Do you eat animal organ?

@scheng1 (24650)
Singapore
February 20, 2011 1:57am CST
Most of us Chinese are familiar with using animal organs in our diet. The pig organ soup (including the pig intestine soup) is one of the most popular dishes in Singapore. The pig brain soup is considered a very nutritious herbal soup but it has a very high cholesterol. Many hobbyists feed beef heart to the fish, such as Discus and Oscar. It sounds gross to eat the same beef heart after feeding it to the fish. Do you eat animal organ? Is animal organ part of the diet in your culture?
2 people like this
23 responses
@EdnaReyes (2622)
• Philippines
20 Feb 11
Oh, same with us,Filipinos, we have many dishes that used animal organs as main ingredients. We have many street foods made of animal organs such as Chicken intestines (WE called it Adidas). We grill them as appetizers and main course like Dinuguan (Pig's blood and innards) Kare-Kare (ox's innards). We always include these favorites in our every celebrations and feasts.
@scheng1 (24650)
• Singapore
20 Feb 11
Hi EdnaReyes, I wouldn't know that Adidas mean Chicken intestines! I think if the founder of the running shoes company know about it, it will not use Adidas as the name of the running shoes. I do not dare to eat Pig's blood, even though I love the kidney and liver. The organs are good sources of protein and other nutrients. Glad to hear that we Chinese are not the only ones enjoying it.
@louievill (28851)
• Philippines
20 Feb 11
@EdnaReyes, I think you made an honest mistake so I would like to correct it, Adidas is chicken feet that's why it's named after the famous shoe brand LOL. Chicken intestine is "bituka ng manok" in contrast to pig intestine which is called "isaw"
@sweet_pea (3322)
• Philippines
21 Feb 11
"Isaw" can be simultaneously used for chicken or pig intestines.
@nzalheart (2338)
• India
20 Feb 11
Hi Scheng, How are you? Hopefully fine and mylotting a lot. I missed you more than mylot... To talk about myself, I am a vegetarian, and don't prefer such food. We hear that Chinese people are really diverse in type of meat they eat. About meat of pigs, most of the non vegetarians are crazy about the sausage here. Nepal is so much affected by the culture of worshiping gods and goddesses. And some of the animals are considered the avatars of gods and goddesses. For eg. Cow is the symbol of mother and so, meat of cow is strictly prohibited in Nepal. But the meat of buffaloes is most commonly preferred meat here in Nepal... Nice to respond after long long time...Keep mylotting..
@nzalheart (2338)
• India
20 Feb 11
Hi again, that was funny ... I don't need to climb Mount Everest because I am tired of climbing mine Everest of Life. The fierce exams runs after me furious than the fierce dog you are talking about. And the time chases me faster, faster and faster... People in Nepal cannot even think of beef. Chinese people are very much different. We can't imagine mice, rabbits, sparrows and ants for the meet. It feels too much odd for us. But like I said before, it just about the circumstances in which people are grown up, right? Perhaps it would be the most difficult thing in life for a Chinese to quit eating meet altogether. I heard that it is the statement of Chinese that, " Every creature in this world exists for the human beings itself." Don't know I heard right or wrong...People in Singapore are Chinese? I thought you are from Singapore... Happy mylotting....
@scheng1 (24650)
• Singapore
21 Feb 11
Hi Nzalheart, most of us in Singapore have ancestors from China, India or other countries. They came over before or after second world war. Most Chinese traveled out of China before the country became a communist country, and their children became Singaporeans when Singapore gained independence. Actually Singapore is a very new country, just a few years old. We gained independence in 1965. We do not have much national history, unlike your country with its rich culture and history, even the birthplace of Buddha. In the past, the Chinese were very poor. If they did not learn to eat everything, they would die. Your statement is basically correct. The actual saying is that everything with four legs is edible, except for the table.
