Is this discrimination?

United States
April 23, 2013 9:36pm CST
Where I work,we have openings for loaders on the contractors end of the parking lot. There are plenty of people that would like this job. It's 7:00-4:00 Monday-Friday. Our store manager will only put people that speak spanish for the position. He says it's because a lot of the contractors are Hispanic(i.e. illegals). I say this is discrimination. What do you think?
1 person likes this
7 responses
• Serbia
24 Apr 13
That is bu!!$h!t!!! This whole political correctnes cr@p! Why is it discrimination. It's his business. If he wants to hire only blacks, only whites, only hispanics, only babies, only aliens, only animals, IT IS HIS BUSINES. HE SHOULD BE ABLE TO DO WHATEVER AND HIRE WHOEVER HE WANTS! This whole political corectnes thing is just a tool to control people. I think that everyone is just too good damn sensitive, it's sensless. :p Seriously, the government should stay out of it. They just want to be able to lock people away and build more jails (another business) and they will find any means to do that. Your business. You should be able to hire anyone and anything you want in Your business. My business. I should be able to hire anyone and anything i want in my business. And that is without having to explain yourself to anyone. For example, if i have my own business tomorrow, meaning i own it and am the boss. And i decide to hire only 15 year old Arab girls (just to make it look weird). And somebody comes up to me asking me why and wanting answers. If i dont want to answer, i will not answer. It's my business and i do what i want! And if that person/s has a problem with me not answering. The door is right ----- There! :)
1 person likes this
@andy77e (5156)
• United States
24 Apr 13
Of course it is discrimination, and there is nothing wrong with discrimination. If you decide to date someone, you choose who to date based on their attractiveness, their personality, and so on. That's discrimination. Should everyone have the right to demand you date them, because you are discriminating? It's not your money. You have no right to even question what a company, business, or CEO does with their money. It's not yours. If you want someone to fix your driveway, or something, and I show up offering to do the work, if you refuse should I sue you for discrimination? No, I have no right to demand that you hire my services, anymore than a worker has the right to demand a company hire them. It's not our deal, we have no right to question it. We have the choice to work somewhere else, or shut up. If more white people want to get these jobs, they need to work harder and with fewer problems, than the alternative. The main reason Mexicans take jobs, is because Mexican's work. White fat Americans are lazy. I'm an American, I can say this, and I've seen it for years. I work right now at a company where half of my co-workers are the most lazy people on Earth. I have constantly wondered how the company is still open when so few do any real work.
@Taskr36 (13963)
• United States
24 Apr 13
I agree except on the "white fat Americans" part. I've worked with lazy people that were black, white, Hispanic, Arab, etc. who were lazy regardless of their weight. To be fair, I've worked with only one lazy Arab, but he was the single laziest sack of crap I've ever worked with. The union just made sure he couldn't be fired no matter what he did, or didn't do.
@andy77e (5156)
• United States
24 Apr 13
Well yes... Unions tend to have an amazing capacity to create the most lazy useless people on the planet, regardless of any other attribute. White fat Americas, was meant more as a generality. America is still primarily white. America is the single most fat country on the planet. As an over all generality, this is where my statement came from. I mean honestly, I had a white lady as a roommate, who laid her mile wide girth on the sofa, shoved chips and dip in her mouth for hours, while watching biggest loser on TV, and openly talking about how she "dreamed of being on the show". I could not possibly make this up. I can see dreaming of being on biggest loser, while riding an exercise bike, or even after doing a 3 mile walk... but to sit there shoving chocolate cake in my face, after not moving for 3 hours, watching biggest loser... Seriously, America is in crisis. The budget crisis is only a fraction of our societal break down.
@Taskr36 (13963)
• United States
24 Apr 13
I knew someone who was married to a girl like that. She wasn't white, but that's neither here nor there. A buddy of mine used to refer to her as a "couch barnacle." I'm betting that term fits a lot of people in America right now. Still, I totally get what this roommate of yours was thinking. I mean, can you imagine only having to exercise an hour a week and lose hundreds of pounds by the end of the season? That's the "reality" people like her see. The show only lasts an hour and they only watch it once a week so in their fantasy, that's them, struggling for 1 hour on a Wednesday night while eating fast food and laying around the rest of the week until it's time to weigh in and cheer that they lost 7 pounds that week.
@bobmnu (8157)
• United States
24 Apr 13
It seems to me he is just trying to serve the customers needs. He can make any requirements or skills for the job he can defend in court. Speaking Spanish i no different than requiring a person to have the ability to lift 50 pounds if you are going to be a dock worker. For him to list the ability to speak Swallie because his best friend can speak it and he wants him to get the job would be illegal because it has nothing to do with the job. From what you tell us the ability to speak Spanish would be a benefit for this position. If you really want this position then learn Spanish.
@mythociate (21437)
• Oklahoma City, Oklahoma
25 Apr 13
No, it's not "discrimination" ... not in the unlawful sense of the word. It's the same as 'only hiring tech-assistants with experience in HTML or C++'
• Canada
25 Apr 13
I would say it is discrimination but what can you do. The USA thrives on business and the power of the dollar so as a businessman he is doing whatever he can to make his wages and doesn't care what he has to do to get them.
@randleus (15)
• United States
24 Apr 13
To me, he is filling a need. It may seem discriminative(if that is a word) but he wants to better communicate with the contractors. On the other side, if he isn't open to hire people who just so happen to have Spanish as a second language under their belt, then it's discrimination all the way.
@RAJASB (109)
• India
24 Apr 13
It all depends on the job role and few jobs have specifications. If it's not the case, then discrimination is highly unacceptable. If you cannot love your fellow human being, whom can you love then? Such people should be sent for proper counselling and should be isolated.