Mother-in-Laws

@gdsdb4 (173)
Canada
December 17, 2006 9:14pm CST
I need help. I have to send a gift to my mother-in-law for Christmas but I really don't want to. My husband doesn't want me to but I feel we should send something even though we haven't spoken for months. She doesn't call our children on their birthdays or doesn't really want anything to do with us unless it benefits her. When she was ill in the summer she couldn't stop calling me because everyone else in the family was long distance. She requested all sorts of things to be brought to the hospital for her and I did it. As soon as she went home, she has called me once! and that was 2 days after she was released. Well what do you think? Should I send her something or not? If I do, what do you suggest that I send...
5 people like this
84 responses
@ozangel82 (753)
• Australia
18 Dec 06
lol, i would get her a calendar and write on all the birthdates 'must call ___ for birthday' maybe she would get the hint. It is very sad that she only rings when she wants something, and perhaps your hubby should be the one to say something to her as it is his mother after all.
@reinydawn (11643)
• United States
18 Dec 06
Actually, that's a great idea!!! You can make calandars pretty easily, I think... Make each month a different picture from your family "albumn". The months that have a birthday, make the picture of that persons past birthday. It might be a little late for something like this though... I know it's time consuming. Good Luck!
• United States
18 Dec 06
HAHA that's hilarious.. I would totally do that if it was my MIL..
@gdsdb4 (173)
• Canada
19 Dec 06
What a great idea! Too bad she would probably put the calendar in a drawer and say she lost it...lol My hubby has talked to her before but she thinks she is the ONLY one that's right. He's given up talking to her. Merry Christmas
• United States
18 Dec 06
It doesn't matter if you currently are not getting along. It does not appear as if this is a love/hate relationship. I say to maintain this woman in your children's lives, you have to be the bigger person and extend the olive branch. Christmas is on Monday this year and most people will have off that weekend before. Give up a few hours and go visit her. It will mean alot to her and take a nice flower arrangement or potted plant and maybe some homemade cookies. It will give her something to admire when you leave and will bring a smile to her lips each time she waters it. Everyone is so quick to give gift cards, they are over done and their is no personal thought put into the gift. What about lottery scratch off tickets, inexpensive and if she wins, she will be thrilled.
@gdsdb4 (173)
• Canada
19 Dec 06
Great ideas but this woman is very materialistic and is not satisfied unless you spend a small fortune on her. My children are grown now and they don't even wish to see her. (She has never really been close to them.) Thanks for the advice though. Merry Christmas
• United States
18 Dec 06
I totally agree. I have trouble getting along with my mother (let alone my mother-in-law), but I want to know that I've put in the best effort into our relationship before she's not here any more.
@cheongyc (5072)
• Malaysia
18 Dec 06
Are you fighting with her? But seems like you were treating her well when she was hospitalized. I don't think hatred and loath should exist within a family. Don't prolong it and you should think positively when handling this kind of conflict. Mayb she has some kind of prejudice on you, but the fact, she is your husband mother. Sometimes, the elder might have been stubborn, but we as younger generation should be tolerate & be thankful to them. (Imagine, without her, you won't meet your hubby). Imagine also when you are getting old, and your son-in-law or daugther-in-law is doing nasty thing or thing you do not favour to you. (it could be right thing to do, but just that you might not like it). So be kind to the elders, you won't have much time with them. Value and appreciate their contributions, and look at things positively. If you think an appropriate gift to her will make her happy, then you should do it. If you think it will make her angry then, ask your hubby to send it.
@gdsdb4 (173)
• Canada
19 Dec 06
No I'm not fighting with her. She just wants attention when she is not getting it from someone else. She treats all her daughter-in-laws like this, (she has 5 of them). Thank you for your input. Merry Christmas
• United States
18 Dec 06
what is up with this responder who says he agrees with your opinion. He has said that in 4 discussions I have been to this morning and it is always the same exact thing.
@lulylove (1560)
• Brazil
18 Dec 06
perfume - perfume frasc
I believe that it must make yes, therefore thus will show that you it is superior. It gives a perfume....
@gdsdb4 (173)
• Canada
19 Dec 06
Merry Christmas
@isha900 (1459)
• India
18 Dec 06
it can be right way to express ur feeling
• United States
18 Dec 06
send her candles
@gdsdb4 (173)
• Canada
19 Dec 06
She would probably blame me if she burnt the house down! Merry Christmas
• India
18 Dec 06
hehehehe!!!!!!!! who going to send her match BOX????????
@serenetee (380)
• Singapore
18 Dec 06
My mum seldom call me too but I make a point to call and visit her instead. Maybe as they age, they expect us to play a more active role in taking care of them and not the reverse. I can tell you are a very kind-hearted person. Why not bake her something and bring it to her personally. No matter how she treats your family now, she was once a caregiver to your husband.
@gdsdb4 (173)
• Canada
19 Dec 06
Thank you for your advice. Unfortunately my husband didn't have a very good childhood and has little respect for his mother. She has grown to be a very bitter woman. She is not too far away, but doesn't appreciate the little things like baking and pictures and such. I hope you have a very Merry Christmas
• United States
18 Dec 06
Baking is a good idea.. But does she live too far??