@scheng1 (24650)
• Singapore
20 Feb 11
Hi Nzalheart, nice to have you back in mylot. I thought you have gone to climb Mount Everest! But then I remember how lazy you are, so climbing mountain is definitely not for you. Probably when someone releases fierce dogs to run after you, then you will start to run up the mountain. Many Chinese do not eat beef too. They believe it is a sin to eat beef since cows help in farming, and people who pray to Goddess of Mercy cannot eat beef. However, many Chinese do not hold the same belief. That is why they eat practically everything, including ants, field mice, scorpions, rabbits, sparrows and other creatures. I wish I have the determination to quit eating meat altogether.
@1hopefulman (45123)
• Canada
20 Feb 11
So far this year, I haven't eaten any animal products yet. No meat, no fish, no milk, no eggs, not anything! It doesn't mean I won't, but I try not eat animal products too often. I don't condemn those that do. I just think that a fruit and vegetable diet is better. Bon appetit!
@1hopefulman (45123)
• Canada
22 Feb 11
Like I said, while I eat mainly vegan, I do not condemn those that eat animal products. Though I do think that we overdo it. Our main foods should be vegetarian and animal products occasionally and not the other way around. Enjoy!
@scheng1 (24650)
• Singapore
20 Feb 11
Hi 1hopefulman, I try to limit my intake of meat too. Fortunately many Chinese dishes are vegetables based, with minced meat to add to the taste. However, I will not tell myself that I will not eat meat anymore. I think the human nature is such that forbidden food is the best food. If I tell myself to quit taking meat, I will definitely crave for it. As long as I keep telling myself that I can always eat meat when I want it, I do not feel the temptation. The same with animal organ dishes. The fact is that these are available in abundance.
@scheng1 (24650)
• Singapore
23 Feb 11
Hi 1hopefulman, it seems that the rich people are more health conscious than the poor. The rich people and the middle class are better educated, and they know the value of eating more vegetables and fruits. They value their health more. The poor are the ones who eat fast food, and refuse to exercise much. I think when people fall sick, they should not blame God for their sickness. They have to blame their eating habits and their lifestyle.
@inu1711 (5285)
• Romania
20 Feb 11
Hello Scheng, We, Romanians, also eat animal organs. I think the bladder, the bile, the eyes and the uterus are the only parts that are thrown away when people sacrifice an animal. We also have some recipes for intestine soup and even stomach soup (the latter is very much appreciated but I hate it ) but only the stomach/intestines from large mammals are used. The intestines from rabbits, birds or fish are usually fed to dogs or cats. I never thought there could be people who don't eat animal organs, I thought it was something normal.
@scheng1 (24650)
• Singapore
20 Feb 11
Hi Inu, glad to hear that we Chinese are not the only ones fond of animal organs as food. I am even gladder to hear that the bladder, eyes and uterus are thrown away. I think it is very awful to have a bowl of soup, and find the eyes of the cow staring up at me. I like the pig stomach as well. It takes a lot of work to season and clean the stomach. However, adding the pig stomach slices to the boiling hot steamboat adds to the taste of it. If I ever travel to Romania, I would definitely try the pig intestine soup.
@scheng1 (24650)
• Singapore
21 Feb 11
Hi Inu, I keep it in mind. I guess if i forget the name, I would have to describe it or to draw the pig, then the intestine. Hopefully they dont mistaken it for pig and snake. I think the combination will be too powerful!
@inu1711 (5285)
• Romania
20 Feb 11
Ciorba de burta - This is the intestines soup, in Romanian it is called "Ciorba de burta"
If you ever travel to Romania, ask for "Ciorba de burta" in any restaurant. This is a dish that can be found in any restaurant's menu. It is usually eaten with vinegar and garlic, and some people also add cream and pepper. I never tasted it because I don't like the idea of eating such a soup, but most people love it.
