Who must keep the income of the family? The Wife or The Husband!

@visavis (5934)
Philippines
October 12, 2010 6:18am CST
Hi guys here is my new topic for today. I hope you like it and need your opinion, views, discussion and urgue. We are composed of various family background, tradition, culture depends on country belongs, religious and society. Husband and wife have own particular purpose in the family, own function and action. But in terms of money, income who is the true keeper the wife or the husband? What do you think? Because for me wife is the one shall keep, budgetting and others? Do you agree with me, tell us.. thanks and enjoy.
14 people like this
56 responses
@JUNGLE (1157)
• South Africa
12 Oct 10
The Wife is the true keeper of the income.Even if the husband is the wage earner,I know that women are the ones who know how to handle the financial affairs of the family.My Mother did it perfectly and now my Wife does it perfectly.Amen. !!!!Lol
@laydee (12798)
• Philippines
13 Oct 10
It's not always the case. I know of a friend who's wife isn't very good at budgeting. If he gives all his income to her, it will be gone even before the month ends. I guess some are just not good with money.
@visavis (5934)
• Philippines
12 Oct 10
Amen I like your answer... receive my rewards... coming
3 people like this
@kodukodu84 (1569)
• Malaysia
12 Oct 10
My partner and I are both working. Basically, my salary is mine, his salary is his....as we both deserves what we worked for lol. But if I were talking about the family income, then that should mean the combination of my husband's income and mine. So we ought to keep it, arrange, and budget it together, this is what we call TEAMWORK. If companies and jobs etc need teamwork, so marriage does. Through this method, it is possible to avoid an argument about money, money, money, money.. who kept it? who budgeted it? who spent it?..whatsoever.. I like tolerance, co-operation, understanding, and team work when it comes about running a marriage life...and the most important is sharing a task
1 person likes this
• Malaysia
12 Oct 10
I hope you didn't neglect the word of COMBINATION that I included in my comment That means half of his salary and half of my salary, the rest we keep to ourselves for emergency stuff. Those combined salary, we put into one account which is both of us have a right to handle it together..
1 person likes this
@visavis (5934)
• Philippines
12 Oct 10
sorry to as in that case - do you have trust to each other/
1 person likes this
@visavis (5934)
• Philippines
12 Oct 10
thanks to your views.. your talking about your situation that both of you are working... I have a little confused because you said your salary then his salary would be to your owned. How do you manage to say income for the family meaning your giving something same as your husband for family income right.. you call it TEAMWORK. Meaning if you need something you will ask to your husband certain amount for that, for this and those... Then you said you budgetted together - how it will happened since money are not visible.
1 person likes this
@SimpleBB (1329)
• Philippines
12 Oct 10
This is a nice topic. For me, the responsibility of a husband is to make a living to provide for the family. And the responsibility of the wife is to manage for what the husband has provided to her and the family. Thus, the money should be with the wife for her to be able to manage it appropriately. I agree with you, it is the wife who is the housekeeer. Happy mylotting.
1 person likes this
@SimpleBB (1329)
• Philippines
12 Oct 10
Nice question again. Not that because I'm a woman too. But I think it still the wife. Because the wife, even working and even they have a maid at home,it is natural for a woman who wants to take part or to have the so-called woman touch or mother touch to somethings for their family. If I would ask you, aside from working, did you take part to some household chores? I'm just asking, ha? Happy mylotting.
1 person likes this
@visavis (5934)
• Philippines
12 Oct 10
Ok thanks to your views and complements. How about if the situation is both wife and husband having work - who is the rightful keepper?
1 person likes this
@sender621 (14894)
• United States
12 Oct 10
I believe that both the wife and the husband should have an equal say about what becomes of the family's income. Neither husband nor wife should shoulder this burden alone. A marriage is a union. Everything should be shared, including the family's income.
@visavis (5934)
• Philippines
12 Oct 10
yes no question about that.. the real question is who is the rightful keepper? Then spending that income both should be known and agreed. ok
@jinjer168 (1596)
• Philippines
12 Oct 10
Hello! The one who knew how to handle the finances better, and the one who could give better importance to the hard earned money of the couple should be the one that will be given the responsibility of handling family's finances. Budgeting is one vital process in one's family that should be observed and done properly. I believe that there's really a person that good in doing this than others so better determine who among the husband and wife is better doing this to secure family's better financial flow. Goodnight!
1 person likes this
@visavis (5934)
• Philippines
12 Oct 10
thanks but I believe like you regardless your background of study family budgetting is a basic knowledge to be known for a wife.. Wife knows everything in the house requirements.
• Philippines
12 Oct 10
In the present time, both husband and wife should work together or else they can't send their kids to school. Nowadays, it's really difficult to make both end meets so both parents should work very very hard. Everything is expensive, food, clothing, fuel,electricity, name it, all of them is expensive! I sometimes envy the time when only the husband should work and he can still give his a family a good future, but that is not he case now, every one, including students, should work just to have a brighter future. So thanks to mylot, it gives us all the chance to earn additional income by sharing our thoughts and learning new things from other users. :)
1 person likes this
@visavis (5934)
• Philippines
12 Oct 10
I believe budgetting wife is the best.. but for both wife and husband work still wife should be the who keep and budgetting because wife knows everything in the chicken and in the house.
1 person likes this
@Pose123 (21635)
• Canada
12 Oct 10
Hi visavis, Once again I think there can be no one answer that fits all. We are all unique, despite our culture etc. Often the wife will be best, but sometimes it will be the husband. Personally I prefer a joint venture where there is agreement between both. Blessings.
1 person likes this
@visavis (5934)
• Philippines
12 Oct 10
Yes as you said we are all unique, but being unique it is character why some are not trusting their respective wife of keepping it?
