Scotland might separate from Uk by 2014

Calgary, Alberta
June 9, 2012 5:45pm CST
When I think of Scotland, The first thing that gets into my mind is the movie Braveheart which is the Biopic of their National Hero William Wallace. Scots had been a part of the United Kingdom for a long time but i do know in some sports events and beauty pageants they competed as a separate country from UK. Now This had been an Issue in the UK, a lot of Scots thinks its about time for them to be on their own. I dont know if they were strong enough to be on their own though. Look what happened to the Philippines when the US sets it free. I think Scotland is an oil producing country, so it may be enough to keep them strong. Do you think Scotland is strong enough to be an Independent country? What will be their currency if they split up from UK? Is losing Scotland an advantage or disadvantage for the UK? What is going to be their government system. The last country that splits up with the UK is I think is Scotland.
1 person likes this
4 responses
@topffer (42155)
• France
10 Jun 12
Scotland has already its own pound banknotes printed by the Bank of Scotland. I suppose that with oil, distilleries, breweries and tourism -- haunted castles, Loch Ness and a wonderful nature -- they can separate without difficulties from UK. In fact Scotland is rich and underpopulated compared to England, and England would have serious problems without Scotland ; it is why the UK Prime Minister is offering more autonomy to Scotland if they choose to reject independence in 2014 -- there is already a Scottish Parliament deciding in domains like education, health and justice --.
1 person likes this
@topffer (42155)
• France
10 Jun 12
Actually a Scottish pound is worth a UK pound. As Scotland will stay in the EEC, and no passport is needed to go in another EEC country -- you cross interior borders of the EEC without control today --, there is no advantage here "to be a colony" for Scotland. Speaking of the economy, the results of Scotland are better than the global results of UK since 2006 : in fact the only loser would be UK if Scotland was independent. And Scots ask more for an economic and military independence than a true independence, because they say they will continue to recognize the queen of England as their queen.
1 person likes this
@topffer (42155)
• France
10 Jun 12
There is no more the queen on all Canadian stamps, but there is rarely a year without a stamp showing her : maybe some Eskimos don't know the existence of the queen, but you would also certainly find some peasants in Russia thinking that they are still governed by a czar. Scotland would be a small country in the EEC comparable to Ireland, and they would certainly have their entry at the Eurovision. But will they sing in Scottish or in English ?
1 person likes this
• Calgary, Alberta
10 Jun 12
meanwhile in Canada, many Canucks have no idea that Queen Elizabeth is actually their Queen. That could mean Scotland will do well and William Wallace will be happy wherever he was. I heard Scotland wanted their so called Independence to be a global event. They might finally have their own entry at the Eurovision.....Makes me wonder if they will give UK the coveted 12 points.
1 person likes this
@celticeagle (189915)
• Boise, Idaho
10 Jun 12
They probably don't have the answers to these questions either yet so haven't seperated yet. If they think strongly enough that they need to seperate then they are thinking about these things. It may be an advantage for the UK to lose Scotland. It hasn't happened yet so I would wait and see what happens.
• Calgary, Alberta
10 Jun 12
I wonder if they will revive their dying language once the separation happens. we are still not yet sure of their future. there are countries that became stronger after independence while there are countries that failed after the separation.
1 person likes this
@celticeagle (189915)
• Boise, Idaho
11 Jun 12
I would hope they would become stronger. They have been around a long time.
1 person likes this
• Calgary, Alberta
13 Jun 12
I just found out they already have their own currency, I guess that is a good start for them once they were free.That's not all their currency is the same value with British Pounds. I wonder if people from Wales and Northern Island wants to stay with England or separate as well.
@celticeagle (189915)
• Boise, Idaho
9 Mar 13
I have heard this too. But then I have been hearing itfor years. When they feel they can support themselves they will seperate. I don't if they are really strong enough to be on their own are not. I don't know why it would be any disadvantage for the UK. I guess we will see.
• Calgary, Alberta
9 Mar 13
I havent heard any new updates by far, but it makes me wonder, if they separate to UK and join Eurovision..... are they going to give their 12 points to UK.... if Scotland will get independence though, I can see it as a huge global event.
• Philippines
23 Oct 12
Sorry for the late reply, but I am just up to speed in the moment. It is a serious and complicated matter. I have been a fan of European history and UK history with a little Scottish background. But I also know to acknowledge Wales and NI. I don't know how much it will count. In my humble and outsider opinion, both nations have a long history against each other. I think even preceded the conflict between Catholics and Muslims. It is only when they were united (whether forcibly or not, depending on which you read or believe), they do make a great force in the world (read the British Empire) but I guess that they retain their own national identity even after 300 or so years. It's like a business deal, hardly personal. But in a sense, the UK in itself is a diverse and probably united when it suits it (again the British empire). As opposing countries over long years but of the same DNA stock, its difficult to erase their long history and conflicts. There are people (I mean all the nationalities) who claim to both their nationality and British or will be angry if they are associated with the second 'identity'. I think it also kinda applies to our country because we do practice regionalism, whether we admit it or not. Whether or not Scotland will separate is a matter of choice. However, I have been reading something that if you are pro-this, then you are anti-this. Some really want to set up camps. No neutrality and some who are of mixed descent might be the swingers but confused. Their reasons are very varied for economics, to nationalities, to politics and all that mix. Also there is too much unconfirmed detail. People in forums are volleying arguments, statistics, numbers one after another. I'm not saying that they are true or false but it's easy to get lost within good discussion and petty fighting. It's good to know that people can research these things and debate over them but the real debate isn't really happening soon. Anyway, one thing that you cannot dismiss from this is politics. Whichever camp you belong is is your choice. Just in like in our country.
1 person likes this
• Calgary, Alberta
27 Oct 12
if they will split up wth the UK, they better resurrect their language. They see the selves as Scottish and not as English, I heard their language is more alive compared to the dying Irish language. I think there are still a decent amount of Scottish Gaelge language. Ukraine is able to restore the Ukrainian language after they split up with Russia.