Can teachers punish students ?

@subathra (3519)
India
August 4, 2007 4:40am CST
Recently a teacher had cut the hair of a girl student as she was not wearing a two plat which is mandatory rule of the school.But subsequently the event caused a big issue and it had been reported to the department and enquiry held.Being found the teacher at fault, she has been transferred to another school with a strict warning.Like this some teachers behave rudely and some incidents take place which we could read in daily newspapers. Because of this rude behaviour of some teachers the reputation of other teachers too get spoiled.Teaching is such a noble and dedicated profession to admire.I still remember some of my teachers even now because of their great attribution towards my education. I feel it is correct for the department to take action against this errand teacher. My argument is that no teachers looses temper for nothing but with valid reason the teacher when she or he takes action on student who is disobedient will have to be very careful what punishment to be given. when a student fails in a subject when a student is disobedient when a student misbehaves in the class when a student is coming late to the class student getting absent to the school very often student coming to school without neatness student fighting with other students The above are some regular offences done by the students. My opinion is that there should be punishment but at the same time should not be harsh to the students.Please share your opinion.
1 person likes this
15 responses
@dpk262006 (56599)
• Delhi, India
5 Aug 07
Very Good Post indeed! You must be some officer in the Government of you must be some Minister in the Government. I always find you fighting for social causes and writing on the social causes. So great on your part. I entirely agree with you views, whatever you have written here. There should be a debate, which punishment be given to children and upto what extent the teachers can punish a student. Sometimes, teachers are compelled to punish a naughty student due to his behaviour, but there should be some guidelines, conventions and parameters for the same. You should write your opinion to Education Ministry, Govt. of India and your State Govt. also.
1 person likes this
@dpk262006 (56599)
• Delhi, India
5 Aug 07
You would have done quite a research to post this discussion.
@subathra (3519)
• India
5 Aug 07
Tnks for the appreciation deepak.Hope if i get a job in that grade i will try my maximum to change the education pattern first. Some teachers dont follow the norms of punishment and simply use abusive lanuguages and some harsh punishments over students.Actually i started this post as i get to read lot of incidents in the recent past with relavant to teachers punishing students in a rude manner.
1 person likes this
@dpk262006 (56599)
• Delhi, India
6 Aug 07
I agree with your thoughts and posts in general. I wish that you could acquire such a position in your life so that your could carry out such types of reforms for the benefit of societ. Best of Luck! Keep it up!
1 person likes this
• India
21 Aug 07
Very bad news. How a teacher can punish student in such a unhuman way. School should throw out such teachers. It shows that particular teacher is not suitable for the job of teacher. Discipline is necessary and they should get punished for that but not in such a manner. I am realy happy when I read news about a creative way to punish students, who were smoking in school premises. Every teacher, educationist, parent and student should learn lesson from that news. You can read that news: http://www.mylot.com/w/discussions/1246349.aspx.
1 person likes this
@subathra (3519)
• India
22 Aug 07
I read your discussion.Its great and a very good way to tackle such naughty students who spoil their health in this small age.I hope after that incident they never dare to touch cigerattes.. you have rightly commented to my discussion..but unfortunately the teacher who did this blunder to the female student was only transferred to another school.I think she should have received the dismissal order from the education department.
1 person likes this
• India
22 Aug 07
Not so good news. That teacher should take a lesson and try to do things in creative manner. Punishment is necessary but, don't behave like a criminal to students.
• Philippines
5 Aug 07
Well i agree.I believe there must not be any mandatory super strict dress codes unless if it looks way tom indecent but anyway who gives damn about the clothes u wear or how u dress ur hair???It is about what u learn in school that counts. As for scolding children, this must be done within reason and must be done if the student really crosses the line
1 person likes this
@subathra (3519)
• India
5 Aug 07
If if a students fails to follow dress code or hair style the teacher should only warn the student but doesnt have rights to cut the hair or use verbal abuse against him/her.tnks for the response.
• Philippines
5 Aug 07
Well honestly i dont believe in dress codes or whatever.......Dress codes means nothing nor will it ever become relevant since for me everybody in school should be who they want to be...this includes dressing how they wish
@cefaz_21 (2597)
• Philippines
16 Aug 07
This is my own opinion: Teachers can discipline the students but they cannot punish them because even the word "punishment" when kids hear that brings about negative things. I was a tecaher before and I never punished any of my students, I corrected them and disciplined them but never given punishments. Children are all playful and can irritate you once in a while but as a teacher you should be very patient with them and you know how to hold temper at your best..
@subathra (3519)
• India
16 Aug 07
Wonderful response.i think you aptly said what a teacher should do and shuold not do.Even in my school days i have never come cross any harsh teachers and whoever taught me were very much focussed on us towards our improvement in studies.
