How far you can trust a stranger and do you take money from them?

Malaysia
January 16, 2010 8:08pm CST
The situation was like this. Last few days my car broke down when I was on my way home. There was a guy passed by and helped me to call the tow car to tow back to the workshop. he told me that I can leave the key with him so that he can pass the key to the people that will tow my car later, and he can sent me home. But I was hesitate to give my car key. If you were in my shoes, will you give your car key? The situation continue, this guy sent me home, and a minute after that he text me that the tow car people waiting at my car, he picked me up to go to my car, and i saw there is a tow car there. so I left my car key with them, and this helping-guy sent me home again. when I was at home I felt worried (worry been cheated), and my housemate said I'm so dare to leave my car key like that. So, I get another friend of mine drove to the place where my car broke down, and the people there putting chain on my car to tow back. And the helping-guy saw me come back to check on my car. I know I must hurt people feeling by coming back there and thinking that he has any bad intention. At the end, this helping-guy was really sincerely to help me, and he did pay for the towing. I'm very insist to pay him back, because I don't feel comfortable to take money from other people. For me, this is very personal and I don't want to spend other people's hard-earn-money. I wonder if you were me, will you leave your car key? do you feel okay if strangers spend money for your stuff, i mean like repairing car etc.. Please feel free to share your opinion or maybe if you have any experience been helped by a strangers. have a nice day=)
1 person likes this
12 responses
@andy77e (5156)
• United States
17 Jan 10
Different cultures, different answers. In some cultures like Israel, they have explicit trust, and the moment someone violates that trust, they would be run out of town. In other cultures like Jamaica, you can't trust them even if they show up with the police and the president. Here in the US, I would have the name of the company, and a some other proofs with me, to show this or that company had my car. If something happens, I can sue or call the police. I don't know about your country. I would like to visit there someday.
@andy77e (5156)
• United States
18 Jan 10
Very true. They can fake that as well. Sure, I'd love to come. But I can't even afford to get out of my city, so it'll be awhile.
• Malaysia
18 Jan 10
I think it will be more easy for you to travel to asia compare to asian travel to the west. Sigh.. the currency exchange not good for us :(
• Malaysia
17 Jan 10
Hi andy, thanks for sharing here. You are welcome to visit our country. My town is a wonderful place, and maybe you can meet some of the good people here =) Haha.. That day I did take the company business card, but we never can 100% sure it is real and exist. Happy mylotting to you.
@Channy88 (11)
17 Jan 10
tbh people like that you just described are rare. I mean super rare. I understand a lift home is possible as I have experienced it but paying for your car repair as well? woah? its either hes rich and doesnt know how to spend his money, he likes you, some king of cheater, or is just in one of them good moods?
• Malaysia
18 Jan 10
Hi Channy, i did think the same. This guy must be rich and in a good mood =)
@Lucky09 (1763)
• Philippines
18 Jan 10
i agree! he's one in a million
@cream97 (29087)
• United States
17 Jan 10
Hi de_angel97. I have never been quite in a situation as this one. But, I have been in a situation that reminded me kind of this though. I was driving our car and I was on my way to the store right behind the gas station. And I was about to get into the lane that took me straight to the store. And the car cut off right on me! I was so shocked and scared! So, I was trying to crank the car up and I was in the middle of the road. Cars had to past me as I was stuck in the road! I was there for about three minutes and this young guy flagged me and got my attention. He was asking me if I needed help. I told him that the car had cut off on me and that I was on my way to get gas, very soon. So he offered to give me a push. Because we both was right beside the gas station. Thank God for that! And, so he pushed the back of my car into the gas station driveway. And, once I was there he noticed that I was fumbling for my money to pay for the gas. And I had about $6.00 on me. And he asked me if I needed some money. I told him that I got $6.00 and he was like hold on.... And he went back to his car and he gave me about $4.00 extra. So, I added this to the gas. I felt very guilty for him helping me like he did. He was so kind. Most people would have just kept driving and watching me stay in the middle of the road. But, he was nice enough to stop for me. I can understand how you feel. Some people are crazy these days. They will act like they are there to help you, only to find out that their intentions are to personally harm you. I am glad that you are safe and that this guy was honest and generous to you. It was smart that your friend took you back to the location where your car was supposed to be towed at. Even though he felt a little bad, it was still good that you made sure that he did what he said that he would have done for you. I am very uncomfortable around strangers. You have every right to be. An lunatic could have ran off with your car and car keys. Thankfully, this guy was very trustworthy.
