Was I wrong?

@cynthiann (18602)
Jamaica
September 3, 2012 8:57am CST
This morning, my sister needed her blood taken as she is having a medical procedure on her heart later this week. As she has been advised to stop some of her meds she was feeling a bit dizzy so I naturally assisted her to the Medical Practice. I wish that they had advised her to stop the drinking but that is another story. On leaving the practice we then we picked up a few itmes and decided to have a coffee and went into a nearby coffee shop. Whilst enjoying my coffee a lady comes in with two children. One was a baby girl who was under a year and the little boy was about 30 months at the most. She then put down a hot chocolate and cookies for her son and a cup of hot coffee for herself and disappeared into the restroom to change the baby's diaper. She told her son to stay there until she got back. I watched the boy like a hawk and when he reached for the hot coffee I removed it out of his way. I then played with him until his Mother returned. I smiled pleasantly at the mother as I put her coffee back on the table and said that I had put it out of hs way and stayed with him to protect him until she returned. She became so cross and said that he didn't need looking after and that I should have minded my own business. The Manager came and said that he could have called the police as she left her child unattended and that she should thank me. I didn't need or want thanks as I just wanted the little boy to be safe. I left the shop and my sister was waiting impatiently utside as she had told me to leave the shop as someone would have looked after the boy. So I just can't win. I honestly do not see where I went wrong. Lady - I had three children in just over three years and took them all with me into a restroom whenever the baby needed changing. I have been a bit upset since morning over this. So, was I wrong?
8 people like this
26 responses
@rocketj1 (6955)
• United States
3 Sep 12
You did the right thing! You know it too!
3 people like this
@cynthiann (18602)
• Jamaica
3 Sep 12
I do think that I did the right thing even though my sister was telling me to leave, But I was so surprised at her being quite vicious
2 people like this
@dawnald (85135)
• Shingle Springs, California
3 Sep 12
No, you were not. She should have thanked you. Really, she should have taken him into the bathroom with her.
2 people like this
@Hatley (163781)
• Garden Grove, California
4 Sep 12
hi cynthiann you know you can grow older b ut if one is a good mom you cannot take the mom out of us, and seeing a child in danger comes naturally to most good moms to help that child
1 person likes this
@dawnald (85135)
• Shingle Springs, California
3 Sep 12
Well, like somebody else said, it could have been maternal instinct coming out, and "who's that stranger with my kid". But more likely it was defensiveness, and she's an idiot. I'm glad the manager came and backed you up. And what's your sister's problem?
@cynthiann (18602)
• Jamaica
3 Sep 12
That is what I thought. She rreally attacked me and only quietened down when the Manager came and told her ythat he could have called the police. She was really quite vicious actually
1 person likes this
@maximax8 (31053)
• United Kingdom
3 Sep 12
You did the right thing keeping the little boy safe. A mother shouldn't leave a hot drink like a tea, coffee or a chocolate. The lady should have taken her kids to the restroom and asked the assistant to keep an eye on her family's drinks. The manager was right that the child shouldn't have been left unattended. Yes, he could have called the police. The lady had no reason to be cross since you saved her little boy from getting burnt. When I worked in an office I had to see the telex girls sometimes. One of them got a burning liquid down her legs. She had very sore burns from that. It is important to keep children away from hot drinks. Getting burnt would be painful and no parent should take that risk.
2 people like this
@cynthiann (18602)
• Jamaica
3 Sep 12
You are so right. I was worried about the hit coffee. His chocolate was just warm but then it was in a heavy cup which also caused me concern. The mother did take more than one risk with the safety of her son.
• Kenya
3 Sep 12
S true, no parent should take the risk, we need more people like her to avoid such avoidable accidents around us.
