Can you eat with your hands?

@eileenleyva (27562)
Philippines
May 22, 2010 4:39am CST
An American born cousin came to visit his mom's birth land, the Philippines, for the very first time. My 38 year old cuz was more Filipino in more ways than one. He liked the gossip. He could stand the heat. And he ate everything that was offered him, ha ha. He was just surprised to see us eating much rice with gusto. And we held the fried chicken with our hands. I explained that we eat with utensils because it is the educated way to do so. But back in the barrios, people eat only with their hands. When we go to the beach, we eat on banana leaves and we do use our hands. Can you? Eat with your hands, I mean?
11 people like this
62 responses
@saphrina (31552)
• South Africa
22 May 10
Sweetie, you should come to South Africa when we have a braai. You actually eat with your hands. So, much easier. TATA.
2 people like this
@saphrina (31552)
• South Africa
24 May 10
Thanx sweetie. Nice, now i'm hungry. And uumm, we normaly have a braai each saturday. No one can wait that long you know. TATA.
• Boston, Massachusetts
25 May 10
Hi Bing and Saphrina, Thanks for this new learning. You are smart Bing for checking out themeaning of it at once and generously shared it with us. Do both of you enjoy it? have a happy braai day...
@saphrina (31552)
• South Africa
25 May 10
I don't enjoy it seetie, i love it. TATA
@basqui (3888)
• Philippines
22 May 10
We enjoy it a lot at home and especially when we go to picnics at the river or in the beaches. I even eat with bare hands on some restaurants and it's how lots of Pinoys do.
2 people like this
@eileenleyva (27562)
• Philippines
25 May 10
basqui, you are rich! You eat at Kamayan!
@jdyrj777 (6530)
• United States
25 May 10
Thats really odd. Im american and everybody i know and some people i seebut dont know always eat fried chicken with their hands. Pizza too.
1 person likes this
@jdyrj777 (6530)
• United States
26 May 10
Im sure there are still people there that eat with their hands. I do not know how your cousin even being from there can speak for the whole state of new york and the country of canada. There are so many people from different places of the world living all over the USA. that bring there own ways and customs with them. I know one thing if i ever go there im still gonna eat with my hands.
@eileenleyva (27562)
• Philippines
30 May 10
@eileenleyva (27562)
• Philippines
26 May 10
My cousin hails from New Jersey and frequents New York and Canada. He says that they don't even eat chicken with rice, mostly with potatoes or vegetable salad.
@bellis716 (4799)
• United States
24 May 10
I ate fried chicken with my hands even before It became necessary for me to do so because MS made my dominate hand shake too much to get much food into my mouth with a fork.
1 person likes this
@bellis716 (4799)
• United States
26 May 10
Eileen, you would be the hero of thousands of people all over the world afflicted with the disease multiple sclerosis if you could devise a treatment that reverses the demilination that causes the symptoms of MS. Super will power will not do it. People with ideas like yours frequently cause those with disabilities to become ashamed to go out in public.
1 person likes this
@eileenleyva (27562)
• Philippines
26 May 10
bellis, shake it off. Requires super will power but you can do it. Get that right hand in control again.
@eileenleyva (27562)
• Philippines
16 Jun 10
Did I offend you bellis? I am sorry if I did. I had been incapacitated once in the not so distant past. I thought it was my time. It took me all my will to be up on my feet again, literally. I know MS is a difficult condition. A cousin is afflicted with the ailment. But she looks gorgeous, as if she ain't sick at all. I see some people with debilitating diseases struggle with their canes but can finish half a kilometer at the university walkway. I wish I could comfort and support you. I mean it. I do not mean to put you to an embarrassing situation. I'm sorry.