@sweet_pea (3322)
• Philippines
21 Feb 11
I occasionally do. Most animal organs are being used as street foods in my country. Some where even given names such as the following: -adidas : not the shoe brand, but refers to chicken feet -IUD: not your contraceptive, but refers to chicken or pig intestines. Also known as isaw -walkman: not your music gadget, but refers to pig's ear -helmet: not your head gear, but refers to chicken's head -betamax: not your old video player, but refers to chicken or pork blood You see, nothing is wasted.
@scheng1 (24650)
• Singapore
21 Feb 11
Hi Sweet_pea, I wonder how is the one who names all the animal parts food after popular gadget. The founder of Adidas shoes will not be happy to hear that Adidas mean chicken feet. if the buyers think of chicken feet when they buy shoes, they definitely will not buy Adidas. And walkman becomes pig's ear! That fellow needs a good spanking to give pig's ear such a nice name.
@scheng1 (24650)
• Singapore
22 Feb 11
HI Sweetpea, the names are very funny. Fortunately they did not name after a person. I mean if you name a dish of pork intestine after a famous person, that famous person may die of anger or laughter or disbelief. I think animal organs food dishes are nice to eat, as long as you do not get to see the actual preparation.
@sweet_pea (3322)
• Philippines
22 Feb 11
I really don't know how naming these things started. It just evolved amongst the people. I really believe Filipinos have a great sense of humor. No matter how hard their life can be, they find reasons to still laugh and smile.
@SIMPLYD (90722)
• Philippines
22 Feb 11
Here in the Philippines, we do eat the intestine of the chicken. It's grilled and called "isaw" . We tag it here as street food. We also would put the beef organ we call "tuwalya" on our porridge like dish and it's delicious. So far, those are the animal organs we make use of for our foods.
@scheng1 (24650)
• Singapore
23 Feb 11
Hi Simplyd, I think as long as we do not see the food preparation, we will not think of the food as dirty. Anyway the deep frying of the chicken wings, animal organs and whatever kill off the virus and bacteria. The best is to eat it right after the sellers deep fried it. I used to enjoy street food, but seldom eat them anymore, mainly for health reason. I try to eat more vegetables and fruits, and less oily food.
@scheng1 (24650)
• Singapore
23 Feb 11
Hi Simplyd, I have learnt a lot from this discussion thread, including all the creative names of your street food. i think tourists have to exercise caution when eating street food. Otherwise they may end up with diarrhea. Most people in the West do not have the habit of eating animal organs, unlike us in Asia. I think the culture of eating animal organs enrich our life. Imagine what happen if Isaw and Tuwalya were to disappear from the country. It will be a huge loss.
@SIMPLYD (90722)
• Philippines
23 Feb 11
Dirty though they may seem those street foods, they are so delicious to eat. People really patronize them because they are cheap and easy to eat. I guess, Isaw and tuwalya will not disappear , but they will thrive, because of their demand from those hungry passers by.
@Galena (9110)
20 Feb 11
a lot of people in the UK don't like Offal, which is their loss really. offal has a lot of good flavour. I particularly love liver and heart. offal is tasty, good for you, and it's a shame to waste any part of an animal you kill for food. I don't think people give it enough of a chance, they just assume they won't like it, so don't try it.
@Galena (9110)
21 Feb 11
I've not tried brain yet. I would be interested. I've heard that it's nice.
@scheng1 (24650)
• Singapore
21 Feb 11
Hi Galena, I think the people in many developed countries have not experienced poverty, that is why they do not understand those people in developing countries who can eat everything. The rich culture of Chinese includes many food dishes and herbs from various sources. We eat the roots, the bark, the stem and the leaves, beside the flowers and the seeds. I think only the Chinese is capable of eating the needle-leaf of the pine trees, and stir fried the flowers. Eating animal organs is part of the culture too. It is a shame to waste the organs, since organs are often the tastiest parts of the animals, and most nutritious. However, the cholesterol level is very high, especially the brain.
