PDA2 and Pinoy Idol result are you satisfied??????

pda2 and pinoy idol - Are you satisfied with the result
@dong1970 (1573)
Philippines
September 14, 2008 11:39pm CST
This two singing talent search have same basis on proclaiming winners.The results are based on the Text Vote.I'm Just curios and ask your opinions,Are you satisfied with the results of this Talent Search.PDA2 has Laarni Lozada and Pinoy Idol has Gretchen Espina as their grand winners respectively.Do they really deserve to be the grand winner?
1 person likes this
4 responses
@rsa101 (15467)
• Quezon City, Philippines
15 Sep 08
Well I could not compare thetwo shows as I wasn't able to watch the Pinoy Idol myself. For Laarni to win well I think she deserves it because Pinoys are just very supportive of the underdogs. Whoever seems to be the most that was not treated well is being supported by the majority. I think the two Bugoy and Laarni just was able to make the public got attention. The third placer is what I really question since I know that Miguel could very well afford to buy his votes. And Liezl was not just able to afford to cope up with the votes.
1 person likes this
@ayenacsi (911)
• Philippines
15 Sep 08
They were all complaining how hard it was to get along with Laarni and how Laarni was always crying and too sensitive, and too insensitive when she would vocalize inside the house. And look what happened most people symphathized and empathized with her. Look who's laughing now? Between Laarni and Bugoy, I really expected Bugoy to win because a few people didn't really like the way Laarni was behaving inside the house. Both of them look and sound good on the stage. I am quite satisfied with the top 2. Both of them will be more visible on TV after the show. But about Miguel's ranking? I was really expecting Liezl or Van. Oh well, they are more talented and that is what's really important.
@rsa101 (15467)
• Quezon City, Philippines
15 Sep 08
I don't really question the top 2 since they are both good in their own voice range. What really surprised me is the third placer Miguel. After being always on the probationary status and always being saved by text votes he was able to make it to the top 3. Amazing but we can always say that text votes did made him to the top.
1 person likes this
@djoyce71 (2512)
• Philippines
16 Sep 08
Sorry dong, but I don't watch Pinoy Idol. I was tuned in to PDA 2 only because I'm more of a Kapamilya than a Kapuso I wasn't satisfied with the results in PDA 2 because I was not expecting that Miguel would be on the top 3. I was shocked, really. But then again, that was the result and we can't do anything about it anymore. Anyways, Miguel knows how to play the piano like teacher Monet. Laarni deserves to be the winner because she has a good voice and worthy to be called a singer. Bugoy, too, but I guess his best wasn't good enough. Good day!
1 person likes this
@alena824 (376)
• Philippines
15 Sep 08
It has always been a toss-up between Laarni and Bugoy and whoever was proclaimed Grand Star Dreamer deserved it, talent-wise. Besides, being the champion does not always guarantee you will eventually become popular so it remains to be seen if Laarni can really prove she deserves the title. As for Bugoy, I think he has a lot of talent that ABS should not ignore. Let's face it, there are so many stars who are forced to render song numbers in variety/musical shows yet they don't deserve to be heard. But Bugoy really enjoys what he is doing and he's got the voice to boot. Now, you ask: Pinoy Idol? So who won again?
1 person likes this
• Philippines
15 Sep 08
Well I could only respond to the PinoyDream Academy 2 option because I dont really watch pinoy idol.I am really not satisfied on who the grand winner is I really thought that it would be bugoy because here in our place a lot of people really love bugoy and his performance while they detest laarni because they say that she has an attitude problem.Hope you liked my response and have a nice day?
1 person likes this