• Malaysia
18 Jan 10
Hi cream97. You did meet a great helpful guy that day. I feel like it is quite embarrassing to push car in the middle of a busy road. He really did that for you? Nowadays it is very hard to meet someone that really care someone else. Some of them will take advantage on you while you are in trouble, pretending trying to help, but with a bad intention. There is a Chinese saying "robbing you when your house on fire". It sounds weird after i translate it. Yea, i really glad that guy really did what he said. Thanks for sharing your experience here, this just prove that there are still good people in this world.
• China
17 Jan 10
Probably not. it's a dangerous thing and risky. if something bad happens, you will be regretful.
• China
18 Jan 10
In china we have this kind of saying. you can't harm people but you have to watch out.
• Malaysia
17 Jan 10
That's why i'm so worried, though the helping guy showed me where is his office, but stranger still a stranger. I did take his plate number, just in case.. If something bad happens, i can't imagine making the police report and telling them how stupid and naive i am surrender my key to a stranger :( Thanks for the comment..
@geniustiger (1694)
• Philippines
17 Jan 10
It depends upon the situation for me. In your events I hardly give the key to him it because he is a stranger but its okay that in your case that he really be trusted. Its awesome to a people having that kind of honesty to people also that she did not know. It's a kind of lucky day to you that someone help honestly. I will not take money , but if he insisted so I have no choice instead say thanks for that help.
• Malaysia
18 Jan 10
Huh.. not sure whether it was a lucky day or what. Really in deep trouble that day. One after another come. Maybe lucky for me to meet a helpful guy on my bad day. Thanks~~
@Lucky09 (1763)
• Philippines
17 Jan 10
hi de_angel^^;; well, you are lucky. maybe he's an angel in disguise though, if i were in your situation, i wouldn't leave or entrust anything to him. i would surely appreciate him calling for the tow but wouldn't leave the car and let him wait for that. well, atleast he was really kind to do that favor for you. and as of the payment...i really wonder why he also had paid for the expenses..i think it's too much of just a help. but well, just be thankful. i have watched the movie "Pay it Forward" and maybe he's just trying to do the same thing
• Malaysia
18 Jan 10
Hi lucky.. i watch that movie "Pay it forward" too. This movie should motivate more people. Though i found the plot is quite boring (for me..) yea, we cannot entrust anything with a stranger. I found it strange too, for him to pay for me. He said I'm still a student, just let him pay. But i really felt not right, and it is damn hard for me to get his account number so that i can transfer the money. Actually i did scold him for not letting me pay him back. Of course i said sorry after got his account number.
@vandana7 (98874)
• India
17 Jan 10
Hi de-angel97, I think, 50 percent of people would not even notice you as they have their own schedule to adhere to. Another 25 percent would like to help but cannot because they lack the funds or ability. Of the balance 12.5 are good and helpful and 12.5 are bad. So what are your chances of finding the right person to surrender your car keys, 50 percent! :) I wouldn't take help from such person unless he is willing to come down to my place, and take monies from me the same day. Which means, I would not go back. I would wait there along with him till my car was towed, and let him drive me home! Though that also carries a risk, there are more people in my surroundings. But I've been helped before, and I thank the hands that helped me. People whose faces I dont know or remember but who are there in my prayers. They keep on inspiring me to be good like them. As to the helping guy, he will understand. If he understood so far, he will definitely understand what must have been going on in your mind. :) Times are hard, such people are rare. Hope god is good with him.
