Her dads email...

United States
December 22, 2009 2:45am CST
So I started a discussion a few weeks back about my 27 year old friend that was able to find her dad through facebook and sent him a letter well to recap a bit he contacted her back(through his wife's account) and told her that he thought another man was her father and that he had four kids of his own and wasn't able to go back and replace those missing years and what she was looking for and then added her to his facebook account so she could see pictures of him. She then wrote him back and told him that she wasn't sure exactly what she was looking for maybe possible throughout time to build a relationship and that if he wanted a paternity test she would be willing to as well because if there is possibly someone else than she too would like to know although she doesn't believe there is. Well she didn't hear anything back for about two weeks and then finally she got a message from his wife through facebook and she gave my friend her dads email address stating that maybe it was best to contact him instead of going through her. So she sent the same letter to him that she sent through his wifes facebook because it has questions that she wanted answered and she has yet to hear anything again. In total it has been 25 days since the first contact and he has yet to really answer any of her questions. There is a part that thinks that he may of been hoping she went away after he said he thought he wasn't the father although he held her when she was a few months old and never questioned it so I am thinking maybe this is the story he gave his family to cover it up??? But why would if he didn't want anything to do with her would her accept her as a friend on facebook and then give her his email? It has been 12 days since she sent that email should she send another or just let him respond no matter how long it takes? What should she maybe say to him if she does write another letter? She is tired of waiting and deserves answers but in the same doesn't want to seem to pushy and potentially hurt what relationship they may be able to build.
3 people like this
8 responses
@carolbee (16230)
• United States
22 Dec 09
I was in the same situation a few years ago. I was adopted at 3 weeks by a loving family and was able to locate my birth parents when I was 31. By this time I had two kids and one on the way. It was time to complete the puzzle and find out my roots. I found and met my mother. It was a decent meeting. Quite uncomfortable for both of us but we were able to build a lasting relationship. We lived in different states so I wasn't able to see her regularly. Was hard at first but I adjusted. A few years later my mother told me who my father was, things about him that she could remember but had no idea where he was living or his marital status. Doing some research and contacting others, I found him. He denied he had a child. I was hurt and confused. One of our kids contacted him and he responded. I was able to meet him along with our kids and my husband. It took a few years but it finally happened. I look just like him and am built like him. There was no denying after our meeting. I keep in touch and he and his wife in turn call during the holidays and on my birthday. His wife had no clue he fathered a child when he was 18. He had to straighten that out prior to our meeting. I respected his thoughts and wishes and waited patiently for our first meeting. He also had three other children that had no clue there was another child who was the oldest. I would suggest that your friend just sit back and be patient. Persistence is good but it's always a touchy situation and being too persistent might cause him to run and hide. I would also suggest she tries to contact him once more maybe after the holidays and ask him if he does not want to hear from her again. Nobody likes rejection so explain to her that she might prepare herself for this to happen. Regardless of the story, I don't believe it's right to deny a child the right to their biological family whether it be for medical reasons or curiousity. I wish your friend the very best and please let her know she's not alone in this type of situation. Who knows, this may turn out good and she can have further contact with her father and maintain a healthy relationship. Happy Holidays, carolbee
1 person likes this
• United States
22 Dec 09
Wow carolbee that is quite a story and I am glad to hear that it all worked out in your situation. While my friend is hoping for that contact with her father she has also told me that she doesn't know if she ever wants it to get to the point to where they are making actual physical contact but I am sure with time that will come. I know that being patient is what she needs to do but I also now that it is very hard for her. She doesn't understand why if he wasn't ready to talk to her why he would give his email and I have no idea what to tell her and I was hoping someone just like you that has dealt with something like this and may have some ideas on how he may be thinking. Thanks for your response carolbee I appreciate it....
@carolbee (16230)
• United States
22 Dec 09
Unfortunately he may have given her his email address out of guilt. He might be afraid to have actual contact with her not knowing how she feels. He may not know how he feels either or what to think. It's a confusing situation. I was hit with rejection by my father but didn't give up. It's only right to want to know the situation or her biological father. When I was adopted, there was no such thing as an open adoption so I didn't have access to my records. My adopted mother helped to contact the attorney who handled the adoption and we got names and possible locations. I took it from there and was able to find my mother within 3 days in another state. I hope it all works out for your friend.
1 person likes this
• United States
22 Dec 09
Thanks again carolbee...I wish he would just either write back to her and try to build that relationship or tell he that he could care less while I know that that would hurt her I also think that then she would be able to go on a bit more and in the long run be a better and stronger woman...Thanks and happy holidays to you as well..
@celticeagle (189838)
• Boise, Idaho
23 Dec 09
She does deserve an answer! I do recall this and I think you and I discussed the show The Locators at that time. I think this man has given her her answer. He doesn't believe he is the father. He doesn't want to believe in the possiblility of it being him either. I think he has other kids and this is all he can handle. It is sad but I doubt she will get much more. Maybe she can get the woman on her side and work from that direction. Sadly I don't think there is much hope.
@celticeagle (189838)
• Boise, Idaho
23 Dec 09
Why does he think someone else is her father? Is it hope or really thinks so? I wonder. I would think it would be hard in the best of circumstances and if he already had alot of kids he probably feels pretty uncomfortable. Over coming that can be a hard one. I think she should just occasionally write him and readdress what she wants and continue this until such a time as he tells her to bug off. As long as it isn't constant and is just ongoing then maybe he will breakdown and want to communicate and go to the next level.
