Public school? Private school? Religious School? Homeschool? Which is best?

@rocketj1 (6955)
United States
September 16, 2008 11:39am CST
Which form of schooling have you chosen for your children? Why have you chosen this type of education? Do you feel it's best? For Everyone? For your child in particular? Why?
3 people like this
23 responses
@gtdonna (1738)
17 Sep 08
My daughter have always gone to the Public school and in Italy the educational level is just great. I have no complaints and she is now proficient in 4 languages and still learning another one, so yep public school for her plus it is free. If it was the case that the public school was lacking teachers or something, then maybe I'd considered a private school.
1 person likes this
@gtdonna (1738)
17 Sep 08
Well we are English speakers, so she speaks English, Italian, Latin and Sicilian dialect that is very different from Italian, and school teaches them French. She learnt Italian on her own alsong with Sicilian. School taught her Latin and French. She is just 12.
1 person likes this
@rocketj1 (6955)
• United States
19 Sep 08
Very impressive!
@rocketj1 (6955)
• United States
17 Sep 08
Wow! Four languages! Are that many required? I believe my state is now implementing that our students must take at least a year of one language. Of course, college-bound students usually take more than one year but that is only suggested for college entrance. I know that Europeans are more aware of other languages since the countries are all close together. Do you speak as many as she does? Thanks!
@savypat (20216)
• United States
16 Sep 08
I don't have children in school anymore, but around here many children are home schooled. I have wondered about their socialzation, but there are so many doing this now that clubs and group activitys have started.
@rocketj1 (6955)
• United States
16 Sep 08
It's really big around here too especially with religious families. Thanks!
• United States
17 Sep 08
My children all attend public school. If I had the means I would probably try private school and see how the kids handled it. Our school is not bad, they are just overwhelmed. With some classes having over 30 students, they don't get much individualized attention. Two of my children do fine without much individual attention. I do have one child who I feel would benefit if he had a smaller class. I think the key to a child's success regardless of what school he is in is parental involvement.
1 person likes this
@savypat (20216)
• United States
17 Sep 08
It's true every child is different, what are you doing to help your child who is special? Are there any fun classes that can help him in your aarea?
1 person likes this
@shell94 (990)
• Canada
23 Sep 08
I think the type of school a person chooses is a very personal choice. I have my daughter in a public school. I like the fact that she has a variety of differrent people to mingle with and she will learn about the different cultures this way. I don't think it is nearly as segregating as some of the other types of schools. But this is just my opinion.
@rocketj1 (6955)
• United States
24 Sep 08
Yes. I believe it is the choice of the parent, and that each child requires different things for success. I'm glad that I live in an area where we have an opportunity to exercise our freedom of choice in education. Thanks:)
@jonesy123 (3948)
• United States
16 Sep 08
We chose public school as the private schools, one of which is religious, are not only super-expensive, but also notoriously behind what the other kids learn in public school. So far so good for us, but our oldest is only in second grade and our middle one just started Kindergarten. Many of the parents who felt led down by the private schools opted for homeschooling as a way to keep their kids in a what they deem safe environment. I don't think I would have the patience for that but may have to resort to it, because my oldest is ahead of her class and is starting to get bored. She was supposed to get enrolled in the gifted program to be provided with a better challenge, but while last year each school had a gifted teacher, there is now one for the entire district, which has seven elementary schools, two middle schools, and two high schools. So scratch enrolling a second grader. We do as much as we can at home to challenge her and the teacher is trying to keep her occupied with 'jobs', extra assignments and coloring, when it is time for quiet work as she gets done within a few minutes what takes others fifteen or more minutes... And no, she is not extra-ordinary smart, just has a good support system at home and quite a few kids in her class who can barely put a word together when asked to write something. That's the downside of the public school, which you won't get at a private school, because those students usually don't get accepted there. In public school the class proceeds at usually the level of the 'dumbest' kid in class.
1 person likes this
@rocketj1 (6955)
• United States
16 Sep 08
Thank you for your reply. I could not have the patience to homeschool either. Although, I think it would be easier with my daughter than my son. Just a personality thing. We have an excellent private school in our town that is associated with an excellent college here. Mucho Dinero! Not an option for us. There are also a couple of religious schools. Also expensive. And a couple of "charter" schools which are public schools. These were not something I was interested in. The one charter school was until recently meeting in separate "pre-fab" buildings. The head master just didn't sit right with me either. We are fortunate that we have an excellent public school district and there are many options for our kids to be challenged here. I sympathize with your frustration over your child's lack of challenge at her school. Have you taken it up with the administration?
@jonesy123 (3948)
• United States
16 Sep 08
No, they can't help it. Thanks to our economy, the state has less revenue and made major education cuts. Our district had to fire a whole bunch of people for non-essential programs. The gifted program is just one of them that got hit. They also fired special ed and literacy aids. Bare bones until the state gets more money. But behind it is also a political agenda on several levels. But that would be for another topic, lol. Looks like you are well on your way to making the right and well thought through decision for your child.
