I was invited as a Jury Member to adjudge Best Startup idea

@Rimps85 (3420)
India
September 13, 2026 11:03am CST
Yesterday, I was invited as a jury member to adjudge top 3 innovative ideas/concepts/prototypes in the field of Sports Management that can go to pre-incubation with a national level incubator. The winning team would get mentorship, infrastructure support and government funds, in their journey to become a successful startup. I was amazed to see such fabulous ideas from the college kids, and had to evaluate them along with other jury members. Even though, the concepts were unique, the basic fallacy in them was that it never got ratified with the target audience & hence, I told the students - although ideas generate from personal problems/struggles, it might not have commercial value. What is your problem, might not be others. I had to take some harsh decision in denying few teams to go to the next level, but then rejection is a way of learning. I am sure, they will work on the feedback given and come back strong in the next season.
4 people like this
4 responses
@DaddyEvil (178312)
• United States
8h
I bet that was difficult. In my opinion, though, you could have told them niche markets also exist so their ideas might not work for that class but to keep them in mind for the future. Some people get quite wealthy working in niche markets.
1 person likes this
@Rimps85 (3420)
• India
7h
execution is the key & finding the commercial demand of what you create will shine
1 person likes this
@DaddyEvil (178312)
• United States
7h
@Rimps85 Very true. I hope they all do well.
1 person likes this
@AmbiePam (126970)
• United States
7h
I’m sure the feedback was invaluable, even if they don’t see it right away.
1 person likes this
@Rimps85 (3420)
• India
7h
yes, am sure some groups will hate me for it...
1 person likes this
@nawala123 (23085)
• Indonesia
1h
Younger people always have amazing ideas on something to solve problems
@Wrexxo (7264)
7h
That must've been tough having to pick just a few when everyone worked so hard. Your point about validating with the target audience is so true though, a lot of people skip that step. Sounds like the students are lucky to get that kind of honest feedback this early.
1 person likes this
@Rimps85 (3420)
• India
7h
yes, it was a tough job
1 person likes this