The Big Apple Top Ten: Cold Hands From New York (#10)

Video screen grab
@FourWalls (87853)
United States
September 21, 2026 8:48pm CST
Good evening! I’m back from a wonderful time. Fed, bathed, and folded the clothes that I forgot about Sunday morning, and I’m ready to get into the top ten songs mentioning the nation’s biggest city: Falls of Rough, Kentucky! Here we go with the Big Apple top ten. #10: Cold Hands From New York - Gordon Lightfoot Surprised? Anyone at all?? Didn’t think so. Yep, if Gordon Lightfoot can make the list, he’s gonna make the list. Now you understand why Don Henley was relegated to the alphabetical list. This is early (1960s) Gordon Lightfoot. That’s when I first discovered him, although not from his own recordings. It was mostly country singers like Waylon Jennings, Bill Anderson, and George Hamilton IV covering his songs. I didn’t actually hear Gordon himself until “If You Could Read My Mind.” And, let’s face it, that’s a fabulous place to start! This is a song about the stereotype of New Yorkers who are distant and uncaring. I didn’t find that at all in my day there. I was initially surprised when a man at the diner counter talked to me at breakfast, but I quickly discovered that we’re all the same, small town or big city. Go to a small town and you might find no one willing to offer you help, too. They had a greatest hits album for Lightfoot called Gord’s Gold, but he had so much gold in his discography that it’d be impossible for me to narrow it down to a dozen. Cold Hands From New York Written by Gordon Lightfoot Recorded by Gordon Lightfoot From Back Here on Earth, 1968 NYC LYRICS: title There were preachers of the Word and poets who were never heard:
Your browser isn’t supported anymore. Update it to get the best YouTube experience and our latest features. Learn moreRemind me later
7 people like this
8 responses
10h
One of his relatives stays in our town Looks just like him
2 people like this
@FourWalls (87853)
• United States
10h
That’s a cool thing!
2 people like this
10h
@FourWalls How do you mean?
2 people like this
@FourWalls (87853)
• United States
10h
@Ineeddentures — I don’t know if we have any celebrity relatives in town, so it’s cool that you not only have one, but he resembles Gordon! (Sorry, the new AI put “cold” instead of “cool,” I changed it.)
2 people like this
@teamfreak16 (46834)
• Denver, Colorado
9h
Everyone likes Gordon! Even my buddy, who had a darkwave band years ago, was wanting to cover him.
2 people like this
@FourWalls (87853)
• United States
9h
Do “Edmund Fitzgerald” in a minor key and you’ve got a goth song.
2 people like this
@teamfreak16 (46834)
• Denver, Colorado
9h
@FourWalls - I don't think it was that one, though. His producer suggested it. I forget which song.
1 person likes this
@AmbiePam (127677)
• United States
9h
I have a special place in my heart for him because I used to watch a sports show that always opened with a Gordon Lightfoot song.
1 person likes this
@jstory07 (149769)
• Roseburg, Oregon
10h
What a great song and great singer.
1 person likes this
@FourWalls (87853)
• United States
10h
Glad you enjoyed it!
1 person likes this
@MarieCoyle (63291)
8h
I remember hearing this. I just listened to it twice to see if I missed anything. He found New York cold and unfriendly, and was looking for more than that. As we know, any size town or city can be unfriendly. I know of some of all sizes that don't seem to radiate any positivity to anyone not born and raised there. In the song he appears to be looking for a dream in a way, but he didn't find it there.
@Wrexxo (7921)
6h
Gordon Lightfoot deserves way more credit than he gets, glad you started the list with him. Funny how those stereotypes about big cities never really hold up once you actually go there. Cant wait to see who else makes the top ten.
• Philippines
8h
If the music makes me feel good and its not irritating in my ears, it means only one thing, the lyrics is good. I what the song is talking about its still happening and it getting worst. God bless you with your retreat.
@Deepizzaguy (125515)
• Lake Charles, Louisiana
9h
Wonderful song performed by Gordon LIghtfoot.