Donald Trump doesn't want Apple to "Make in India"
@abhi_bangal (5740)
Ahmednagar, India
May 17, 2025 1:01pm CST
Donald Trump is a mysterious character. I fail to understand if he is really a friend of India. Yes I can understand that he will first put the US at the top of his interests.
But he isn't likely happy that Tim Cook is producing the iPhones in India. He feels that if he (Cook) cares for India he can build in India. "You can build in India if you want, to take care of India."
But Mr. Tim Cook is determined to continue his earlier plans regarding producing the iPhones in India. Apple gets cheaper manpower in India.
What do you think? Who is correct?
6 people like this
6 responses
@LindaOHio (188873)
• United States
18 May
It will be cheaper to make them in India.
2 people like this
@abhi_bangal (5740)
• Ahmednagar, India
18 May
Exactly. It's already cheaper to manufacture iPhones in India and that is why Tim Cook may persist with the original policy. It remains to be seen if he buckles down under the pressure of Donald Trump.
3 people like this
@porwest (99865)
• United States
18 May
Trump seeks fairness and is, as you said, of COURSE looking out for American interests. Look, the bottom line is this. America got screwed in the globalism deal, and as a result retail and fast food jobs, which are lower paying, dominate the jobs. We HAVE to find a way to turn this around at least somewhat. It's not about being friends. It's about making sure our friends aren't taking advantage of us.
1 person likes this
@abhi_bangal (5740)
• Ahmednagar, India
20 May
Do friends take advantage of each other? Or does the friendship help each other - be it between countries or individuals. The same logic applies, I feel. And if it's the question of taking "advantage" then I think, that shouldn't be called "friendship".
For outsiders like me, or at least talking about me, I have always felt that the US is a fairyland. There is everything that is positive, good and that is one place where nothing can go wrong. But as I grew up and started reading more and more about the US and the current scenario it looks like it is just not this same picture that I had visualised.
If I am not wrong, unemployment is a growing concern for the US Administration. There may be fast food jobs, etc but they are low paying as you say.
What do you think about the turnaround for a developed country like US?
@snowy22315 (189666)
• United States
17 May
I am sure it will cost less to make them there since China has the tariffs.
1 person likes this
@abhi_bangal (5740)
• Ahmednagar, India
18 May
Well yes China does have tariffs. But those are for exports for as I know. Please enlighted me if I am wrong. But for iPhones I don't think they might increase the tariff because lately I haven't heard that iPhones are also included in the increased tariff from the US to China.
@ptrikha_2 (47889)
• India
18 May
Companies would do what they want to do. Yes, the volume of Production in India could be diluted but because of the currency exchange rates, it would still be more cost effective for these companies in India.
Trump should get rid of those sudden, knee jerk reactions not only in terms of Economics but Politically as well.
1 person likes this
@abhi_bangal (5740)
• Ahmednagar, India
20 May
Talking about your second paragraph, if that had been so easy, we all would have lesser headache today. Let alone us, there are citizens in the US who also don't want him donning that post. But he being a businessman has more to contribute.
Coming to your first paragraph yes there policies of companies to get done more out of less. India being a huge country with such a huge amount of manpower can easily be the target of companies to get there products manufactured here.
The exchange rates may fluctuate to an extent. But generally speaking the cheap rate that mega companies like Apple get, make them more prone to manufacturing products in India.
@LeaPea2417 (37860)
• Toccoa, Georgia
17 May
Tim Cook because he is going to do business where he is more profitable.
1 person likes this
@abhi_bangal (5740)
• Ahmednagar, India
18 May
I also feel that Tim Cook. And I am inclined towards saying Tim Cook as well. Definitely as the head of a company be it Apple or any company for that matter, the CEO or any other responsible high postholder, (or even employees), will obviously think that his company should be profitable. And he will do business accordingly.
But only other hand, I think Donald Trump isn't wrong either. He wants employment for his citizens and his point of view may not be wrong. He has been a businessman after all. I am just putting up both the sides.
1 person likes this
