Should people only adopt children of the same race?

United States
December 4, 2006 11:37pm CST
My husband and I are planning on adopting two boys from Haiti. We are white and they are black. Do you think that whites can raise black children as well as black parents could? Do you think that since we are white we should only adopt white children? It is quite common in the United States for parents to adopt children internationally, especially from China, Russia and Guatemala. What do you think?
4 people like this
54 responses
@brokentia (10389)
• United States
5 Dec 06
Love knows no color. Outside we may have differences...but we all the need the same. Love, acceptance, guidance, and nuturing are the things a child needs to be happy. It does not matter the race, only what is in the heart. Congrats on adopting some children that need a home. I am sure you home will be filled with love. Hey, who knows...you might even have 7 kids one day and then I can tease you. Won'y this make 5? Or would that be 11? LOL
2 people like this
@divir_vij (1591)
• India
5 Dec 06
Very well said.
• United States
5 Dec 06
LOL! This will make "ONLY" five! But we hope that once the boys get adjusted that we will be able to adopt a girl from Guatemala. The biggest obstacle right now is time (and perhaps money). We do have a joke about having 7 by 2011! By then you'll have reached double digits so there's really no point in trying to keep up with you!
• Australia
5 Dec 06
I must confess I don't know much about Haiti and the conditions there, but evidently the situation there must be pretty grim for the authorities to allow adoption of their children. I am sure you have investigated the pros and cons and how these children would fit in with your community. Colour should make no difference, but unfortunatly in many areas it does. If these children are underprivileged, and you can offer them the security of a loving home, you are doing more than most of us and I commend you. God bless you.
• United States
5 Dec 06
I must say that you hit it on the head that the situation in Haiti is pretty grim. Haiti is the third hungriest nation in the world and the poorest in the Western Hemisphere. 70% of the population lives in utter poverty. 1 out of 5 children will not survive to adulthood and of those who do survive to adulthood they're life expectancy is in their early 50's. Haiti is about the size of Maryland and has well over 200,000 orphanes. And perhaps one of the most unfortunate things that I have heard is that many Americans who choose to adopt internationally will not adopt from Haiti because the children are so dark skinned. :(
• Australia
6 Dec 06
Praying for you - Flowers and cross, praying for you
Thanks for the info. I'll add the problems of Haiti to my prayer list. If you go ahead with the adoption I'm sure God will bless you and use you to bless them and others.
1 person likes this
• United States
5 Dec 06
Good parents are good parents no matter what race. To that end, yes, whites can raise black children as well as black parents. So many children need good homes, and it saddens me we are even having a discussion which raises questions such as those posed. I would add, though, it may be helpful to speak the language of the children.
2 people like this
@mansha (6298)
• India
5 Dec 06
it is sad that Racism is out there despite the huge changes in our world. there are some serious issues to consider before you go ahead and adopt one. like when you adopt a child interracially you are also adopting their culture. Can you help provide the child with a sense of pride in their culture and heritage? Each race has its own susceptibility to different medical problems-are you ready and educated enough to deal with these issues.what about education of the child- Are the schools diverse? It is important for children to see people around them who are similar to themselves. Do you have friends of different races? Is there racial diversity in your church?Are you prepared to handle questions from people, sometimes total strangers, about your child's heritage or parentage? What about the opinions of your extended family?can you deal with immediate family members using racial slurs? if yu can answer all these qwuestions and are aware of them and ready to seek help you should gho ahead ans adopt.Otherwise first educate yourself and then decide.
1 person likes this
• United States
5 Dec 06
I think it is very wise to point out that when adopting a child internationally that there are many considerations that one must first take. Just as the new mom reads every book available about her pregnancy so should adoptive parents educate themselves. Here is a taste of what we have done to prepare ourselves thus far. Without getting into into Haitian law too deeply I will say that it will be February 2008 before we even start our paperwork and most likely 2009 before our sons come home. We will spend our time learning as much as we can to learn about Haiti and the people of Haiti. The national languages of Haiti are French and Creole. We have decided to buy software that will teach us Creole. We will also teach our other children Creole. I have researched online many native recipes and will practice preparing these meals and any history that might be behind them. We have also researched the history of Haiti and discussed many aspects of their history with our family and friends. We really desire for everyone within our family to know as much as possible about our sons' history as well. I have not done much research on the medical problems of the culture, but when we receive a referal we will have a list of any medical problems that our sons might have. We live in NE Iowa and honestly there is not a lot of diveristy. It is pretty white around here! That is one of the reasons why we have decided to adopt brothers. We want them to have the support of one another ... another face that resembles theirs ... another person who knows what they have been through. As far as our extended family goes - we couldn't have had a greater response. See Medooley's comment! Also my husband's sister has adopted a girl from India and his brother is also planning on adopting from Haiti. We also would like to adopt a girl from Guatemala in years to come. We joke that Christmas will look like a meeting of the U.N.! Thanks for your post!