1 person likes this
@ashakki (196)
• India
16 Sep 08
oops........i responded twice. my browser was down for some time.....maybe that is what caused the error
1 person likes this
@rocketj1 (6955)
• United States
16 Sep 08
Not to worry. I've done the same myself. Are the adorable kittens in the coffee cups yours? They are so sweet! Thanks again.
@ashakki (196)
• India
16 Sep 08
sadly....... nope. I would love to have one though :)
1 person likes this
@dionesioz (100)
• Philippines
23 Sep 08
for me the best school is in public school, you do not need to expend big money but the learning are same from the private school.
1 person likes this
@rocketj1 (6955)
• United States
24 Sep 08
Thanks for your comments:)
• Canada
17 Sep 08
I have chosen public school as we don't have private schools where I live and I would never be able to sent my chidren away . I would love to home school if I was able to do this but woudln't know where to start and would not be able to do this myself as I would not have the smarts to be able to do this . I do not care for the school my children go to and will never trust them because my son was injured in school and has never fully recovered and the school accepted no responsibility for this even though it happened in there school and my son ended up in the hospital as a result . If there was any other school to send my children to I would for certain but this is the only school we have unless we were to move a couple of hours away and we are not in any shape to sell our house and just move away because I don't trust the school they go to .
1 person likes this
@rocketj1 (6955)
• United States
17 Sep 08
I can see you are in a dilemna. I don't know what I would do in your situation. Do you at least have the benefit of choosing their elementary teachers? Sometimes there are decent teachers in a rotten school district. Thanks:)
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
17 Sep 08
Our sons went to public school, but at that time it was all right over twenty years ago, but now I would prefer a private school, and if I could do homeschooling if there were not a private school in our area. The trouble is that at the time, I was learning to be a Christian and that private school demands that parents raise the children up in the faith. I do think that private schools or home schools are best since they demand a higher standard and do not let things slide.
@rocketj1 (6955)
• United States
17 Sep 08
The Christian schools in our area are too expensive for us but more importantly than that, They are very small. The opportunities for other activities associated with school would not be available there. Thanks:)
@mflower2053 (3223)
• United States
17 Sep 08
I wouldn't mind homeschooling my children b/c I really think they would learn more with me then at school since they would have one on one time. They really don't have time to socialize at school with other kids much b/c they are always telling them to be quiet but I don't know if I would be able to teach my kids. I know b/c I am teaching my 3 year old her ABC's right now and its alot of work. My 1 year old always wants to learn with us but she doesn't give me much time b/c she gets bored with things I give her very easily. Our kids will more then likely go to public school. I make sure even now to save box tops, campbells cans to get money for the school before they get there which will be next year for my oldest. :'{
1 person likes this
@rocketj1 (6955)
• United States
17 Sep 08
Oh, I remember when my kids were little like yours!:) I loved that time. They learn so many new things everyday and it is such a privelege to introduce them to the world! Thank you for your comments:)
@ANTIQUELADY (36440)
• United States
17 Sep 08
both my children went to public schools. i didn't have enough sense to homeschool them & we have no private schools here so they didn't have a choice. they did o.k. they both graduated, thank heavens.
1 person likes this
@rocketj1 (6955)
• United States
17 Sep 08
Hey there A.L.! Thanks for the post!
@psalmist (109)
• Philippines
20 Sep 08
whatever school you enroll your children it doesnt matter. Because there is best school only best parent... Because education starts in the home.
1 person likes this
@rocketj1 (6955)
• United States
23 Sep 08
Very true. Some parents allow the teachers to do all the teaching and fail to do their own teaching at home. Values are the most important things to be taught at home. Thanks:)
• Malaysia
16 Sep 08
i myself went to public school and it turned out good for me. As for my children now, my daughter is now at a private school which combines the normal curriculum as well as religious studies. She looks like she likes the school, the only thing is that she is still a bit weak in the Arabic clssses since she had no basic before in her kindergarten. The only 'bad' things about private school is that it could be very expensive. But i personally prefers to homeschool my children as i think, i could give much more attention to the child as well as prevent him/her to be exposed to all the bad things that is at the school. It is also not forcing them to learn what they dont like. But the time had not come as there are not much people who believe in homeschool and the government would 'punish' those who did not send their children to school.
1 person likes this
@rocketj1 (6955)
• United States
17 Sep 08
Home schooling DOES sound like a great option for a situation where the public school is exposing kids to bad things. Thank you:)
@lkoenig07 (289)
• United States
20 Sep 08
My husband & I have agreed that when our kids get to the age of going to school, I'll be homeschooling them. We chose this, because we don't like public school and the things that are taught there and go on there, and we're going to be moving soon and won't be able to send them to our church's school. Most people say that homeschooling is bad for kids, because "how are they going to make friends?" or "they're going to get such a culture shock when they go to college." But my husband was homeschooled, and said they have groups were they get a lot of homeschooling families together to participate in classes that are harder to teach (chemistry, etc.) and for sports, and so the kids can socialize.