@scheng1 (24650)
• Singapore
22 Feb 11
Hi Galena, I think pig brain herbal soup is an once in a lifetime experience. Not many people can tolerate the extremely high cholesterol level in the soup. The herbs do not help in reducing the cholesterol. The herbs make the pig brain herbal soup a complete food in term of nutritional value.
• Singapore
21 Feb 11
Yeah, I do eat animal organ. My favourite would be pig intestine and pig stomach. But organ usually have very high cholesterol so I would try not to eat them too often.
@scheng1 (24650)
• Singapore
21 Feb 11
Hi Daveisdavid, I seldom eat the animal organs too. The reason is partly the high cholesterol, and partly the love for natural fruits and vegetables. The organ with the highest concentration of cholesterol is the brain. I think if you enjoy a bowl of pig brain herbal soup, you need to exercise for days to get rid of the cholesterol.
@daeckardt (6237)
• United States
20 Feb 11
Hi scheng1, I will often eat liver (usually beef or chicken) or chicken heart or gizzard (but those were my parents favorite parts). Many people in America don't like eating liver. Some like eating intestines (I think they call it tripe?) but I couldn't do it. I am willing to try some things, but it is better if you have me try it before you tell me what it is or I may not even try to eat it. Have a great week!
@daeckardt (6237)
• United States
21 Feb 11
I think you are right. When I was in China, I did try many things that I normally didn't eat in America because I couldn't afford to eat western food. It was easier (and cheaper) to eat the way the locals ate. The only thing was I had to tell them not spicy because I don't like hot foods. I never heard of walking catfish, but I'm not from Florida. While I like eating Chinese food in America, the food in China is far different and far better than the Americanized version I was exposed to all my life.
@scheng1 (24650)
• Singapore
22 Feb 11
Hi Daeckardt, if you ever visit the western part of China, and tried the spicy food, you would never forget about it. The kind of chilli pepper is very different from what we used in other parts of the world. When you happen to bite into the chilli pepper, you will feel the area going numb, as if the dentist has given you an injection. The numbness spreads through all your mouth. That is the best part. After that, the numbness goes away, and the hot and spicy feeling hits you hard. You start to grab the rice bowl, and literally pour rice into your bowl. The real suffering comes the next day, when you practically camp in the toilet, and diarrhea throughout the day.
1 person likes this
@scheng1 (24650)
• Singapore
21 Feb 11
Hi Daeckardt, I think many people in America are not adventurous when it comes to the matter of food. If those people in Florida have eaten those walking catfish, those walking catfish will never become a terror. If those catfish enters the rivers in China, I can guarantee you that the Chinese will think of a thousand and one way to cook it. Over here in Singapore, even though we are completely different from China in education and thinking, we still enjoy many Chinese food. After all, our ancestors come from China. I guess eating ants is out of our limit of tolerance for food.
1 person likes this
@akangirl (2436)
• India
24 Feb 11
we eat only fish and chicken and that too i prefer the leg piece.Fish also very rarely.As for pig it would be a big no.I have seen on discovery people eat cockroaches as well. ewwww
@akangirl (2436)
• India
24 Feb 11
I can never eat beef as we consider cow as auspicious and as for animal organs here meat shopkeeper sell them at very low price to dog owners and cat owners.We boil it to soften it a bit and feed it to animals.
@scheng1 (24650)
• Singapore
25 Feb 11
Hi Akangirl, if only the animal organs are as cheap in our place. Too bad many people love animal organs, and the selling price is rather high. I think many people love to eat pig intestine soup everyday, except that they are worried about their health. Most of us who pray to Goddess of Mercy do not eat cow too. It is considered holy. However, the younger generation is indifference to the meat. They eat everything. Even Muslims who are not supposed to eat non-halal food are not following it strictly.
@scheng1 (24650)
• Singapore
24 Feb 11
HI Akangirl, it is common to eat fish and chicken. However, most people do not eat the organs of the animals. Most people throw away the organs of the chicken, and just cook the meat. Same as eating pork and beef. I think I stay away from cockroaches. I guess I will vomit for days if someone eats cockroaches in front of me.