• United States
27 Dec 09
I have no clue why he is saying that he doesn't believe he is the father they are guessing it is because this is what he has lead his family to believe or even that maybe this is his hope and if he says it long enough it will be true and she will go away. Her mom has told her about him since she was little and she says that she believes her mom and doesn't know how it would benefit her mother to lie. She is thinking he is just hoping she will believe it and leave or something but then again with the email she is hanging on that hope. I wish if he didn't want anything to do with her he would just say because while it may be very hurtful I think she would accept it and be able to move on.
1 person likes this
• United States
23 Dec 09
I am thinking he is just hoping the she will go away I mean first contact was made on November 28th and she has yet to hear anything from him directly other than he understood someone else was the father and then this email which I don't understand and I have no reasoning for her. They live a country apart from one another so DNA testing won't be that easy if that is what he is pulling for. Thanks for your response celtic
1 person likes this
@gabs8513 (48686)
• United Kingdom
22 Dec 09
It sounds to me like he is hoping that he is not her Dad and that he will not admit it to himself that he could be I hope she gets this Test done one to settle her mind and 2 so that he knows to It is not nice to let her hang like that as she must be very upset and confused about this all
@gabs8513 (48686)
• United Kingdom
23 Dec 09
They should be able to do it as he goes to a Place there and she goes to a Place where she lives I really hope that it will be sorted soon for her the poor Woman
• United States
23 Dec 09
I think he is trying the same thing but I wish he would just tell her that because as her best friend i am the one that she comes to. In my opinion if there is some false belief on his side then he should be the one to get the paternity test, i know that she would take it but the only thing is is he is California and she is in Pennsylvania and I am not sure if a test can be done from the far away and even if it can can she fully believe that it is his DNA or vice versa.... it is so hard and I am not sure I can handle her heartache much longer =) Thanks for your response gabs
1 person likes this
• United States
27 Dec 09
I am sure there probably is a way that that can be done especially with todays technologies but I would almost be sketchy on that one because he could easily have someone else take the test so it would come back negative when really it isn't...
1 person likes this
@winterose (39887)
• Canada
23 Dec 09
she has done her part to contact him the ball is in his court, this is a very big thing she has put on him too, imagine not knowing you had a child and 27 years later somebody comes out of the woodward and appears on facebook. He has some issues to deal with of his own. Whether he answer her or not will tell her exactly what kind of relationship he wants if any at all.
@winterose (39887)
• Canada
24 Dec 09
my story is worse, my dad and mom was not married, my dad brought me home to his mother to live with her and him at the time, I was his daughter until I was 9 years old and we were living in the same house. Then he gets married to someone else and all of a sudden I am no longer his daughter and he has a new family now and he wants nothing to do with me. He claimed I was not his biological daughter after 9 years.
• United States
24 Dec 09
From what I understand he knew he might be the father when she was born and even held her a few times as a baby but them ended up moving states away and has had no contact with her since. Her mother has never had any second guess on who her father is and she is guessing that he is just trying to use that as an excuse so maybe she would just go away....Thanks for your response winterose
1 person likes this
• United States
27 Dec 09
I am very sorry for your story as well winter...I agree that that would be much worse to know your father for so long and then to lose him. I think that is why this time it bothers her because before she never knew him but now that there has been some contact the thought of his rejecting her is driving her nuts....
@ANTIQUELADY (36440)
• United States
24 Dec 09
Sounds very obvious to me he doesn't want anything to do w/her & that's very sad for her. It was really tacky of him to tell her he thought someone else w/her dad. He needs to take the test for her & himself.
• United States
24 Dec 09
I agree and I have told her that if he thinks that he is not the father than he should be the one to look into and pay for a paternity test. I think he is just hoping she will go away as well but what I can't explain to her is why he would give her his email(if it is a real email) Thanks for your response antiquelady
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
25 Dec 09
That is so sad to hear for your friend. I know that probably what she is looking for is to build a relationship with her father that has never existed in the past, but I also think that for him it could be quite difficult to do. To add another member to a family after so many years would be a very difficult thing to do and it may be something that his other children wouldn't accept. I think that she should probably just take as long as it would take for him to respond back to her and not push the issue. Sometimes, I think pushing the issue does destroy a relationship that could have developed.
• United States
27 Dec 09
These are the same things that I have tried to explain to her about his family and she understands that it is hard for him as well but I think she is too the point too where she says that they are both adults and it is not her fault that he may not of explained this to his family or is having problems with his family because of this because she also deserves answers. I somewhat agree with her but them there is a part where I have no idea what it must be like and while this is hard for her it might be even harder on him...Thanks for your response dorann
@BarBaraPrz (51818)
• St. Catharines, Ontario
22 Dec 09
Thanks for the update, even though it seems nothing has changed. I have no advice for your friend, though.
• United States
22 Dec 09
No, still no real contact. Thanks for your response barbaraprz
1 person likes this
@dawnald (85137)
• Shingle Springs, California
22 Dec 09
I think perhaps she should at least ask for the courtesy of a reply as to whether he is willing to talk to her or not. And then if he doesn't reply, sadly, she should take the hint.