• United States
5 Dec 06
I think it is very wise to point out that when adopting a child internationally that there are many considerations that one must first take. Just as the new mom reads every book available about her pregnancy so should adoptive parents educate themselves. Here is a taste of what we have done to prepare ourselves thus far. Without getting into into Haitian law too deeply I will say that it will be February 2008 before we even start our paperwork and most likely 2009 before our sons come home. We will spend our time learning as much as we can to learn about Haiti and the people of Haiti. The national languages of Haiti are French and Creole. We have decided to buy software that will teach us Creole. We will also teach our other children Creole. I have researched online many native recipes and will practice preparing these meals and any history that might be behind them. We have also researched the history of Haiti and discussed many aspects of their history with our family and friends. We really desire for everyone within our family to know as much as possible about our sons' history as well. I have not done much research on the medical problems of the culture, but when we receive a referal we will have a list of any medical problems that our sons might have. We live in NE Iowa and honestly there is not a lot of diveristy. It is pretty white around here! That is one of the reasons why we have decided to adopt brothers. We want them to have the support of one another ... another face that resembles theirs ... another person who knows what they have been through. As far as our extended family goes - we couldn't have had a greater response. See Medooley's comment! Also my husband's sister has adopted a girl from India and his brother is also planning on adopting from Haiti. We also would like to adopt a girl from Guatemala in years to come. We joke that Christmas will look like a meeting of the U.N.! Thanks for your post!
• United States
13 Dec 06
I really think that it is admirable that you have decided to open your hearts and homes to these brothers. Congratulations to you! I also admire you so much for taking the time do so much research in order to understand their culture and heritage. The only thing that really bothered me about your statement was the fact that it's so UNdiversified in the area where you live. Even though they may have each other, it is really important for them to see similar faces around them. With it being so "white" there, you may need to educate yourself on the problems that black children, especially black males have in this country. For instance, the other day I with my nephew in the store, and the store owner (though there were other white children in the store at the time) chose to follow him around the entire time we were there. Or the time that my brother was walking down the street in an all white neighborhood, and was surrounded by several police (two of which had their weapons drawn), despite the fact that he was never charged with any crime after the incident. And I could go on and on about a lot of the injustices inflicted on black males in this country.
@honeybfly83 (1021)
• United States
5 Dec 06
My parents have adopted a little girl from China and are in the middle of adopting their second one. I think we should adopt from wherever we want to adopt. My little sister is much better off with my parents than she was in the orphanage where she was at.
2 people like this
@medooley (1873)
• United States
5 Dec 06
Of course you should be allowed to adopt any child that you want. If you are willing to be loving parent to a child the race of the child and the parents should have no relavance on anything. The love is what is important. And I am sure that you and your family will be able to provide that love. Shoot you new sons might even have a crazy uncle that will love them too.
1 person likes this
• United States
5 Dec 06
Thanks so much medooley. You'll never know how much you mean to me! Enough with the sap... you're right you are crazy.
@Lindalinda (4111)
• Canada
5 Dec 06
I admire you for your courage and generosity to adopt the boys from Haiti. You will have a more difficult row to howe because of the different race, especially when the children reach teen age years. I think however these extra obstacles can be overcome. The most import thing for these children will be loving parents. Best of luck to you.
1 person likes this
@alchemistrx (2547)
• Philippines
5 Dec 06
It's not the color of the skin that measures how well can you parent a child.it's up to how responsible you are to upbring a child who is not your own. It doesn't determine it in the color of the skin.
1 person likes this
• United States
11 Jan 07
Please do not get offended or hurt. I do love everyone, and am not prejudice. I think what you and your husband want to do is a blessing for any child, and for yourself. I admire you. But you asked opinions. I feel that each race should raise their own. There are things that while people cannot relate too a black about. It goes into the deep core of each person.
• United States
12 Jan 07
First of all, I'm not offended or hurt because I did ask for opinions. "There are things that while people cannot relate too a black about." Such as what? Would it be better for a white couple to leave a black child in an orphange then to try to deal with the things that we have trouble "relating" to?
@funfreak2k2 (1734)
• India
5 Dec 06
congratulations ! u made the right decision! its gr8 to see that u r practicing haitian recipes, their culture and their language. definitely u will be good parents. race is not an obstacle for adoption. the only thing is that u shouldn't change ur mind if any body points that out and u should be able to answer him in brevity and in a convincing manner. be prepared for that. most important thing is : study their culture, and learn to bridge their culture and urs so that the kids cud feel at home. Else, they cant adapt themselves to the new culture and may feel secluded. tell them that u love them very much and appreciate and at times do follow their culture. congratulations again. i am with ur decision.
