Are you openminded (a discussion about book genres) ?

@Porcospino (31366)
Denmark
December 30, 2012 5:26am CST
This discussion is about books and genres. How openminded are you when it comes books from a genre that you don't usually read? Are you willing to give them a chance or do you prefer to stick to the genre that you know that you will enjoy? Did a book from another genre ever surprise you in a positive way? Which book? I don't think that I am very openminded because most of the time I read realistic books or books based on true stories. I am very attracted to realistic books, but I am not sure why they interest me so much. I like to read true crime stories, but I never read fictive detective stories. I also love to read other kinds of realictic stories for instance stories about people who face some problems and find a way to solve those problems and learn something about themselves. I think that comes from my interest in people and psychology. I have read a few books from other genres like fantasy and science fiction and I didn't dislike those books, but they didn't attract me the same way.
3 people like this
19 responses
@carmelanirel (20942)
• United States
30 Dec 12
I think I am somewhat open-minded, but I do have a favorite genre. The only kind of book I don't like, (and I did try to read one over the summer) are secular romance, mostly because the character's do things I don't think is right. Ironically it was this genre that got me into reading so much, but now I try to read something that is more "cleaner" I guess you'd say, and I have read everything from fiction to non fiction, sci-fi or adventure, romance and suspense.
• United States
6 Jan 13
Secular or worldly; the characters have no faith even at the end and they things I would not allow my young son to read. This also means that every genre, Romance, Suspense, and yes, even Sci-Fi doesn't have to be ungodly. This is the same with my music, I like almost every genre; rock and roll, classical,hip hop, even heavy metal, but all have one thing in common, the words exalt the Creator.
1 person likes this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
5 Jan 13
I didn't know what a secular romance was. Your response inspired me to look it up online and I found some descriptions. I haven't read much of that genre myself. I like horror and suspense, but I also read a lot of books based on real stories. I have read a few books that belong to the adventure and science fiction genre, but I usually enjoy the books from my favourite genres more. When I pick out new books at the library I tend to stick to my favourite genres that I know that I will enjoy. I would like to be more open-minded and give other genres a chance instead of basing my opinion on a few books.
1 person likes this
@Cutie18f (9551)
• Philippines
31 Dec 12
When it comes to book choice, I am not open-minded as I have the tendency to stick to those that make me laugh.
2 people like this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
5 Jan 13
I am not very open-minded either when it comes to book choice, I tend to stick to my favourite books which are horror, suspense or books based on realistic events.
• Valdosta, Georgia
30 Dec 12
I am usually not very open minded about books from a genre that I don't like but I did read a book one time that I thought I would like from the description. Then as I was reading I thought okay this is nothing like what was described but I actually ended up loving it! I am not usually into Sci fi and all of that but that is what this book was... It definitely surprised me a lot. I cannot remember the name of it unfortunately but I'm glad I read it! Would I change my usual books over it though? NOPE!! Lol. I usually read mysteries, crime stories and books in those genre's. I have never strayed from it except that one book. I like to read the same kind of books that you read. And I also like the Lifetime movie kind of books, I LOVED the series "A Child Called It". If you have not read it yet I HIGHLY recommend it, from what you described you will love it like I did but definitely expect to cry!
2 people like this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
3 Jan 13
I agree with you about "A child called it". I read it a long time ago, but I still remember the book very clearly. It was really sad to read about the things that he went through, but I really liked the book. I have also read many other touching stories from real life. Another story that I can't forget was a story about a girl from Korea who saw her mother get killed by her own family members. The book is called "Ten thousand sorrows" and it is written by Elizabeth Kim. I haven't read much science fiction except from the books that I was forced to read at school (we had to read and analyze a couple of science fiction books in elementary school) but I have thought about giving that genre another chance. It is possible that I see the books in a different light now.