@joepat (129)
• Philippines
23 May 10
Of course, but it depends on certain situations and occasions. In third world countries including the Philippines, this is the usual practice specially in the rural areas. In situations like when you are at the beach picnic style where there are no formal settings of table and chairs but instead you just make do with banana leaves to serve as your table cloth. As long as your hands are clean by washing, eating with one's hands is an acceptable practice. There are occasions too where you are invited to dine with people who are used to eating with bare hands. It would then be awkward to ask your host for utensils or face the consequence of being ridiculed and ostracized. Or perhaps when you are in your own home, nobody will stop you from eating with bare hands specially if the food you're eating would increase your appetite by eating bare - food like, grilled seafood, dried salted fish, roasted pig (litson), etc. However, if you are in a formal dining setting, it is imperative that you use utensils and in the proper manner too like any educated person.
@eileenleyva (27562)
• Philippines
26 May 10
Well explained joepat, but I disagree the Philippines is a third world. I always thought of this country as my haven. According to your description, we are a cultured people, just by the way we eat!
@eileenleyva (27562)
• Philippines
16 Jun 10
joe, everyday I pass by mendicant children begging for alms. The sight of the poor is something I had to live with. Who is not angry at our greedy politicians? Who is not trying to make tomorrow a better day? As far as I am concerned, my Philippines is my homeland. How could anyone say this is a third world? In South Africa, the youth are devoured by beasts and the children eat roots. Is it also a third world? In New York, the learned and the educated were disenfranchised by the collapse of the stock market. And the shockproof Lehman Brothers sent its investors wobbling to as much as intensity 7. Can we call that first world? My world is what I chose to make my life with. And my life ain't third world.
@joepat (129)
• Philippines
26 May 10
Hello Eileen. The Philippines not a third world country? Well, everybody is entitled to his/her opinion. That's the beauty if Mylot - anybody can speak his/her mind. In some ways I would agree with you but there are aspects and issues that would call for further debate and discussion. This country is not wanting in terms of natural resources, in fact, she are rich in minerals and other nature's bounty. The country is globally competitive in education, tourism destination, labor force, etc. But what has the government done about it? Practically nothing - just too pre-occupied with too much politics, wrong priorities, graft and corruption...to name a few. If there are signs of industrial development, they are being done by foreign business conglomerates to the point of total exploitation at the expense of the welfare of the country and the people. We are now far behind our Asian neighbors economically. On the other hand, as a people, Filpinos are complacent, hospitable, mostly literate and educated, and industrious. These are plus assets of Pinoys but where are they being utilized? Abroad. Anybody who has the chance goes out to seek better opportunities in other countries. And they are the economic saviors of this country. If not for them and their inward remittances, this country would have long been bankrupt. The great majority, the masses are left here wallowing in extreme poverty, enjoying a hand to mouth existence (eating without utensils, ha ha ha...}, wooed by traditional politicians with money and promises and voting into power (well, almost, based on the result of the recent elections) retired movie stars and other popular personalities. With people in government who have no knowledge in governance except enriching themselves in power, this country will remain third world. Oh, by the way, I am Filipino and I still love this country despite her infirmities.
1 person likes this
• Australia
22 May 10
My wife is from the Philippines and will eat with her hands at home but not out at a restaurant etc. That is everything including rice. It always intrigues me to see her eating rice with her hands because it is done so well with special little finger movements and makes no mess at all. I have trouble eating most things with my hands because I don't like messy fingers although a burger at Maccas is OK. Finger food is always popular especially pizza and just think of the washing up. There is none. Lovely.
1 person likes this
@eileenleyva (27562)
• Philippines
25 May 10
Nick, most of the aliens I know, including revisiting relatives, are turned off by eating with the hands. Their facial expressions somehow show how disgusting and how uncultured Filipinos are by eating with the hands.
• Australia
24 May 10
You are right. Sorry, my mistake. My wife always calls it McDo. Maccas is more an Australian expression. We have Hungry Jacks here which is a franchise of Burger King. Much better burgers.