1 person likes this
• United States
6 Dec 06
yes,i believe white parents can raise black children as good as black parents.skin color does not matter at all its how you care for the kids that matter.it is alot easier to adopt internationally.so many people think that skin color matters when your raising kids but it does not its doesnt to a child so why should it other people.
@Ravenladyj (22904)
• United States
5 Dec 06
good for you!! I think its fabulous and of coure race has no factor or place IMO but I do hope that you will always teach them about their culture/homeland/etc since it is a part of who they are....I was adopted by white and they denied me that and to this day my mother only acknowledges my black heritage if it fits into an insult she's throwing my way.....All the best to you
1 person likes this
@Desdemona (1301)
• Canada
5 Dec 06
Skin colour has no bearing! If a dog can raise a pig, than any human can raise a child. Take that with a grain of salt. Glad your adopting. Best of luck!
1 person likes this
@lilmissy (481)
• United States
5 Dec 06
i think that is wonderful and no you should not worry but you should not try and make them oreo's either . be sure to learn as much about haitian heritge as possiable and get them color appropriate dolls and so forth also be ready for the day when the ask "why are we a different color ?" but thier biggest heartache will be when they say "why are we treated differently than our (white) brother(sister)s ?"not by you of course but there will always be color issues you will have to deal with and people asking if you are babysitting and so on , i m have japanese and that caused enough problems in my school in japan to be the only somewhat blond girl and why was i treated so badly even told to color my hair black and make myself seem like the others to which my mother exploded in rage on the teacher . just realize as a mother it will involve a whole new world of issues for you to deal with but it is very good thing (adoption).
1 person likes this
• United States
9 Dec 06
I say yes, go for it. But honestly, my feelings on adoption are just that first we should make homes for all the children in our own country that need homes, and THEN go elsewhere and give those children homes. But, this was not the issue you were asking about. To answer your question, regardless of color or race, the children need love, and you do not have to be of the same color or race to love that child! Go for it!
• United States
9 Dec 06
I believe that a child is a child, no matter what country they were born in. All children need homes and parents and a chance to grow up in a healthy environment.
• United States
5 Dec 06
I don't think it matters if you have love in your heart to give to someone else. You might find it difficult to educate them on their native culture, but you can help them research it and learn something for yourself. I don't think it matters what color you are or what country you were born in as long as you love the child or children.
• United States
5 Dec 06
I hope to spend the rest of my life learning about their culture and doing whatever it takes to make them feel as though their roots are important. Just as a tree cannot grow and be healthy apart from its roots I believe that a child needs to understand his/her roots and be made to feel that all parts of their life is important.
@Kaorin (756)
• Australia
7 Dec 06
I know many people who come into my work that are 'white' and raise 'black' children. Skin colour is an attribute, skin pigmentation that makes us all wonderfully unique. I can't understand how raising a white or black child could be any different. They're both children, and they both need to be raised by loving, committed and adoring parents who love and support them in every step of their life. There are no 'special needs' for skin colour. Congratulations on your choice to adopt. I hope that the skin colour of these children will NOT deter you from adopting and giving them a loving and stable home.
• United States
7 Dec 06
There's nothing that could deter us from adopting. Actually one of the reasons why we are adopting them is because they're black ... We've been told that many Americans (I assume the agency meant White Americans) won't adopt from Haiti because of how dark skinned these children are. I hate racism in any form and this is perhaps one of the worst kinds. It's as if some people think that because they're not just a "little" black but since they're "really" black we couldn't adopt them so we'll leave them in an orphange until someone who could "handle" that comes along. Though I agree that there is no "special needs" for skin color I must say that there are considerations that must be taken before one adopts transracially. Are you bringing children into a community where they will be discriminated against or put in a potentially harmful situation? Are there family members who will be opposed to children of another race ... etc. We have considered these things and have decided that we can give a black child a wonderful future in our home, family and community.
@gotcho0O (1257)
• United States
5 Dec 06
Just be like Angelina Jolie ^_^.
• United States
12 Jan 07
I don't want to be Angelina Jolie ... but that's a whole different discussion!
• Ireland
9 Dec 06
If I was to adopt I would not mind what creed or colour the child was. Maybe years ago, it would have mattered but I think in to-days society civilised society people respect and accept each other no matter what nationality you are. Good luck with your adoption.
@dmanuel (411)
1 Jan 07
color should never be an issue. color is not a basis for superiority of personality. we are all the same. continue with the adoption. good luck to both of you!