Is hate speech an abuse of the 1st amendment?

Tweet

The photo is of Miriam Margolyes, a British actress whom many people will remember as Professor Sprout in the Harry Potter films. She recently made a short series of TV programmes about a road trip she made across the United States from north to south. She spoke to many people as she progressed, her aim being to try to work out what makes Americans tick. She is a woman of strong liberal views and she came across many people with whom she profoundly disagreed. However, the tone was always dignified and respectful on both sides. Except once. This was when an interview was arranged with a pastor in Arkansas who ran an organization called the Kingdom Identity Ministries. When he was told that Miriam was a Jewish lesbian he refused to meet her face to face, so Miriam sat in her car outside the building while her questions were relayed to the pastor via one of the film crew. It soon became clear that the pastor was an extreme white supremacist who was both racist and anti-Semitic. Miriam asked him what - given the choice - he would do with America's blacks and Jews. He said that he would deport all the blacks to Africa and the Jews would be sent to an island - he suggested Madagascar - where all the men would be castrated and the women given hysterectomies. At this point Miriam could stand it no longer and terminated the interview. She said that she was glad that she was not in the same room as the pastor because she did not know that she could have kept her temper and not thrown something heavy at the man. The thought that struck me was - how on earth can this man be allowed to say such things and peddle this desperate filth to his fellow Americans? The answer is obviously the clause in the Ist Amendment of the US Constitution that allows free speech. We allow free speech in the United Kingdom, but with limits. What we do not allow is hate speech, which can be defined as statements that seek to vilify other people on the grounds of their race, religion, gender, sexuality, etc, etc. This pastor would most definitely have fallen foul of our hate speech laws, and be sent to jail, but the US Constitution defends his right to be as vile and nasty as he likes. My question, therefore, is - is it not high time that the US Government looked long and hard at the 1st Amendment and amended it so that vile creatures such this man - and there are plenty of others - are stopped from their activities?