TV Review War Of The Worlds

Preston, England
November 18, 2019 8:02am CST
Good to see a nearly the right period adaptation of the story at last. Spoiler alerts. I was disappointed by the over-emphasised soap opera elements - good role reversal in taking much of the focus onto the wife, Amy, largely unseen and I think un-named just like the narrator after the seperation in the novel. The shift from Victorian to Edwardian era is a little jarring, given it is about a three year difference (the novel was written in 1898, Victoria died in 1901. Lots of foreshadowing, characters just being set up to die later, mostly the it'll never happen, we have it all under control' people. Lots of people including Amy were working on the Woking crater site in their Sunday best without getting the slightest bit of dirt on them until the first Martian let loose. I do like the Martian look, as much three legged spider organic as machine, and the heat haze being invisible until it ignited people rather than giving out visible laser blast death ray flashes was really scary. Even while looking for the Maid (who will be dead right after they find her) George pauses the desperate panic to tell Amy that he has asked about divorce papers. Not exactly the right time or place George). Also impressed by his casual Dr Doolittle ability to stop a spooked horse in mid gallop panic just by stepping in front of it and saying whoa! George should have been on the floor with hoofprint indents at that point as the horse kept going to the next county. Lots of people getting knocked over and assumed dead before coming back again. The odd flashes forward to Amy wandering over the Martianized dust-bowl landscape with some Dickensian urchin in tow over the red weed variation wasteland was eiree but also confusing. Hopw far ahead of events is this leaping already? There was too jmuch emphasise on whether the two planet crossed lovers will reunite, giving it a Titanic tone, with everyone else expendible except the romantic self-proclaimed social pariahs. I found the struggle to get divorce papers annoyiing. Much more impressive was Amy seeing the Robert Carlysle photos date stamped to show the month dominated by Martian missile launches. Youtube - Song from the Jeff Wayne Musical Version of The War Of The Worlds Arthur Chappell
Skip navigation Sign in Search Loading... Close Watch QueueQueueWatch QueueQueue The next video is startingstop Loading... Watch Queue Queue __count__/__total__ Loading... Did you know... Loading... There’s a new YouTube Music web player for desktop! Work
7 people like this
7 responses
@LadyDuck (458894)
• Switzerland
18 Nov 19
I have watched "The War of the Worlds" and it was the one made in 1953, I think there is a recent remake that I have not seen.
2 people like this
• Preston, England
18 Nov 19
@LadyDuck There are several versions with at least one more in production even now - the 1953 George Pal movie is one of the best after the book itself
2 people like this
@LadyDuck (458894)
• Switzerland
18 Nov 19
@arthurchappell Correct, it was after the book and I liked that one.
1 person likes this
• Mojave, California
18 Nov 19
That is true I forgot about this version not sure as why. Spoiled brat maybe.
2 people like this
@LindaOHio (157012)
• United States
19 Nov 19
I've seen the original and the Tom Cruise remake. Which one was this and where was it playing?
1 person likes this
• Preston, England
20 Nov 19
@LindaOHio this is a new BBC TV version, airing over three weeks - two episodes still to go
1 person likes this
• Preston, England
20 Nov 19
@LindaOHio it will be on the i-player
1 person likes this
@LindaOHio (157012)
• United States
20 Nov 19
@arthurchappell We get the BBC. I should look for it. Thanks.
1 person likes this
@egdcltd (12060)
19 Nov 19
I'm not going to read this as I have it saved for later viewing!
1 person likes this
• Preston, England
20 Nov 19
@egdcltd that is a good plan - hope you enjoy it
1 person likes this
@crossbones27 (48444)
• Mojave, California
18 Nov 19
Not getting good reviews thanks for making it more clear and to be fair story just never interested me. I guess Tom Criew's can spice up anything, first one, but I would not have watched if someone told me description and no famous actor involved. War of worlds is nor bad just what you expect though. I like the unexpected. Hollywood needs to get that back or anyone at this point in time.
1 person likes this
• Preston, England
18 Nov 19
@crossbones27 the Tom Cruise version was let down by a lousy ending
1 person likes this
• Mojave, California
18 Nov 19
@arthurchappell Straight truth there.
1 person likes this
• Preston, England
18 Nov 19
@crossbones27 somehow the whole family and the city of Boston survive unscathed
• United States
18 Nov 19
Funny I was just talking about this last night Arthur War of the Worlds. Right on.
1 person likes this
• Preston, England
19 Nov 19
@TiarasOceanView a great story for discussion and dramatization
1 person likes this
@jprtist (656)
• Pueblo, Colorado
22 Nov 19
Darn, I wish you hadn't posted this. I've been working hard trying to resist buying youtube tv. I have a DVD, of a period piece of the War of the Worlds, produced in Great Britain, it's long, and pretty good except for some poor special effects. It's my understanding when Steven Spielberg stated his War of the World Movie starring Tom Cruise, he was intending to make a period piece out of it. Then he heard the British version was already in production, so he took some of the originall elements from the book, the three legged war machines etc. and put them in modern times. I didn't really care for the Spielberg version, my favorite is still George Pals version from 1951. I'm going to have to check out this newest version.
1 person likes this
• Preston, England
29 Nov 19
@jprtist The Orson Welles radio play and the Jeff Wayne musical are both great too
1 person likes this
@Janet357 (75656)
18 Nov 19
I think I watched this war of the worlds. i like it a bit. am not really into alien flicks.
1 person likes this
• Preston, England
18 Nov 19
@Janet357 This is a new version - the first of only three episodes aired yesterday for the first time