1 person likes this
@katsmeow1213 (28717)
• United States
3 Sep 12
You weren't wrong. She was wrong. What was she thinking leaving her child alone in a crowded place where anyone could have taken him away.. and all the things he could have hurt himself on such as hot coffee, etc. What is wrong with parents these days? My youngest children are now 6 and 4 and they're never left alone! If they need to go to the bathroom while we are out they are escorted by my oldest son or their daddy. If I have to take them, they go in the women's room with me so I know they're safe. I'd never let them in a men's room by themselves. If I need to use the restroom they come in with me. They're never left alone. Even at their ages there's still too much that can happen to them. This reminds me of something that happened to me when my twins were babies. My daughter got RSV when she was 6 weeks old. It's a serious respiratory infection that can turn into pneumonia. She had to be hospitalized for a couple of days. Due to lack of babysitters, if we ever wanted to get out of the house, the twins had to come with us. So they were very young, but it was after my daughter had RSV, and we took them to the mall. As usual, whenever we were out with them, people always had to ooh and ahh over the baby twins. It got on my nerves really. I just wanted people to leave my kids alone, especially after my daughter had gotten so sick. So here we are in the mall and this woman comes up to ooh and aah over my kids. I quickly jumped between her and the babies who were in a stroller and asked politely for her not to get too close, and I did try to explain that my daughter had recently been very ill. She immediately started screaming at me and even called me a few nasty names. I was shocked. What's so wrong with me trying to protect my children and where does she get off thinking it's perfectly okay for her to go touching a strangers child??
2 people like this
• United States
3 Sep 12
What I think is that she got defensive because she knows what she did was wrong, but she just doesn't care. She doesn't want to take proper care of her children, but at the same time she doesn't want others thinking badly of her in that manner. So instead of thanking you for your help (which would admit that she did something wrong) she accused you so as to place blame on you instead of herself. In the long run all she did was look like a fool and make everyone involved feel bad. She doesn't feel any better about herself for what she did. Perhaps though she will learn a lesson from this and start taking better care of her kids.. if nothing else at least so that she never looks like an idiot again in public.
1 person likes this
@cynthiann (18602)
• Jamaica
3 Sep 12
I really understand how you felt when you spoke to the woman but she should have listened and understood. What I found distressing was I did not touch the little boy but just stood there making sure that he was safe. Yes, I moved the hot coffee and yes, I laughed and chatted to him and told him that his Mum would soon be back but I did not touch him. If someone had or tried to take him then I would have raised the alarm and probably tried to grab him! But she screamed at me and accused me of touching her child, and that I shojuld mind my own business. I am sorry when a child is in potential danger that it the time that I do not mind my own business. The Manager was great and leapt to my defence but her anger was directed at me. I felt like a criminal for a fewmoments before I saw how ridiculous it was. I used to take all three into the bathroom with me. I never left my kids alone in a public place.
1 person likes this
@cynthiann (18602)
• Jamaica
3 Sep 12
I really hope that she does take better care of them as they deserve it. When I think of what you have said then I realise that your assessment of her is accurate. Blessings
1 person likes this
@ANTIQUELADY (36440)
• United States
3 Sep 12
OF COURSE U WEREN'T WRONG. She was a moron for going off & leaving the child by himself. There could have someone not as nice as u that could have snatched the child & went out the door w/him. U probably saved the child from getting burned by the hot coffee.Good for the manager for taking up for u. I DO TO.Don't try to win w/coleen, Cynthi, u are just wasting your time & getting upset for nothing. I don't like her for the way she treats u & i don't even know her.. U did what u should have done & u can't do more than that. That silly mother needs a boot in her behind.. hugs.
2 people like this
@cynthiann (18602)
• Jamaica
3 Sep 12
I can always depend on you for not only support but you have a knack of putting things into the right perspective Now I am smiling. I just hope that the mother does not do this again.
1 person likes this
@ANTIQUELADY (36440)
• United States
3 Sep 12
Glad to be of service, lol.
1 person likes this
@bunnybon7 (50973)
• Holiday, Florida
3 Sep 12
what a nasty dam lousy mother that woman is.!makes you wonder why people like that is allowed to have kids and nice of that manager to tell her off also because you never know what her agenda was. she could have planned on sueing the manager. or maybe shes been hopeing someone would go off with the kid. she surely knows how people run off with kids these days. you know you did a very nice thing. it seems that when we do the right thing it often just gives us trouble. if i was there id still be patting you on the back instead of being mean like your sister. just hearing about it makes me mad at that woman and your sister. KUDOS to you i say!!
@cynthiann (18602)
• Jamaica
3 Sep 12
Thank you my friend. She really should not have left him alone. However, he wasn't anxious which leads me to think that she has done it before. I was so glad that the manager intervened with her. I cold have done with a hug!
