How to make a kid like a musical instrument?

@safety69 (592)
Taiwan
April 26, 2012 3:23am CST
I Play some guitar and flute , I would like my kids to play them too, but, I dont want to force them. I asked my kid yesterday if he would like to play the guitar and he said yes , then I asked him: are u going to dedicate to it?? and he said : ok , then I dont want to play. I felt guilty for asking that. He is already playing some flute but , he likes to play by ear , not by reading, I am trying to do my best , but , he practice only when I tell him. I would like him to do it by himself. What do you think mylot s friends?
2 people like this
13 responses
@allknowing (130064)
• India
26 Apr 12
It is a good thing that your child says he likes to play the guitar but he said that without knowing the struggle one has to go through to grasp it. Let him just play by ear for a while and let another child who has learnt it professionally give a performance in front of your kid and let your child see the difference. I am sure your child will then realise that without learning the instrument he will not make much progress.
@safety69 (592)
• Taiwan
26 Apr 12
Thanks for your advises , I will try my best to do what you said about , asking or going to a kid s performance . Yes , I am sure , it will call the attention on my kids. Have a good day my friend.
@allknowing (130064)
• India
26 Apr 12
But never ever compare your child to this professional. All what you could do would be ask your child's opinion on how he liked that boy's performance and tell your child that this boy is taking lessons.
@PVanne (29)
• United States
27 Apr 12
I got into guitar around 14, and only for two and a half reasons. 1.) impress girls 2.) rock out with my friends 1/2.) express myself That's it. Its still dear to me though, I mean, I'll straight up fight someone that drops my gibson SG....
• United States
27 Apr 12
I have my father's 40 year old Gibson SG. I never learned how to play but it's one of my most prized possessions.
@youless (112124)
• Guangzhou, China
26 Apr 12
I agree with you that you should not force children to play a musical instrument. And you know that most of the time children's interests come and go easily in a short time. So you shall not expect that his passion will last for a long time. However, you shall still encourage him and hopefully he will practise to play the musical instrument willingly. Since you know how to play the musical instrument, perhaps you can make a band with your son and he may have interest in playing the musical instrument. I love China
@safety69 (592)
• Taiwan
26 Apr 12
Thanks for answering my comment. Yes you are absolutely right , passion in kids come and go , today they like something , tomorrow they wont. Yes , last night we were talking exited about playing all together , I said : you (10 years old) can play the guitar , the little one who is 5 years old can play the flute and I can sing or viseversa, we were just discussing where to buy the guitar , I would like to buy an small guitar so , they both can play. I am exited about it. I wont force them . I want them to be happy and enjoy what they do.
@jazel_juan (15747)
• Philippines
26 Apr 12
as for me, there is no point in forcing them.. you cannot force them to LIKE it, as liking comes from within. Ask them what they like, they might be more affiliated to arts than music, or sports in that matter. As for my daughter i would love for her to learn dancing but she is not into it as she loves to have some voice lessons and learn guitar.
@safety69 (592)
• Taiwan
26 Apr 12
Yes , I know, I wont force them to play , its only if they want , I am going just to motivate them. They dont like art , but, they are into sports , they are going every saturday for soccer classes and they seem to enjoy that , but , I would really love them to play guitar . Hahahah , Lets hope for it. thanks for your comment.
@doroffee (4222)
• Hungary
26 Apr 12
I'm not going to MAKE my children anything. All children are like that naturally that if you force anything on them it's not going to be efficient enough. They have to consider this fun. I started to play the flute because I could go to the teacher with friends and I liked the music. My parents weren't like you have to be dedicated with three exclamation marks. It's just not a right thing to do to expect stuff from them especially as they are forced to do way too many things in school. In their free time, even if they are doing something they are going to benefit from mentally, they should do something out of fun. That's all. I thibk you should change your attitude a bit, and let them learn music how they'd like it. I guess for you, your child's happiness is worth more than making a musical prodigy out of them right? They may not be as dedicated as you on the long run, but at least they are having fun... and they might find another thing they are so obsessed with, like sports and dancing.
