Is it allowed to photocopy books that you borrow from libraries in your country?

China
June 24, 2010 3:30am CST
Now the academic works are very expensive! Most of them cost about 50 dollars, some even cost more than 100! So I don't think a student can afford to buy some books like that. Furthermore, the library can never offer enough copies for students to borrow, so is it allowed or leagal to photocopy books just for study purpose in your country?
3 people like this
17 responses
@inedible (768)
• Singapore
27 Jun 10
Yes, but there are limits to how much we can legally photocopy. We can copy one chapter, or a certain percentage of the total pages (I can't remember the exact number) if it's not divided into chapters. There are rules about printing digital sources too, I think.
@inedible (768)
• Singapore
28 Jun 10
It probably can get you into trouble. Better not do it, just in case.
• China
5 Sep 10
It seems a little scary to be caught doing that. But I have photocopied two bookes which I want to take them with me to study abroad, what should I do?Throw them away or just keep them and never do that again?
• China
27 Jun 10
No one tell us what is allowed or not allowedin our country! So we just borrow the book and photocopy the whole book. But if I take the photocopied book with me to go abroad, will it cause trouble or will those foreigners look down upon me?
• Philippines
21 Jul 10
Photocopying is not allowed by our copyright laws. But an exception is if the copy will be for your personal use and you will not profit from it.
• China
5 Sep 10
I heared of that either. But I am not sure will it be a trouble if I would like to take some photocopied books with me if I want to study abrod. It is hard to say, there was an English guy said the same thing as you did, but some others said it is not allowed. Confusing...
• Philippines
8 Sep 10
That's a different thing. Our copyright laws operate only within the country. If you are in another country, you have to observe their own laws. You can have books photocopied for your personal academic use, but you cannot take those photocopied books abroad.
@cream97 (29087)
• United States
29 Jul 10
Hi, songbaofang. I am unsure about this. But I do know that if we copy something from the computer, the library charges, 15 cents for every additional copy that we need.
• China
5 Sep 10
I am still not very clear about that. But most of friends said that it is ok if it is just for personal use rather than commercial use.
• United Kingdom
24 Jun 10
I think this is considered to be illegal in the United Kingdom but I'm pretty sure that there are people that do this as it's convenient for them and they don't have to worry about returning books and so forth. That is the other thing to consider, the fact that books these days are so expensive and a student definitely needs all the help they can get! I personally would not photocopy pages from a book that I was studying as this would definitely hit my conscience! I have not borrowed a book from my local library for a very long time now that I come to think about it! I do everything on the Internet now including any research! I guess life goes on and we do the best that we can! Andrew
• China
25 Jun 10
To be honest, the thing that makes me feel guilty the most is the fact that photocopying books sometimes can damage the books to some extent! I have just photocopied book once and fortunately the book was not damaged! But I will do that as less as I can! The other thing is that reading electric books online is so uncomfortable so I really don't like that idea, besides, I found it is difficult to understand a book well without reading the paper copy carefully. Thanks for you discussion!
• Philippines
25 Jun 10
in my country? yes library here is always full of people especially students and also those people who like to read books and they can photo copy the books anytime they want i think its a good way of attracting people to read books rather than searching in the internet instead.
@cassisto (63)
24 Jun 10
here in India , guide books or book having most of the question as solved are not allowed in the libraries.. almost every book in the library , the writer or the publisher has the copyright that no part part of the book can be reproduced or published without the permission of the publisher blah..blah.blah..but we have shop with Photostat machine in almost every locality..so why cant we get them Photostatted..the book Photostatted ans then the pages are spiral bound ..the spiral bound is the book for the student..yes there are a few books that are in the reserved action..these books cant not be issued,,so we can get them photostat only if the librarian permits.. BUT NO PERMISSION IS REQUIRED FOR THE BOOKS THAT CAN BE ISSUED...hurraY!!!!
• China
24 Jun 10
Sometimes I think that how the writer and publisher can make money if every one just photocopyes their books! But the fact is that we can't afford those books and we are not photocopying it for commercial purpose! So why not just do it and study it! What do you say?
25 Jun 10
see..we are not using the copies for the commercial use..but if we cant get them Photostat, then we have to buy them..that means we have to buy them which will increase the business of the publishers..
@o0jopak0o (6394)
• Philippines
24 Jun 10
well if it is not for commercial and for research and educational purpose you can push with "fair use" this is a site that a discussion with fair use http://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/article-30100.html
@o0jopak0o (6394)
• Philippines
27 Jun 10
yes, publishing companies have some pretty nasty lawyers.
• China
25 Jun 10
Thanks for your information! It seems that in different districts the situation is pretty different! I think the same as you do, but I heared of that in some countries it can make troubles if people do that! Especially in European countries. Maybe people there pay more attention to the protection to the copyright of the publishers......
• United States
25 Jun 10
My college textbooks cost alot too! Last school quarter, I bought a textbook and I took it home to my computer and photocopied all 400 pages so that I don't have to buy it. I spent three days photocopying it and saved fourty dollars. I don't think it was illegal, I wasn't photocopying it to sell it or anything. The authorities won't know anyways because it is only on my computer for my personal uses.
