How Many Religions Can One Practice at Once?

@bagarad (14283)
Paso Robles, California
September 16, 2015 11:02pm CST
I recently read the best seller The Life of Pi by Yann Martel. In this book, the main character, Piscine, aka Pi, searches for truth in religion. He studies with a Christian priest, a Muslim Imam, and a Hindu pandit. He joins each religion and practices it at the same time. When he is found out by his religious mentors, they insist he choose only one of them. He finds it impossible to choose, so says only that he loves God. Do you think it's possible to be a sincere believer in each of these three religions at once? Why or why not?
9 people like this
11 responses
@FourWalls (62731)
• United States
17 Sep 15
I think people can study the different religions as a means of seeing which one they want to accept and follow, but to simultaneously adhere to two or more different religions that teach contradictory things (e.g., polytheism versus monotheism, who is a prophet and who is not) isn't possible.
5 people like this
@bagarad (14283)
• Paso Robles, California
17 Sep 15
I would agree.
1 person likes this
@Rollo1 (16679)
• Boston, Massachusetts
17 Sep 15
I would say that if he studied all those religions and couldn't decide which one had the true God, then Pi never met God in all of his studies. And Pi would need to know who God is to believe in Him. I don't think you could practice all those religions, whose Gods are very different in nature.
4 people like this
@bagarad (14283)
• Paso Robles, California
28 Sep 15
I think you are right. The concepts of God are different in those three religions Pi investigated.
2 people like this
@Inlemay (17713)
• South Africa
28 Sep 15
i think you say it quite plainly there - nicely done
2 people like this
@pumpkinjam (8547)
• United Kingdom
17 Sep 15
I've read about many religions and I've taken parts of each which make sense to me. Perhaps you couldn't say a person could BE a Muslim and a Hindu and a Christian and whatever else all at once, simply because doing so would, in itself, be a contradiction of the teachings of one or more religion. You can, however, take parts of different religions and practice them in combination. I know, I'm an eclectic witch.
4 people like this
@bagarad (14283)
• Paso Robles, California
1 Dec 15
I can understand a person picking and choosing a little of each religion to practice, but in Pi's case (fictional) he became a member of each religion to the extent that his mentor in each believed he was a devout believer.
1 person likes this
@thesids (22180)
• Bhubaneswar, India
18 Sep 15
Having read some of the Holy Texts from all three, I have realized one thing for sure - every one of them preaches Love, Universal Brotherhood. I agree, there can be many more things and ways on how to get them accomplished. That said, I will still say, that yes, it is possible. One should use his/her brain to weed out the things that are contradictory (if any) and pick up the ones that are common to all. None of these texts have been written by God Himself. At the end what we get to read, listen, and follow are skewed interpretations that have been passed onto us since generations. This definitely gives me scope to be my own judge, use my own understanding, conscience.
3 people like this
@bagarad (14283)
• Paso Robles, California
1 Dec 15
I don't agree, but that's OK.
1 person likes this
@SIMPLYD (90722)
• Philippines
17 Sep 15
In my opinion , it would be difficult because each religion have their own beliefs , rituals and traditions .
3 people like this
@bagarad (14283)
• Paso Robles, California
1 Dec 15
Exactly. When one religion's teaching contracts that of another, they can't both be right. Maybe neither one is right or maybe only part of each one is right.
2 people like this
• Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
17 Sep 15
I call myself a Catholic Baptist because I was raised as a Catholic but enjoy Baptist services. Furthermore, Second Pilgrim Church is right in back of my house and St. Francis is 10 blocks away and the on street parking options are terrible. The issue with Second Pilgrim is that if I take time to pray after services people keep asking if I am alright. Catholic churches don't have any problems with private silent prayer and I always feel better when I light several candles. I respect all religions, but find the Pentecostals' exuberance a little scary.
3 people like this
@bagarad (14283)
• Paso Robles, California
1 Dec 15
One thing about Christianity is that you can usually find some church with a worship style that fits you.
1 person likes this
• Preston, England
2 Oct 15
All three have the same roots - hence their collective label as monotheistic religions, and some overlap though Islam rejects much of the New Testament, seeing Jesus as a human prophet - not as the son of God incarnate. Islamic halal food is essentially the same as Jewish kosher and Allah is a harsh angry God in keeping with the older Jewish Yahweh. It is harder to fit Christian doctrine in other than where Jesus pays lip service to the Old Testament. As an atheist, I do give equal belief to all three faiths, namely none.
@bagarad (14283)
• Paso Robles, California
1 Dec 15
As a Chrisitan I would not expect an atheist to see what I do. Yahweh was not always harsh in the Old Testament, and Jesus did more than pay lip service to it.
1 person likes this
@hereandthere (45651)
• Philippines
17 Sep 15
i heard about that movie. i didn't know there was a book. my parents watched tv programs of other religions and i would hear them discussing what they heard. some they agree with i think because some concepts are universal.
2 people like this
@bagarad (14283)
• Paso Robles, California
17 Sep 15
Most religions have similar ethics, but they often have different concepts of God's character and how one pleases him.
2 people like this
@sofssu (23662)
17 Sep 15
Great novel that.. Its kind of strange to you but Hindus have 300000 god and goddesses and other gods are just one more to count. I have many friends who follow all religions.
2 people like this
@bagarad (14283)
• Paso Robles, California
1 Dec 15
It still seems to me that one can only follow parts of the various religions. Each religion as beliefs that contradict the teachings of other religions. Judaism and Christianity are the closest and a Christian with Jewish background considers himself a "completed Jew."
1 person likes this
@seren3 (387)
• Los Angeles, California
17 Sep 15
I think it is possible. If you separate God out from all the divide and conquer issues, then you've just got -- God!
2 people like this
@bagarad (14283)
• Paso Robles, California
1 Dec 15
The question, though, it what is that God like? Each religion seems to have a different view of his character, except that the Jews and Christians pretty much agree on what God is like.
1 person likes this
@SWAP0768 (88)
• Lucknow, India
30 Nov 15
it a funny thing because in India, there are so many religion that they end up influencing one another for example, during Hindu festival Muslims help out a lot and during Christmas everyone goes to church. BTW, I'm from India and to truly know what I'm talking about, you have to visit this country
2 people like this
@bagarad (14283)
• Paso Robles, California
1 Dec 15
One thing I like about this site is hearing what people from other countries have to say about their countries. I learn things I would not learn any other way.
1 person likes this
• Lucknow, India
4 Dec 15
1 person likes this