Who will be booted off tomorrow?

Barring another shocker, I think the bottom three will be Carly and Syeshia and also (one of my favorites) Brooke. I don't know which of those three I think will go...I think you're probably right.

It should be Kristy Lee to go, but she should have been gone a long time ago. I would not be surprised though to see Carly or Brook get the boot. David Archeleta's novelty has worn off. I found myself extremely bored with his performance last nite. I cringed listening to Kristy. I actually enjoyed Jason's performance. He has grown on me from the beginning. Something about his voice is starting to intrigue me. You said tonight was the first time you liked Jason. Actually, I loved the Somewhere Over the Rainbow. That is when the tide turned for me with him. I loved that version. I think he will continue to pick up more fans. He's very original. I could see myself buying a cd by him, just based on the fact that his voice just makes me feel good. I like Carly. I would definitely like to see her make the final 3. Syesha has a beautiful clear voice. I think she's lost her way though, and is becoming more unsure of herself. The show last night belonged to David Cook though. HE OWNED IT. I admit, I was thinking "OMG, how on earth is he going to do a Mariah Carey song? This isn't fair to the guys." But really, they pulled it out. His tears last nite, I think it was from relief. I think he was worried that people wouldn't get it. But they did. Simon did. Randy Did. Paula... well, she's always gotten it. I see David Cook being another Chris Daughtry in the end. He'll be at the top of the charts in no time. Interesting tid bit.... I'm thinking it won't be long before the whole naysayers and such start in that David Cook and Jason Castro just have rabid teen age fans.. SO not true. I'm 40. I don't get David Archeleta. I probably never will. I was happy to see Simon bring up the fact that Kristy was "whiny" in parts. It's not so much whiney as too "twangy" A good artist, country or not, can sing a song without sounding like a hick.... and she still sounds like a hick. Even the other country bumpkin blonde wasn't as twangy as this one.

Kristy lee Cook got voted off tonight. I figured it would be either her or Syeshia. It was out of Kristy, Brooke and Jason though.

I actually think Brooke might go this time round or even Carly. Syeshia might go also because not many people knew that song, I didn't LOL. Love David Cooks version - wow!

I think it should be either Syseshia or Jason, I think they are the bottom two right now. And I have to say I wouldn't be TOTALLy shocked if Carly went home. i think david cook did good tonight, but I'm still not a big fan of his. I love David A. and Brooke. Those are the 2 I'm rooting for. Yeah I actually think Kristy did really good tonight too! It was a pleasant surprise.

Tonight was the first time I watched American Idol all season and I fell in love with David Cook! LOL I dont know who should be booted off but he's def my fave to win it

I was hoping that the girl with the tattoos would go home. I just don't think she sings well at all. I think Jason should have a singing carreer. He is my favorite to be the next American Idol. Kristy did do better but she got sent home.

One of the girls will definitely go. Bottom three Syesha, Kristy and Carly. I loved Jason last week with his "rainbow" song and I even downloaded it. His style is growing on me, and I don't know how he can be so relaxed up there week after week. I think this may be the year that Idol will get the most recording contracts for its contestants too. I adore David A with all the rest - one critic noted on TV last week that while David A may very well win the contest, he may be the least marketable.

I think it should be a blond night, Brooke or Kristy, but possibly Syesha might go because: 1. not sure she has that big a fan base 2. not very well known song