1 person likes this
• Australia
25 May 10
I was lucky my first trip to the Philippines because I lived with my wife and her family in the suburbs and not some fancy hotel. I lived in the small house with 9 others and lived and ate and did what they all did. I experienced a CR with no paper for the first time and the dipper in cold water for a shower and traveling in jeepneys etc. Eating with the hands was only a small part of the overall cultural difference which I found so fascinating. We went to the malls every day and I laughed at the driving system which I just found so different it was amusing to me. But I just loved the place and we are building a house to move there permanently in a few years. Of course the house will have hot water etc. and a few western comforts but we will still be living there in your wonderful culture. I can understand some westerners frowning at eating with hands but some westerners frown at many things in their own countries. When I read some of your history I am distressed by accounts of things like the war time invasion where your people were systematically shot and raped. It is a shame when westerners and even returning relatives think they are better when they actually have far less than the average Filipino in regards to happiness and contentment. Those things are very scarce in the west.
1 person likes this
@Hatley (163781)
• Garden Grove, California
29 May 10
hi eilenleyva I am fascinated with some of the things my filipina tablemate eats with her fingers things that i as an American use a spoon or fork for. we do hold pieces of fried chicken in our fingers but messy stuff we use forks or spoons for.just different cultures is all so we all get along just fine. but technically we all eat with our hands as our hands are u sed when we use our forks or spoons or knifes, but finger eating is different to me.I have seen her pick up piecesof canned pears with her fingers while I slowly stab them with my fork.lol her way is easier. lol.
1 person likes this
@eileenleyva (27562)
• Philippines
30 May 10
I would have told her to use the fork for the canned pears. There are some food that we can't use just our fingers.
@anuraa32 (2446)
• India
26 May 10
What is the harm in eating with hands. In India we eat with our hands. Yes food is served on the plate but then the prefered way to eat is putting the food from the plate to your mouth with the use of one's hand.
1 person likes this
@eileenleyva (27562)
• Philippines
26 May 10
There's no harm. It is actually a natural way of eating.
1 person likes this
@anuraa32 (2446)
• India
26 May 10
@nonersays (3329)
• United States
29 May 10
I eat LOTS of things with my hands and fingers. Even some things that most peole don't eat with their hands. I find myself doing it more and more often since my son was born. I'm often eating while holding him and he'll try to grab the utensils, but won't try to grab just my hand.
@eileenleyva (27562)
• Philippines
30 May 10
• Boston, Massachusetts
25 May 10
Hi Eileen, I admire your cousin for being acculturated and not culture shocked with what's happening around him while in the Philippines. Well, this is another unique trait of being pinoy...eating with bare hands. of course i love eating with my hand but hate too bacause i eat plenty of food when i do so. Beach is one of the best places to be eating with bare hands over banana leaves with grilled fish, chicken barbeque and of course hot rice having that aroma of pandan leaves. by the way, congrat friend...this is a blockbuster discussion. i am happy for you!
1 person likes this
@eileenleyva (27562)
• Philippines
26 May 10
ms, I was surprised myself. Now it's taking me time to answer. But thanks for just being there. You are a real friend.
1 person likes this
• Boston, Massachusetts
29 May 10
you are welcome. continue posting discussions like these and i am pretty sure you will be more excited responding on such blockbuster responses...hugs! how's the weekend?
1 person likes this
• China
26 May 10
Maybe..when I was a child i ever do that, but now I would not eat wiht hand..i just interesting about this culture, what about a long nail on the finger? it must be funny~~
1 person likes this
@eileenleyva (27562)
• Philippines
26 May 10
red, there is an art of eating with the hands. You will be surprised that longs nails are not impediments to swallowing the food.
@RobtheRock (2433)
• United States
23 May 10
I am American (North) and when I go out I know that you are supposed to use a fork to eat your chicken with, but I think it ludicrous to try stabbing every inch of chicken with a fork when you can pull it off the bone and eat it. If you're eductated, then you are educated. Trying to look like you have class be eating a certain way makes you miserable when you know some folks will try to look down on you anyway.
1 person likes this
@eileenleyva (27562)
• Philippines
26 May 10
Rob, did I rub something on theRock? The last line sounded a little sensitive.
