How Can You Be Against The Death Penalty But Be For Abortion?

@gewcew23 (8007)
United States
July 28, 2008 10:37am CST
The other day I talked to a person that was against the death penalty. Just to set the table I am for the death penalty, just if you were wondering. I ask these person if they were for Pro-Life, and I got a no. So I asked why, the response why all women should have the choice over their body. My response back to these person was, well should not the jury have all the choices available to them. The counter response was that the death penalty was inhumane, primitive, and it would be better punishment to make someone have to suffer behind bars. I decided to take response 1 and 3 on at the same time. You say that the death penalty is inhumane but you want the murderer to suffer, why not save the time and have the murderer suffer while being put to death. Counter response was that the death penalty was just too cruel and some innocent person might be put to death. I was puzzled by this counter response, this person had no problem with the idea of innocent babies being killed in the womb which sounds pretty primitive to me, but was against the death penalty. The person I was talking to did not see the comparison between abortion and the death penalty. So I am proposing the question to the MyLot community.
7 people like this
2 responses
• United States
28 Jul 08
Far too many people do not see babies as human beings. Thus, they have no problem with the idea of killing a baby in the womb.
2 people like this
• United States
28 Jul 08
Everyone sees babies as human beings, which they are. The problem is that anti-choicers have romantic delusions that cause them to see EMBRYOS as BABIES. That's the confusion. A human being is an individual. An embryo is not an individual. It is a living PART of the woman, and this remains true until they cross the line of 'viability', which is blurry but is certainly somewhere in the third trimester (and no one who is planning on aborting a pregnancy would purposely wait 6-7 months--why would they?).
@lixiaos77 (1030)
• Shijiazhuang, China
30 Jul 08
Youth are always make mistakes. But it don't hamper them to be broughted rationally and maturely. They can't responsile for what they do for a certain period. When should give them time to grow and give them opportuities to change. If they are pregnant, something should be done to help them, or it will ruin both of them and their babies.
1 person likes this
@alpha7 (1910)
• France
29 Jul 08
When you abort,you're really killing a person and not just getting rid of clotted blood or whatever! There are some Countries that are still against abortion but they are all considering changing, so where do we go from here? Their points been that unwanted pregnancies either resulting from rape or on medical ground are allowed to be terminated,well they advise them to go to another Countries to abort since it's against their law. Probably,those Countries will start to execute as well with time.Let's keep our finger cross.
1 person likes this