would this work?

April 19, 2012 12:06pm CST
I have come up with a idea to make money but am not sure if it would work. My idea is that you take your local currency in my case British pounds and use it to buy a foreign currency like the euro or the US Dollar. Then what you do is keep a eye on the currency rates and either convert the money back to your local currency or you,convert it to another currency. Then the final step would be to convert it back to the local currency. So for me i would take £100 and use it to buy euros, (at the moment it buys 122 euros) over the next month or week I would keep an eye on the currency rates to see if I convert the euros back to pounds if i would make a profit on it or not. (If the 122 euros would return me back more than the £100) If it does not I would look at the conversion rate between euro and the dollar and so then check the rate of the dollar against the pound To be honest you do not need to move currency around, all you need to do is convert your local currency to either the dollar or euro and then keep a eye on the market and sell it to a currency exchange when you get more back then you paid. Do you guys think this is worth the time?
7 responses
• United States
19 Apr 12
I believe this is a transaction fee everytime you do this, so in the end you would come up with less than you started with. Doesn't sound like a profitable or maybe even legal idea to me.
1 person likes this
19 Apr 12
It is legal because when you go on holiday you convert your currency to foreign money then when you come back you change it again to local currency. it is legal as you are not mmoney laundering. As for the fees if you actually use some places where you buy the foreign currency they offer to convert it back free when you come back off holiday so it does not always include a fee.
@owlwings (43915)
• Cambridge, England
19 Apr 12
This technique is the basis of something called Foreign Exchange or Forex for short. It is something which large banks and money markets do all the time and which many others with smaller resources do through a number of websites set up for the purpose. Search for 'forex' and you will find plenty! It is never as simple as it seems at first. It requires a great deal of skill (not to mention a certain 'art') to be able to spot trends before they happen and to know the exact time to buy or sell. Like any form of gambling, you must only invest as much as you can genuinely afford to lose and you must not, on any account, allow emotion (either euphoria or desperado) to influence you. Something which many people who look at exchange rates often forget is that the markets which you have to use to buy and sell currency will always charge fees for doing so. This is, of course, quite normal and reasonable. If someone performs a service for you, they expect to be paid. If you look at the foreign exchange board of any bank, you will see these rates expressed as 'Buying' and 'Selling' rates. Of course, these are charges which the banks make for buying and selling actual currency. They are rather higher than the rates which the forex markets charge but it demonstrates the principle. 98% of people who try Forex will make little or nothing and most will suffer losses. Only about 2% make any significant long-term or consistent gains. You may read stories (especially from those who have a vested interest in promoting sites in order to obtain referrals) which suggest that huge profits can be made. I have no doubt that, exceptionally, they can be ... with a good deal of experience, a lot of luck and by building up the amounts you can trade gradually. Stories like that are just bait for the unwary, however. The people who tell them are more than likely making their money by selling tutorials and instruction (of a sort) to wannabes!
@ecaron (678)
• Canada
19 Apr 12
I just had to comment on your response to this discussion because I'm very impressed as to how knowledgable you are on this subject.
@owlwings (43915)
• Cambridge, England
19 Apr 12
I have done a lot of reading, mostly in order to advise others against throwing their money away!
@sylvia13 (1850)
• Nelson Bay, Australia
20 Apr 12
The only problem with your idea is that currencies fluctuate, so one would need to keep checking so one does not end up with a surprise! I know this, as at the moment we are soon moving to Australia, but we need to take our Euros with us and everyday I find a different exchange rate!
@ottona (141)
• China
20 Apr 12
It's more-or-less gambling, UNLESS you are extremely knowledgeable when it is more-or-less a full time (and very difficult) job. It can make money (but when you subtract the transaction fees it is not that easy to do so I think, unless you are managing a fund of millions of dollars) and likewise it is easy to make mistakes, banks make money this way because they mange millions of dollars, and so one small mistake wouldn't affect them - it'd affect you though!
@ecaron (678)
• Canada
19 Apr 12
I'm not sure about your idea because it seems like a lot of work to watch currency rates and markets and so on. I think that GOLD is the best thing to invest in these days because it's value keeps getting higher all the time and I think that perhaps some day paper and coin currency will be no more and we may trade and buy with gold again like they did in past centuries.
@owlwings (43915)
• Cambridge, England
19 Apr 12
Gold is certainly one of the commodities which is always likely to more than hold its value (until chemists discover how to fabricate atoms rather than just molecules). That is why currency used to be based on it (as well as being actually made of it). The economic reasons for most currency being no longer based on any kind of actual physical reserve such as gold are very complex but the fact is that 'money' is now regulated by some very airy-fairy concepts, many of which may not have any reality at all. Most people do not have any idea what money REALLY is. They may think about it in terms of how much they are paid and how much of that monthly paycheck has to go towards living expenses and so on and that, indeed, is all that is really relevant to them. If you are running a business, however, money is quite a different thing. For a business, it isn't how much you have (or receive each month) that matters so much as how fast money is flowing through the company - something called cash flow and turnover. The confusion arises because both are measured or calculated in the same units - dollars, pounds, rupees or whatever. To illustrate it somewhat, think of the ways we can talk about a car. We may boast that it "can do 120 [mph]" or that it can "do 0 to 60 in 5 seconds" but that doesn't tell us anything about how long it will take to get from A to B (or how much it will cost in gas, of course). *** lecture over *** I believe, like you, that, in the not too distant future, we shall not be handling paper or coins. Already we are beginning to receive funny looks from certain places when we pull a wad of notes out of our pockets! Many places deal only with plastic and I can see this going even further so that everyone will be carrying a 'Universal Communication Device' with them - it might even be surgically inserted - which will do everything including calling or sending messages to friends, remembering calendars and shopping lists, paying for goods and receiving payments, identifying you when you vote in elections, allowing you into different countries (border/passport control) and many, many other functions.
• India
19 Apr 12
A good idea but I dont think you can make lot of profit here because currency exchange agent also make some profit out of you and also there is a little risk here.
@Lucky12 (767)
• United States
19 Apr 12
Well I think that you will end up with less money than you put in. I mean if you think that it is something good for you then all you have to do is crunch numbers and see how much you will make and how much you will actually lose. If the losing number is greater then maybe it is something that you do not want to do.