I got chills from David Cook tonight!
By icyorchid
@icyorchid (2564)
United States
April 22, 2008 10:03pm CST
I loved how he sang that song. I was just sitting here watching him and I got chills up and down my arms. I really think it is going to be out of both David's in the end.
David A. is really getting better every week and Carly does yell when she gets into a song. I like her, but Simon is right when he tells her that. lol
I LOVED her t-shirt tonight "Simon Likes Me (this week)" I thought that was the cutest thing. 
I felt bad for Brooke, you never start and stop and then start over, but she had a lot of guts to do that. I think she sang the song well after she started, but I think that mistake could have cost her.
I really didn't know these songs with the exception of the last one that David Cook sang.
Who do you think will be booted out?
I am unsure but I think the bottom 3 will be Brooke, Jason and either Syeshia or Carly.
I felt bad for Brooke, you never start and stop and then start over, but she had a lot of guts to do that. I think she sang the song well after she started, but I think that mistake could have cost her.
I really didn't know these songs with the exception of the last one that David Cook sang.
Who do you think will be booted out?
I am unsure but I think the bottom 3 will be Brooke, Jason and either Syeshia or Carly.1 person likes this
4 responses
@Shaun72 (15959)
• Palatka, Florida
24 Apr 08
I thought it was going to be Brooke the way she messed up last night. I thought Syeshia did really well myself. I hated that she almost got booted off. I figured it was out of Brooke, Carly, Jason or Syeshaia though last night. Both David's are great singers. I have a feeling they will be the final 2 singers.
@makingpots (11915)
• United States
23 Apr 08
Yes, David Cook nailed it tonight. He is just so good. As the judges have said, he could already be a recording artist. I think tonight it will be Brooke to go home. I hope it is not Jason, although he will surely be in the bottom 3.
@ladym33 (10979)
• United States
23 Apr 08
David Cook is amazing. I was a bit worried about his song choice because that song from the Phantom of the Opera is quite a song and meant for a certain type of singer, but he pulled it off.
I know who the bottom three should be tonight, but it won't work out that way. Based soley on last nights performance, I think the bottom three should be Brooke, Jason, and David Archuletta. I believe the Syesha, Carly, and David Cook all had really good performances last night. David Archuletta was good, but not as good as these three and as Simon said his performance was not memorable, and was actually kind of dull. But, I am pretty sure he won't end up in the bottom three because of his popularity.
So I agree with you about who will end up in the bottom three, but neither Syesha or Carly deserve to be there this week.
Brook really needed to pull off an amazing performance last night to stay. It is a shame that she messed up on the begining, and then sang kind of tight and shakey for the first few seconds of that song, because once she did get going, I think she sung the strongest she has ever sung. I fear it is her time though, it is not possible for her to win. She is adorable, but she just is not as strong (or unique as Jason), as the other contestants who are left.