• Malaysia
17 Jan 10
Hi Vandana, that's a good number you have 50% =) actually I don't surrender my key to the helping guy. When he called for the mechanic to come over and check on my car, i insisted and told him that I want to give my car key to the mechanic myself. So he just sent me home, and after a while, he text me said that the mechanic arrived already. So actually i gave my key to the mechanic. But what i scared of was that, maybe this two guys were pretending. This so called mechanic is a Chinese and he don't know that i can speak Chinese, so i heard him talk over the phone calling for the tow car. That's why at last i gave the mechanic my car key. But i still felt worried. Sure after everything settled, i did thank that helping guy.
@allknowing (130064)
• India
17 Jan 10
This is the saddest thing in this world. Everyone is put in the same cast because of a few who have cheated people. You were right in having that worry that this man could also be a cheat and it is wrong for the man to get hurt. After all he is a stranger and he also knows that people cheat. You took a risk and it worked well for you this time. If I had no other alternative I too would perhaps take that risk. After all it is the risks that we take that pay us rich dividends!
• Malaysia
17 Jan 10
Yea, i still believe there are some good people in this world. Actually i did think and checking on how much i really trust this person. Though he is a complete stranger, but I did analyze the mechanic that check on my car. He seems like a real mechanic and really calling for tow car(because the mechanic was speaking in other language and he don't know that i understand). I'm 60% sure that these people didn't try to cheat me, the another 40% was because a complete stranger introduce me to another so-called mechanic (second stranger), and the mechanic introduce me to the tow car guy (third stranger). Can i trust these three strangers? But I'm not driving any expensive fancy car, people shouldn't be trying that hard, playing a play to cheat on my cheap economy car. But people can be so desperate enough and can just do anything to cheat us.. Sigh.. so many reasoning..
@saphrina (31552)
• South Africa
17 Jan 10
You know, i think that guy was almost like your guardian angel. He sound like the kind who help others from the bottom of his heart, without expecting anything in return. Remember him in your prayers. There is nothing to feel ashamed about. Those kind of people, comes along, only once in a lifetime.
• Malaysia
17 Jan 10
Hi Saphrina, you are right. I'm not staying with family, so I'm by myself in this town. Meeting someone like this, really making my day easier on a bad day. Thanks for sharing here =)
@vickie_b (36)
• United States
17 Jan 10
Within the last 8 months I would say, more than my whole lifetime..for real.. I have been approached 3 different times and have been nervous and scared out of my wits because I just sadly to say don't trust strangers. They were in one way or another (not going into the long details) wanting a ride, money or assistance and I felt so guilty not helping them but the way the world is these day's just knew better not to. Guess I watch too much news...lol
• Malaysia
17 Jan 10
Hi vickie, you have your point here. Sometimes our good intention to help others may turn ugly. But sometimes i did helping random girl, because I'm a girl, so if the stranger is a girl, if anything happens maybe i still can protect and defend myself. But we will never know.. lot of things may happened, though we think that we have been acting smart and taking all the precautions. Guess I'm just like you, watching too much crime investigation..
@syedayub (252)
• India
17 Jan 10
It depends on the suituation, think if your are in a place where find one body, at this suition you need some who can help you, at the same time you find across you and he ask, can i help you, have no option, then you have trust him. It depends the suition, am i right.
• Malaysia
18 Jan 10
Yeah, you are totally right. Though it is a stranger, sometimes we have to take the risk. Like what you said, in those situation we really need to trust a stranger, though we are not willing too.
@Kent90 (71)
• Malaysia
17 Jan 10
to stranger, most of the time i will ignore them. unless i seeing him/her in a very difficult situation where he/she really need help from people. and you need to consider the type of help he/she want. in term of energy i will give because i can take it back when i eat. but a car key... is something that i wont do.
• Malaysia
17 Jan 10
hi kent, thanks for sharing here. I used to help strangers (only girls), but nothing financially. Huh, i did give my car key for the mechanic to tow my car back to the workshop. Though he gave me his business card showing where is the workshop, i still felt not right. Actually my friend and I following the tow car all the way to the workshop.