@Aja103654 (5646)
• Philippines
30 Dec 12
Well, sometimes I find ebooks that are under a genre I don't often read. There was this one time I tried to read this lesbian love novel. It was interesting and not all that bad. I often read romance and adventure. Sometimes I read detective stories and other forms of fiction. Realistic stories or non-fiction, I don't read them often. I can sometimes read them on magazines like readers digest and others. Some can be very interesting to read. I make a point to always look at new things in a positive way. Who knows I might start liking them? So I guess, I'm open minded.
2 people like this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
2 Jan 13
I think that it is great attitude If we aren't open to new things we might never discover that we actually enjoy those things. We are opposites because I often read realistic fiction and non-fiction and I don't read much adventure. Somehow I feel more attracted to the realistic books and I often end up choosing the same kinds of books. In the past I read many detective stories (fictive stories) but today I usually prefer to read true crime stories instead. There are quite a few of those books and some of them are written by policemen. They describe the criminals that they have met in their work. I find most of those books interesting and I like to read them.
• Philippines
30 Dec 12
Hi Porcospino! I also think I am not open minded. I always stick with love stories...fiction or non-fiction....though lately I am into non-fiction because of the reality strikes that I got to feel. I've been reading a lot of books lately and I hate it since instead of heading on to my priority which is studying...I just couldn't get away from books. And now, I am still reading one instead of studying! Argh! Anyways, I used to read self-help books before...so might as well think that I will change my preferences as time goes by. Happy Holidays!!!
2 people like this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
3 Jan 13
I used to have the same problem when I was a student. It was so tempting to read my own books instead of studying especially when I had just visited the library and had a lot of interesting books to read. Today I am no longer a student, but I don't have that much time to read because I am busy with work and other activities. Like you I have read self-help books in the past. I still read some self-help books every once in a while when I find an interesting self-help book, but most of the time I read other kinds of books for instance books that are based on real stories or non-fiction books about topics that I am interested in.
@olliekobra1 (1825)
30 Dec 12
variety is the spice of life if we dont ever experiance different things life would be so boring. I like to read different genres such as horror, sc-fi, personal autobiographies and crime books but i also try to read other books. I read the book 'the art of war' by Sun Tsu and i found it very complelling, he was very clever beyond his years.
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
3 Jan 13
I like the thing you wrote about variety. I also believe that variety makes life interesting. I love to try new things and visit new places, but when it comes to books I tend to stick to my favourite types of books most of the time. Like you I read horror and personal autobiographies. I also like to read books that are based on true stories and sometimes I read non-fiction books about psychology, religions, history, art, crime etc. I don't usually read fictive crime stories, but I like to read true crime stories from my country.
@Asylum (47893)
• Manchester, England
30 Dec 12
I do not feel that this is truly representative of how open minded we are, mainly because we will always tend to select a book based on our own genre preference. At the time when I was an avid book reader I tended to choose books from a selection of genres, which included science fiction, history and mythology. I would not consider that this qualified me as not being open minded, simply that I preferred those subjects. The fact that you did not enjoy the science fiction or fantasy is no doubt due to your personal taste, but the fact that you made the effort to try them really makes you open minded in my opinion.
2 people like this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
30 Dec 12
I hadn't thought about it like that (that I am openminded because I made the effort to try those books) but I can see what you mean. I did try to read other genres, but I felt that I judged those genres too quickly and that I might miss a great fantasy or science fiction book because I didn't give them a fair chance. That is was I meant when I said that I wasn't very openminded, but I like the way that you look at it, and it is true that I did try. I wouldn't define a openminded person as a person who reads many kinds of books, in my opinion it is not so much about the books that you read, it is about the unknown books that you are willing to give a chance.
1 person likes this
@ElicBxn (63235)
• United States
1 Jan 13
I think what we read are an extension of what we like. I like science fiction and fantasy and read them extensively. But I will also read other types of books. I like mysteries and books about horses, I've even read romances. Just because a book is fiction, doesn't mean that it doesn't deal with how people deal with life and problem solving. I also read a lot of history books, well, actually I listen to them mostly, but that doesn't mean I don't enjoy them. I find most of the books I "read" now a days are in audio format.