1 person likes this
@rocketj1 (6955)
• United States
20 Sep 08
If your kids are attending church where there are many other children, then they are also getting that social interaction. Thanks!
• United States
17 Sep 08
We chose public school for all 5 of my children. I was raised in a dominantly religious school and we had the same problems as any other school. We are a religious family, but we want our children to learn not to be prejudice of other religions, handicaps, etc. Education does not include book learning only. There is education in life's daily experiences. If our kids don't have daily temptations and adversities, how will they learn to deal with them in real life? You can protect them all you want at home, but eventually, they have to learn to make their own choices.
@rocketj1 (6955)
• United States
17 Sep 08
We have always considered our Christian children to be little beacons in the public school system. My son was able to stand up to an Athiest teacher and I believe she was surprisingly impressed. There are so many kids from hurting families in our public schools and my kids are able to reflect God's love to them. Thanks:)
@Ohara_1983 (4117)
• Kuwait
16 Sep 08
For me i have one daughter but still young for school, but i think the best & good will be in public not to much expensie & they will learn the good lesson & also i can afford to pay in the school, we need to put our children the place that they are fit also for our saving. not putting them in private but they just learn how to like a spend but not thingking for thier future.
@rocketj1 (6955)
• United States
16 Sep 08
Here in the U.S, public schools are paid for by our taxes. We need only to pay for supplies ( not including books - at least in my state) Thanks!
@ronaldinu (12422)
• Malta
16 Sep 08
We have chosen a Church School for our child. At least it was my wife's decision but I backed it. In Malta the Public school is good as the churches and private schools at the primary sector. Problems begin at the secondary sector, where there is lack of discipline. Most of the most qualified teachers (including me) work in public schools. It is difficult to say which is the best school.
1 person likes this
@rocketj1 (6955)
• United States
16 Sep 08
Ah, A teacher's perspctive. Have you always worked in public schools?
@Pose123 (21635)
• Canada
16 Sep 08
Hi rocketj1, Although I have no children in school today, I still think that public schools are best. There is no doubt that many changes are needed, but I think that the alternatives are no better and often cause even more problems when the children are grown. Blessings.
1 person likes this
@rocketj1 (6955)
• United States
16 Sep 08
Thanks! In small towns, like my own, there seem to be some really great public schools. We do not have the problems of the big city schools. We do, however, have a lack of funding and that can be a problem too.
@mom4kids (657)
• Canada
16 Sep 08
Well for us we have chosen a private christian school. We have chosen this type of education because it meets the values and standards we would like to teach our children. I considered home schooling but my daughter who is now 6 is too stubborn and her and I butt heads too much so that just ended up not being an option. My daughter is now in grade one and her kindergarten class last year more than met our provinces standard and in fact they were even doing some grade one stuff at the end of the school year. It is expensive but we just make it work because it is important to us. I feel this is best for us but for everyone, no. Each parent decides for themselves which best suits your family.
@rocketj1 (6955)
• United States
17 Sep 08
In the part of my state that I came from there were many fantastic Christian schools that were fairly good sized too. Where we live now, the nearest Christian school is in the sticks. It is tiny. Not much of an option for us. Thank you for your response. God bless you as you sacrifice financially to give your children a godly education.:)
@Humbug25 (12540)
16 Sep 08
Hi there rocketj1 Well I don't really have any choice but to send my kids to a public school as I can't afford to send my children to a private school as I do believe they would get a better education there. We are not a particularly religious family and that would be hypercritical to send them to a religious school. My sanity wouldn't stand teaching them at home!!
@rocketj1 (6955)
• United States
16 Sep 08
Yes, sanity is rather important! Thank you for your response:-)
@Pikelet (79)
16 Sep 08
I can appreciate that there are reasons why parents may think it necessary to send their child to a private school,with all ht bad press that some of the state schools get lately.But there are many good state schools,with very good Ofsted reports,and the children are flourishing in them.It is a shame though that the press seem to constantly hapr on about the state of the education system.Im sure there are many parents out there who send their children to a private school.and they feel they get good nileage from sending them,but many of the private schools mean that the child has to become a boarder ,and sometimes boarding children are a little alienated from their parents,and not only that the salary of the parents must b good to cope with the school fees,but there are not only schllo fees there are also extra curricular activites to be paid for,the school outings and trips become more luxurious and they are expected to go on them,a freind recently had to pay for a skiing trip for her daughter ,she also had to buy all of the skiing gear,and the list for the holiday requirements was long and lengthy,her daughter went skiing and enjoyed it,but now will more than likey neve rgo again,and the ski equipment will be put away in the loft and get forgotten about.But I was happy to send mine to a state school,they all did well,and as the saying goes,if the child wants to learn then they will learn,but if they dont,well they wont.
@rocketj1 (6955)
• United States
16 Sep 08
Wow! I have neglected to mention boarding schools. I personally would never choose this option except in a special case. I can't see sending my own children away for someone else to essentially raise. Thanks for your comments:)