A mother who lets her son wear a skirt in kindergarten
By Porcospino
@Porcospino (31365)
Denmark
July 14, 2012 11:32am CST
I read an article about a mother who lets her son wear a skirt in kindergarten. She thinks that it is perfectly fine. If a girl can wear pants, a boy can wear a skirt she says, and she lets her son decide what he wants to wear.
The acticle about that woman and her son has lead to some discussions in my country. Some people agree with the mother, and they think that is is harmless and some people think that it is wrong to let a boy wear a skirt, and they are afraid that the other children are going to make fun of the boy.
What do you think about the mother's choice? Would you let your son wear a skirt if he wanted to? Why/why not? Do you consider it harmless or wrong?
4 people like this
13 responses
@matersfish (6306)
• United States
14 Jul 12
So my son wants to eat a burger. Okay. Harmless enough. A burger isn't going to do anything. But if he eats too many of them, he's going to get fat. Then he wants to sit inside and play video games instead of playing outside. Sure. Play some games, son. But wait -- the townspeople would string me up and beat me like a pinata for allowing my son to become an out-of-shape lazy slob.
But my son wants to wear a dress, and that's okay with everybody in the proverbial know. Why? Because it's his self-expression, and there's nothing wrong with it, and it's other people who create gender stereotypes and blah blah friggin' blah.
Yeah. My kid might want a million dollars too, but he's SOL on that one.
If my son were gay or gender confused or a girl trapped inside of a boy's body, etc, that'd be perfectly fine with me. But a kid in kindergarten doesn't know that sort of stuff, no more than they think it'd be great to eat burgers and chips all day while playing video games.
There's a time for these topics. Parents don't have the "talk" with their kids while they're still just little kids. What good would it do? So to me, encouraging a boy to dress up like a girl might cause him to become extremely confused and depressed or worse.
My little brother used to put on high heels and pretend to be a woman around the house. He grew up to be a 6-4 redneck and the farthest thing removed from a crossdresser you could imagine. But had my parents encouraged him to keep doing it, it's hard to say.
A progressive world doesn't need to be so damn progressive. It's the mother's right, sure. But people don't need to applaud it. It could actually be damaging the kid very much.
2 people like this
@Porcospino (31365)
• Denmark
14 Jul 12
It sounds like the mother lets her son make make his own decisions about the skirt. If he wants to wear a skirt she doesn't want to stop him, but the question is if she is really doing what is best for her son. She wants to break down the old thought abouts that things that you can and can't do, but like you say the boy could get confused. I also think that she other children might bully the boy if he wears something that unusual, and I would be worried about that if it was my son.
@maximax8 (31042)
• United Kingdom
14 Jul 12
I am shocked to hear that the little boy had to wear a skirt. I would refuse to let my son wear a skirt. A Scottish man or boy can wear a kilt because it is their tradition and heritage. My son can wear trousers, dungarees or shorts. I will not let him wear a skirt or a dress. I feel it would harm my son if I let him wear something feminine like a skirt.
Life is not equal. A girl and a lady can wear skirts or trousers. Both are perfectly acceptable. A boy would be thought sissy if he put on a skirt. The color pink is girly and blue is male like. The mother's choice was wrong. It is right to let a child have a choice like a blue jumper or a yellow cardigan. It would be nasty to let a child be the laughing stock because he is in a skirt.
1 person likes this
@Porcospino (31365)
• Denmark
20 Jul 12
If it had been my son I would also have refused to let him wear a skirt. I would have been worried that the other children would laugh at him or make fun of him. This little boy and his mother has received a lot of attention in the news because the mother lets him wear skirt. Some people support the mother and thinks that is harmless to let him wear a skirt, and many people think that the mother had made the wrong choice. I think that it would be very sad if the boy becomes the laughing stock because the mother wants to prove that she is very openminded. The mother says that her son is happy and doesn't get bullied, but I would still be worried about the other children and their reaction.