1 person likes this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
13 Jan 13
I used to listen to audio books, but I haven't done it for a while. Unfortunately the selection of audio books at my local library is quite limited, and it is much easier to find good books. I guess most of the users still prefer to borrow books instead of audio books. It sounds like you read many different types of books and I think that it is great. I tend to stick to the genres that I know that I enjoy (often realistic books or books based on true stories) and some non-fiction books. I have read a few fantasy novels and science fiction novels, but I get much more attracted to the realistic books.
1 person likes this
@artemeis (4194)
• China
31 Dec 12
I wouldn't and you shouldn't say that there's no open mindedness when we exercise our preferences on the genres or books to read. Even in genres, I am sure you have preferences for certain writers or authors where writing styles differ for our choosing. It could be my pleasure but it could be someones' trash. For me, I read everything I can lay my hands on fictions, non fictions, crimes, thrillers, war, travels, autobiographies, self improvements, parenting, medical, English, Chinese and so on. Also, I am a fan of several authors like Charles Dickens, Orson Wells, Stephen King, George Lucas, Dr. Miriam Stoppard, Danielle Steel, Barbara Taylor Bradford, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, Dale Carnegie, Judith McNaught, Shakespeare, Alexandre Dumas, Nicholas Sparks, Tom Clancy, Elaine Mazlish and Adele Faber. So you can see that I read a wide range but I would always be willing to check out the new ones on the shelves. I wouldn't say that I am not open minded but I think eclectic is a better term to describe me.
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
5 Jan 13
I would define an open minded person as a person who is willing to read books outside their favourite genre and willing to experiment and read books that they aren't sure that they will enjoy in order to try something new. It is true that we all have preferences, and there is nothing wrong with that, but I think that it is a positive thing to be willing to try unknown books and genres instead of saying: "I like this, so I stick to this and avoid other genres". I sometimes tend to think that way and I would like to become better at trying other genres, because I might actually enjoy the books from other genres if I am willing to give them a chance.
• United States
1 Jan 13
I've grown much more open about the genres I read in recent years. I used to read pretty much nothing but high fantasy. It wasn't that I didn't like other books, it was just "OH! I want to read that one! And that one!" and I would just never get around to anything else. The past year I've been reading lots of non-fiction, I surprised myself because before I would never read non-ficiton, even when I strayed from fantasy. Various subjects, mostly to better my own knowledge about things. I can't say I've enjoyed the non-fiction more than my average high fantasy novel, and high fantasy is still very much my favorite genre, but I've enjoyed knowing more about the subjects that I was reading about.
1 person likes this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
13 Jan 13
I would like to read other genres, but somehow I never really got around it, and when I visit the library I tend to pick up the books from my favourite genres instead of experimenting with other genres. I did read a few books from other genres, but it really didn't happen that often, because my favourite genres attract me too much. I think that it is nice to read non-fiction sometimes and it gives us the chance to learn more about different subjects. I like to read about other countries and cultures, psychology, history, art and many other topics. When I visit the library I usually borrow a mix of fiction and non-fiction, but I tend to read the novels first especially if they are written by my favourite authors.
@Shavkat (137212)
• Philippines
1 Jan 13
I can read all genre of books, but I don't like the love story. I just don't feel reading it. But I will not close my door for trying to read a very meaningful love story.
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
13 Jan 13
I think it is great that you read many different genres. I used to read love stories when I was younger, but I haven't read many of them as an adult. I usually stick to my favourite genres, but I would like to become better at reading other genres. I might discover a new kind of books that I like.
@Otanetix (508)
• United States
3 Jan 13
While I hate to admit it, I do stick with the genres I enjoy. Branching out to other genres is very difficult for me because I tend to have a certain perception about genres of books. Every so often, I have tried books from other genres after reading some reviews on Amazon, but I just can't get past the style of how certain genre of books are written. For instance, romance novels are books I just can't understand its entertainment value. I am not saying romance novels are bad, but they just do not suit my taste.