• United States
26 May 10
This discussion just reminds me of when (I can't remember specifically) I learned that you're not supposed to eat chicken with your hands. So I used to go to restaurants and try to eat with a fork. I confess, I love to eat and I love to enjoy every morsel of food. Eating chicken with a fork takes away from my enjoyment of eating it. So this discussion allowed me to release my "attitude" that no matter where I go (unless it's to a formal gathering of some kind) I will eat chicken with my hands.
1 person likes this
@nangisha (3496)
• Indonesia
23 May 10
Hello eileen!. I usually eat certain food with hand, It it more delicious that way. Like most Asian food they can be eat with hand. I usually eat with if eating rice plus friend or baked chicken, which is a little hard to eat with spoon and fork. I think you eat with hand not related with education its for simplicity. But I think its depend on the occasion, I will never use hand in formal party but I will use hand to eat at home.
1 person likes this
@eileenleyva (27562)
• Philippines
26 May 10
Is baked chicken the same as oven roasted chicken?
@nangisha (3496)
• Indonesia
26 May 10
Yap its the same.
1 person likes this
• China
28 May 10
I donot eat with my hands because I am not used to it. I know that some country like India eat with their hands. I am surprised that why they can eat anything like rice with hands? I think some food we can use hands to eat, some food we should use scoop or chopsticks to eat.
1 person likes this
@eileenleyva (27562)
• Philippines
30 May 10
@kkanaka (886)
• Singapore
24 May 10
Hi, I also eat with my hands at home, at work place I use a spoon, but sometimes I dont feel full enough until I use my hands to eat.....
1 person likes this
@eileenleyva (27562)
• Philippines
26 May 10
• United States
23 May 10
Yes, I can eat with my hands and actually enjoy having a special meal every now and then when utensils are banned. Not only is it fun, it's hilarious to see the look on guests faces when there isn't a spoon,fork or knife in sight!
1 person likes this
• United States
23 May 10
When I was in grammar school, we had fried chicken for lunch one day. A young lady, with excellent table manners, attempted to cut each bite of chicken from a drumstick. It slipped from her fork and knife, flew across the table, hit another girl in the mouth, dropped into her tray, landing squarely in the applesauce which splattered the kids on either side of her. Everyone else at the table had treated the chicken as finger food and teased the first girl mercilessly about her elegant flying chicken leg! Fourth graders can be rotten little creatures. It took getting out of grammar school completely for the flying chicken to come to roost and fall into the girl's background.
1 person likes this
• United States
23 May 10
Hmmm..I guess I'm an unedjakated heethen then and wouldn't have it any other way. I often eat with my hands..Don't see anythin' wrong with it or with other folks who do..Enjoy!
1 person likes this
@eileenleyva (27562)
• Philippines
26 May 10
green, you are so touchy! Whoever says there's something wrong with eating with the hands?
• Philippines
23 May 10
Hi, yes I can eat with my bear hands; of course I have to wash them first. When I eat with my hands all the foods taste delicious. It's not that I'm used to doing this, it's just that the fun of eating with your hands give me a freedom to unleash the stress. We're not only have a culture like this, this is also practice in Malaysia and ironically Filipinos are descendants of Malay race.
@eileenleyva (27562)
• Philippines
26 May 10
I never thought of eating as one way of unleashing stress. But if you say so! We are both brown blood! And neighbors, too!
@laniekins (4579)
• Philippines
24 May 10
Yes, I do, actually I love it when I only feel like eating with barehands specially when I'm eating friend chicken with rice. I can eat more than eating with utensils. Filipino's are known for that but now only few do this.
@eileenleyva (27562)
• Philippines
26 May 10
@acey76 (1276)
• Philippines
24 May 10
Yes, i love eating with my hands..... Filipinos are known by that......I love it when eating seafoods and fishes along with rice yumyum!=)
@eileenleyva (27562)
• Philippines
26 May 10