@anklesmash (1412)
•
14 Jul 12
I believe it is perfectly ok for a boy to wear a skirt if that is how he feels most comfortable and it is how he wants to express himself.However I'm not sure a child of that age has enough understanding to that kind of decision i didn't have enough understand of who i was at that age to make such a complex decision.If he was older then it would be fine as it would be more likely to be his true feelings i however think they are the beliefs of his mother and i think that its wrong for a parent to put their child in a position where they may be bullied just to show their beliefs off.
@Porcospino (31365)
• Denmark
20 Jul 12
I agree with that. An adult who chooses to wear female clothes understands the consequences of his decision. He knows that he might get some negative comments and that people might laugh at him and make fun of him, but he still chooses to wear a skirt, because he is strong enough to handle the situation. I have known several tranvestites, and it is not an easy life, but when you are an adult you understand the conquences of your decision and you know what you are doing. A small child doesn't understand the situation the same way, and I don't think that he understands that other people might react in a negative way. I don't think that a child is old enough to make that decision.
@Porcospino (31365)
• Denmark
15 Jul 12
Personally I would also have made a different choice. I don't think that I would have bought a skirt for my son, because I would be worried that other people would make fun of him. The mother thinks that she made the right choice and that it is best to let her son decide what he wants to wear, but I am not sure that it really is the right choice.
@Torunn (8606)
• Norway
14 Jul 12
Hmm, sounds like some of the things I've heard from Sweden too. Parents that don't want to tell the gender of their child, that use some kind of mix of mother and father for both parents, childrens book with main characters that don't really have a gender and are called hen instead of han/hon.
I don't think it's wrong of her to let the boy wear skirts. After all, Scots look great in skirts :-) Seriously though, I think small girls trying to dress like sexy grown-ups is more disturbing. However, he might get bullied by the other children, but once you decide to let your child dress that differently from the social norm, I suspect that the mother is ready to deal with the questions the child will have if the reactions aren't to his liking.
If you are one of the first to do something, then you'll get reactions. If you make your children part of it, then you have to be more aware of the consequences, but I don't think that it has too be bad if you handle it the right way.
However, I suspect that once you go outside Scandinavia/the Netherlands, it will be different. At least according to Hoofstede :-)
1 person likes this
@Porcospino (31365)
• Denmark
17 Jul 12
I remember reading about the parents who wanted to keep the gender of their child a secret and in a way that mother is doing the same things. She wants to break down the traditinal ideas of gender roles and allow her child to do everything that a girl could do like wearing a skirt, because she thinks that there shouldn't be a difference between the things that girls and boys are allowed to do. Her decision has lead some discussions in my country. Some people agree with her and support her decision and some people feel bad for the boy and are afraid that people will make fun of him. I would also be afraid that the boy would get bullied or made fun of.
@melindataylor22 (959)
• Waltham, Massachusetts
14 Jul 12
I understand both sides to this incident. I believe that that little boy should be able to wear what he wants and that the mom is right to allow him to express himself. It is true that he may teased and maybe at that point he and his mom will decide to do things differently but for now he's happy and not being teased so it's fine with me. I am very liberal and agree with her liberal attitude. I believe that in Scotland or it may be another country but I know there's a country where men wear skirts because it's part of their culture. Skirts are seen as feminine while pants are more masculine but are fine for women too. I think that men should be able to wear skirts if they want but if they don't that's fine like it's fine for women to wear pants. Society and the world is too strict and picky about things like this that are really no big deal compared to more important things in the world that are real problems such as war, violence, abuse, inequality, injustice, the economy, and the environment. People need to learn to open up and let their fears about anything different than what they're used to control how they think, act, and feel about what people around them do.
1 person likes this
@Porcospino (31365)
• Denmark
15 Jul 12
I am also able to see both sides. Your response reminds of me a post that I read on another discussions site. The post was written by a man who wanted to wear a skirt. Not because he was a transvesite or because he wanted to look like a woman, but simply because he thought that the unwritten rules saying that men outside Scotland can't wear a skirt were oldfashioned and stupid and ought to be abolished. I thought about his post when I read your response because I can see from your response that you also think that society is too strict.