• China
25 Jun 10
So it seems it is not very bad to photocopy books in United States:). I have done that once and in China it is a common phenomenon. I thought it is not allowed in the US or other European countries before. Is it common in your school? I mean have your classmates ever done that? Thanks for your discussion, enjoy the mylot!
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
27 Jul 10
In my country we are allowed to photocopy books, but there are some restrictions. We are only allowed to take copies to ourselves, our familymembers and our close friends. We are not allowed to take copies to all of our classmates and things like that. Schools have to pay a fee if the teachers hand out copies to the students. The students pay a certain amount of money before the new semester starts, and the school spends the money on the fee that they have to pay.
• China
5 Sep 10
yes, the same things are being down in our country. I just don't know whether it is allowed in most of couries. According to the discussions, it has been done in many countries and most of thoes guyes said that it is ok for just personal use. In school, sometimes teachers really photocopy some books and deliver them to students, most of time freely. Obviously it is not for commercial use so it is also allowed in my conutry.
@Rainegurl (2156)
• Philippines
25 Jun 10
Hi, song! I think we are allowed to photocopy books if it is only for personal use. It is prohibited to reproduce it if for commercial purposes. Books have really become expensive and, when I was still in school, I photocopy some books that we use if in my opinion, I cannot use it as a reference whenever I am already working. These are usually books for my minor subjects. Cheers!
• China
25 Jun 10
Sometimes I think so! Going through the discussion these days I found that it happens everywhere, although in some countries it is considered to go against the copyright law! Thanks! Enjoy the day!
@med889 (5941)
24 Jun 10
I always do this, as it costs less and I even get the photocopies for free in the office where I work so I just need to borrow the books and get it done in the office and return it the other day, my law books cost a fortune so I cannot but all so I try to have them in photocopies and get them bind by a friend.
• China
24 Jun 10
We usually do it publicly! It is a common activity in our college! But I have always doubted its reasonablity considering the copyright of the writers and publishers. I just what to know is it allowed in other countries. Thanks for your reply!
@mimiang (3760)
• Philippines
24 Jun 10
I have the books borrowed from the libraries and have them photocopied. It has long been my practice since high school
• China
24 Jun 10
Yes I have done that several times. I have thought it ok until yesterday one friend told me that it was not allowed to photocopy those English books in European or American countries, so I ake you for to make sure of that.
@oldchem1 (8132)
25 Jun 10
In the UK it is against Copyright rules not to photocopy books or any copywritten material without permission - HOWEVER, most people do it
• China
25 Jun 10
I thought in UK it should be considered wrong to do that. In my mind, European countries have very strict laws on copyright! But according to what you mentioned it seems that people still do it usually, isn't it? So there should be no one who has been punished for doing that, right? Thanks for your reply:)
• United States
24 Jun 10
I borrow the books I need, then take it to a photocopier. I'll have them copy the title page, leave the index and then bind it into a whole book! They won't allow us to photocopy the whole entire book from cover to cover.
• China
25 Jun 10
Who donnot allow you to photocopy the whole entire book from cover to cover? The library or the photocopier? I have heard of your situation but I am not so sure, so I ake to check. Thanks for your discussion! :)
• Saudi Arabia
24 Jun 10
first u should ask to the librarian; where he allows u or not.he will tell u its legal or not...
• China
24 Jun 10
In our college the librarian doesn't care about this. But I really think that photocopying the book can sometimes severely harm the book! So personally I really think that we had better not do that, but the book especially the foreign books cost so much that we have no choice!
@Torunn (8609)
• Norway
24 Jun 10
Yes and no. The library don't mind I think, but it some books it said that you're not allowed to photocopy the whole book. Usually in the really thick American text books that are filled with pictures and 600 pages long, so copying would cost nearly as much as buying it :-/ I got many of my text books used for that very reason, too long to copy and quite expensieve to buy new ones.
• China
24 Jun 10
Indeed, our library doesn't tell us that the books are not allowed to be photocopied. So we usually borrow the book and photocopy it. In my country, photocopying the foreign books is much cheaper than buying it, that's why we choose to do that.
• India
24 Jun 10
Hey Buddy Well I'm from India and I haven't came across any such kind of law which prohibits students from getting books from libraries photocopied. Although such kind of restrictions are rather imposed by authors or publishers but not by the government here. yeah I know that there are some books which are extremely costly to buy and it is always economic to get them photocopied. So we dont have any such legal restriction for getting books photocopied here in India.
• China
24 Jun 10
I also think so! no law prohibits students photocopying books borrowed form linrary! The law just prohibit that for commercial purposes, do you think so?
• Philippines
24 Jun 10
It depends on the policy of this libraries. There are libraries that allow the borrowing of books and photocopying it. There are also some libraries that are strict on this kind of stuff.
• China
24 Jun 10
Our library doesn't has such regulations and it is cer common phenomenon in our college. But is I take these photocopied books with me to go abroad, will the foreigners blame me for doing that? I have no ideal!