1 person likes this
• Canada
3 Sep 12
A two and a half year old "didn't need looking after"?? Unbelievable. That little boy was left alone in a public place -- I hate to seem dramatic but he could have been gone in an instant! Even if he were safe in the surroundings, he could have spilled hot coffee or hot chocolate on himself. There are documented cases of people suing (not that I agree with it, though!) because coffee has been served so hot in restaurants that it has burned them when spilled (remember the infamous woman who sued McDonald's for that?) You are completely right. She should have taken both children with her when she went to change the baby. She is giving too much responsibility to a child who is WAY too young. It was good of you to help her by watching that little boy -- even though she wasn't smart enough, or courteous enough, to appreciate it.
2 people like this
@cynthiann (18602)
• Jamaica
3 Sep 12
Her coffee was scalding hot but the hot chocolate was just warm as they do not give hot drinks to kids. He was such a trusting cute little boy who would have gone with anyone.
2 people like this
@carmelanirel (20942)
• United States
3 Sep 12
No, you did nothing wrong and it is people like you who prevent children from getting hurt unnecessarily. Plus the fact that the manager came over and agreed with what you did shows that he also knew you prevent the child from getting hurt.
@cynthiann (18602)
• Jamaica
3 Sep 12
Thank you. Deep down I know that I did the right thing but the way she almost attacked me was horrible. The Manager was great and she was wrong so decided to go on the offensive
@bellis716 (4799)
• United States
5 Sep 12
What you did was exactly right.
1 person likes this
@cynthiann (18602)
• Jamaica
5 Sep 12
Thank you. What upset me was that she verbally attacked me.
@celticeagle (159782)
• Boise, Idaho
3 Sep 12
No, you weren't wrong! What was this woman thinking of anyway? What she should have done was take the children into the restroom right away, changed her baby and then ordered their coffee and hot chocolate. Some people are just weird in their thinking. Mothers have a sixth sense and you knew this was a burn looking for a place to happen. Your instincts told you to do the right thing and come to the rescue of this little child since the mother obviously had no common sense. What was she thinking? You did right.
@celticeagle (159782)
• Boise, Idaho
4 Sep 12
You're so welcome! The mother was obviously not thinking. Leaving hot coffee there and leaving was just stupid.
1 person likes this
@cynthiann (18602)
• Jamaica
3 Sep 12
Thank you for saying that I did right. In my heart I knew that my action was correct as I could never have just walked out of that shop and left the little boy. Never.
2 people like this
• United States
3 Sep 12
You did nothing wrong in watching the child. A child that young is not capable of sitting by himself and waiting for his mother to return. Some people just shouldn't have children. Unfortunately, those people usually are extremely fertile.
@cynthiann (18602)
• Jamaica
3 Sep 12
On reflection, because the child was so accepting and did not cry for his Mum, it is my guess that it wasn't the first time this had happened to him. He was in danger of being calded with hot water or by being abducted. he really was a beautiful little boy. I will always look out for children. They should be kept safe at all times. You are right about the fertility!
1 person likes this
• India
3 Sep 12
Hi friend, your activity is good and you are not wrong, the mother's activity is wrong. She must conveyed her thanks at the beginning, but she behaved harshly at first, after the manager entered in to the issue, she realized her fault and conveyed her thanks to you, sadly you spent your precious time with this issue and faced your sister's anger.
2 people like this
@cynthiann (18602)
• Jamaica
3 Sep 12
To me,children always come first. Especially their safety. I could have understood her anger if I had touched her child by lifted him up but I didn't. I just wanted to protect him. I have fourchildren and four grandchildren and I never left any of them alone in a public place.
@tetris15 (539)
• Philippines
3 Sep 12
No, you're not. You just did what you had to do on that moment and that is to protect the kid from harm. I just can't comprehend why the mother has the nerve to say those things to you instead of thanking you for the little time you spared which in fact is her responsibility to look after her kids. Don't feel down, just remember that we can't please everybody. You don't have to worry, what comes around goes around.