@maryannemax (12156)
• Sweden
18 Dec 06
gifts for loved ones - gifts for the people we love...
since you're asking this question, you might be feel bad if you won't send her a gift. it's just that there's this gap between you two which hinders you to do so. but since she's your mother in law, atleast, give her something as a sign of your respect. that in a way, you still look up to her as your second mother.
@gdsdb4 (173)
• Canada
19 Dec 06
Thank you. Merry Christmas
@nancygibson (3736)
• France
18 Dec 06
Why not send a charity present, you know, the ones where you sponsor a child in a developing country or pay for a well to be dug or trees planted. That way you are doing it in her name, but she isnt personally getting the benefit. She can't be cross because sombody will dount that it is a good thing to do, but you know she hasnt personally benefited from it. Might send a subtle message about not being selfish!
@gdsdb4 (173)
• Canada
19 Dec 06
A great idea but she would really hate that. She would expect that any money I spent should go to her personally. She's really not into charity. My ears are burning already with what she would say about me to the rest of the family, (not that I really care!). If it was anybody else I would do it. Thanks Merry Christmas
• India
18 Dec 06
l - LOVE u r enemy as u r self
LOVE YOU'R ENEMY AS YOUR SELF DONT YOU READ A BIBLE?
@gdsdb4 (173)
• Canada
19 Dec 06
too many years, to much love merry christmas
@harsh1985 (593)
• India
18 Dec 06
well, i think your mother-in-laws wants to use you only when she wants your help and nobody is available with her. so stay away from her!!
@gdsdb4 (173)
• Canada
19 Dec 06
Wow! Do you know her. That is exactly what she is like. Thanks for understanding...lol Merry Christmas
@shemb1 (464)
• Sri Lanka
18 Dec 06
Yes you should have to because this is christmas. Forget about what she done to you givw a mercy to her, because she is your Mother-in-Laws. Visit her place when christmas day. spend sometime there and give gift that trally touch her heart. I dont know what to give to touch her heart think and give something you guess it good be best for her.
@gdsdb4 (173)
• Canada
19 Dec 06
Thanks for the advice but I just couldn't do that. She makes it too hard to feel love for her. Merry Christmas
@ashiflett (1045)
• United States
18 Dec 06
Just because it is Christmas, you are not required to buy this person a gift. There are many gifts or ways to express the fact that you are thinking of her apart from purchasing expensive gifts. You could have the children create drawings for her, send her a family photo in a card, or maybe even a phone card so that she could call more often.
@gdsdb4 (173)
• Canada
18 Dec 06
Thanks, those are all great ideas but it's not that easy to please this woman. My kids are older now and they don't care to see her. I gave her a family portrait last year with her other gifts and she didn't think that was a proper gift. As for the phone card it would be great if I actually wanted to hear from her.
• United States
18 Dec 06
HAHA I love the phone card idea.. Think she would get the hint??
• India
18 Dec 06
i would suggest you send her a family photo beautifully framed...maybe picture of ur kids playing or something that can touch her heart and maybe make her realise how selfish she has been over the years...
@gdsdb4 (173)
• Canada
19 Dec 06
Nice idea but she's not emotionally bound to my children. They are grown now, 24 and 21 and they don't even want to see her. That's how selfish she has been. Merry Christmas
@kulpreet1 (116)
• India
18 Dec 06
yes u should buy her a nice gift for christmas..
@gdsdb4 (173)
• Canada
19 Dec 06
OK Merry Christmas
• United States
18 Dec 06
I would send her something small maybe a framed family photo or a candle or something like that.she is still your mother in law even though she dont bother with your family its christmas time.
@gdsdb4 (173)
• Canada
19 Dec 06
The last picture I sent her she put in a drawer. She is close to only one of her sons and dotes on his family. That's OK with me but I feel bad for my children. I have tried to be nice at Christmas but it isn't always easy. Merry Christmas
@isha900 (1459)
• India
18 Dec 06
sorry im single
@gdsdb4 (173)
• Canada
19 Dec 06
Sometimes I wish I was too! Merry Christmas
@onesiobhan (1327)
• Canada
18 Dec 06
It would be a very loving and Christian think to send her a token. It doesn't have to be something expensive, just an acknowledgement. The Bible says to honor one's father and mother and you should do that even if she is not close to you.
@gdsdb4 (173)
• Canada
19 Dec 06
Thank You Merry Christmas
• United States
18 Dec 06
Your lucky!!! I wish my mother in law wasn't so involved. She can't stand me but always wants to see my kids and get btwn my husband and i by causing trouble.:(
@gdsdb4 (173)
• Canada
19 Dec 06
Mine used to be like that when she lived in the same building as us. Well not the kids part. She always said she was too young to be a grandmother. She wouldn't even tell people she had older kids when they saw her with the younger ones. There is 5 years difference between my husband and his twin brothers and another 5 years difference with a younger brother. Merry Christmas
• India
18 Dec 06
i love my mother-in-law
@gdsdb4 (173)
• Canada
19 Dec 06
You're one of the lucky ones. I hope it lasts. Please have a very Merry Christmas
@winnyver (40)
• Brazil
18 Dec 06
perfume - perfume
I imagine that this desire appeared in its good heart as something! you must make yes, therefore somebody has that to yield so that a good relation again either, and if you feel that it would be good, then... that she is you to make something good so that this relaƧao again comes back to be beautiful. I find that he would have to order FLOWERS.
@gdsdb4 (173)
• Canada
19 Dec 06
Merry Christmas