@mermaidivy (15395)
• United States
21 Feb 11
I am a Chinese as well. I don't mind organs.
@scheng1 (24650)
• Singapore
22 Feb 11
Hi Mermaidivy, I think for us Chinese, eating animal organ is a very common occurrence. Even if some of us tend to eat more vegetables or become a vegetarian, we still accept the culture of eating animal organs by our people.
@shia88 (4571)
• Malaysia
5 Mar 11
Hi, I do eat animal organ and the most I like is pig liver, chicken inner parts and even chicken blood. For chicken blood, it is most suitable to cook with curry chicken.The taste is nice. Pig organ soup is very famous in Singapore and Malaysia and you can easily find this dishes at hawker centre. For chinese people, we do eat Bak Kut Teh and when I ordered this dish, I will add a bowl of pig liver. It is best to eat with chilly. Taste delicious.
@scheng1 (24650)
• Singapore
6 Mar 11
Hi Shia, guess what I see when I visit the Sheng Siong Supermarket? Pig skin, pig oil, pig heart and others. I buy pig oil only for prayer. Cannot imagine how anyone would want to eat this disgusting item. However, i like the fried noodle with pig oil, tastes so nice. Do you know where I can find beef heart? I have visited so many supermarkets in west side, and nowhere can I find beef heart. I hope to get it, and feed to my fish.
• Israel
20 Feb 11
I would really like to try and eat these animal organs, but unfortunetly, i live in Israel, most of the food here is kosher (that means that we usually don't eat this kind of food here), although i eat here a lot of chicken organs (that is kosher) and i like it a lot, esprcially the liver and hearts. it is a dream of mine to travel to chaina and taste all of this interesting food.
@scheng1 (24650)
• Singapore
21 Feb 11
Hi Gnmfashion, in this case, I think you can forget about eating pork organs or beef organs. Even if you visit Singapore, where you can find pig intestine soup everywhere, I doubt your conscience allows you to enjoy the food. China has more exotic food, such as fried ants, scorpions, field mice, dog meat, skinned cat and other food. As long as you do not ask the origin of the food, the cooking will deceive you. Once you know what meat it is, you can never swallow it.
• Israel
21 Feb 11
hi scheng1! i do eat food which is not kosher, so that's why i said that i"m curious about the food in china,i really want to try and taste all the "weird stuff". when i visited thailand i tasted fried cockroaches and warms. even in my country i eat lots of sea food which is not kosher although it's very expensive here. i just love it!
• Canada
21 Feb 11
Yes, Filipino used to eat different foods out of animal organs. One of the best so far is bopis and dinuguan.
@scheng1 (24650)
• Singapore
21 Feb 11
Hi Mbagullo, I just learnt the meaning of dinuguan. The dish sounds horrible. I mean to cook the organs with blood sauce is really weird. Some of the Chinese soups are herbal soups with meat or animal organs. Somehow it sounds better to think of pig brain and different herbs. I do not like the taste of blood, especially not with organs. I think I give dinuguan a miss. I would like to try bopis.
@sweet_pea (3322)
• Philippines
22 Feb 11
Weird but tasty. It really is great as a viand and we usually eat it with rice. This usually goes with puto or a white rice cake in my country. Well black and white compliment don't you think? Some cultures would really find it gross. But when you are exposed to it, you would really say that it wasn't all that bad. Before, I've never eaten chicken intestines and feet. But now, I can eat it.
@careguarden (5670)
• Philippines
20 Feb 11
Hello scheng..Me too, I love to eat animal organ especially I can see how they clean the organs..Just like an exotic food.I am craving for it especially during summer..I love the pig intestine to cook like dinuguan with puto in our country and that is my favorite dishes during breakfast and snacks.. Happy mylotting..