1 person likes this
@chrislotz (8137)
• Canada
24 Sep 11
If my husband would have let me be in charge of the money we would probably still be married. He wouldn't let me control his money and he never gave me any at all. He paid the rent and the bills and I paid for the food and entertainment. Of course he was paying more than me but he made about 10 times as much money as I did and he should have been paying even more or do what I wanted, open a joint account and we both just pay everything from it. I thought we would both get an allowance per say and if we needed more, no problem, just go to the bank and get more. As it turns out he had his reasons for not letting me control the money. It turns out he was a gambler and spending all the extra money. After 12 years of gambling and me not knowing it, he bandrupted us, literally. That is when I found out we were broke and then some, when we went to file. He had to tell me everything then because we both had to go since we were married. I am no longer married to him, for 2 years now I have been divorced. Cheers and happy mylotting my friend, Chris
@chillpill90 (1936)
12 Oct 10
it depends on the relationship. In some cases women spend alot and cannot help themselves so in this case the man should keep the money but at other times the man spends alot. It all depends on the people.
1 person likes this
@visavis (5934)
• Philippines
12 Oct 10
In general we are trying to get is who is the real keepper the wife or husband regardless of spending. Because I believed before wife is the one, the changes occured when the husband saw the expenses then vice versa. you got my point
1 person likes this
@anurag3786 (6267)
• India
12 Oct 10
I think it is depend on the person because in some families there are wives keeping their husbands salary. But there are also many families who investing their salary in some policies. So I think it is depend on the persons who must keep the salary.
@visavis (5934)
• Philippines
12 Oct 10
You I think "it depends" is not applicable here because being husband and wife husband should do his duty to earn money for his family, then wife do her duty to take care of the income, budgetting, controlling expenses and others.
@nangisha (3496)
• Indonesia
22 Oct 10
My mom and dad both work but my mom the one who keep and arrange the money. She keep in really well because they have commitment what will they used most of the money. So they are saving most of it for our education and buying a house. I think in the future its should the wife who keep the money and I will made planning for the money.
@ifa225 (14364)
• Indonesia
22 Oct 10
mother often have some great planning to save and spend the money. they think about the future of their kids and other stuffs.
@DoctorDidi (7018)
• India
4 Oct 11
A family comprises of a wife and a husband. So I think it is the duty of both of them to keep the income of the family and to help one another in this regard.
• India
12 Oct 10
Yes I agree with you. But nowadays, jobs are not permanent. Wives also have to go to work because if the husband get resigned or dismissed from the office, at that time his wife's salary will use to run the family. If he has a permanent job, she won't have to go. I have a cousin sister. She is earning more than her husband. Her husband have 2 brother. They all get married. But they all are earning very little than my sister's earning. They run their big family with my sister's salary only.
1 person likes this
@visavis (5934)
• Philippines
12 Oct 10
If the money whether from wife or husband bring together it is family income - our discussion here is who is the rightful keepper the wife or husband. If you said wife is the one who will keep then whatever expenses going out should be having decision from both of wife and husband. It is not question of wife is bigger salary than husband as long as both wife and husband agreed to spend it.
2 people like this
• Philippines
12 Oct 10
I don't really think so. There are also men who are gifted in allotting budgets. There are some couples who split the budgeting. For example, if one partner is mindful of the bills, he/she should be selected to budget for that area. Whoever does best at budgeting for groceries, haggles prices the best at the flea market should be assigned to do just that. It can be tiring if the budgeting alone is done by only one person. It is good if both partners are aware of all the bills so that there will be no argument when it comes to money.
1 person likes this
@visavis (5934)
• Philippines
12 Oct 10
Thanks to your views... yes it is so tiring for keepping the money. budgetting it for the family. My idea is to give, keep and budget to the wife but before spending or any expenses incurring she should ask permission from the husband to that case the decision is from husband. Some country tradition husband is the keepper like in chinese...
1 person likes this
@bellis716 (4799)
• United States
14 Oct 10
Whichever has the best business sense should take care of the money. Sometimes the job can be shared.
@ifa225 (14364)
• Indonesia
22 Oct 10
the husband have his main responsibility to make some income, but i think it would be fine if wife are try to make money too. they both can cooperate to earn while they are still doing the household chore
@aerous (13434)
• Philippines
16 Oct 10
In general; Wife is the keeper of the income of the family because wife knows more about family expenses...and this is also a good practice
@Memnon (2170)
14 Oct 10
I don't see that it should necessarily be either. The one who is best with money perhaps. May be whoever does most shopping- dependant on the family work pattern.
@RamRes (1723)
• Argentina
14 Oct 10
I think both should share both the income and the expenses. They are a couple, and both are supposed to work and live togeter, don't they? Why one should be in charge of earning and the other in charge of the cost? I see this as a cooperative chance, not a dependance. And in these times, men and women equality had made great advancements from those times that women were "property" of the men. Now each one has the same rights, and the same right to administer the family finances.
@dwin26 (32)
• Saudi Arabia
14 Oct 10
At present, i believe the wife is the one keeping the budget of the family while the husband is the supplier only, but there are cases that the wife has the job and the husband stays at home and it follows the husband should handle the budget. Of course, you cannot insist the wife to handle this thing if she is already the bread winner and for sure she wants the husband to take care of this. Because our life nowadays has full of complicts and issues in life, it is not a matter who will keep the income of the family for as long they have a good understanding on this matter. But i believe on the point of the bible, the husband should be the keeper and should provide the needs of his family while the wife should only be the helper to the husband in any means, of course the wife will not be a robot, she will decide things that pertains to her, but over all still the husband is the foremost ruler of the family. Since the world we live in dectates differently, therefore, decide among you who will keep considering both of your status, characters, availability, etc..Would you rather follow the dictates of the world or the dictates of the bible?