TV Review Doctor Who Rosa
@arthurchappell (44941)
Preston, England
October 22, 2018 6:46am CST
Spoiler alerts
A very daring TV episode in which the travellers witness the Civil rights Movement in 1955 and in particular the refusal by Rosa Parks, to vacate a bus seat in favour of white passengers in Montgomery, Alabama.
The Doctor and companions prevent a rogue and racist time traveler from preventing the event, and face no choice but to sit back not interfering as Rosa makes her brave challenge and gets arrested, knowing this will help destroy the hateful Apartheid of the period. Vinette Robinson is perfectly cast as Rosa. Martin Luther King is only given the briefest of scenes.
The Doctor having a young, proud black assistant and a Pakistani girl on her team too, makes the episode more poignant and powerful. The youngsters get a poweful scene together iscussing the kin of racism they have both endured in their own Our own time, now)
A lovely episode in every respect.
I was wondering how they might do it without just doing a history episode. Keeping the time travel disruption guy quite low key enabled them to show the actual events with all due gravitas and respect, with Team TARDIS clearly uncomfortable about just letting the event unfold as they had to, without giving in to any instinct for intervention.
The companions were well used here, and each played a strong role in keeping events on track.
I would have liked to have known more about the time-crook guy and I wouldn't be surprised if he returns from wherever he ended up at some point. This was very much Rosa's story and it deserved to be. Though it had alien elements it felt like a very authentic slice of history.
As I thought before even seeing this it was very brave story telling as getting this wrong might have been a critical problem but the episode works perfectly.
Arthur Chappell
4 people like this
4 responses
@LadyDuck (502657)
• Italy
22 Oct 18
It is interesting to show important events of the past pretending to be there using a time machine. Have you read the book 11/23/66 by Stephen King? It is the story about a time traveler who attempts to prevent the assassination of President John F. Kennedy. Very good book.
1 person likes this
@arthurchappell (44941)
• Preston, England
22 Oct 18
Not read that one @LadyDuck but I did read Gregory Benford's Timescape which deals with the same subject and that is a great novel
1 person likes this
@LadyDuck (502657)
• Italy
22 Oct 18
@arthurchappell I will check Timescape. Stephen King is a bit weird, the book is great, the ending is strange, but in a whole I liked the book.
1 person likes this
@arthurchappell (44941)
• Preston, England
22 Oct 18
@LadyDuck King can be a great writer though other books of his can be disappointing too.
1 person likes this

@arthurchappell (44941)
• Preston, England
22 Oct 18
@amadeo there is a film starring Angel Bassett playing Rosa
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia Jump to navigation Jump to search Mighty Times: The Legacy of Rosa ParksDirected by Robert HoustonProduced by Bill CouturiéDulanie M. EllisRobert HudsonWritten by Robert HoustonCinematography Geoffrey GeorgeEdited by N

@DWDavis (25797)
• United States
22 Oct 18
Was there any sense in the show that the Rosa Parks bus incident was staged for the press and publicity? In reality, it was done exactly for that reason. The whole thing was carefully planned and modeled after an incident some months earlier where a younger black woman was forcibly removed from a bus for the same reason. Only Claudette Colvin was not the person the Civil Rights Movement wanted as the face of the cause. She was a troubled teenager pregnant with a married man's child. Rosa Parks was a much more suitable icon for the boycott.
1 person likes this
@arthurchappell (44941)
• Preston, England
23 Oct 18
@DWDavis it is indicated that Rosa fully expected her arrest - it was done to highlight the cause
1 person likes this