2 people like this
@cynthiann (18602)
• Jamaica
3 Sep 12
She raised her voice in a public place and |I think that this distressed me as I had nit touched her child and people could have thought that I had. Thank you for the encouragement
• United States
3 Sep 12
They really should make people get licensed to have children. Obviously the woman was in the wrong and you did the right thing stepping in. That situation probably happens to that woman often and she's probably a bit sensitive about it, therefore she overreacted. I see situations like that all the time and like you I watch the kids. I remember sitting in a movie theater once and this tiny, tiny thing just about able to walk comes into our aisle and sits on my lap. The movie was playing so obviously it was dark and I had no idea where he came from. I hate to tell you how long it took for someone to come looking for that baby. You handled it better than I would, when she came back I'd be giving her my opinion before she'd have a chance to say anything to me ;-)
@cynthiann (18602)
• Jamaica
3 Sep 12
How could the parents have missed a cild in a movie theatre? Don't they care? Unbelievable. I think that I was embarrassed really and did nit know what to say. I did not touch the child - just moved the hot coffee away and chatted to him. I also think that you are right and that she over reacted thinking attack is the best mechanism
1 person likes this
@AmbiePam (85862)
• United States
8 Sep 12
No, you were not wrong and I'd like to rip into that lady. I'm glad the manager backed you up. Her rudeness is really inexcusable.
@AmbiePam (85862)
• United States
13 Sep 12
I'm okay. Thanks for asking!
@cynthiann (18602)
• Jamaica
8 Sep 12
I felt pretty dreadful at the time but I am over it now and just hope that she will not do it again. How are you doing my friend?
1 person likes this
@jillhill (37354)
• United States
3 Sep 12
She was lucky you were there and that no one came and snatched up the little boy and left with him. That was totally irresponsible on her behalf and kudos to you for watching him!
1 person likes this
@cynthiann (18602)
• Jamaica
3 Sep 12
Thank yiu Jill, I was worried about him and she was gone for so long so she probably had to wash the baby before diapering her. I think she attacked me as it was her defense mechanism kicking in
1 person likes this
@Canellita (12029)
• United States
4 Sep 12
Of course you were not wrong! That woman never should have left her child unattended like that. Anything could have happened. Your sister should have been more patient, but don't forget, she wasn't feeling well.
@cynthiann (18602)
• Jamaica
4 Sep 12
My sister is at an age and stage where she only thinks of herself. She used to be a Child Protection Officer in charge of the well being of over 3 million people in her district in London. She was very good too and this is why it was upsetting for me to see her acting this way. I do know that I was right deep down but the attack by the mother distressed me
@Canellita (12029)
• United States
4 Sep 12
I am always cautious at intervening in situations with othere people's children in public, but sometimes you just cannot help it. That mother may already have a file with the Child Protection agency; I can't imagine no one has ever said or done anything like what you did before based on her and her child's behavior. As for your sister, did she have any bad experiences on the job? Did she burnout? Do you think she has a reason for only thinking of herself right now? Sometimes circumstances in life cause us to behave more self-protective.
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
5 Sep 12
You were not wrong at all. The woman should have taken the baby and the toddler to the bathroom and changed the baby's diaper before she even ordered her food at the coffee shop. A child that small should never be left unattended, and yes, in my opinion that is a form of child abuse. Heck, I've been going through it these last several weeks because I've been having to get physical therapy and I have to find someone to watch Paul while I'm at the doctor's office. I know that there are other people that take their children in and expect the staff to watch over the children while they are getting their treatments, but I don't want to do that because it makes it difficult for the staff to get their actual work done.
1 person likes this
@cynthiann (18602)
• Jamaica
5 Sep 12
I do know that I did the right thing but was glad that the manger was there to observe that I did not ouch the child but just made sure tht he was safe. I do hope that you get relief from the physiotherapy - these back problems seem to be so difficult to get better. Take care and best of luck
@toyota4k (1208)
• Philippines
4 Sep 12
Who ever said you were wrong when in fact you were doing what is right is insane.
1 person likes this
@cynthiann (18602)
• Jamaica
4 Sep 12
Thank you as I know that I did the right thing by looking out for the little boy
@kassych (16)
• Kenya
3 Sep 12
well, I would look at it on the mother of the kids perspective. She could have had her fears regarding strangers handling her kids and these fears came out faster than her expression of gratitude to a clear prevention of an accident,You were not in the wrong, You did the right thing, Your impatient sister also has her concerns and fears too concerning her medical procedure and these came out more, so I would try to understand them both and ask yourself if you had not seen this mother, and you did not have your sister with you at that time, and you happened to notice the kid with the coffee, would you have acted differently ?
@cynthiann (18602)
• Jamaica
3 Sep 12
I did not touch her son although if I had nit been there then somene could have taken him as he was not nervous of strangers. I would have always stayed with a child in this situation. He was alone in a coffee shop and could have either been taken or wondered off into danger.
1 person likes this