It is true that clothes is a small thing compared to the many other problems that exist in the world. Part of me want to let a boy wear when he wants, but I would be afraid that he would get bullied or that people would want fun of him, and that it is main reason why I wouldn't a buy skirt for my son.
@ladygator (3465)
• United States
16 Jul 12
I dont really think that I would let my sons wear skirts to school. I think that in that grade, they really dont understand what they are doing so it seems more like the mother is just trying to make some waves in the school and just trying to show off in some way to be noticed.
1 person likes this
@bunnybon7 (50970)
• Holiday, Florida
14 Jul 12
now thats a tough one. I guess if he wants to and the kids dont make him feel bad about it, Id let him until I saw a problem with it. so i think shes right. besides in some countries guys wear skirts @myfb2009 (8296)
• Malaysia
16 Jul 12
Hi Porco, i would never allow my son to wear a skirt. Besides that, he don't want to wear skirt although my sister ever jokes asking him whether he want to wear skirt like her. It is because since from his toddler age until now, he never wear any skirt. I never buy any skirt for him to wear. I think it is depending on the parents. I had seen one of my neigbors before, ever gave their only son wear the handing it down skirt from his sisters. It is because the mother felt it is wasting as not to let her son wear it while the skirt is still in good condition. I am not sure what happen after that, since i had moved away from that area a few years ago.
@cecil04 (408)
• South Africa
14 Jul 12
I think it a little bit too soon for this mother to let her child in kinder garden decide on these kind of things. Sometimes I get the feeling that some parents forget that children are not their friends. Just imagine how the child will turn out in a few more years for one the child could become a brat who only thinks the world revolve around them and let's face it we all hate spoilt brats. The mother should let her son dress like other boys we don't want the child's mind to be damaged, do we.
1 person likes this
@ryanong (9664)
• Vietnam
15 Jul 12
Omg, she is wrong when let her son wear skirt. a girl can wear pants but please a boy should not wear skirt. If she does it regularly, her boy will love to wear skirt and he may got many troubles later in his life, he may have a wrong thinking of his gender also even though in fact he is a straight boy...
@subhojit10 (7375)
• India
14 Jul 12
Well i strongly feel that the mother should not have let her son to wear a skirt. This is because a skirt represents feminism. So this could potentially lead to bullying.
1 person likes this
@Porcospino (31365)
• Denmark
14 Jul 12
That was also my first thought. I have worked in a kindergarten myself and it is easy for me to imagine that the other children would bully the boy who wears a skirt. In the article the mother said that the boy was happy and he didn't get bullied, but I would still be worried about that if I let my son wear a skirt. It is true that girls can weat pants without a problem, but a boy who wears a skirt would attract a lot of attention because it represents something feminine.
@riyauro (6421)
• India
14 Jul 12
If the boy wants to wear skirt to kindergarten and he doesn't feel bullied and on top of that he is happy about it. Then it is okay for him to wear a skirt. We have to understand that he is a small boy who has a wish to wear skirt. when he goes to 1st standard he will have to wear school uniform and he will have no choice but to boys uniform. I feel that kids are kids whether girl or boy. And nowadays kids are going to kindergarten at very early age like 3-4 if i am not wrong. I hope i have made my point clear to you Porcospino
1 person likes this
@Porcospino (31365)
• Denmark
14 Jul 12
Yes, the boy's age is probably between 3 and 5. The boy's mother sees things the way that you do. She thinks that if her son is happy and doesn't get bullied he can wear whatever clothes that he chooses. I read that the boy likes to wear a skirt because he likes to dance and he enjoys wearing a dress while he is dancing. I would be a little worried if it was my son, not because he wants to wear a skirt, but because of the way that other people might react. He doesn't get bullied now, but that could change in the future especially if he continues to wear a skirt at school. That would be possible in my country since we don't have school uniforms and you choose your own clothes.