@scheng1 (24650)
• Singapore
20 Feb 11
Hi Careguarden, i cannot imagine eating animal organs first thing in the morning, even though I like animal organs as soup too. I seldom take animal organs even though these are very common dishes. I prefer to eat more natural food, and save the animal organs, such as pig intestine soup, pig stomach, pig brain soup and the rest for times when I have the craving for it.
@topffer (42156)
• France
20 Feb 11
Some organs are eaten in my country : stomach and intestine of porc and beef -- intestines were also used for salami and sausages --, heart and liver -- indeed foie gras, but also calf liver --. I don't like brain and tongue, but calf kidneys are a good dish.
@scheng1 (24650)
• Singapore
21 Feb 11
Hi Topffer, I seldom eat sausages, so I am not aware that intestines were used for making it. I do not think I can eat the tongue of the animals. It sounds too horrible. At least the organs do not look like any visible parts of the animals, unlike the ears, the eyes or the tongue.
• Philippines
21 Feb 11
Organ meat is actually becoming more and more mainstream recently. One of my favorite writers and TV personality, Anthony Bourdain, has been extolling the tastiness and virtues of eating all the bits found inside an animal, and I mean ALL. As for me, I like sweetbreads, brain, tripe and the occasional chicken liver, especially when it's made into a pate. Unfortunately, I have to limit my intake of organ meat because of the high uric acid content that would be bad for me. Calf and Pig Liver, is NOT something I would eat voluntarily however. In my opinion, there's just no way to make these two edible.
@scheng1 (24650)
• Singapore
21 Feb 11
Hi Stellar, actually pig liver does not taste much different from the organs of chicken. The only difference is that it is more tender and sweet. I personally do not like pig brain herbal soup. The cholesterol level is simply too high. I do not see how I can burn away all the cholesterol.
@tiffnkeat (1673)
• Singapore
20 Feb 11
Pig organ soup and Kway Chup yummy. I do take them although not often. Do you know of any good ones to recommend? I don't take pig brain...I hope my brain good enough. I don't quite like liver because of the texture and the taste. Kidney, yummy. Intestine, yummy...blood...was yummy, now I try to abstain.
@scheng1 (24650)
• Singapore
20 Feb 11
Hi Tiffnkeat, I think once I can find beef heart in the supermarket, I will give you the leftover after my fish has eaten the best part of it. You can cook with maggie mee for instant nourishment. i seldom eat Pig organ soup and Kway Chup. Maybe you can write an article about finding the best pig organ soup in Jurong area. This type of articles seems more suitable for you. What about the lasi Lemak stall in Boon Lay hawker center? The one that opens near midnight, and closes a few hours after midnight. I think you can write a great article about your experience of eating the rich food. The keyword will be Boon Lay hawker center and Lasi Lemak.
• Indonesia
20 Feb 11
Hi scheng, I only eat the meat of chicken, beef and fish and not any other part of animal, I don't even eat the chicken's skin or liver. I got anemia, so people said that it's good for me to eat beef or chicken liver but I'll always say no thanks. I can't eat them, not even for my health's sake.
@scheng1 (24650)
• Singapore
20 Feb 11
Hi Loveandpeace, I can understand your feelings toward eating the organs of the animals. The rare organs do look very scary, and bloody. The liver and kidney look like a big lump of blood. The cooked version does not look so bad, especially when it is well cooked. I prefer the chicken skin to the meat, since the chicken skin absorbs all the seasoning. However, I do not take chicken often. I think frequent consumption definitely leads to health problem.
• China
21 Feb 11
Yes but not usually. I like stomach best, sometimes liver and kidney, but no brain...
@scheng1 (24650)
• Singapore
21 Feb 11
Hi Comiclee, I do not eat the animal organs everyday too. I think even once a week is too much. The organs have high cholesterol and high calories compared to the meat of the same size. Pig brain is the worst of all, since it contains the highest cholesterol content. if you have a chance to try pig brain herbal soup, you may like it. The herbs disguised the origin of the organs very well.