Should men have a say in choosing abortion/adoption?

@astromama (1221)
United States
February 2, 2007 7:51am CST
Tricky question, but one I have often wondered about... should a man, who is the father of the fetus, have a say in regards to the woman's choice? I ask because it seems like many women are comfortable choosing abortion without telling the father she was ever pregnant! No wrong answers, here... I'm just interested in what women and men think about this issue. thanks for responding.
1 person likes this
10 responses
@jhrcsr (348)
• United States
7 Feb 07
I think that both the mother and father have a right to make the decision as a couple. Even if they are not a "couple" per se. It takes two to create a child, it should take two to make a decision about that child. The decision effects both the mother and father's futures for 19 years legally and for their entire life emotionally. It also effects the unborn child as well because maybe one parent feels very strongly about one option and the other parent feels very strongly about a second option. There are no right and wrong answers set in stone. I have my personal opinions, but they are not that of my best friend, my sisters-in-law or my neighbors. Each of them has their own opinions. I just feel that both parents have a right to voice their opinion, explain their opinion and make an informed, educated choice.
@astromama (1221)
• United States
7 Feb 07
I agree with you totally... and you are right, there are many, many voices out there regarding the issue..
• Romania
6 Feb 07
Of course , it's a serious mather that need both opinions ! If a girl that caryes my baby would want to kill ( cause that what abortion means ) him , i think that it would be bet to ask for my opinion first !
@astromama (1221)
• United States
7 Feb 07
And what if she did ask, and the two of you disagreed?
• United States
3 Feb 07
I think that if the man wants to keep the baby he should have a say in it, but if the woman wants to keep the child & the man says she needs to abort it-- I don't agree with that. I think it should be a joint decision on the adoption, as long as both feel it is the best for the child-- then I think it's a good idea--but, I know a situation where the man wanted the baby & he could take care of it-- but, the girl said that if she didn't have the baby and keep it she didn't want him to raise it so she gave the baby up for adoption & I just find that very sad. Because, we all know that if she would have kept the child herself, she would have been depending on him for support as well for the child & he would have had to help then, but when he wanted a say in it before-- she wouldn't listen.
@astromama (1221)
• United States
3 Feb 07
that's terrible... it's such a tricky issue and I feel that some women believe themselves to be the 'primary' parent because they carry the baby, and I will admit sometimes I feel that way, too... being pregnant presently, I wonder if my husband feels as invested and connected. I believe that 'mothering' is inherent in many men, though... and I feel as though their voices are not heard as often when it comes to abortion and adoption. I know that fairly often a child is born or aborted and the father never has any knowledge that it even happened. Is that fair? In some states an underage girl cannot abort/adopt without parental consent... what about the consent of the other parent?
• United States
4 Sep 08
I definately think that the father has the right to know that he is going to be a father. I do not think it is fair of a mother contemplating the decision of abortion to not even consider the baby's dad in the decision. I do not believe in abortion.
@FrancyDafne (2047)
• Italy
6 Feb 07
I think that a woman could say to her man that she is pregnant, but she is not forced. The body is her and only she can decide what to do with her future fetus. I think that a man has the right to say what he thinks about the decision of her woman, they could start an honest discussion and to talk about a lot of things, but hte latest person who can say the last word is the woman. That's Nature: the woman is pregnant, not man, the woman lives 9 months with her fetus growing more and more, not man, and it's the woman that can decide for her own body.
@astromama (1221)
• United States
7 Feb 07
thanks for your input. The only thing I can think to comment on is that you said 'her fetus'... when in all fairness it is his fetus, too. I don't think any body outside the couple who made the baby should have any say, but I do think it's unfair to men if a woman is pregnant with his baby and never considers his opinion. But, true, this is the way nature designed it...
• India
6 Feb 07
of course men should have a say in choosing abortion or adoption.....afterall the condition has arised due to a man. well jokes apart its a serious matter and it is concerned to both the man and the woman goin to have a child so....
@justreal (2364)
• Canada
2 Feb 07
Of course a man should have a say about choosing to abort or not. First of, abortion is a sin. You should be responsible enough wether you decide that you want to have a baby or not. You cannot be pregnant if you want to decide to abort the baby after, that's not right, at all. If you are pregenant is because you want to be and you want the baby, responsible enough towards what you decided.
@kmgupta (561)
• India
6 Feb 07
i think both should decide
• United States
2 Feb 07
Yes, it is as much his as it is hers therefor if she dont want to raise the baby, let him. and i also think she should pay.
• United States
2 Feb 07
Obviously, this depends on your feelings toward abortion. I believe that abortion is murder. That will impact my opinion on whether the Father should be informed. I believe that the Father should be informed. The woman did not create the fetus by herself. Therefore, she should not be allowed to destroy it by herself. As fas as adoption goes, this should also be obvious. It is their child, collectively. Therefore it needs to be a joint decission. It is difficult for me to imagine situations that happen every day to other people, specifically that they are parenting a child outside of a monogamous relationship. When in that relationship, it, again, is obvious that the two people need to make the decission together in their normal decission making process. If they are not, then that makes it more difficult. I guess that difficulty should be reason enough to not put yourself in that situation in the first place. Anyway, to make a long answer short, the mother has an obligation to inform and discuss her discissions regarding her child with the Father. If the Father disowns the child in some way, then it is up to the mother to make the best decission she can without the Father.