• Philippines
13 Aug 07
I dont think teachers have the right to punish the children. Their obligation is to teach them and help them learn. If they have attitude problems, they should talk to them and if they wont listen, they bring the case to the guidance counselor so that their parent would be informed about the problems their child is encountering in school.
1 person likes this
@subathra (3519)
• India
13 Aug 07
you have rightly said..teachers have to inform either the school management or parents if the students behaviour is not good and indisclipined.Good response..rated +
@yanstill (1491)
• China
10 Aug 07
i think that depends on what kind of punishment.i was punished when i was a little girl,but my teacher knew the way,so when i look back now,all i remember is good memory. physical punishment is absolutely not allowed,i think.if what the teacher did makes things worse,or cause a bad impact,then i consider that teacher did it wrong.like the teacher you mentioned,he didnt think of the results. i know what the feeling if others cut my hair,it's like an insult,and the hurt is big.
1 person likes this
@subathra (3519)
• India
13 Aug 07
you are right yanstill..tnks for the sensible response.
• United States
5 Aug 07
That incident was very wrong. The teacher could have just given her a warning or sent her home explaining to the parents that her hairstyle was an infringement of the school's dress code. It could have been very serious if the girl's religious beliefs did not allow her hair to be cut.
1 person likes this
@subathra (3519)
• India
6 Aug 07
You are right.Otherwise the teacher could have brought it to the notice of school management rather to do this cruel way of punishment.
@ayris77 (1304)
• Malaysia
5 Aug 07
Surely teacher can punish they students,if they student doesn't want to hear they advice or follow the school law! It is the faileure of the teacher if the students become more powerfull then teacher!Also the parents must take control they children carefully.Dont let they children become uncontrolled!The education world is to teach the person to more educated in knowledge and behaviour!
1 person likes this
@subathra (3519)
• India
6 Aug 07
Teachers should punish butneed to adopt certain methods of giving punishment.It should not be any verbal abuse or beating or treating them like in the case the teacher cut the hair of the girl student.
@rb200406 (1825)
• India
5 Aug 07
Yes you are quite right.Actually there has to be punishment but there has to be a limit.Thrashing,insulting is not a way of punishing.Actually a student should respect a teacher not be afraid.Then student can never be free with teachers.Teacher should be able to understand a student more than mere punishment.
1 person likes this
@rouwel23 (1353)
• Philippines
5 Aug 07
teachers should not do any physical punishments to these children or students. even though some of these children are very much misbehaving. There are very stubborn students, some students fight with other students. punishments should be with suspensions and terminations from school. not physical punishments like push-ups or sitting on the air or spanking.
@subathra (3519)
• India
5 Aug 07
yes you are right that physical punishments must be totally banned from schools.
• Philippines
4 Aug 07
maybe its how the teacher punish or discipline the student.my stand about this is that teachers dont have any right to spank there students.i believe that the teacher is there is guide the students my verbal discipline.teachers can talk to there students..
1 person likes this
@subathra (3519)
• India
5 Aug 07
I agree with you that teachers should have tolerance to make the pupils understand their errors and warn them not to commit anymore but dont have the right either to beat or use abusive words against them.
• India
4 Aug 07
Hi!I do agree that punishments should be there to a certain extent but not severe that they should have adverse effects on the child.It should be avoided to the maximum & taken up as the last resort.A child would do something willingly if it makes up its mind to do so, & this is what the teacher has exactly got to do.The teacher has to somehow make the child realize to do what the teacher wants the child to do but not by force, but in the way the child is ready to listen....through friends, or books or whatever the interest of the child.Then nothing would stop the child, for now it has become the INTEREST of the child. GOD BLESS, www.creatingcolourfulfuture.com
1 person likes this
@subathra (3519)
• India
5 Aug 07
I agree with you that nothing can be attained through force and proper channel to educate children should be adopted by teachers.tnks for the response.
@touchnshine (2821)
• India
4 Aug 07
Dear subathra I think that teachers should have the right to punish students but it should be in limits .. and not crossing the limits which will affect child's growth. Parents send their child for their development and not for things which will affect their physical and mental health .. What the teacher did is a crime in my opinion and she should be punished for that .. rather than just getting a warning and transfer. That teacher can repeat this behavious .. why is she still a teacher ??
1 person likes this
@thefuture (1750)
• Nigeria
4 Aug 07
Yes friend. I think in a similar way. I think teachers should be very careful when punishing students no matter the offence they commit. Here in Africa, people are used to using their hands in punishing others which is too bad, but over the years, some of them have realized how bad it is to hurt people using either cain or their bare hands. Thanks
@subathra (3519)
• India
4 Aug 07
beating children with cane and makig them to kneel down in hot sun are some harsh way of punishment which needs to be banned from schools.tnks for the response
@balasri (26553)
• India
6 Aug 07
Will you please tell how not to punish harsh the habitual offenders.
1 person likes this