ever has questions she should address them to her prenatal caregiver. She should also be wise enough to not believe everything she reads. Some people just do what they see and writing without consulting their doctor and when there is something wrong with them or the baby they want to sue the people that gave the information. If the information is general like that and people infer, then they should take responsibility. I could say I have purple hair and if you believe me and later see me then will you sue me for giving out false information? Everyone is to ready to put the blame on someone else.
@stephcjh (38473)
• United States
13 Sep 09
I think we all need to exercise no matter what or how much we do eat, whether we are pregnant or not. I think you have to exercise more if you eat more though so you can burn off the calories you took in. None of us should overeat though. It is not good for our body.
@spalladino (17891)
• United States
12 Sep 09
Exercise is beneficial for pregnant women but it's not a good idea to start working out during pregnancy if you weren't physically active before and if you don't have some guidelines to follow so that you don't overdue. For these reasons I don't think that emailer was a good idea because it sends the wrong message. I guess they thought that more women would be interested if they were bribed with the ability to eat more food but they should have included more instruction.
@xannebull (1793)
• Philippines
13 Sep 09
it's nice for pregnant women to eat more, but do eat a lot of nutritious foods like fruits and vegetables, milk and protein. pregnant women must not take for granted her health because she is not alone in taking care of her body but the two of them including her baby so be sure to avoid junkies and hi cholesterol foods to avoid in getting fat so much. and pregnant women should consult her doctor firs before doing some exercise, walking is good but consulting a physician first is the safest way for her and her baby inside her.
@m_rose06 (35)
• Philippines
13 Sep 09
We need to eat to live. It depends on how you control your appetite. You can eat all you want. Exercise is a must to keep us healthy, to burn all the excess fat in our body and to keep us away from heart diseases. In the case of pregnant moms, they have to eat more because they also have to feed the fetus inside them. But they should limit their salt and sugar intake, as what i have learned. Because they might develop complications during their pregnancy or when they gave birth. They should exercise as well to help them when they have their labor. There is such thing called ante partum (before giving birth) and post partum (after giving birth) exercises.