Why do we cry when we cut Onions??

United States
October 12, 2006 9:30pm CST
I love onions, but everytime I peel, slice, dice, chop onions I cry. Is there a specific reason for this or are onions curse or something else. Please give me you honest expert opinions.
1 person likes this
12 responses
@MINDY0882 (2302)
• United States
13 Oct 06
When peeled or cut, onions release a chemical that reacts with tears on the surface of your eyes. The chemical reaction produces sulfuric acid which irritates your eyes. When you slice through an onion, you break open a number of onion cells. Some of these cells have enzymes inside of them, and when they are sliced open, the enzymes escape. The enzymes then decompose some of the other substances that have escaped from sliced cells. Some of these substances, amino acid sulfoxides, form sulfenic acids, which then quickly rearrange themselves into a volatile gas. The gas reaches your eyes and reacts with the water that keeps them moist. This changes the chemical's form again, producing, among other things, a mild sulfuric acid, which irritates the eyes. The nerve endings in your eyes are very sensitive and so they pick up on this irritation (this is why our eyes sting when we slice onions). The brain reacts by telling your tear ducts to produce more water, to dilute the irritating acid so the eyes are protected. Your other reaction is probably to rub your eyes, but this will actually make the irritation a lot worse, of course, if you have onion juices all over your hands. Oddly enough, this volatile compound is also responsible for a lot of the great taste in onions, as well as the pleasant aroma when you cook the vegetable. You'll also get sulfenic acids by cutting up garlic, chives and leeks, among other vegetables, but they don't form the same irritating gas, just a strong smell. There are all kinds of remedies for dealing with this irritating phenomenon, some more effective than others. As a general rule, move your head as far away from the onion as you can, so the gas will mostly disperse before it reaches your eyes. If you really can't stand the tears, the simplest solution might be to wear goggles. This measure is very effective, but it may seem a bit extreme to those around you, and if your kitchen is steamy, you might not be able to see what you're doing (never a good idea when you're using a knife). Peeling the onion and then chilling it in the refrigerator before you slice it will minimize the release of gas somewhat, because the change in temperature alters the compounds in the onion. Cooking an onion before you slice it will work also, for the same reason. Another easy solution is to cut the onion under water or run the tap over it as you slice. Some people say if you hold a lemon, piece of bread or a sugar cube in your mouth, the food will absorb the gas before it reaches your eyes. Breathing with your mouth, instead of your nose, might also help because as you inhale, you suck the gas in and as you exhale, you blow it away. This keeps a lot of the gas from ever reaching your eyes. hope this helps
• United States
13 Oct 06
WOW, it looks as if you researched this. I wasn't expected a whole scientific explaination. Thank you, you provided far more information than I had anticipated.
@MINDY0882 (2302)
• United States
13 Oct 06
thanks sorry if i was more than u wanted to know lol
• United States
14 Oct 06
hey, no problem. I was just hoping to get a little mileage out it. I'll come up with something else. I did rate your response. So kudos for an excellent response. Thank you!
• United States
16 Oct 06
It effects something in the tear gland to make you have tears coming down.
1 person likes this
• United States
16 Oct 06
Thanks for the reply.
• United States
16 Oct 06
Thanks for the reply.
@xbrendax (2662)
• United States
23 Oct 06
Mindy said it best but here's how I will say it: When you cut into an onion, fumes come up and sting and burn your eyes, causing them to tear up, plain and simple!
• United States
23 Oct 06
Bravo for reading all of the responses!!! I'm impressed! Thanks for your reply.
@melody1011 (1663)
• India
23 Oct 06
Whenever i cut onions, i soak them in water first for abt 5 mins and then my eyes dont water. However I've found that changing the place where im standing and cutting (i think it has to do with the way the breeeze is blowing) helps minimise tears
1 person likes this
• United States
23 Oct 06
Thank you, I will have to try that.