1 person likes this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
24 Feb 13
I do the same thing. I have tried to read other genres than my favourite genres, but somehow I never really learned to appreciate the other genres. I recently read one fantasy book that I kind of enjoyed, but that doesn't mean that I intend to read the rest of the books by the same author. Over and over I tend to return to my favourite genres (even when I had promised myself to be more open minded ) My favourite genres are realistic books, books based on true stories and psychological horror stories and I have read a lot of books from those genres.
• St. Peters, Missouri
30 Dec 12
I tend to stick to my preferred genres. Over the years I've tried others, but never really get any satisfaction or enjoyment from reading these books.
1 person likes this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
2 Jan 13
Which genres do you prefer? And which genres did you try to read? I usually prefer realistic books or books based on true stories. I like to read books where people describe their experiences and write about things that happened in their lives. I also like horror stories and ghost stories and I have read quite a few of them. I have read a few books that belong to fantasy and science fiction, and I found some of the stories okay, but I didn't get the same kind of enjoyment from those books compared the books from my favourite genres.
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
3 Jan 13
I agree with you about Stephen King. I was so disappointed when I read one of his recent books, and I think that his old books are much better. I have also read some Dean Koontz books and I liked some of them. Some weeks ago I bought a huge book full of horror stories, there are more than 1100 pages and a lot of different authors including some authors that I haven't heard about before. I have only read about half of the book so far and there are a lot of great stories. One of my favourite authors is a Norwegian author called Ingvar Ambjornsen who wrote 4 books about a character called Elling. I think that they are funny and very well-written. I also like Richard Kalich, but it is hard to find his books in my country and most of them haven't been translated to Danish. I like Guy Burt especially the first two books that he has written. I love book with a twist and books that are able to surprice me.
• Philippines
30 Dec 12
I guess in everything we have a bias even in selecting books. We're sort of the opposite. When it comes to books, I like fantasy and crime stories. I sort of don't like nonfiction. However, I am always willing to accept reading new books that do not fall under the genre I usually read, but of course I am not as excited to pick up said book over the books I like reading.
1 person likes this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
3 Jan 13
Yes, it sounds like we are opposites, because I have never really read much fantasy and I don't read crime stories. I feel the same way as you when I read a book that doesn't belong to the genres that I usually read. I don't feel the same kind of excitement when I try to read other genres and I don't have the same expections, but I have still read other genres every once in a while for instance when I have heard a lot about a book from a genre that I don't usually read.
@inedible (768)
• Singapore
5 Jan 13
Only when I'm really bored or don't have a choice of reading materials. I already have a good idea of what I like, so there's not much point in trying anything outside of that range, unless I really don't have anything better to go for. I've already given other genres a shot before, and was mostly disappointed. (By the way, I prefer fantasy, science fiction, and occasionally some crime novels.)
1 person likes this
@Pegasus72 (1898)
28 Jan 13
I am open minded but do prefer to stay to the kinds of writing I enjoy rather then branch out.
1 person likes this
@akhil112 (58)
• India
13 Jan 13
That dependes on the reader right ,am open towards any geners mostly i read novels. Which book is the best in realistic gener according to you?
1 person likes this
• India
15 Mar 13
yeah i am very much openminded. i was surprised when i read a book on student and it was on crime and not on student. it was of the Chetan Bhagat.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
13 Mar 13
You have a most interesting taste in books Porcospino. I do get moody when it comes to reading. Sometimes I want to read a particular thing and won't read anything else and sometimes I am satisfied with reading anything. I want to give an author at least a chance, so I would read a book of theirs that most interests me and if I like it, then I would read more. In fact, I am almost obsessive about it. I think I am scared of overlooking a book then find out that I want to read it but won't have time to anymore. But I also know the genres that are safe, or books that I would usually like, and genres of books that I find hard to get through. I'd read them but I won't enjoy or appreciate them as much.
1 person likes this