@safety69 (592)
• Taiwan
26 Apr 12
Yes , I will let them be , just naturally , little by little , lets see what happend. thanks for your comment. have a good day my friend.
26 Apr 12
Hello there safety69! It seems like me and your child are on the same boat. I also practice playing the piano whenever I feel doing so. I also like playing by ear and not by reading notes because it gives my a certain sense of freedom. I advice that you let your child discover different kinds of genre so that his interest in music will boost. That way, he will have the initiative to study, learn, and play music.
@safety69 (592)
• Taiwan
27 Apr 12
Oh yeah , thats good , yes , I know is good to play by ear , means you have a musical ear. I want him to learn to read also, he is reading some , he just need to practice a little bit more, I wont force him , just let him be. Just with some pushing everyday. thanks for sharing.
@alottodo (3056)
• Australia
28 Apr 12
Music like any other talent one has to be born with it...yes we can all learn anything we want to but are we going to be good at it? all my children tried a few different instruments and they are good at it and they all play at family reunions...but only one[ my youngest] have real talent and dedication[ she is a singer in her own band]she learnt guitar so fast and she also write her own songs! now no one forced her to do this she just does it because she likes...mind you she is 33 so she made up her mind to do this! When she was a child she could not even think about playing guitar! what I say is if your child have talent for music he/she will develop that talent in he's/her's own time!
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
26 Apr 12
First off, I have to say that playing by ear is a great way to start to play music. I have never been able to actually play an instrument by ear (I can play the piano and the viola) but I am able to sing by ear and I've actually realized a little bit later in my life that singing is actually my passion. As far as getting children to like to play an instrument (or have an interest in music) I think that the real key is to expose them to lots of different music. My children are nine and five years old and they both love to sing. In addition to that, my daughter has recently started taking violin lessons and she really seems to be enjoying it so far. Next year, when she is in fourth grade, she will get to join the school orchestra as well as the private lessons that she is getting and she really seems excited about that.
@megamatt (14292)
• United States
26 Apr 12
In the end, all you can do is offer your encouragement and your support. If they are bound to be talented, then true talent will shine through and if they are interested, then true interest will shine through. Musical instruments are fascinating as only a handful of people who really intend to learn them often follow through for an extended amount of time. In the end, support is the best and hopefully it will be something that will be enjoyable. If not, then perhaps it is just not meant to be. Different people will have different talents. Heaven knows that there were just many things that I have tried when I was younger, But some things were just never meant to be.
@lady1993 (27225)
• Philippines
27 Apr 12
Maybe you should just let him continue playing it by ear- my friend did that before and he is really good at it now. He can compose his own tunes too. You should also let him see professionals in youtube play those instruments, maybe he'll be inspired and want to do better at it.
• Philippines
26 Apr 12
hi safety69, for me i let my children play what they want to do, like drawing,singing and do what they want to do, and i support them, like my youngest daughter her hobby is singing and drawing.
26 Apr 12
Nice Discussion Friend. If you want to hear the voice of guitar from your kid you have to encourage him for playing it. But if you think asking him for playing guitar is difficult so dont force him. Allow him to do what he want.
@dzzziei (39)
• United States
27 Apr 12
You can't make him like anything. We're each our own individuals. I would suggest to try playing it with him. If he feels like you're forcing him to practice, naturally he won't want to do it. If you just ask him to play with you, he might do it as a nice gesture. Once he gets better, he might like it more. It's hard to start out with something you know nothing about. He might be willing to take lessons which would help out with this. I'm not sure how, but find ways to make it fun for him, instead of being a chore. Perhaps you could try taking him to a performance of someone that plays guitar. Good luck, but just remember how it'd feel if he tried to make you play an instrument you had no desire to.