@Azita888 (315)
• United States
21 Oct 06
wash the onion and the knife you gonna cut it with then you won't cry
1 person likes this
• United States
23 Oct 06
Thank you, I will have to try that.
• India
23 Oct 06
There is scientific reasone behind this.
1 person likes this
• United States
23 Oct 06
Yes, there are and Mindy said it best in post #2. Thank you for your reply.
@simonpaul (737)
• Nigeria
16 Oct 06
we do not really cry but tears comes out of our eyes because of chemical reactions,the tears that comes out has no emotional ties to it.
1 person likes this
@zubair439 (3183)
• India
15 Oct 06
When you slice through an onion, you break open a number of onion cells. Some of these cells have enzymes inside of them, and when they are sliced open, the enzymes escape. The enzymes then decompose some of the other substances that have escaped from sliced cells. Some of these substances, amino acid sulfoxides, form sulfenic acids, which then quickly rearrange themselves into a volatile gas. The gas reaches your eyes and reacts with the water that keeps them moist. This changes the chemical's form again, producing, among other things, a mild sulfuric acid, which irritates the eyes. The nerve endings in your eyes are very sensitive and so they pick up on this irritation (this is why our eyes sting when we slice onions). The brain reacts by telling your tear ducts to produce more water, to dilute the irritating acid so the eyes are protected. Your other reaction is probably to rub your eyes, but this will actually make the irritation a lot worse, of course, if you have onion juices all over your hands. Oddly enough, this volatile compound is also responsible for a lot of the great taste in onions, as well as the pleasant aroma when you cook the vegetable. You'll also get sulfenic acids by cutting up garlic, chives and leeks, among other vegetables, but they don't form the same irritating gas, just a strong smell. There are all kinds of remedies for dealing with this irritating phenomenon, some more effective than others. As a general rule, move your head as far away from the onion as you can, so the gas will mostly disperse before it reaches your eyes. If you really can't stand the tears, the simplest solution might be to wear goggles. This measure is very effective, but it may seem a bit extreme to those around you, and if your kitchen is steamy, you might not be able to see what you're doing (never a good idea when you're using a knife). Peeling the onion and then chilling it in the refrigerator before you slice it will minimize the release of gas somewhat, because the change in temperature alters the compounds in the onion. Cooking an onion before you slice it will work also, for the same reason. Another easy solution is to cut the onion under water or run the tap over it as you slice. Some people say if you hold a lemon, piece of bread or a sugar cube in your mouth, the food will absorb the gas before it reaches your eyes. Breathing with your mouth, instead of your nose, might also help because as you inhale, you suck the gas in and as you exhale, you blow it away. This keeps a lot of the gas from ever reaching your eyes.
@zubair439 (3183)
• India
16 Oct 06
i got the whole in somewebsite i dint saw that she also copied the same from that site i m sorry for posting
• United States
16 Oct 06
Hey Zubair439, Did you just copy Mindy's response. It is verbatim. If I was a professor, I'd have to give you an F for forgery!! Thanks for the reply
• United States
16 Oct 06
No need to apologize, I thought it was kinda funny. I had to match the paragraphs up to make sure. I appreciate the response and you taking the time to look on the internet for the scientific reasoning. THANK YOU!!
@bblessed (1822)
• United States
15 Oct 06
If you peel them under water the tears wont be so bad:)
1 person likes this
• United States
16 Oct 06
Thank you, I will have to try that.
@terriann (4450)
• United States
16 Oct 06
I don't know why.
@hindol_86 (232)
• India
23 Oct 06
i also "cry" when i peel an onion ...i think theres some type of chemicals present in onion which makes us cry rather induces tears to come out of our eye...
1 person likes this
@indiandevil (2410)
• Canada
15 Oct 06
Yes onions give off a strong odour however you can get rid of this. Take the peeling off the onion, then run it under very cold water for at least 10 seconds if not more, when you cut the onion you will not cry
• United States
16 Oct 06
Thank you.